User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Offical Thread for Promotion System Changes (Enforcing Level Caps Etc)
Page:
 
DarthVisor
offline
Link
 
I sent Catch22 a message saying this is my biggest complaint.

Here was my suggested solution -

First, wait until after the last day of offseason to hand out teams so that everyone has performed their boosts.

Then promote as such -

League champion gets bumped 3 caps, but can request 2 (same as now)
Other playoff teams get bumped 2 caps, but can request 1 if all players are below that cap
All others get boosted 1 cap if all players are below that cap or to the lowest cap all players fit under.
 
DarthVisor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
Punishing teams for doing badly and then stripping them of their players

-1

If a team tanks on purpose to game the caps (some team play all their guys OOP, etc) take the team away.

Very rarely do any of the bad teams with players over the cap end up winning something.


No one is punishing them, just not rewarding them as is the case now.
 
geekor
offline
Link
 
We hear this complaint at the beginning of EVERY season.

How come we don't see it at the end?

Because these teams suck, even with higher leveled guys, their builds tactics, etc suck. That is why they are over the cap to begin with

Show me the team who did this and won??

This comes out at the beginning of every season, then goes away.

/thread
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
We hear this complaint at the beginning of EVERY season.

How come we don't see it at the end?

Because these teams suck, even with higher leveled guys, their builds tactics, etc suck. That is why they are over the cap to begin with

Show me the team who did this and won??

This comes out at the beginning of every season, then goes away.

/thread


There are lots of them, here's one I experienced in my league last season. http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1281165

And you are right, they suck.. that's why the use exploits and even though they don't all win the league or even conference they put the hurt on many other teams that might have made a playoff had it not been that for that loss to them.
Edited by Dr. E on Aug 3, 2010 19:56:12
 
bridady0323
offline
Link
 
Heres some lvl 25 teams in a lvl18 cap

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=1316

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=437

if they where lvl 21 i would understand but to be 7 lvls above the cap to start the season! There effective level is 25 as well.
 
DarthVisor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
We hear this complaint at the beginning of EVERY season.

How come we don't see it at the end?

Because these teams suck, even with higher leveled guys, their builds tactics, etc suck. That is why they are over the cap to begin with

Show me the team who did this and won??

This comes out at the beginning of every season, then goes away.

/thread


Maybe you don't hear it at the end of the season because everyone has accepted the fact that they got screwed that season and HOPE that the next will work out.

Yes, some teams suck, but just as many are just sandbagging waiting to get just such an advantage to "go for it".

Also, this thread is not just about teams that are way to high for their league, but also teams that get over promoted such that they have little if any chance in their new league the next season.

In the 26 cap league my team is on, we had a couple of teams come in with nearly a full team of level 28s who boosted to level 31 after teams were reassigned but before the beginning of the next season. Those teams would have been able to boost to level 34 on day 1 (although they appear to be holding off on that... probably just to piss me off come playoffs!).

Meanwhile there are teams that went 8-8 and got double promoted from a level 18 league and are sitting there with a team full of level 21 guys going WTF how do I compete against level 31 teams?

The goal SHOULD be to put teams of somewhat equal level in the same leagues so that competition will be better, and teams with better builds and better coaching are rewarded for their skill.

We should not be rewarding teams that sandbag in order to achieve an unfair advantage.
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
well said, Darth.
 
geekor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DarthVisor
We should not be rewarding teams that sandbag in order to achieve an unfair advantage.


Teams who purposely lose (I have seen teams play all defense on offense and vice versa) should have their teams removed.

Creating a hard cap for teams that don't do well is just stupid and creates an even harder to recruit.

Example, my own team: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=4360

we had made the playoffs in every season, until last season. We lost a couple of close games and ended up 8-8, in 9th place.

We had 2 guys over the cap by 1 level and 2 levels, so our team (which we have many guys still in the 30's) should have gone to 46 and got creamed again for those 2 players? Or I lose 2 guys who have been with me for 4 seasons? Your way punishes teams who already lost and makes them lose again. It's stupid, tbqh.

Originally posted by
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.


This at least makes sense. But the OP is at best stupid, at worst a whine thread.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
Originally posted by DarthVisor

We should not be rewarding teams that sandbag in order to achieve an unfair advantage.

We had 2 guys over the cap by 1 level and 2 levels, so our team (which we have many guys still in the 30's) should have gone to 46 and got creamed again for those 2 players? Or I lose 2 guys who have been with me for 4 seasons? Your way punishes teams who already lost and makes them lose again. It's stupid, tbqh.



well, were you in elite, competitive or regular league? If you made the playoffs than you would have to be elite or competitive. So you should promote to 46, and drop a cap (unless you chose to remove the few players over the cap).

that's just me, the tiers are there to allow the great teams, the good teams, and the struggling teams separate a bit, but I don't htink they've really been used properly
 
Brewster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
Originally posted by Dr. E

Below are two rules in minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.


1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.



With Dr.E idea I think you need to add a few player movement restrictions as well.
1. No team will be allowed to sign any player with a level higher than the cap the team is in, this would include trades
2. Any player on a team roster at the start if preseason must maintain those players for a min of 8-12 regular season games, exceptions- trades, player contract expires. This to lessen the idea of ave player level manipulation.

The whole idea behind this us to make leagues more comparative, cause everyone only wants a reasonable chance to win the games they play in, not a snowballs chance in hell to win.

 
geekor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Brewster
Originally posted by Chysil

Originally posted by Dr. E


Below are two rules in minor league cap promotion, I suggest the second rule be altered to include the bold section.


1.The bottom two teams in each conference remain in the same level cap, unless the players on the team are above that cap, in which case the will go up by 1 level cap.
2. The rest of the teams in the league move up 1 level cap. If the team's average level exceeds the cap the team will be moved up two caps.



With Dr.E idea I think you need to add a few player movement restrictions as well.
1. No team will be allowed to sign any player with a level higher than the cap the team is in, this would include trades
2. Any player on a team roster at the start if preseason must maintain those players for a min of 8-12 regular season games, exceptions- trades, player contract expires. This to lessen the idea of ave player level manipulation.


What???

1. it already works this way
2. wtf does this do? By the preseason you're already set in your league for the season. At that point the average level doesn't matter for anything



Originally posted by
The whole idea behind this us to make leagues more comparative, cause everyone only wants a reasonable chance to win the games they play in, not a snowballs chance in hell to win.


The people bitching have a reasonable chance to win games. They won't miss the playoffs. Not everyone can be the clear-cut-#1-guaranteed winning team. That has typically (not always) been the case with people bitching. It's the, "this team we have no chance of beating" argument. Well there are 14 other teams to beat up on. There are the Colts and then the Bengals, not every team is equal.
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
Your way punishes teams who already lost and makes them lose again. It's stupid, tbqh.


We can't help it if you can't think the entire thing through... ultimately you would not be the only person that went through this... you are going by what happened in the past and only changing your situation to the purposed idea.... that is not how it would work.. I understand why you would think this way though... the current method does not put everyone on equal footing.... the suggestion would.... the thing is.. if you have poor builds in comparison you should lose... if you have good builds you should win..... that is how games work.. if you suck you lose.. if you are good you win.. what is the harm in equality. If you want to keep your team together you have to make a tough choice.. what is the problem there.. the answer is not to remove that choice and make it so that everyone just gets to do whatever the hell they want and to hell with the cap as it is now...... I know it is set differently now.. now it is not technically a cap though.... so why call it one.....
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor

The people bitching have a reasonable chance to win games. They won't miss the playoffs. Not everyone can be the clear-cut-#1-guaranteed winning team. That has typically (not always) been the case with people bitching. It's the, "this team we have no chance of beating" argument. Well there are 14 other teams to beat up on. There are the Colts and then the Bengals, not every team is equal.


the point would be that no one should be the clear cut winner? A team that games the system to get into a lower cap than they truely belong can simply run away with it.

the people complaining are not wanting to be there "shoe in to win it all", they are trying to make it so that there is no "shoe in the win it all" etc
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
the point would be that no one should be the clear cut winner? A team that games the system to get into a lower cap than they truely belong can simply run away with it.

the people complaining are not wanting to be there "shoe in to win it all", they are trying to make it so that there is no "shoe in the win it all" etc


Exactly.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by Chysil

the point would be that no one should be the clear cut winner? A team that games the system to get into a lower cap than they truely belong can simply run away with it.

the people complaining are not wanting to be there "shoe in to win it all", they are trying to make it so that there is no "shoe in the win it all" etc


Exactly.


yep this
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.