User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > DB's become overly aggressive in the endzone - BUG FILED #233
Page:
 
robponce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
When players go for the interception (aggressive), they step forward to try and catch the ball at the highest possible point:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1281550&pbp_id=1708056

I would have to say this one looks to be the perfect example to counter your idea, Rob:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1281550&pbp_id=1705580
CB2 Officer Jake Hoyt was set to aggressive for interceptions
CB3 Corn Erback was set to semi-aggressive for interceptions
This pass to the endzone has them both reacting to the same point.

When players go for the deflection (semi-aggressive), they stay back with the WR:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1343001&pbp_id=3384699
CB1 Murphy Sable was set to aggressive for interceptions
CB3 Elijiah Hawk was set to semiaggressive for interceptions
This pass in midfield has them trying to reach the ball at different points.


I'm well aware of the mechanics of the game, however, I think you misinterpreted my post.

The mechanics of an INT/ PD/ Catch are thus (for purposes of this):

1. CB INT ROLL (pass or fail?) - IF pass INT - IF fail move to #2
2a. If CB in position - CB PD ROLL - If Pass PD - IF fail move to #3
2b. If CB not in Position move to #3
3. WR Catch Roll.


I'll stop there, but my post was saying, that it's possible that BECAUSE the ball is crossing the goalline, the CB MOVES to the front to GUARANTEE he gets the PD roll and thus it looks like he's trying for the INT roll every time when in reality he's not. He's simply guaranteeing his position on the WR.

Hope I've clarified for you.
 
Link
 
That does help clarify your post, thank you.
Still doesn't seem that way to me, though .
I requested in Addicts, and LoEA to post additional replays if anyone else notices this.
Edited by stromstarhammer on Aug 2, 2010 19:57:46
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
That does help clarify your post, thank you.
Still doesn't seem that way to me, though .
I requested in Addicts, and LoEA to post additional replays if anyone else notices this.


Yeah, and I think the point is that they are set to that setting so that they try and intersect with the ball path at a specific point. The players set to semi-aggressive/medium have builds specific to it, and same with the aggressive guys. So part of the point of the tactic for us is to have them go for the ball at a specific spot.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
My instinct tells me that this isn't the case, just because i believe they behave differently with there being no over the top ground to cover at the back of the end zone.
 
Barlol
offline
Link
 
I think you should all just bow down and acknowledge Strom's prowess as an evil genius
 
Link
 
edit:
Bad example
Edited by stromstarhammer on Aug 3, 2010 23:00:59
 
robponce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
This was in today's scrimmage:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1342939&pbp_id=4297895
FS is set to semi-aggressive, shouldn't step forward like that.


The FS?

Is this the right play?

The FS here is in zone, and covering his zone.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by robponce
The FS?

Is this the right play?

The FS here is in zone, and covering his zone.


lol DTD post sry...
beleted
 
Link
 
CB3 Elijah Hawk is set to Semi-aggressive
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1343315&pbp_id=4498282
 
robponce
offline
Link
 
my fist reaction is not a bug.

The way they interact seems to be steady and looks very intentional.

Any other QA mods want to chime in?
 
Link
 
Really appreciate you all looking into this. Some people from LoEA acknowledged they've noticed the endzone issues in the past as well, and are trying to look for new examples of it. Hopefully we can figure out what's happening here.

Originally posted by robponce
my fist reaction is not a bug.

The way they interact seems to be steady and looks very intentional.

Any other QA mods want to chime in?
Something is wrong with the endzone with CBs. If it's not an aggressiveness issue, then maybe the end line is too close or something. "steady and... intentional" means not a bug? I've provided examples from as early as season 7, I think. Just because it's always been there doesn't mean it hasn't been always wrong, does it?

Originally posted by RMiller517
My instinct tells me that this isn't the case, just because i believe they behave differently with there being no over the top ground to cover at the back of the end zone.

the CBs shouldn't automatically step up for the interception because the ball is thrown to the -0.5 yardline. I could understand that if it was thrown to the back of the endzone, but not any pass to the endzone. How often IRL do you see DBs run up for the INT, and leave their WR wide open in the endzone. If they did, then wouldn't you say that was an "aggressive" move? I'm pretty sure I've seen this with players set to medium as well, but we stopped using medium a few seasons ago because it seemed broken everywhere else on the field.
Edited by stromstarhammer on Aug 5, 2010 18:44:22
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Barlol
I think you should all just bow down and acknowledge Strom's prowess as an evil genius

Thanks Barlol, if there's one thing I think I excel at with GLB, it's DBs. 14 season's as D-coord, you start seeing things in the matrix.
 
robponce
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
Something is wrong with the endzone with CBs. If it's not an aggressiveness issue, then maybe the end line is too close or something. "steady and... intentional" means not a bug? I've provided examples from as early as season 7, I think. Just because it's always been there doesn't mean it hasn't been always wrong, does it?


Well....

You think it is wrong. Others may see logic and appreciate it. For whatever reason this seems to be intentionally happening.

Thus it would belong in the suggestions box and not the bugs box. Weird thinking, I know, but part of the bug mod job is to separate what is a bug (not supposed to be happening) and what is a suggestion (happening on purpose even if it's whacky).

Trust me,

I've built the only CB to win back to back INT WL trophies ( http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=50442 ), and WL DC'd a couple times as well as DC'd for a billion seasons now. If there was anything I would want to fix to be better it's CBs. But, unfortunately, I have to keep a level head when I have my mod hat on and make sure things are going through the right channels.

Another QA Mod should weigh in soon and see what he thinks.
 
Link
 
Suggestions? Nothing ever works in suggestions.
Might as well just delete the whole thread then, damnit this game is frustrating.
If I think somethings wrong, other LoEA d-coordinators think its wrong, bug mods think it looks wrong, and jdbolick thinks its wrong, then why do I, a peon in this game have to go through this entire process. In the meantime games could potentially be decided by this sim aspect that's been communally decided to be wrong.
If it's wrong, it's wrong. If Bort made a mistake in season 1, and it took until season 17 for someone to notice it for him, then why isn't someone in here saying, whoa wait a minute that was a mistake thanks for pointing it out.
If it is intentional, then why has this debate been ongoing A MONTH and sifted through tiers of the bugs thread before someone tells me that I should make a suggestion to be ignored.

The system frustrates me to no end right now. Maybe it's cuz I'm up late that I'm on here PMSing about this.
robponce, I don't mean this about you in the least. You've been great, really put your time to look into this, and have provided great insights, and I really appreciate you trying to help steer me in the right direction. Just feeling defeated right now.
 
robponce
offline
Link
 
I hear ya, unfortunately my mod powers only exist in the Bugs realm. That's just the way it works. Even if I wanted to MOD up a suggestion I can't. Nor do I have any "increased sway" over Bort and the team. I don't know if it's right or wrong because there are benefits to it happening as well, but I do agree it's happening regularly. Just determining whether or not it is a bug is my job. I feel it's deliberate (for the reasons I posted) and thus would not be a bug.

Like I said though, we have multiple QA Mods who might think otherwise. Then you'll get your debate

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.