User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Need some sort of X-Factor
Page:
 
ferocious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vyeth
All they would need to do, is at the begining of next season and to all new crated characters before nxt season, just secretly add a luck attribute to everyone. No one can see it but the devs and everyones luck attribute would be a totally random number from 1 - 100 with 100 being your absolute tom brady's and of course 's being your ryan leafs. Your luck attribute could help you pull off certain things in the clutch as well as boost your stats a little more after gaining a level. But we could never just LOOK at someone and automaticly KNOW if they are going to be good or not (like some of you guys are wanting).

This way it would add some of that unknown factor BUT will allow some players to become GREATER than others even at the same level, but in order to KNOW that they are greater you'd have to scout them. I think this would make a great addition to the game and allows for greater variation in team buildup because honestly we cant all be GREAT super stars.. just doesn't work that way..



Is anyone sure that this isn't already implemented? I've seen some low level guys have some pretty huge games against much better competition.

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
I would suggest tying this all to EXP accumulation rate.

For instance, an over-achiever might have an across the board +10% rate of EXP accumulation while an under achiever might have -10%.

This would result in a 6 level swing after 30 levels, which is fairly significant.

It might be best to delay the application of these mods until level 10 or so, as all players might be expected to progress at the same rate until they become somewhat competent. This would also mean that "bust" players require some investment of time and energy before their true potentential is known, which seems realistic.

You might even randomize the starting point at which the bust or boom phenomenon kicks in (to keep folks guessing a bit).

Another path is to have an "invisible" modifier to a players stats, something like +/- 10% across several primary stats (or even all stats)or perhaps a +/-20% to a single critical stat. The advantage here is that coaches would have to evaluate actual play to try to figure out is a player was a bust or a boomer, and coaches who engaged in trading would have to be fairly studious in evaluating game performance rather than just looking at level and a few key stats.

I would recommend such phenomenons be pretty rare...perhaps 5% of all players?
Last edited May 20, 2008 12:27:51
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Why are you so sure that there isn't some type of X-factor in the game right now?
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
I've been thinking about this a lot also. The continuum feels a little too constant and stagnant. We need some freaks in GLB. Players that make no sense - the LT's, the Barrys, the Montoyas, Deions and Marinos that dominate the sport.
We don't need to make this complicated by adding a feature that users control - and we don't need busts that just aggravate users. This is something that adds to - but doesn't take away.
Most players won't ever have it happen but I think it would be cool if there was a "Bort Boost" floating around that randomly just dropped 5 (or more?) skill points on a player. Log in and check out your player and oh my! Bort Boost baby! 5 free skill points. No level up or anything - just some more skill points.
You might never get one - you might get it six times on the same guy over the course of a career and become a legend. Or you might screw up your "God given" talent and build a lame duck anyway...
Guys are starting to figure out builds and only the truly clueless have 'bad' builds. In a year a bad build will be even more rare. This will add some fun. It can be totally random and totally unfair. Just like life.
Last edited Jun 14, 2008 21:29:56
 
Link
 
Haven't read the entire thread so apologies if this has been said..

If players are able to choose how much risk they want to take, like KGrob suggested, then players that choose X amount of risk are only worth a reduced refund of flex when you retire them. It could work on an escalating scale, with each season you keep them they're worth more. That way you can still get rid of them, but you can't dump them after 5 games when you realize your risk taking landed you on the bottom rung of the ladder. Something like 20% of how much you spent to create them for each season you keep them. So if you get a dud and want to retire him, you would have to keep him for 5 seasons in order to get back all of the flex you spent to create him.

Maybe something like he has to play at least 8 games a season too. That way people can't just let duds sit as free agents until they can be retired.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
If there was some sort of x-factor (and I have no reason to believe there is not), it should only be applied after one season. This way, you cannot just keep making players until you get a stud. One entire season means putting a lot of work into a player. If you keep retiring your player after one season, you would end up with a "stud" eventually, however, you could have had a high-level player with a good build that does well.

Those that want to spend the money and create a ton of players and retire the duds would have still put a lot of money into the system and wasted a season on so many players. Plus, it would be an x-factor that is only to be determined by game stats (not improved increases in attributes). The gains from a stud vs. dud would be minimal to the point that you do not really know if it is based on matchups, defensive coordinator settings, etc.

Again, though, I am not entirely sure that this is not the case already.
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Is it not possible that this is already in the game to a certain extent with confidence?
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
I dont mean to break up the party and all of these ideas sound great but I think they added these hidden factors with morale and confidence or even vision. Just because the player out level you doesn't mean he is going to play better. I seen many lower levels out perform the higher level not just in one game but in several games. It wouldn't even take an owner with a good eye for potenial to notice it. All he has to do is look at averages...Take how many plays it took one player to reach one goal and look at another player who which the same goal in less amount of plays. Level 7 might invest in spped and agility but level 4 has greater vision and has just enough spped and agility to make the play. Which one would you say was a better player. The one with the glory attributes or the one with a good balance in the under rated attributes. Thus giving him potenial to be a better player than the level 7 will ever become.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddencoach
I dont mean to break up the party and all of these ideas sound great but I think they added these hidden factors with morale and confidence or even vision. Just because the player out level you doesn't mean he is going to play better. I seen many lower levels out perform the higher level not just in one game but in several games. It wouldn't even take an owner with a good eye for potenial to notice it. All he has to do is look at averages...Take how many plays it took one player to reach one goal and look at another player who which the same goal in less amount of plays. Level 7 might invest in spped and agility but level 4 has greater vision and has just enough spped and agility to make the play. Which one would you say was a better player. The one with the glory attributes or the one with a good balance in the under rated attributes. Thus giving him potenial to be a better player than the level 7 will ever become.


Good point. However, backups get to play against weaker players or weakened starters. Just keep this in mind, if you haven't already.

And confidence is definately the most underrated stat (as Bort once said).
 
Maddencoach
offline
Link
 
You're right but lets forget about stats, I'm saying if you invest in those under rated attributes, even if you were the same level as one guy- where you're both a RB but one has high speed and agility with avg vision and confidence and you have avg speed and agility with high confidence and vision. He would get pick up for the starter job but in reality you have more potenial to make a big play happen on any given sunday

You dont need someone else to give you the tools to make you a potential threat. You have them right in front of you.
Last edited Jun 30, 2008 01:07:04
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.