I didn't read the whole discussion here, but I did catch:
Originally posted by Warlock
Turnovers are basically random, while we can influence the odds a little, it still comes down to the dice. So yes, I will take the defense that gives up 80 less yards over the one that got lucky with 3 good rolls.Normally I'd agree with this statement, but I'm leaning the other way this season having witnessed this team in action:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2784I have a player on So Cal BDC, a team that was among the very best in GLB last season, and Gunny racked up 11 interceptions against us this season. 11 interceptions against a perennial WL playoff team... and they've had at least 4 ints in every ranked game they've played against a team that threw at least one pass.
I'm a long time DC as well, and typically I judge my performance on yards allowed more than turnovers caused, but there are absolutely things you can do with your AI and tactics that will increase turnover production. Mostly those also increase the risk of a big play being made against you, but if your dots are good enough, the risk is minimal. A big part of the DC's job is finding the proper balance to get stops while also turning the ball over to help out the offense against another great defensive team.
In the end, the best DC is the one whose team wins the championship.