User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AAA Leagues > Canada AAA #1 > Conflict of interests in East??
Page:
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheShow215
Originally posted by mickey dalgleish

Should there not be some sort of rule excluding owners from having any part of other teams in same league never mind conference?


yes there should but as long as nothing dubious is going on its not a problem.

Locked thread question answered.


...except for one fact, in my opinion. There doesn't need to be such a rule. That's insane! Teams should be left to manage themselves, for the most part, and such a rule would not help anyone but maybe a team that made the decision to give a competitor a GM role. That's the only team it could really hurt. Besides that, what are we afraid of? Are we afraid of information being shared? It could anyways. Such a rule wouldn't help the rest in the league.

Manage yourself, I say. Stop trying to get everyone else to manage everyone else. This game is supposed to be about people winning based on decisions THEY make. Why would we try to take the only thing this game really is away from people? It's not even a game if we stop being able to manage things ourselves and make our own decisions about such matters as who can do what for your team.
 
TheShow215
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn


...except for one fact, in my opinion. There doesn't need to be such a rule. That's insane! Teams should be left to manage themselves, for the most part, and such a rule would not help anyone but maybe a team that made the decision to give a competitor a GM role. That's the only team it could really hurt. Besides that, what are we afraid of? Are we afraid of information being shared? It could anyways. Such a rule wouldn't help the rest in the league.

Manage yourself, I say. Stop trying to get everyone else to manage everyone else. This game is supposed to be about people winning based on decisions THEY make. Why would we try to take the only thing this game really is away from people? It's not even a game if we stop being able to manage things ourselves and make our own decisions about such matters as who can do what for your team.



I do understand where you are coming from because I agree people should be left to fend for themselves but in this case it does have the potential to create many problems.

On second thought in this case it has the potential to help a new owner get adjusted.

Still...it's like having Bellicheck (sp?) help coach the Jets too. Now I'm confused so I'll stick with my original answer, Yes a conflict of interest but as long as nothing shady is going on and it's for the betterment of the league then it's no problem.
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheShow215
Still...it's like having Bellicheck (sp?) help coach the Jets too.


And if the Jets are okay with that and the Patriots are okay with that... then I just don't think that the rest of the teams should have much say in the matter.

Bad idea for the Jets? Yeah, probably. But that's on the Jets.
And let's pretend Belichick and Eric Mangini were still buddies. They'd talk. Like Dungy and Edwards talk. No stopping that.
Keeping Belichick from an official position on the Jets team wouldn't help any other teams. It could only prevent him from sabotaging the Jets!

Again... that should be on the Jets. No one else's business, really.
Last edited Jun 18, 2008 21:18:20
 
TheShow215
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Again... that should be on the Jets. No one else's business, really.


Agreed

Originally posted by Malachorn
Keeping Belichick from an official position on the Jets team wouldn't help any other teams. It could only prevent him from sabotaging the Jets!


But this statement is exactly why some would support it being a rule. It protects the naive (though I think if your that naive it's your own fault) and it keeps those with ill intentions from having that kind of power.

 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by TheShow215

Keeping Belichick from an official position on the Jets team wouldn't help any other teams. It could only prevent him from sabotaging the Jets!


But this statement is exactly why some would support it being a rule. It protects the naive (though I think if your that naive it's your own fault) and it keeps those with ill intentions from having that kind of power.


It's a terrible precedent to set. You wanna see admins set the tactics for newbs too? I just think that it's their team, their call, and their responsibility.
Last edited Jun 19, 2008 07:04:13
 
Brooks
offline
Link
 
You all are right! This was Jim's plan from the beginning, he plans on taking a spot on all the Canada AAA teams and taking the whole league over.

On a serious note, I do not believe Jim is up to anything shady. He is a good owner and will help Hamilton.
 
GuieetarBen
offline
Link
 
That was pretty crappy seeing Hamilton get torn down the way they did. That was one tough team to play. If Jim wants to help them out it is his choice. The guy has been pretty stand up since I have had any interaction with him.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.