The thread The entire defense shouldn't stop when someone is attempting a tackle -NEEDS BUG ADMIN VERIFICATION has been merged into this thread
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > Open Field Pathing is Bugged - FILED BUG #159
Bukowski
offline
offline
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1230918&pbp_id=4934212
While the RB is breaking the tackle, the entire defense pauses, instead of attacking towards the RBs direction.
The defenders shouldn't stop until the play is over.
While the RB is breaking the tackle, the entire defense pauses, instead of attacking towards the RBs direction.
The defenders shouldn't stop until the play is over.
blaslo
offline
offline
The odd thing is, it looks like every defensive player EXCEPT the RE pauses, it looks to me like the RE continues on the path to try to cut off the HB downfield. Think we'll need some more examples to make a move on this one.
Bukowski
offline
offline
The RE definitely slows down. He doesn't completely stop, but he doesn't keep running at full speed either.
This can't be the only example of this though, I wouldn't think.
This can't be the only example of this though, I wouldn't think.
TheGreatPuma
offline
offline
This is similar to the problem earlier where all but one of the defensive players seems to be following the direct path of the ball carrier. I'll see if I can find the original post.
Here:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4073701
Was determined not a bug
Here:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4073701
Was determined not a bug
Looks like the entire defence is directly following the ball-carriers movement, so when he is breaking the tackle, and thus going slightly backwards, the defence all seem to stop or start moving up the field.
Most likely not a bug, as such.
doobas™
Most likely not a bug, as such.
doobas™
TyrannyVaunt
offline
offline
That is definitely a bug. There is no way an entire defense should stutter like that.
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
That is definitely a bug. There is no way an entire defense should stutter like that.
Seriously. I can't believe someone would think that it wasn't.
I'm going to try to find more examples, but this should definitely be looked at.
That is definitely a bug. There is no way an entire defense should stutter like that.
Seriously. I can't believe someone would think that it wasn't.
I'm going to try to find more examples, but this should definitely be looked at.
Originally posted by Bukowski
Seriously. I can't believe someone would think that it wasn't.
Watch it in slow motion, mate. You can see that they all start moving back up the field at the point the runner backs up whilst breaking the tackle.
doobas™
Seriously. I can't believe someone would think that it wasn't.
Watch it in slow motion, mate. You can see that they all start moving back up the field at the point the runner backs up whilst breaking the tackle.
doobas™
Bukowski
offline
offline
Originally posted by doobas
Originally posted by Bukowski
Seriously. I can't believe someone would think that it wasn't.
Watch it in slow motion, mate. You can see that they all start moving back up the field at the point the runner backs up whilst breaking the tackle.
doobas™
I hear you, but that doesn't mean that there isn't a problem.
The defense shouldn't be copying the runners every move, that doesn't even begin to make sense. They should be heading toward the runner no matter what, and that doesn't mean going backwards if the runner is trying to juke someone.
I have a feeling that this is related to the known open-field pathing bug, which has already been confirmed to be a bug. But that's just a guess, because of the defense doing similar things in both instances.
No matter what it is, it needs to be looked at.
Originally posted by Bukowski
Seriously. I can't believe someone would think that it wasn't.
Watch it in slow motion, mate. You can see that they all start moving back up the field at the point the runner backs up whilst breaking the tackle.
doobas™
I hear you, but that doesn't mean that there isn't a problem.
The defense shouldn't be copying the runners every move, that doesn't even begin to make sense. They should be heading toward the runner no matter what, and that doesn't mean going backwards if the runner is trying to juke someone.
I have a feeling that this is related to the known open-field pathing bug, which has already been confirmed to be a bug. But that's just a guess, because of the defense doing similar things in both instances.
No matter what it is, it needs to be looked at.
blaslo
offline
offline
I'm inclined to think it IS a bug, or at least a pathing issue, I'd just like to get more examples in the thread before moving it along
Hokiemon
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bukowski
I have a feeling that this is related to the known open-field pathing bug, which has already been confirmed to be a bug.
I'm in this camp as well. When you see an entire defense reacting in the exact same way, with the exact same movements by multiple dots, there is an issue. Since there are already many examples of said such issues, I don't think we need anymore information on this one. Also since there seems to be some differing opinions in here I'm going to move it to QA NEEDS DETERMINATION and let them decide
I have a feeling that this is related to the known open-field pathing bug, which has already been confirmed to be a bug.
I'm in this camp as well. When you see an entire defense reacting in the exact same way, with the exact same movements by multiple dots, there is an issue. Since there are already many examples of said such issues, I don't think we need anymore information on this one. Also since there seems to be some differing opinions in here I'm going to move it to QA NEEDS DETERMINATION and let them decide
STG
offline
offline
We need to keep in mind that the graphic representation of the play isn't to be considered 100% accurate of how the play panned out (which could very well be the case) . That said, I agree that it definately looks buggy. If this isn't a pathing related issue (and I am 50% that it is), I'm not sure what else this could be
RMiller517
offline
offline
i have a feeling that this bug has to do with the ongoing pursuit pathing discussions... but i'll leave it here for other potential examples to be found.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























