I'd like to see how much this still occurs post new salary cap. If bort makes it such that a team in a low cap couldn't have enough in their salary cap to support a team over the cap, i think it would definitely be a change for the better.
Forum > Suggestions > Fix the Promotion System
Clarka3
offline
offline
Originally posted by SikoraP13 DTD
I'd like to see how much this still occurs post new salary cap. If bort makes it such that a team in a low cap couldn't have enough in their salary cap to support a team over the cap, i think it would definitely be a change for the better.
that perhaps, but also this: is the cash/morale hit going to be noticeable?
the difference in cap salary caps has to be enough that a cap 18 team won't have enough money to pay the minimum salaries of 48 or so cap 22 players though. I suspect that'll be a ton of number crunching to pull off, but it certainly would solve this problem.
I'd like to see how much this still occurs post new salary cap. If bort makes it such that a team in a low cap couldn't have enough in their salary cap to support a team over the cap, i think it would definitely be a change for the better.
that perhaps, but also this: is the cash/morale hit going to be noticeable?
the difference in cap salary caps has to be enough that a cap 18 team won't have enough money to pay the minimum salaries of 48 or so cap 22 players though. I suspect that'll be a ton of number crunching to pull off, but it certainly would solve this problem.
Edited by Clarka3 on May 19, 2010 15:28:28
Edited by Clarka3 on May 19, 2010 15:28:07
Mynno
offline
offline
Since I DC for the team that was posted about and it has happened to us several times as well before we restarted the team I agree. It sucks. And no we did not tank any games on purpose. You can ask any of the agents from our team if we ever tried to tank a game. There were gameplans done for every game. We just never got our running game up and going like we thought we would and had to rely on our passing down the stretch.
As I posted in our league forums, we did not ask to be put where we were but we sure as hell are not going to ask to be put in a cap 24 when our effective level is 21 and thats after some of our players boosted. We are being accused of something we did not plan nor ask for. Plus we are being called all kinds of things which we do not deserve. We have always played strictly by the rules and even though there were exploits on both sides of the ball we always refused to use them. Thats probably why we had an 8-8 record.
I do agree with most of the posters that if your effective team level is higher than what the league was intended for, in this case our EL being 21 and we are in a cap 18 league then the team should be moved. It's not my call though and I am tired of apologising for something that the owner and I had nothing to do with. The computer put us in that league. Put the blame where it belongs which is the program that put us there in the first place.
As I posted in our league forums, we did not ask to be put where we were but we sure as hell are not going to ask to be put in a cap 24 when our effective level is 21 and thats after some of our players boosted. We are being accused of something we did not plan nor ask for. Plus we are being called all kinds of things which we do not deserve. We have always played strictly by the rules and even though there were exploits on both sides of the ball we always refused to use them. Thats probably why we had an 8-8 record.
I do agree with most of the posters that if your effective team level is higher than what the league was intended for, in this case our EL being 21 and we are in a cap 18 league then the team should be moved. It's not my call though and I am tired of apologising for something that the owner and I had nothing to do with. The computer put us in that league. Put the blame where it belongs which is the program that put us there in the first place.
Clarka3
offline
offline
no offense, but a team gameplanning to win doesn't run 75% of the first half and go up to a 28-7 lead only to pass 90% of the 2nd half and lose.
even if you have "bad film" inputs that fire when you have a sizeable lead to do the opposite of what you normally do, when the score gets back close, your original, successful AI should start back up. just my opinion, and i'm only an amateur OC with 1 season of OC-ing under my belt.
edit:
who says anything about going to cap24? You've got a roster close to full of lvl 22's- regardless if your EL is lower. You should volunteer to go to a cap 22 league, as it's the morally right thing to do, regardless of your performance last season.
even if you have "bad film" inputs that fire when you have a sizeable lead to do the opposite of what you normally do, when the score gets back close, your original, successful AI should start back up. just my opinion, and i'm only an amateur OC with 1 season of OC-ing under my belt.
edit:
who says anything about going to cap24? You've got a roster close to full of lvl 22's- regardless if your EL is lower. You should volunteer to go to a cap 22 league, as it's the morally right thing to do, regardless of your performance last season.
Edited by Clarka3 on May 19, 2010 15:54:55
Empire_Strikes_Back
offline
offline
Lets not get bogged down in picking out individual teams and accusing them of playing against the spirit of the game.
Fact is, alot of these guys haven't tanked on purpose - we need to stick with the proposed solution and try and make this suggestion epic.
Last year my team faced another team in the final of a cap18 tournament and their whole roster was level 22 - plus they boosted right at the start of the year.
Cue 16-0 season and Championship. - this needs to be sorted.
Fact is, alot of these guys haven't tanked on purpose - we need to stick with the proposed solution and try and make this suggestion epic.
Last year my team faced another team in the final of a cap18 tournament and their whole roster was level 22 - plus they boosted right at the start of the year.
Cue 16-0 season and Championship. - this needs to be sorted.
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
offline
Originally posted by SikoraP13 DTD
I'd like to see how much this still occurs post new salary cap. If bort makes it such that a team in a low cap couldn't have enough in their salary cap to support a team over the cap, i think it would definitely be a change for the better.
like i said, this would help tremendously if you could make it work.
I'd like to see how much this still occurs post new salary cap. If bort makes it such that a team in a low cap couldn't have enough in their salary cap to support a team over the cap, i think it would definitely be a change for the better.
like i said, this would help tremendously if you could make it work.
wil75
offline
offline
Originally posted by amace
effective levels are crap.
my solution is quite simple, and will easilly work.
Force teams into the lowest cap they qualify for unless they request a higher cap. no more teams full of level 15s in cap 22, no more teams with mostly level 28's and a 39 runningback merking cap 28, they move up to cap 42, or cut the runningback.

effective levels are crap.
my solution is quite simple, and will easilly work.
Force teams into the lowest cap they qualify for unless they request a higher cap. no more teams full of level 15s in cap 22, no more teams with mostly level 28's and a 39 runningback merking cap 28, they move up to cap 42, or cut the runningback.

joesox
offline
offline
Originally posted by stromstarhammer
For this particular situation, I would agree that it appears the system has failed.
I guess it works if you're a commie.
not really but more or less this is a broken system so FIX IT
For this particular situation, I would agree that it appears the system has failed.
I guess it works if you're a commie.
not really but more or less this is a broken system so FIX IT
Guppy, Inc
offline
offline
non playoff teams should have to follow the same rules as the 15/16th place teams. all the current system does is to encourage SB teams to only train while in cap 14 then dominate 18-26-34-42 because they'll always be over cap.
personally i'd get rid of cap 18 and make all 14 go to 22 the following season, and cap 4 to 14. this would also discourage cap 14 teams from starting with level 1s, who should really be cap 4, which would improve competition.
personally i'd get rid of cap 18 and make all 14 go to 22 the following season, and cap 4 to 14. this would also discourage cap 14 teams from starting with level 1s, who should really be cap 4, which would improve competition.
chief c
offline
offline
Originally posted by The Other Football
First of all, Herm was and is a piece of shit...period.
Second, you taking his approach...and this other BS with a Cap 4 "trying to learn the game" crap means that you have absolutely no room to speak...period.
Go game plan your season and come back when you actually have enough time to realize how stupid you sound.
very good, touche
First of all, Herm was and is a piece of shit...period.
Second, you taking his approach...and this other BS with a Cap 4 "trying to learn the game" crap means that you have absolutely no room to speak...period.
Go game plan your season and come back when you actually have enough time to realize how stupid you sound.
very good, touche

I had started a thread about this exact thing earlier. I am not accusing the team of any wrong doing at all. but this is ridiculous that a team works their butts off to try to win while they are in cap 4 then they get put in cap 18 to see a team that even after the teams boost they are still outleveled by this team. it is morally wrong for this crap to keep happening especially in the capped leagues. I can see it when you go uncapped since there is no restrictions on player ages to be signed.
I have been told there is nothing we can do about the team because they meet all of the rules. Well the rules are garbage imo.
Jazlotus
offline
offline
Come on BORT and CATCH!!!!! Change this, how is it fair to let teams with squads full of level 22 players be in a level18 league??????? This HAS GOT to be changed!
Clarka3
offline
offline
the team has to take some moral responsibility here as well, which is always in short supply on the internet. they could, at any time, have PM'd support and asked to be upped to cap 22 since the majority of their players are 22's. alas, they didn't.
toobad4u_00
offline
offline
Here is the funny thing.. the powers that be will like come back with, "Working as intended." Like they always do.. the problem with that is that it doesn't mean something isn't broke.. they just don't want to put the time in to fix it.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























