User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Extra boosting incentive tied to extending player plateau
Page:
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
a player that doesn't boost hits level 40 or so at 400 days old

a player that boosts whenever they can takes about 280 days to reach 50. This is about where they because equal in terms of SP value. that means, a player that boosts is only "better" than a non booster for the last 3 seasons of their non plateau years.

meanwhile they've spent 21 x creation cost (which even for a 100 flex player is like $20) before they have reach a non boosters effectiveness.

does that really seem fair to the booster?
 
cosine4
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
Hmmm is that really the problem he says he is trying to fix? He says there is a problem that a 32 booster can't compete with a 32 nonbooster which is a fact he goes on to say that giving the booster an extra few days would earn back the time that the player lost. You can often gain something back with time rather than making something equate.


I am interpreting this as the reason this is needed/desired, maybe it is just added information.

Originally posted by Loco Moco
My suggestion is to basically repay those boosting players that are forced to compete with nonboosters early on in their "lolminor" careers.



I would support an added plateau without boosting, but that is a different thread.
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 


Originally posted by cosine4
I am interpreting this as the reason this is needed/desired, maybe it is just added information.


Think outside the box for a moment. There really are 2 options available, not the 1 that you seem to think. You can try to equate the 2 methods as you go, which does not seem quite fair or you can compensate the spender for the lost seasons of being able to be competitive with an older player during those lower levels. Often money spent on something means you get it for a longer period of time. This makes sense in this case since it seems unfair to give the player who is boosting training points and level.
 
Deadpool55
offline
Link
 
+1 I like it
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
Not a bad suggestion...... most suggestions that give something back to those who have contributed hundreds/thousands to a beta game almost always gets a major +1 from me fwiw.

However, why the need for extra "boosts"? If plateau was extended a little for boosting players, then there is clearly a benefit...... consider it a repayment for money wasted on builds that were Borted into oblivion if you want, or call it an agent appreciation gesture. Adding another layer of boosts though is clearly not necessary in any way, and that line of thinking is skewing the thread here IMO.

Maybe some prerequisites, such as 30 total boosts on the player before any extension is given at all? I mean, the dude who boosted his level 40 player who is 500 days old one season only doesn't really deserve anything in return for that (even if that benefit is small.... 3 days).

As far as the moderators coming in here & putting up the good fight for worthless freeloaders, I understand where you are coming from (and no disrespect DG, we agree on 99% of all things in GLB IMO), but most mods are clearly looking at this backwards. If there were a reward for boosting (ie, a slightly longer life span) then all it would do is encourage boosting not inhibit it. I mean, players can play here for free and have a good time, but to reap any benefit they have to pay for it..... pretty simple. I don't see a single situation where giving those who pay an incentive to continue to pay, would in any way inhibit a freeloader from at least seeing the benefit in buying some flex (whether they do it or not TBH). Frankly, those who play for free here are either.....

1. Casual players who are not 100% serious about building a player or playing the game...... not hurt by handing out some appreciation for those who choose to do more than they do, and in fact these folks may choose to pay a little for some extra perceived benefit.

2. Minors who have no money or any hope for getting any soon..... not hurt by the process, as they can still play for free, and might just hit up mommy/daddy for some money for their hobby. And besides, even though a mod will never acknowledge, nobody cares if these guys stick around. All they do is come up with lame-brained suggestions, troll the forums, and rage quit on teams because they have little-to-no real life experience in dealing with other people in a constructive way. AND THEY DO NOT SPEND ANY MONEY HERE so it certainly isn't like they will be missed from a business perspective (plz don't come back with "they'll be 18 and have a job in 2 years" mentality here.....).

3. The unemployed or financially struggling...... in our economy there are many in this boat, and some would probably love to spend some money here but can't. Again though, it isn't like a plan that would reward those who have gone through the growing pains for 10 seasons with their players would really change these people's perspective or behavior either.......

In a nutshell, GLB is an awesome idea with a huge following....... good things. It costs too much, and the front-loaded cost model with a "refund" at player retirement has run it's course (in other words, start-up capital is no longer a concern)...... bad things. So, in the guise of making things better for the long run, instead of revamping the financials etc or other clearly blaring issues........ we get coaching and a hotdog cart.
 
talmon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
Not a bad suggestion...... most suggestions that give something back to those who have contributed hundreds/thousands to a beta game almost always gets a major +1 from me fwiw.

However, why the need for extra "boosts"? If plateau was extended a little for boosting players, then there is clearly a benefit...... consider it a repayment for money wasted on builds that were Borted into oblivion if you want, or call it an agent appreciation gesture. Adding another layer of boosts though is clearly not necessary in any way, and that line of thinking is skewing the thread here IMO.

Maybe some prerequisites, such as 30 total boosts on the player before any extension is given at all? I mean, the dude who boosted his level 40 player who is 500 days old one season only doesn't really deserve anything in return for that (even if that benefit is small.... 3 days).

As far as the moderators coming in here & putting up the good fight for worthless freeloaders, I understand where you are coming from (and no disrespect DG, we agree on 99% of all things in GLB IMO), but most mods are clearly looking at this backwards. If there were a reward for boosting (ie, a slightly longer life span) then all it would do is encourage boosting not inhibit it. I mean, players can play here for free and have a good time, but to reap any benefit they have to pay for it..... pretty simple. I don't see a single situation where giving those who pay an incentive to continue to pay, would in any way inhibit a freeloader from at least seeing the benefit in buying some flex (whether they do it or not TBH). Frankly, those who play for free here are either.....

1. Casual players who are not 100% serious about building a player or playing the game...... not hurt by handing out some appreciation for those who choose to do more than they do, and in fact these folks may choose to pay a little for some extra perceived benefit.

2. Minors who have no money or any hope for getting any soon..... not hurt by the process, as they can still play for free, and might just hit up mommy/daddy for some money for their hobby. And besides, even though a mod will never acknowledge, nobody cares if these guys stick around. All they do is come up with lame-brained suggestions, troll the forums, and rage quit on teams because they have little-to-no real life experience in dealing with other people in a constructive way. AND THEY DO NOT SPEND ANY MONEY HERE so it certainly isn't like they will be missed from a business perspective (plz don't come back with "they'll be 18 and have a job in 2 years" mentality here.....).

3. The unemployed or financially struggling...... in our economy there are many in this boat, and some would probably love to spend some money here but can't. Again though, it isn't like a plan that would reward those who have gone through the growing pains for 10 seasons with their players would really change these people's perspective or behavior either.......

In a nutshell, GLB is an awesome idea with a huge following....... good things. It costs too much, and the front-loaded cost model with a "refund" at player retirement has run it's course (in other words, start-up capital is no longer a concern)...... bad things. So, in the guise of making things better for the long run, instead of revamping the financials etc or other clearly blaring issues........ we get coaching and a hotdog cart.


Do i have to flip the page to read the rest?
Edited by talmon on May 13, 2010 17:07:53
 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I am down wit this idea
 
Loco Moco
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
Maybe some prerequisites, such as 30 total boosts on the player before any extension is given at all? I mean, the dude who boosted his level 40 player who is 500 days old one season only doesn't really deserve anything in return for that (even if that benefit is small.... 3 days).


I'm adding this to the OP.

This would make good business sense for Bort because it could help discourage agents from retiring their dots early.
A lot of dots pull the plug at level 40+ when teams start gutting after the Minors.
I think this would give them more reason to keep their player and keep boosting.

Edited by Loco Moco on May 13, 2010 19:18:25
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
This is an interesting idea. I'll pass it on to the rest of the admins as something to factor into idea discussion.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
perhaps it's tiered, like every 10 boosts you get an additional 1 season?

meaning that a normal person who boosts every season would get 3 additional seasons of plateau
 
Xar
offline
Link
 
That would solve the extended plateau discussion. The guys that deserve an extended plateau are the guys that pay for it.
 
Xar
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
perhaps it's tiered, like every 10 boosts you get an additional 1 season?

meaning that a normal person who boosts every season would get 3 additional seasons of plateau


You would have to have each boost give a certain number of days, so say 1 boost is equal to 4 days extension before decline kicks in. Each time you boost you gain 4 days, 10 boosts = 40 days (1 season), etc. That would be to cover the guys that don't fully boost, but only do say 20 boosts instead of 30.
Edited by Xar on May 13, 2010 20:07:38
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Another way to solve the problem is to get boosters past non-boosters faster. Perhaps you could have boosting apply a multiplier to XP earned daily and for games. I.e. 1X boost gives you +10%, 2X boost +20%, 3X boost +30%. Obviously you'd need to balance this out - I'm just tossing out numbers. This could also be built in at the low levels so it's not such a waste to boost early in the season.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
This is an interesting idea. I'll pass it on to the rest of the admins as something to factor into idea discussion.


Who says Bort doesn't come in suggestions?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.