User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > this league disgusts me
Page:
 
Primate
offline
Link
 
How did this thread get political?

My take:

I'm damn glad the North won, or we would have ended up a Colony of some European Ex-superpower. All the rest of it is revisionist in one direction or the other.
 
11bgod
offline
Link
 
Mornacle, I'm just smart enough to have anticipated you concluding that anything that doesn't fit into your view of the civil war would be dismissed as 'propaganda', which is why---let me repeat this, which is why I made sure that the words I used were from the actual southern declarations of secession. Unless you can have the readers believe that the traitors themselves were creating 'yankee propaganda', I think you're out of luck on this particular attempt to show off your superior intellect.
 
bigdogshark62
offline
Link
 
History is always written by the winners. Think of how the history books would have looked if the south had won the Civil War, or if the Axis had won WWII...

One thing I've learned is that the truth, even with documentation, means absolutely nothing to those who chose not to believe it. If you don't believe it, it doesn't exist. And if your argument is weak, shout louder than anyone else so your voice is the only one heard. Intelligent discourse is a thing of the past. Five second sound bites rule the day. Hearsay, and even outright lies from one side or the other, is taken as gospel truth by those who chose to believe it.

We've succumbed to the "dumbing down" of our nation, and our world. Our forefathers were often told to "think of the children," or "think of the future generations." We ARE those future generations. And we are left to mourn...
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 11bgod
Mornacle, I'm just smart enough to have anticipated you concluding that anything that doesn't fit into your view of the civil war would be dismissed as 'propaganda', which is why---let me repeat this, which is why I made sure that the words I used were from the actual southern declarations of secession. Unless you can have the readers believe that the traitors themselves were creating 'yankee propaganda', I think you're out of luck on this particular attempt to show off your superior intellect.


Any quote can be taken out of context and sound like it means anything. Furthermore, even if you're able to find a few bad apples that really did misunderstand the lofty goals that motivated the formation of the Confederacy, their false beliefs do not negate the facts that the Heroes of the South were willing to lay down their lives for Justice, Liberty, and the True American Way.
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 11bgod
Mornacle, I'm ... creating 'yankee propaganda'


Case in point.
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
I'm getting sidetracked, though, because this thread is about how Pirate Kid thinks it's funny to threaten to harm old men, not damn Yankees spouting silly tales about the War of Northern Agression.
 
11bgod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mornacale
Originally posted by 11bgod

Mornacle, I'm just smart enough to have anticipated you concluding that anything that doesn't fit into your view of the civil war would be dismissed as 'propaganda', which is why---let me repeat this, which is why I made sure that the words I used were from the actual southern declarations of secession. Unless you can have the readers believe that the traitors themselves were creating 'yankee propaganda', I think you're out of luck on this particular attempt to show off your superior intellect.


Any quote can be taken out of context and sound like it means anything. Furthermore, even if you're able to find a few bad apples that really did misunderstand the lofty goals that motivated the formation of the Confederacy, their false beliefs do not negate the facts that the Heroes of the South were willing to lay down their lives for Justice, Liberty, and the True American Way.




Mornacle, it would have taken you about 3 minutes to locate the southern states' declarations of secession for yourself. Had you done so you would know that I quotes said declarations word for word, imposing no context onto the words themselves. I cannot figure out if you're too dumb to have done so, or if you simply believe that the rest of the readers are.

The 'few bad apples' you make mention of in an effort to diminish their relevance are the very same people who FORMED the Confederacy. If the folks who formed the confederacy weren't aware of the 'lofty goals that motivated the formation of the confederacy', then I'm not sure anyone would be qualified, least of all you, to speak to what the actual goals were.

 
Track6Track7
offline
Link
 
blah blah blah lets argue about math or whatever these wurds r sum more
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Track6Track7
blah blah blah lets argue about math or whatever these wurds r sum more


Math is FUNdamental!
 
Primate
offline
Link
 
Everything boils down to math.
 
gpank
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 11bgod
Originally posted by 11bgod

The argument that the traitors who formed the confederacy were working for anything other than the continuance of slavery, is based in ignorance or a willful misrepresentation of the facts and/or words of the very people who did secede.



Pure sophistry. The major point of ignorance in this argument, on both sides, is the lack of discussion involving the relevance and impact of the North's policy of abusing the agrarian focused South's bounty of raw materials and natural resources. You see this on a global scale today. The abuse by the manufacturing Yankees forced the price of labor to a point that slavery was the only way to sustain the demand and while I am sure that many Southerners had no qualm with the institution that is a far cry from having the continuation of slavery as their only goal in secession. As stated it is true that the winners write the history and that is why you guys are conveniently forgetting, just as most history books do, the fact that the mission statement of the North didn't revolve around slavery until just before the EP was issued.

Slavery and bigotry are atrocious things and I in no way condone either but you need to get your facts straight before you start making ridiculous assertions like the many above this post. It's pricks like you that make further strides in race relations in America almost impossible. I'm sure your garbage would make Jesse Jackson and Keith Olberman pleased as punch. The sophists and demagogues of the world are applauding.
 
11bgod
offline
Link
 
gpank, I'm not sure why it is so difficult for you and apologists like Mornacle to understand that I'm not doing anything other than:

1. Quoting the southern declarations of secession


Whether the continuation of slavery was purely a racist policy (or not) is irrelevant to the discussion at hand.

If you wish to discuss/debate whether the moral bankruptcy of slavery can be justified by any circumstances, let alone the almighty dollar, I'm game. In the interest of fair play: It will be my position that nothing can justify the institution of slavery.

Putting the cart before the horse, i.e. blaming the 'yankee manufacturers' for forcing the institution of slavery to be necessary by 'abusing the agrarian south' is an amusing argument. Given that the institution of slavery pre-dates the abuses you attribute to 'yankees', it is only that, (amusing).

soph·is·try (sŏf'ĭ-strç)
n. pl. soph·is·tries

1. Plausible but fallacious argumentation.

2. A plausible but misleading or fallacious argument.



The secessionists themselves said it was about slavery. That would make it plausible, although unless the secessionists themselves were lying, it can't be fallacious, or misleading.

Given that (again) I was quoting the traitors themselves, I would agree that it was 'garbage', though it isn't my 'garbage'.

As for me being one of the 'pricks who make further strides in race relations in America almost impossible', I should point out that I don't have a confederate flag in the window of my pickup truck, nor do I refer to the war that freed the slaves as 'the war of northern aggression'.


Attempting to denigrate my position by saying it would please a Civil Rights leader and a graduate of Cornell is an interesting attempt to make it look like only liberals can hold the position that secession was based on what the secessionists themselves said it was based on. I will not reply in kind, other than to point out that I sincerely hope that most conservatives also are aware that the civil war, caused by secession, was based on the confederate states' desire to preserve the institution of slavery.
Edited by 11bgod on May 2, 2010 09:59:19
Edited by 11bgod on May 2, 2010 09:56:25
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gpank
Pure sophistry. The major point of ignorance in this argument, on both sides, is the lack of discussion involving the relevance and impact of the North's policy of abusing the agrarian focused South's bounty of raw materials and natural resources. You see this on a global scale today. The abuse by the manufacturing Yankees forced the price of labor to a point that slavery was the only way to sustain the demand and while I am sure that many Southerners had no qualm with the institution that is a far cry from having the continuation of slavery as their only goal in secession. As stated it is true that the winners write the history and that is why you guys are conveniently forgetting, just as most history books do, the fact that the mission statement of the North didn't revolve around slavery until just before the EP was issued.

Slavery and bigotry are atrocious things and I in no way condone either but you need to get your facts straight before you start making ridiculous assertions like the many above this post. It's pricks like you that make further strides in race relations in America almost impossible. I'm sure your garbage would make Jesse Jackson and Keith Olberman pleased as punch. The sophists and demagogues of the world are applauding.


hahahaha, is this guy seriousposting?
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mornacale
hahahaha, is this guy seriousposting?


Really, I want to know if gpank is trolling or not. gpank, stand up and answer me homes.
 
Track6Track7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mornacale
Originally posted by Mornacale

hahahaha, is this guy seriousposting?


Really, I want to know if gpank is trolling or not. gpank, stand up and answer me homes.


lol hes probably busy reeding
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.