gpank, I'm not sure why it is so difficult for you and apologists like Mornacle to understand that I'm not doing anything other than:
1. Quoting the southern declarations of secession
Whether the continuation of slavery was purely a racist policy (or not) is irrelevant to the discussion at hand.
If you wish to discuss/debate whether the moral bankruptcy of slavery can be justified by any circumstances, let alone the almighty dollar, I'm game. In the interest of fair play: It will be my position that nothing can justify the institution of slavery.
Putting the cart before the horse, i.e. blaming the 'yankee manufacturers' for forcing the institution of slavery to be necessary by 'abusing the agrarian south' is an amusing argument. Given that the institution of slavery pre-dates the abuses you attribute to 'yankees', it is only that, (amusing).
soph·is·try (sŏf'ĭ-strç)
n. pl. soph·is·tries
1. Plausible but fallacious argumentation.
2. A plausible but misleading or fallacious argument.
The secessionists themselves said it was about slavery. That would make it plausible, although unless the secessionists themselves were lying, it can't be fallacious, or misleading.
Given that (again) I was quoting the traitors themselves, I would agree that it was 'garbage', though it isn't my 'garbage'.
As for me being one of the 'pricks who make further strides in race relations in America almost impossible', I should point out that I don't have a confederate flag in the window of my pickup truck, nor do I refer to the war that freed the slaves as 'the war of northern aggression'.
Attempting to denigrate my position by saying it would please a Civil Rights leader and a graduate of Cornell is an interesting attempt to make it look like only liberals can hold the position that secession was based on what the secessionists themselves said it was based on. I will not reply in kind, other than to point out that I sincerely hope that most conservatives also are aware that the civil war, caused by secession, was based on the confederate states' desire to preserve the institution of slavery.