User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Lv 38 Minor Leagues > Lv 38 Minor League #2 > Thoughts on new League changes
Page:
 
Lambda
offline
Link
 
i really don't think the new changes are going to be anywhere near as bad as you guys think. it's basically just a new training system that will take all of about 8 seconds to figure out and coaches, which are the world's easiest-to-build dots because there's no ambiguity with what "4-3 run defense" does. it helps your 4-3 run defense. it's not like carrying or agility where you can write a small book about what the attribute does.

the morale reserve crap is "meh", but it's not exactly rocket science either. the interface is going to show the expected player salary range. if you pay him within that range, you start with 105 morale. pay him above it, you start with 110. if you buy some dumb item you get +5 or +10 or whatever for the indicated game(s).

i really don't see this adding much complexity to the game, and the expanded use of bt stuff should reduce the number of cookie cutter builds.
 
lbrlove
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lambda
i really don't think the new changes are going to be anywhere near as bad as you guys think.

Normatively "bad" is not nearly so problematic as time-consuming. Time needs to be invested in any tool to optimize its effectiveness, both in learning that tool (worst), and continuing in its use. It is now a serious consideration knowing when to use "Free Hot Dog Night" (or whatever), and that is just silly beyond words. Heck, I hated the AEQ rules when they were implemented, but I lived with them.

For me, the greatest problem stems from just barely having the time now. If these changes required the investment of time into things I gave two shits about, I would likely suck it up without complaint (like seasons past). Believe me, I was among the first to embrace changes on defense that were very time-consuming.

As for what changes for me, I basically see two things as major considerations:

(1) do I want to continue owning a team with the direction ownership is headed? Probably not, they are making that the biggest of their time-sinks.

(2) do I want to continue with any of my current players? There will be winners and losers.
 
Lambda
offline
Link
 
how long can it take you to decide when to use free hotdog night? it's like a 60 second calculation once a season.

you no longer have to pay for gear. sign players to the salaries you want, and see how much you have left over in estimated income. subtract promotions from anticipated playoff games, and see how much you have left over now.

it adds maybe one more level of complexity (and i use this term incredibly loosely--it adds one more time pressing the divide button on calculator). allocate remaining money to most difficult winnable games or whatever. there's no way any of this takes you more than another couple of minutes once a season.

hell, if you didn't cheat your way to 100m+ like we did, you'd have to be doing all of this currently but with equipment money instead of lolhotdogs
 
lbrlove
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lambda
how long can it take you to decide when to use free hotdog night? it's like a 60 second calculation once a season.

LOL, I am sure these things are very easy for a good owner. I am not one. I hate the minutiae that surrounds ownership, and adding stupid shit to it goes beyond my threshold of "time spent on nonsense". I also believe you underestimate the owner time delta. It merely transitions a small part of management to a large amount of communication as would necessarily happen when any large component (ie equip) is shifted to the players. Now you have to go out of your way to keep such things in line with the team vision and efficiency.

The best teams in high-level leagues conform to a strategy in something pretty close to lock-step planning. Those team balance/design issues will become borderline impossible with the new salary cap, "water down the rosters to achieve fairness" rules. I definitely don't want to be people's moms, and I do not want to have to optimize a roster loaded with chaff. Maintaining people's morale? Yeah, I don't want to be a candy-striper either, thanks very much. It used to be that we could maintain morale through winning, not "pizza day". Winning takes a back seat to payroll now. Since they are accurately simulating that one piece of the NFL, do you think they will build in players slacking after signing a huge contract?

You will pardon my skepticism, but I am a computer scientist and economist by training, and I know well what happens when you change a huge number of variables in an economic system very quickly: unintended consequences, huge numbers of them. A complete change in dynamics. That sort of environment creates masses of information that must be assimilated. It is not some little details here and there, but a holistic thing. You are literally going to have to engineer new ways of winning competitive games in the new landscape, and I hardly think that can be summed up with "60 second calculation(s)" here and there.

I could be wrong, but these are huge changes, and the odds favor a hefty game shakeup. I personally am less than enthused about spending the time on such an endeavor. YMMV.
 
K-Wurx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lambda


look, you can argue up and down about whether or not players could be successful without boosting before, whatever

but there are NO changes coming that will favor, in any way, shape, or form, players that spend money on the game. i don't know if you're just making shit up to be angry about or if you horribly misread something, but you need to go re-read things because none of the changes favor boosters.


For the last time, boosting has NOTHING to do with what I was getting at. Once again, IF (and it's a big if because I'm just assuming) we ARE able to buy BT's like we do with flex either next season or in seasons to come, with the increase of importance in BTs, those that spend money WILL have a huge advantage over those that don't. Again, I am NOT talking about boosting. There's an advantage to that and there always will be but at least we are used to it by now. However, if this BT thing of mine comes to fruition, that advantage just escalated exponentially.

Also, although I haven't tested this yet as there just hasn't been enough time, with archetypes it looks like it will be difficult to slow-build them. Currently I slow-build all of my players to make up for not boosting every season like others do. As an example, I have players who are level 35 but play at an effective level of 45 due to them being slow-built so it kind of countered boosters in a way.

They are trying to create balanced leagues but what they don't understand is that this will never happen unless they actually make a non-boosting league which we both know won't be happening anytime soon. We will still have teams full of boosters, teams with some boosters and teams with no boosters creating unbalanced leagues anyways so I don't understand why they are even bothering.

They've taken away cash farm teams, a means to super slow build and possibly slow-building in general to try and come out with a balanced product but in my opinion this will backfire on them. Now the only way to better your team is via boosting which means those that boost will actually have a slightly better advantage then they have had in the past because they don't have to compete with SSB teams or slow-built teams for that matter. The more I write the more I think I'm figuring out what this is all about and in all honesty, it still comes down to money because mostly everyone wants to win and people will do whatever it takes to do so which, at this point anyways, can only be accomplished by boosting and in turn, SPENDING MONEY.

*NOTE* This still ISN'T about boosting even though I mentioned it.
 
Gamecock1
offline
Link
 
I enjoyed being an owner and will continue until this becomes not much fun anymore. I have been around since S3 and seen the game evolve tremendously. It has been a good ride and I can honestly say I dont invest as much time as I probably should. I have a stellar staff that makes my life easy and I give them whatever tools necessary to make me win. I only have my one little trophy but my record has vastly improved over the seasons.

So I defintely know that I am not the guru in GLB but I will get someone to help with those critical decisions. My existing players will continue on since I enjoy building them and well that is all I have to say a bout that....:-)

So as far as the changes go, a learning curve definetly and if it forces me to spend $$, more than I normally do then I will reevaluate, if not game on!

As far as team promotions go they needed upgrade cheerleaders to strippers and water for beer on the sidelines and we will be good to go for me. I may not win additional games but my dots will be screwed blue and tattooed by season'se end.
 
lbrlove
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gamecock1
As far as team promotions go they needed upgrade cheerleaders to strippers and water for beer on the sidelines and we will be good to go for me. I may not win additional games but my dots will be screwed blue and tattooed by season'se end.

I have to admit, "free cheerleader and beer night" would definitely raise player morale.
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lbrlove

The best teams in high-level leagues conform to a strategy in something pretty close to lock-step planning. Those team balance/design issues will become borderline impossible with the new salary cap, "water down the rosters to achieve fairness" rules. I definitely don't want to be people's moms, and I do not want to have to optimize a roster loaded with chaff. Maintaining people's morale? Yeah, I don't want to be a candy-striper either, thanks very much. It used to be that we could maintain morale through winning, not "pizza day". Winning takes a back seat to payroll now. Since they are accurately simulating that one piece of the NFL, do you think they will build in players slacking after signing a huge contract?


There was a huge discussion on the test server about the salary cap. I basically used my team here (Green Bay Greys) and Valhalla as the prime examples of why a hard salary cap wouldn't work. Teams like those, all owned by one person, will have players retired. Frankly, if I couldn't build my team of my players the way I want to build it, the whole damn thing would get retired. Networked teams would have the same end result, players being retired if they couldn't be on the team they were intended to be on. That was why the salary cap was changed to a soft cap with a luxury tax a few days later. Now, you can voluntarily exceed the salary cap, but you have to pay a luxury tax to everyone else. If I go over the salary cap by a million bucks, that is two million bucks that I don't have to spend on other things compared to someone that is more cap conscious. That is a big deal at the end of the day, but you now have the option to do that if you want.

It still sucks if you want to field a good team, but it doesn't pigeon hole you into having to field a bunch of chaff players, and gives you the option to send out max cash offers to fill your last roster hole if you need to.

Everything seems complicated as hell right now by reading Catch22's infamous walls of text, but it really isn't as complicated as it sounds. Team ownership might end up being a little more involved, but not a whole lot. It is mostly just going to be different.
Edited by Kirghiz on Apr 20, 2010 19:58:06
 
erbgotti1
offline
Link
 
im going to take the wait and see aproach.. cuzz im already pissed off that i cant slow build now.. u get exp. points even when your on the bench. its looking like this game is all about the mighty dollar..
 
murgy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by erbgotti1
im going to take the wait and see aproach.. cuzz im already pissed off that i cant slow build now.. u get exp. points even when your on the bench. its looking like this game is all about the mighty dollar..


And it looks like you're just about exploiting a system they are trying to fix. You can slow build, you just cant super slow build. Play the game the way it's meant to be played, and stop crying.
 
puubescent
offline
Link
 
ooooohhhhh sssssnnnaappp!!!!

ohnoudient!
 
erbgotti1
offline
Link
 
like i said its all about the dollar, murgy you must spend money here to boost every year to me thats cheating.. you might play a capped 38 hire 37 and 38s they all boost now there 40 and 41. yeah thats fair. exploit this.. i spend a little bit of money here for myself and my son, i dont have a bunch of money to spend here. my WHATIFSPORTS baseball team charges $14 for the season and i run everything team, the players, great game.
 
Lambda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by erbgotti1
like i said its all about the dollar, murgy you must spend money here to boost every year to me thats cheating.. you might play a capped 38 hire 37 and 38s they all boost now there 40 and 41. yeah thats fair. exploit this.. i spend a little bit of money here for myself and my son, i dont have a bunch of money to spend here. my WHATIFSPORTS baseball team charges $14 for the season and i run everything team, the players, great game.


yes, doing something that bort specifically programmed into the game to pay for his rent is the exact same as doing something that bort has explicitly said is abusing flawed game mechanics. this is flawless logic.
 
erbgotti1
offline
Link
 
yeah yeah yeah, pay the rent.. im all for that .. i justwonder what the rent is now??? theres making money and then theres greed, give you a perfect example is look at the forclosure problem... Bort has made it where you have to boost to compete.. maybe there should be a soft team level cap... say your in a 38 capped league then you cant boost past 38.
 
Lambda
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by erbgotti1
yeah yeah yeah, pay the rent.. im all for that .. i justwonder what the rent is now??? theres making money and then theres greed, give you a perfect example is look at the forclosure problem... Bort has made it where you have to boost to compete.. maybe there should be a soft team level cap... say your in a 38 capped league then you cant boost past 38.


this is the stupidest argument i've ever heard. bort has spent thousands of hours working on this game, and you're actually upset that he encourages people to spend money on it? how pretentious can you be to think that you deserve to reap the benefits of his work without paying him a reasonable amount of money?

you have 22 players and 2 teams. why? you've clearly spent some money on this game. you made the choice to have a ton of nonboosting players when you could have made a small number of boosters.

you should be positively thankful that bort even has a non-paying option. non-boosters barely represent a profit and often even represent a loss. he doesn't owe you anything. it's selfish to want him to make changes to his business based on what people that don't yield a profit want, and it's just plain foolish to expect it and be upset when he doesn't.

and are you SERIOUSLY comparing bort to criminal wall street executives that caused a global economic collapse and ruined the lives of millions of people worldwide? i can't even put in to words just how fucking flabbergasted i am by your posts.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.