I think after week 3 the Cowboys are on the rise after beating the Cobras!! Here we come!
Sulfadias
offline
offline
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by ChicagoBlitz
Not talking smack. I like it when people doubt the rankings I do. Gets some discussion in the forums. Keep doing it, but I will point out things I think are wrong
I think thats the whole point.
Hey bud, is the Pro forum that boring that you are coming back down to slum with us in the AAA?
hehe its not that, I just couldn't believe my eyes when I saw the top 10.
Originally posted by ChicagoBlitz
Not talking smack. I like it when people doubt the rankings I do. Gets some discussion in the forums. Keep doing it, but I will point out things I think are wrong
I think thats the whole point.Hey bud, is the Pro forum that boring that you are coming back down to slum with us in the AAA?
hehe its not that, I just couldn't believe my eyes when I saw the top 10.
Chadstroma
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sulfadias0
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by ChicagoBlitz
Not talking smack. I like it when people doubt the rankings I do. Gets some discussion in the forums. Keep doing it, but I will point out things I think are wrong
I think thats the whole point.
Hey bud, is the Pro forum that boring that you are coming back down to slum with us in the AAA?
hehe its not that, I just couldn't believe my eyes when I saw the top 10.
It's not perfect but then again... what 'Top Ten' is? When more people disagree then it makes for more fun.
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by ChicagoBlitz
Not talking smack. I like it when people doubt the rankings I do. Gets some discussion in the forums. Keep doing it, but I will point out things I think are wrong
I think thats the whole point.Hey bud, is the Pro forum that boring that you are coming back down to slum with us in the AAA?
hehe its not that, I just couldn't believe my eyes when I saw the top 10.
It's not perfect but then again... what 'Top Ten' is? When more people disagree then it makes for more fun.
frenchtoast
offline
offline
The rankings will change....neo will probably not even be in the top 10 now. Their win streak was what got them there in the first place. They just had a huge turn around. The list wlll be more accurate at about the 6th or 7th game. I'm working on it irght now.
Chadstroma
offline
offline
Originally posted by frenchtoast
The rankings will change....neo will probably not even be in the top 10 now. Their win streak was what got them there in the first place. They just had a huge turn around. The list wlll be more accurate at about the 6th or 7th game. I'm working on it irght now.
Cool, although I do agree with others that win streak should be minimized or deleted from your formula. It really ought not have a material impact on 'who is best' argument which is basically what the top tens are.
I mean, how is a team that losses it's first three games but then goes on to win all it's others going to get a 'boost' on a team that won all but one game and that happened to be towards the end of the year?
I can see how levels, wins/losses, strength of schedule, points scored/against, etc make sense to be in the formula but not sure the winning streak makes sense... but then again, it is not my formula and I am not that good with excel to come up with my own..... so I am interested in seeing the new output of your formula.
The rankings will change....neo will probably not even be in the top 10 now. Their win streak was what got them there in the first place. They just had a huge turn around. The list wlll be more accurate at about the 6th or 7th game. I'm working on it irght now.
Cool, although I do agree with others that win streak should be minimized or deleted from your formula. It really ought not have a material impact on 'who is best' argument which is basically what the top tens are.
I mean, how is a team that losses it's first three games but then goes on to win all it's others going to get a 'boost' on a team that won all but one game and that happened to be towards the end of the year?
I can see how levels, wins/losses, strength of schedule, points scored/against, etc make sense to be in the formula but not sure the winning streak makes sense... but then again, it is not my formula and I am not that good with excel to come up with my own..... so I am interested in seeing the new output of your formula.
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
I don't think scores should be considered in rankings at all. Some teams like to beat up on teams like Thung Yai and Hong Kong, and put up 120+ points, while other teams are content to just put up 60. That doesn't mean the team that scores more against them is better. NACJAC put up 108 against Thung Yai. There's a good chance we won't put up that many points against them. Does that make NACJAC better? No, considering we just beat them today. The score of a game should not be considered in rankings. I think that's a big part of why these rankings are FUBAR. And Pa Dong beat Hong Kong by 128, while Tongduchon only beat them by 90. Does that mean Pa Dong is better? No, because Tongduchon is undefeated right now, and Pa Dong already has a loss to their name. And don't forget who won the last matchup between the 2.
Chadstroma
offline
offline
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
I don't think scores should be considered in rankings at all. Some teams like to beat up on teams like Thung Yai and Hong Kong, and put up 120+ points, while other teams are content to just put up 60. That doesn't mean the team that scores more against them is better. NACJAC put up 108 against Thung Yai. There's a good chance we won't put up that many points against them. Does that make NACJAC better? No, considering we just beat them today. The score of a game should not be considered in rankings. I think that's a big part of why these rankings are FUBAR. And Pa Dong beat Hong Kong by 128, while Tongduchon only beat them by 90. Does that mean Pa Dong is better? No, because Tongduchon is undefeated right now, and Pa Dong already has a loss to their name. And don't forget who won the last matchup between the 2.
Well, I disagree and agree to a degree.
I disagree, in that the scores and scores against are indicators of how good or bad the offense and defense of a team are. Hence, would be worthwhile to add to any 'formula' in a spreadsheet of top ten.
I agree, in that some teams beating up on others while other teams send in their second teams can make an impact on the rankings.
I guess that is why you have other things to add into the forumla.
The top ten's have no meaning. I mean, it is not like the BCS that actually is a huge factor in determining the champion and even with all the time, effort, money, etc poured into that, we all know that the system still does not work. So, should we really expect more from one of our fellow players on an internet football simulation game?
I don't think scores should be considered in rankings at all. Some teams like to beat up on teams like Thung Yai and Hong Kong, and put up 120+ points, while other teams are content to just put up 60. That doesn't mean the team that scores more against them is better. NACJAC put up 108 against Thung Yai. There's a good chance we won't put up that many points against them. Does that make NACJAC better? No, considering we just beat them today. The score of a game should not be considered in rankings. I think that's a big part of why these rankings are FUBAR. And Pa Dong beat Hong Kong by 128, while Tongduchon only beat them by 90. Does that mean Pa Dong is better? No, because Tongduchon is undefeated right now, and Pa Dong already has a loss to their name. And don't forget who won the last matchup between the 2.
Well, I disagree and agree to a degree.
I disagree, in that the scores and scores against are indicators of how good or bad the offense and defense of a team are. Hence, would be worthwhile to add to any 'formula' in a spreadsheet of top ten.
I agree, in that some teams beating up on others while other teams send in their second teams can make an impact on the rankings.
I guess that is why you have other things to add into the forumla.
The top ten's have no meaning. I mean, it is not like the BCS that actually is a huge factor in determining the champion and even with all the time, effort, money, etc poured into that, we all know that the system still does not work. So, should we really expect more from one of our fellow players on an internet football simulation game?
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
I don't think scores should be considered in rankings at all. Some teams like to beat up on teams like Thung Yai and Hong Kong, and put up 120+ points, while other teams are content to just put up 60. That doesn't mean the team that scores more against them is better. NACJAC put up 108 against Thung Yai. There's a good chance we won't put up that many points against them. Does that make NACJAC better? No, considering we just beat them today. The score of a game should not be considered in rankings. I think that's a big part of why these rankings are FUBAR. And Pa Dong beat Hong Kong by 128, while Tongduchon only beat them by 90. Does that mean Pa Dong is better? No, because Tongduchon is undefeated right now, and Pa Dong already has a loss to their name. And don't forget who won the last matchup between the 2.
Well, I disagree and agree to a degree.
I disagree, in that the scores and scores against are indicators of how good or bad the offense and defense of a team are. Hence, would be worthwhile to add to any 'formula' in a spreadsheet of top ten.
I agree, in that some teams beating up on others while other teams send in their second teams can make an impact on the rankings.
I guess that is why you have other things to add into the forumla.
The top ten's have no meaning. I mean, it is not like the BCS that actually is a huge factor in determining the champion and even with all the time, effort, money, etc poured into that, we all know that the system still does not work. So, should we really expect more from one of our fellow players on an internet football simulation game?
I'm pretty sure the BCS doesn't use scores in its rankings. The thing about using scores is that it's trivial. One team can win a game 77-74, and then win the next game 10-7 (or lose it).
A high scoring game doesn't automatically mean you have a good offense - it's just as likely (maybe even more so) that the opposing defense was really bad). And a low scoring game doesn't necessarily indicate bad offenses, as it can very well be a result of stellar defensive play.
The only thing that really matters here is who gets the W.
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
I don't think scores should be considered in rankings at all. Some teams like to beat up on teams like Thung Yai and Hong Kong, and put up 120+ points, while other teams are content to just put up 60. That doesn't mean the team that scores more against them is better. NACJAC put up 108 against Thung Yai. There's a good chance we won't put up that many points against them. Does that make NACJAC better? No, considering we just beat them today. The score of a game should not be considered in rankings. I think that's a big part of why these rankings are FUBAR. And Pa Dong beat Hong Kong by 128, while Tongduchon only beat them by 90. Does that mean Pa Dong is better? No, because Tongduchon is undefeated right now, and Pa Dong already has a loss to their name. And don't forget who won the last matchup between the 2.
Well, I disagree and agree to a degree.
I disagree, in that the scores and scores against are indicators of how good or bad the offense and defense of a team are. Hence, would be worthwhile to add to any 'formula' in a spreadsheet of top ten.
I agree, in that some teams beating up on others while other teams send in their second teams can make an impact on the rankings.
I guess that is why you have other things to add into the forumla.
The top ten's have no meaning. I mean, it is not like the BCS that actually is a huge factor in determining the champion and even with all the time, effort, money, etc poured into that, we all know that the system still does not work. So, should we really expect more from one of our fellow players on an internet football simulation game?
I'm pretty sure the BCS doesn't use scores in its rankings. The thing about using scores is that it's trivial. One team can win a game 77-74, and then win the next game 10-7 (or lose it).
A high scoring game doesn't automatically mean you have a good offense - it's just as likely (maybe even more so) that the opposing defense was really bad). And a low scoring game doesn't necessarily indicate bad offenses, as it can very well be a result of stellar defensive play.
The only thing that really matters here is who gets the W.
ChicagoBlitz
offline
offline
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by ChicagoBlitz
Not talking smack. I like it when people doubt the rankings I do. Gets some discussion in the forums. Keep doing it, but I will point out things I think are wrong
I think thats the whole point.
Hey bud, is the Pro forum that boring that you are coming back down to slum with us in the AAA?
Pro is fun, but I do miss the AAA chatter.
Originally posted by ChicagoBlitz
Not talking smack. I like it when people doubt the rankings I do. Gets some discussion in the forums. Keep doing it, but I will point out things I think are wrong
I think thats the whole point.Hey bud, is the Pro forum that boring that you are coming back down to slum with us in the AAA?
Pro is fun, but I do miss the AAA chatter.
sbr32
offline
offline
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
I don't think scores should be considered in rankings at all. Some teams like to beat up on teams like Thung Yai and Hong Kong, and put up 120+ points, while other teams are content to just put up 60. That doesn't mean the team that scores more against them is better. NACJAC put up 108 against Thung Yai. There's a good chance we won't put up that many points against them. Does that make NACJAC better? No, considering we just beat them today. The score of a game should not be considered in rankings. I think that's a big part of why these rankings are FUBAR. And Pa Dong beat Hong Kong by 128, while Tongduchon only beat them by 90. Does that mean Pa Dong is better? No, because Tongduchon is undefeated right now, and Pa Dong already has a loss to their name. And don't forget who won the last matchup between the 2.
Well, I disagree and agree to a degree.
I disagree, in that the scores and scores against are indicators of how good or bad the offense and defense of a team are. Hence, would be worthwhile to add to any 'formula' in a spreadsheet of top ten.
I agree, in that some teams beating up on others while other teams send in their second teams can make an impact on the rankings.
I guess that is why you have other things to add into the forumla.
The top ten's have no meaning. I mean, it is not like the BCS that actually is a huge factor in determining the champion and even with all the time, effort, money, etc poured into that, we all know that the system still does not work. So, should we really expect more from one of our fellow players on an internet football simulation game?
I'm pretty sure the BCS doesn't use scores in its rankings. The thing about using scores is that it's trivial. One team can win a game 77-74, and then win the next game 10-7 (or lose it).
A high scoring game doesn't automatically mean you have a good offense - it's just as likely (maybe even more so) that the opposing defense was really bad). And a low scoring game doesn't necessarily indicate bad offenses, as it can very well be a result of stellar defensive play.
The only thing that really matters here is who gets the W.
The official BCS formula might not consider scores, but any of the human elements(polls) will consider the scores of games, even if unconsciously.
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
I don't think scores should be considered in rankings at all. Some teams like to beat up on teams like Thung Yai and Hong Kong, and put up 120+ points, while other teams are content to just put up 60. That doesn't mean the team that scores more against them is better. NACJAC put up 108 against Thung Yai. There's a good chance we won't put up that many points against them. Does that make NACJAC better? No, considering we just beat them today. The score of a game should not be considered in rankings. I think that's a big part of why these rankings are FUBAR. And Pa Dong beat Hong Kong by 128, while Tongduchon only beat them by 90. Does that mean Pa Dong is better? No, because Tongduchon is undefeated right now, and Pa Dong already has a loss to their name. And don't forget who won the last matchup between the 2.
Well, I disagree and agree to a degree.
I disagree, in that the scores and scores against are indicators of how good or bad the offense and defense of a team are. Hence, would be worthwhile to add to any 'formula' in a spreadsheet of top ten.
I agree, in that some teams beating up on others while other teams send in their second teams can make an impact on the rankings.
I guess that is why you have other things to add into the forumla.
The top ten's have no meaning. I mean, it is not like the BCS that actually is a huge factor in determining the champion and even with all the time, effort, money, etc poured into that, we all know that the system still does not work. So, should we really expect more from one of our fellow players on an internet football simulation game?
I'm pretty sure the BCS doesn't use scores in its rankings. The thing about using scores is that it's trivial. One team can win a game 77-74, and then win the next game 10-7 (or lose it).
A high scoring game doesn't automatically mean you have a good offense - it's just as likely (maybe even more so) that the opposing defense was really bad). And a low scoring game doesn't necessarily indicate bad offenses, as it can very well be a result of stellar defensive play.
The only thing that really matters here is who gets the W.
The official BCS formula might not consider scores, but any of the human elements(polls) will consider the scores of games, even if unconsciously.
Chadstroma
offline
offline
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
I don't think scores should be considered in rankings at all. Some teams like to beat up on teams like Thung Yai and Hong Kong, and put up 120+ points, while other teams are content to just put up 60. That doesn't mean the team that scores more against them is better. NACJAC put up 108 against Thung Yai. There's a good chance we won't put up that many points against them. Does that make NACJAC better? No, considering we just beat them today. The score of a game should not be considered in rankings. I think that's a big part of why these rankings are FUBAR. And Pa Dong beat Hong Kong by 128, while Tongduchon only beat them by 90. Does that mean Pa Dong is better? No, because Tongduchon is undefeated right now, and Pa Dong already has a loss to their name. And don't forget who won the last matchup between the 2.
Well, I disagree and agree to a degree.
I disagree, in that the scores and scores against are indicators of how good or bad the offense and defense of a team are. Hence, would be worthwhile to add to any 'formula' in a spreadsheet of top ten.
I agree, in that some teams beating up on others while other teams send in their second teams can make an impact on the rankings.
I guess that is why you have other things to add into the forumla.
The top ten's have no meaning. I mean, it is not like the BCS that actually is a huge factor in determining the champion and even with all the time, effort, money, etc poured into that, we all know that the system still does not work. So, should we really expect more from one of our fellow players on an internet football simulation game?
I'm pretty sure the BCS doesn't use scores in its rankings. The thing about using scores is that it's trivial. One team can win a game 77-74, and then win the next game 10-7 (or lose it).
A high scoring game doesn't automatically mean you have a good offense - it's just as likely (maybe even more so) that the opposing defense was really bad). And a low scoring game doesn't necessarily indicate bad offenses, as it can very well be a result of stellar defensive play.
The only thing that really matters here is who gets the W.
That may be the only thing that really matters but it sure as hell makes for a boring forum.
Originally posted by Chadstroma
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
I don't think scores should be considered in rankings at all. Some teams like to beat up on teams like Thung Yai and Hong Kong, and put up 120+ points, while other teams are content to just put up 60. That doesn't mean the team that scores more against them is better. NACJAC put up 108 against Thung Yai. There's a good chance we won't put up that many points against them. Does that make NACJAC better? No, considering we just beat them today. The score of a game should not be considered in rankings. I think that's a big part of why these rankings are FUBAR. And Pa Dong beat Hong Kong by 128, while Tongduchon only beat them by 90. Does that mean Pa Dong is better? No, because Tongduchon is undefeated right now, and Pa Dong already has a loss to their name. And don't forget who won the last matchup between the 2.
Well, I disagree and agree to a degree.
I disagree, in that the scores and scores against are indicators of how good or bad the offense and defense of a team are. Hence, would be worthwhile to add to any 'formula' in a spreadsheet of top ten.
I agree, in that some teams beating up on others while other teams send in their second teams can make an impact on the rankings.
I guess that is why you have other things to add into the forumla.
The top ten's have no meaning. I mean, it is not like the BCS that actually is a huge factor in determining the champion and even with all the time, effort, money, etc poured into that, we all know that the system still does not work. So, should we really expect more from one of our fellow players on an internet football simulation game?
I'm pretty sure the BCS doesn't use scores in its rankings. The thing about using scores is that it's trivial. One team can win a game 77-74, and then win the next game 10-7 (or lose it).
A high scoring game doesn't automatically mean you have a good offense - it's just as likely (maybe even more so) that the opposing defense was really bad). And a low scoring game doesn't necessarily indicate bad offenses, as it can very well be a result of stellar defensive play.
The only thing that really matters here is who gets the W.
That may be the only thing that really matters but it sure as hell makes for a boring forum.
darkflashfox
offline
offline
Sorry guys, I thought it would be easier to make a spreadsheet.
I'll work on it as soon as I get my finals done. It would honestly be better if a group of other stat-geeks helped, as if I were to run a sheet on
avg level
avg backup level
points scored x .1
points allowed x .1
strength of schedule
and other variables the sheet would be ginormous.
I'll work on it as soon as I get my finals done. It would honestly be better if a group of other stat-geeks helped, as if I were to run a sheet on
avg level
avg backup level
points scored x .1
points allowed x .1
strength of schedule
and other variables the sheet would be ginormous.
darkflashfox
offline
offline
i would think then quality wins would matter, as beating a weak team by a huge margin is to be expected, but if they drop the ball and score less than expected, then they should be penalized.
frenchtoast
offline
offline
My rankings have been temporarily suspeded while i work out a better formula. I will most likely be taking win streak out of the equation and adding something else.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























