User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make weight not such a gigantic factor in realized speed
Page:
 
skipbertman
offline
Link
 
Add a training option to alter weight. It makes no sense that you can increase attributes like strength, speed, etc but have no option to have that affect a player's weight.

If you just add another option/drop down box like "Shed Pounds" and "Bulk Up" that trains simultaneously with the normal/intense training options then players could be adjusted at the owner's discretion over a set period of time. Make max and mins so we don't have 10lb running backs etc, but create a range that allows weight customization post-character creation.

It would also be a good option to increase the ability(multiplier) to tweak weight during the off season not only because it makes sense that a player would train during that period, but it would also give people something else to do during the down time. You should be able to drop pounds or get bigger during a period of time when there is nothing to do but train. That's one of the main goals of a real offseason/training period.
Edited by skipbertman on Feb 4, 2010 04:30:46
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_awards.pl?player_id=1049423

180 pounds... I haven't really seen him slow down all that much.
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
I appreciate all these suggestions but I really think all that is needed is toning down the affect weight has on speed/
 
w_alloy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
Example 1: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=918835&pbp_id=7555051

Example 2: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1001579&pbp_id=1346505

Both players are the same speed (one is .36 faster). Both players have roughly the same agility (one has ~3 more). Both players are the same age and level of decline in the replays. Neither game is a blow-out at the point of their runs, so no cruise control. There's 29 lbs and 4 inches difference in player weight/height though.

The difference in max speed is 0.34 (i.e. ~1.3% difference from player 2 to player 1). So let's do a little math... 2 points at 80 speed is 2.5% (the visible player creation benefit of being lighter), thus the player in example 2 should be ~2.5% faster if the weight bonus to speed was proportional (or be running at 26.75 max speed). The funny thing is that the heavier player should be slower, no? Well he's actually faster, has better acceleration and has slightly worse attributes. X-factor? Changes to speed from S13 to S14? Speed script is faulty?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=919287&pbp_id=11952254 in S13 he was .48 faster than player 1 in the speed script (.82 faster than he is this season btw)... which is almost exactly what you would expect from a player that is 2.5% faster due to weight (more like 2%, but close enough).

I'm just throwing out some data, you guys make your own conclusions.


Those replays are from the 4th quarter of a game that wasn't close. You need multiple 1st quarter replays, across multiple games before you start tallking about half percents and speed script decimals.

And you realize you never mentioned the speed attribute of either player? Also there are other parts of your post that make no sense.
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Scratch this, realized their agility didn't equal out...
Edited by r87 on Feb 4, 2010 15:27:38
Edited by r87 on Feb 4, 2010 15:25:54
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by w_alloy
Those replays are from the 4th quarter of a game that wasn't close. You need multiple 1st quarter replays, across multiple games before you start tallking about half percents and speed script decimals.

And you realize you never mentioned the speed attribute of either player? Also there are other parts of your post that make no sense.


I looked at a bunch of other replays. Stamina probably isn't a factor considering both players have a fairly light workload and the max speed was consistently showing the same numbers, whether it was the 1st quarter or the 4th quarter. The game not being close doesn't matter as long as it's within 65 points iirc, which both examples were.

I mentioned that both player's speed attribute was within .36 of one another... one of the builds is open, it doesn't take a detective to figure out both player's speed attribute.

What exactly doesn't make sense? Please do tell and I'll clarify.

The bottom line is that between two FBs with ~80 speed and ~70 agility... one is short and fat, while the other is tall and skinny... the discrepancy is very minor in max speed (not a gigantic factor like you said in the OP). I also show how a player with the same build is clearly slower this season than he was last season (speed nerf maybe?). Now obviously this is a small sample size, but the controls are pretty close to identical, so the data should be somewhat accurate.

That doesn't even touch on your premise that the benefits of being heavy outweigh the benefits of being skinny... at least not for all positions... I could show you how the heavier FB breaks about 28% more tackles than the skinny one and the builds are close enough that there is no way that big of a difference is solely build related.

Could the differences be more profound in different positions and at higher attribute levels? Sure, but the burden of evidence falls on you to prove your thesis. I know FBs, so I used them as a starting point to play devil's advocate.
 
BearsFan09
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
+1


 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
I looked at a bunch of other replays. Stamina probably isn't a factor considering both players have a fairly light workload and the max speed was consistently showing the same numbers, whether it was the 1st quarter or the 4th quarter. The game not being close doesn't matter as long as it's within 65 points iirc, which both examples were.

I mentioned that both player's speed attribute was within .36 of one another... one of the builds is open, it doesn't take a detective to figure out both player's speed attribute.

What exactly doesn't make sense? Please do tell and I'll clarify.

The bottom line is that between two FBs with ~80 speed and ~70 agility... one is short and fat, while the other is tall and skinny... the discrepancy is very minor in max speed (not a gigantic factor like you said in the OP). I also show how a player with the same build is clearly slower this season than he was last season (speed nerf maybe?). Now obviously this is a small sample size, but the controls are pretty close to identical, so the data should be somewhat accurate.

That doesn't even touch on your premise that the benefits of being heavy outweigh the benefits of being skinny... at least not for all positions... I could show you how the heavier FB breaks about 28% more tackles than the skinny one and the builds are close enough that there is no way that big of a difference is solely build related.

Could the differences be more profound in different positions and at higher attribute levels? Sure, but the burden of evidence falls on you to prove your thesis. I know FBs, so I used them as a starting point to play devil's advocate.


Thanks for trying to bring data to the debate.

I can promise you though that GLB has no room for scientific method and RAGE is all most people here can muster.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Thanks for trying to bring data to the debate.

I can promise you though that GLB has no room for scientific method and RAGE is all most people here can muster.


That is far from true, but there are a lot of factors in these types of issues and to just post two replays and not post clear or complete build info, not mention VAs etc, not give us an indication of whether First Step is affecting max speed, and those kind of things is simply not much to go on.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
That is far from true, but there are a lot of factors in these types of issues and to just post two replays and not post clear or complete build info, not mention VAs etc, not give us an indication of whether First Step is affecting max speed, and those kind of things is simply not much to go on.


FBs do not get first step.

Moreover, the amount of replays he posts is not what is important.

It is his method of concluding the data. He does not need to post every replay that runs concurrent with his hypothesis.

The fact is he showed actual data. Most people in this game post guttural responses with no testing.
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
That is far from true, but there are a lot of factors in these types of issues and to just post two replays and not post clear or complete build info, not mention VAs etc, not give us an indication of whether First Step is affecting max speed, and those kind of things is simply not much to go on.


I mentioned all the differences in those examples... the ones that pertain to speed, acceleration and max speed. VAs and SAs are pretty much the same, the differences that do exist have nothing to do with the test subject. Also, posting two replays is better than not posting any replays and just saying something is broken.

As for posting Brock's complete build, it's not my place to do so. I know it intimately though, as he has been asking my advice on building that dot for a few seasons now (plus a GM on his new team, the build is open to me). I believe he posted it in the FB private forum a while back too, if you really want to look for it.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Don't get me wrong. I don't mean to discourage the effort. Just looking for more detail.
I just created 10 players, at 5 different positions, max and min weight of each. Height varies depending on the position, but is the same within positions.
They all have the same attributes:
Speed: 25
Agility: 15
Stamina: 14
Strength, Blocking, Tackling: 12
Jumping, Vision, Confidence, Catching, Carrying: 10
Throwing, Kicking, Punting: 8

I'm putting them on the team I co-own for the last two preseason games, on kickoffs. Next game will be on 2/5 at 9pm ET. First kickoff they should all be fresh. So that's 2 plays times 10 players. Any other ideas for these dots?

MaxWt DT (340#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950504
MinWt DT (270#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950510
MaxWt CB (202#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950515
MinWt CB (180#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950517
MaxWt TE (266#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950521
MinWt TE (220#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950524
MaxWT SS (225#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950530 (he has an extra capital letter so he will probably run slower)
MinWt SS (199#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950531
MaxWt OT (320#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950536
MinWt OT (270#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950539
Edited by TrevJo on Feb 4, 2010 23:58:56
 
puubescent
offline
Link
 


<---- interested to see these results
 
Warlock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Don't get me wrong. I don't mean to discourage the effort. Just looking for more detail.
I just created 10 players, at 5 different positions, max and min weight of each. Height varies depending on the position, but is the same within positions.
They all have the same attributes:
Speed: 23
Stamina: 14
Strength, Blocking, Tackling: 12
Agility: 10
Jumping, Vision, Confidence, Catching, Carrying: 10
Throwing, Kicking, Punting: 8
They have 7 SP left to spend. Was thinking of spending them on Speed, Agility, or Stamina.

Was thinking of putting them on the team I co-own for the last two preseason games, on kickoffs. Next game will be on 2/5 at 9pm ET. First kickoff they should all be fresh. So that's 2 plays times 10 players. Any other ideas for these dots?

MaxWt DT (340#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950504
MinWt DT (270#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950510
MaxWt CB (202#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950515
MinWt CB (180#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950517
MaxWt TE (266#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950521
MinWt TE (220#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950524
MaxWT SS (225#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950530 (he has an extra capital letter so he will probably run slower)
MinWt SS (199#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950531
MaxWt OT (320#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950536
MinWt OT (270#) http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1950539


I hear you, but I do not have the time or inclination to organize a mass sample sized test... although, based on what I have seen and taken the time to compare, weight is not the culprit IMHO... at least not to the extreme the OP makes it out to be.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Warlock
I hear you, but I do not have the time or inclination to organize a mass sample sized test...


You can stop being defensive any time now. Let's move on.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.