Great idea, IMO. Consider promoting 2 caps from #1 leagues even for non-playoff though s14->s15, as those teams would clearly would have made playoffs in other leagues. Well I guess you'll re-structure s14->s15 promotions anyway?
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Sorting promoting teams by record this season?
headsigh
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by headsigh
Only if it takes consideration to teams like these: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5627 who didn't play many owned teams and had no real business being 13-3, chief. Those kinds of guys should be auto-bronze'd for now, I think.
I think we'd have to start with sorting the teams pretty cut-and-dry, and then the chips would fall where they need to as teams end up washing out or moving up.
Fair enough. Is there any way to maybe add to a script to do something like
-If team is >.500 record but more than half of the roster is CPU, autobronze or something.
Originally posted by headsigh
Only if it takes consideration to teams like these: http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=5627 who didn't play many owned teams and had no real business being 13-3, chief. Those kinds of guys should be auto-bronze'd for now, I think.
I think we'd have to start with sorting the teams pretty cut-and-dry, and then the chips would fall where they need to as teams end up washing out or moving up.
Fair enough. Is there any way to maybe add to a script to do something like
-If team is >.500 record but more than half of the roster is CPU, autobronze or something.
Timetoshine-Metta
offline
offline
Originally posted by kurieg
Do you like this idea? (link)
[] Black
[] White
[X]Shades of Grey
Dunno, doesn't work for me.
Do you like this idea? (link)
[] Black
[] White
[X]Shades of Grey
Dunno, doesn't work for me.
Edited by Timetoshine-Beta on Jan 20, 2010 18:01:34
Originally posted by Jaxon Voom
Pretty good idea imo. The only problem i had with this suggestion when i saw it a while back was that you'd inevitably get agents who tank their team one season so they can be put in an inferior league the next season and wipe away everyone to an easy trophy.
If that wasn't the case then it would be awesome.
They don't have time to do that now, LOL. But yes, in the future we'd need to figure out the best logistics moving forward.
Pretty good idea imo. The only problem i had with this suggestion when i saw it a while back was that you'd inevitably get agents who tank their team one season so they can be put in an inferior league the next season and wipe away everyone to an easy trophy.
If that wasn't the case then it would be awesome.
They don't have time to do that now, LOL. But yes, in the future we'd need to figure out the best logistics moving forward.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Yeah, it doesn't really affect much about promotions and whatnot other than potentially making for a more competitive league.
Well, it could actually penalize teams for being successful by putting them in a more difficult league than someone who ended up with a worse record. In theory that could mean inferior teams promoting the following season.
Yeah, it doesn't really affect much about promotions and whatnot other than potentially making for a more competitive league.
Well, it could actually penalize teams for being successful by putting them in a more difficult league than someone who ended up with a worse record. In theory that could mean inferior teams promoting the following season.
AngryDragon
offline
offline
What about teams that had a good season but really turned it on in the playoffs?
Originally posted by Bort
How about:
Do you like this idea? (link)
[] Yes
[] No
Yes.
The biggest complaint with the last major poll was that people felt it was setup in a way to go the direction you wanted. I know that wasn't the intent, but make it very simple with two choices t avoid those sorts of claims.
How about:
Do you like this idea? (link)
[] Yes
[] No
Yes.
The biggest complaint with the last major poll was that people felt it was setup in a way to go the direction you wanted. I know that wasn't the intent, but make it very simple with two choices t avoid those sorts of claims.
F8n4tune
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by F8n4tune
No poll , good thought and I can't see anything wrong. Screw the poll idea unless it's yes or no and nothing else , but I am getting tired of winning or losing 255-0.
How about:
Do you like this idea? (link)
[] Yes
[] No
Anything is fine as long as it's streamlined B , too many polls with variation(s) of the same answer. Not saying that's bad or good but the collective here can't decide coke or pepsi most times. Too many choices are not good.
But all BS aside , if YOU think it's a good idea now is the time to just do it and screw the masses imo. Let em go if they want , I know easy for me to say......................lol
Originally posted by F8n4tune
No poll , good thought and I can't see anything wrong. Screw the poll idea unless it's yes or no and nothing else , but I am getting tired of winning or losing 255-0.
How about:
Do you like this idea? (link)
[] Yes
[] No
Anything is fine as long as it's streamlined B , too many polls with variation(s) of the same answer. Not saying that's bad or good but the collective here can't decide coke or pepsi most times. Too many choices are not good.

But all BS aside , if YOU think it's a good idea now is the time to just do it and screw the masses imo. Let em go if they want , I know easy for me to say......................lol
Originally posted by jdbolick
Well, it could actually penalize teams for being successful by putting them in a more difficult league than someone who ended up with a worse record. In theory that could mean inferior teams promoting the following season.
Depends on how the promotions work in the end, and what the incentives are for doing well. I could see bonus cash or things like that as incentive to not tank, etc.
Well, it could actually penalize teams for being successful by putting them in a more difficult league than someone who ended up with a worse record. In theory that could mean inferior teams promoting the following season.
Depends on how the promotions work in the end, and what the incentives are for doing well. I could see bonus cash or things like that as incentive to not tank, etc.
Originally posted by vinman
Why rush this through now,lets take time and implement it properly Season 15
So we can possibly have a more competitive season 14, instead of continuing with something that doesn't work very well.
Why rush this through now,lets take time and implement it properly Season 15
So we can possibly have a more competitive season 14, instead of continuing with something that doesn't work very well.
F8n4tune
offline
offline
Originally posted by DrkSandman
Originally posted by Bort
How about:
Do you like this idea? (link)
[] Yes
[] No
Yes.
The biggest complaint with the last major poll was that people felt it was setup in a way to go the direction you wanted. I know that wasn't the intent, but make it very simple with two choices t avoid those sorts of claims.
My point EXACTLY and it wasn't just the last one either. This is your plan and ask whether they like it or not and hell in the end if YOU think it works make it so regardless imo.
Originally posted by Bort
How about:
Do you like this idea? (link)
[] Yes
[] No
Yes.
The biggest complaint with the last major poll was that people felt it was setup in a way to go the direction you wanted. I know that wasn't the intent, but make it very simple with two choices t avoid those sorts of claims.
My point EXACTLY and it wasn't just the last one either. This is your plan and ask whether they like it or not and hell in the end if YOU think it works make it so regardless imo.
So you do good in your current balanced 32 team league, and upon cap promotion, you also slide over to a higher ranked 32 team league the next season.
In other word you would go from cap 26 league #4 to Cap 34 League #3 or vice versa?
Is so then sounds good to me.
In other word you would go from cap 26 league #4 to Cap 34 League #3 or vice versa?
Is so then sounds good to me.
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Depends on how the promotions work in the end, and what the incentives are for doing well. I could see bonus cash or things like that as incentive to not tank, etc.
I'm not talking about tanking, I'm just saying that if you take the theoretical 32 "best" teams in cap 30 and put them in the same league, then presumably a lot less of them will be promoting two tiers the following season than if they were distributed randomly.
Depends on how the promotions work in the end, and what the incentives are for doing well. I could see bonus cash or things like that as incentive to not tank, etc.
I'm not talking about tanking, I'm just saying that if you take the theoretical 32 "best" teams in cap 30 and put them in the same league, then presumably a lot less of them will be promoting two tiers the following season than if they were distributed randomly.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























