User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > I thought Borts new system was going to eliminate the disparity in teams
Page:
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
there should be no cloud demotions PERIOD except to cap 14 to start over


Agree 100%
 
J Hennessy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hagalaz
Originally posted by J Hennessy

not trying to be a dick, but seriously how long should GLB be a trial? this is the 13th season.

Granted the game has come a long way since season 1 when I joined, but the amount of money that I have wasted due to all the changes Bort and admin have made is getting ridiculous. Its not just me personally its the countless owners on the countless teams I have been a part of. buying more flex to change this or re create that or what not is getting old.

again I understand what the concept was meant to be with the new structures but whats the point in having them if it isnt whats being done. Why should a lvl 34 cap league have players who are 39-46 in it.

same with lvl 22 cap leagues having lvl 27 players. makes zero sense. The league isnt a lvl 34 cap then. he should just not allow any player to be on the roster on day 1 that is over lvl 34. or give it a gap of 1 level instead of coming out with capped leagues that only keep you from signing "depth" players that cant boost above the level of the league



Perhaps you haven't noticed, but we're better off now than we ever were. For the first time in.. well, since I started playing back in 2008, I think parity CAN be achieved given a relatively quick (1-3 seasons) time frame without any new changes to the rules. All I can say is a Well Done (tm) to Bort.


Perhaps I had noticed hence why i said the game has come a long way. i been here since the beginning and all I am saying is that they fix 1 issue and then another comes out.

You had easy passing in season 1, you had ridiclous running games in seasons 2-4 where you had HB up the middle and Str I HB being impossible to stop, then you had ridiculous Sacks, then you had a error with screen passes, then screen passes stunk, then you had DE's who were worthless because the builds they had from the previous seasons that dominated were taken over by new builds which forced players to spend even more money changing custon EQP and rebuilding new players etc etc etc.

so my comment wasnt to say the game hasnt improved as it has but for every improvement they make, they seem to bring out a new flaw. The game has now completed 12 seasons (and I have been here for every one of them) and im just wondering how long is it going to take before it is almost perfect or close to being even remotely the same from 1 season to the next.

I also disagree about the parity. anytime you keep having teams who come into a capped league with a ton of starters above the cap they are going to dominate and in 3 seasons when a team that has lvl 40-45 players get through their 3 seasons of parity it is time to retire them and give out more money

 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
There will never be the kind of parity in this game that some people expect. Not everyone works hard at recruiting or knows how to OC or DC (not to mention real life getting in the way forcing owners to sell back or neglect their team midseason). You can't force everyone to be a good owner/coordinator nor can you make everyone build the right players and build them well.
 
Hagalaz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by J Hennessy
Perhaps I had noticed hence why i said the game has come a long way. i been here since the beginning and all I am saying is that they fix 1 issue and then another comes out.

You had easy passing in season 1, you had ridiclous running games in seasons 2-4 where you had HB up the middle and Str I HB being impossible to stop, then you had ridiculous Sacks, then you had a error with screen passes, then screen passes stunk, then you had DE's who were worthless because the builds they had from the previous seasons that dominated were taken over by new builds which forced players to spend even more money changing custon EQP and rebuilding new players etc etc etc.

so my comment wasnt to say the game hasnt improved as it has but for every improvement they make, they seem to bring out a new flaw. The game has now completed 12 seasons (and I have been here for every one of them) and im just wondering how long is it going to take before it is almost perfect or close to being even remotely the same from 1 season to the next.

I also disagree about the parity. anytime you keep having teams who come into a capped league with a ton of starters above the cap they are going to dominate and in 3 seasons when a team that has lvl 40-45 players get through their 3 seasons of parity it is time to retire them and give out more money



But none of that has to do with parity in levels. Passing, running, strong I slam, screens, whatever. Nothing of that is related to the cloud system, or bbb leagues or whatever.

One thing is the sim having problems, another is the team sorting. I was under the impression that this post was only about the level of teams, not the sim or anything else. And I stick by my opinion. The new system caused no problems, and solved a few of the old ones, and is by far the best we ever had.

EDIT: And dub J, parity just means that the better players, the better planners, the better scouts, the better builders come out o top. It doesn't mean every team has a equal chance, instead it means teams get rewarded more for their efforts.
Edited by Hagalaz on Nov 29, 2009 18:11:59
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hagalaz
EDIT: And dub J, parity just means that the better players, the better planners, the better scouts, the better builders come out o top. It doesn't mean every team has a equal chance, instead it means teams get rewarded more for their efforts.


Why are you posting what I posted but trying to make it sound as if I posted something else? lol
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
there should be no cloud demotions PERIOD except to cap 14 to start over


That would be the fix I favor. If you plan on dropping you drop all the way to the bottom. If you gut and sell your team you can't own a new team in the same league type (Pee Wee, Casual, Regular) for 2 seasons. The lack of consequences for dropping down is what makes it so appealing. Take away the appeal and you will see a reduction in the number of teams self-demoting.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
there should be no cloud demotions PERIOD except to cap 14 to start over


Yep and actually no grandfathering either. League caps should be league caps.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Was reading an article in the paper the other day about how, despite numerous measures taken to try and give an advantage to failing teams, and to make long term success difficult to impossible and to retain parity in the NFL, certain teams seem impervious to this and continue to have winning season after winning season (Colts, Pats, Steelers), or alternatively losing season after losing season (Raiders, Lions)

It made me laugh and think of GLB.
 
TheSandman
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=256

http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=260

Somebody lied......

Edit: Put in the right link.
Edited by TheSandman on Nov 29, 2009 22:53:28
Edited by TheSandman on Nov 29, 2009 22:52:46
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheSandman
http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=256

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2892

Somebody lied......


Wait what? His announcement was about caps, and you posted a Pro league team.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheSandman
http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=256

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2892

Somebody lied......


How? What does a pro team have to do with the announcement you posted????
 
J Hennessy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hagalaz
Originally posted by J Hennessy

Perhaps I had noticed hence why i said the game has come a long way. i been here since the beginning and all I am saying is that they fix 1 issue and then another comes out.

You had easy passing in season 1, you had ridiclous running games in seasons 2-4 where you had HB up the middle and Str I HB being impossible to stop, then you had ridiculous Sacks, then you had a error with screen passes, then screen passes stunk, then you had DE's who were worthless because the builds they had from the previous seasons that dominated were taken over by new builds which forced players to spend even more money changing custon EQP and rebuilding new players etc etc etc.

so my comment wasnt to say the game hasnt improved as it has but for every improvement they make, they seem to bring out a new flaw. The game has now completed 12 seasons (and I have been here for every one of them) and im just wondering how long is it going to take before it is almost perfect or close to being even remotely the same from 1 season to the next.

I also disagree about the parity. anytime you keep having teams who come into a capped league with a ton of starters above the cap they are going to dominate and in 3 seasons when a team that has lvl 40-45 players get through their 3 seasons of parity it is time to retire them and give out more money



But none of that has to do with parity in levels. Passing, running, strong I slam, screens, whatever. Nothing of that is related to the cloud system, or bbb leagues or whatever.

One thing is the sim having problems, another is the team sorting. I was under the impression that this post was only about the level of teams, not the sim or anything else. And I stick by my opinion. The new system caused no problems, and solved a few of the old ones, and is by far the best we ever had.

how do you have any clue on what this new system has done? we havent even played 1 game yet in it. So when a team in lvl 34 cap wins the league but yet started the season with players at level 38-40 you think that is a good system?

again you are back to letting a team suck one year so they can be dominate the next. thats not really fixing a problem. you basically negate all the hard work and recruiting people do because 2 or 3 teams are coming in stacked ahead of the rest with their higher levels and obviously they are good teams (the ones who made the conference championships and only got boosted 2 levels).

you can stand by your opinion but that doesnt mean you are wrong (in my eyes)

EDIT: And dub J, parity just means that the better players, the better planners, the better scouts, the better builders come out o top. It doesn't mean every team has a equal chance, instead it means teams get rewarded more for their efforts.


My statement originally was about the parity and levels, then this thread got into a different conversation with you saying the game is the best it has ever been and that was me pointing out that all they do here is fix 1 problem then they have another.

those were just examples of certain sim issues they have had.

it was also examples of how they change what each position needs to build its players at. (How many times have people had to recreate HB's and DE's) not to mention DT's and O-line to keep up with all Borts tweaks.
 
J Hennessy
offline
Link
 

EDIT: And dub J, parity just means that the better players, the better planners, the better scouts, the better builders come out o top. It doesn't mean every team has a equal chance, instead it means teams get rewarded more for their efforts.

I dont buy that either. Im not saying the team in the league I started this conversation about wont win, but they very well could not and some of that could be based off the fact there are teams who have great built player who just so happen to be lvl 39 in a lvl 34 cap team.

I recruit as good and as hard as anyone else in this game. I rebuilt 4 teams this offseason with 100% boosting agents with what I think is top builds. I know how much time it takes to recruit and I would hate to see my efforts go to waste because the lvl 34 cap team I thought I was building is actually competing against some higher level players that slid into this league because they didnt win the big game in their previous conference.
 
Magneto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Z54
Originally posted by yavozerb

There are teams in my level 22 cap with an entire starting roster of level 23-24 players...


That's only a couple levels, that doesn't really matter.


I do think they should do away with demotions though.


it does matter to the people in that league
 
TheSandman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by TheSandman

http://goallineblitz.com/game/announcement.pl?id=256

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team.pl?team_id=2892

Somebody lied......


How? What does a pro team have to do with the announcement you posted????


LOL....that was the wrong link. My bad. I'll go find the one I was going to post and edit my original link.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.