Originally posted by EchoedSilence
Originally posted by jkid2
I think everyone who plays should just get max XP because that is only fair to everyone. This would allow for more depth.
The game is not about being fair. It's about progression and training.
You're saying that if someone is on the field for one play, they should get the same amount of experience (The definition of which relates directly to the progression of one's skills) as someone who is on the field for 20+ plays.
Despite the fact that it is a blow out win, that player is not going to take nearly as much off the field with him as the player that was in for much longer. Hence why a proportion system would work much better AND keep it from being exploitable. Otherwise, I'm playing all my guys for one play against the next set of horrid CPU teams I play and getting them max exp every time. In my eyes, as much as people would love it, that's an exploit of the system. Hell, in some leagues that could end up as just another way of forming a farm team by signing a large number of players and then doing this the entire season against a dead league (of which we do have some).
Also - Are we going to be looking at the same system for the team that loses? or just the team that wins?
Well along that same line of thinking, you think a player would get as much experience from a game where they're playing the equivalent of middle-school football players? Every punt is a TD, and if you somehow don't score on a punt return, you break 5 weak tackles on the way to the endzone on the first play from scrimmage.
Blowout games against gutted teams are an unintended consequence of the league structure and people quitting. It's not realistic to have in a football sim, so we shouldn't try to treat the experience earned from them as realistic either. People are paying a lot of money for their players, but a lot get screwed out of XP because of the system. That's just not fair. At that point, it shouldn't be about realism anymore, but about treating the customer right.
Originally posted by jkid2
I think everyone who plays should just get max XP because that is only fair to everyone. This would allow for more depth.
The game is not about being fair. It's about progression and training.
You're saying that if someone is on the field for one play, they should get the same amount of experience (The definition of which relates directly to the progression of one's skills) as someone who is on the field for 20+ plays.
Despite the fact that it is a blow out win, that player is not going to take nearly as much off the field with him as the player that was in for much longer. Hence why a proportion system would work much better AND keep it from being exploitable. Otherwise, I'm playing all my guys for one play against the next set of horrid CPU teams I play and getting them max exp every time. In my eyes, as much as people would love it, that's an exploit of the system. Hell, in some leagues that could end up as just another way of forming a farm team by signing a large number of players and then doing this the entire season against a dead league (of which we do have some).
Also - Are we going to be looking at the same system for the team that loses? or just the team that wins?
Well along that same line of thinking, you think a player would get as much experience from a game where they're playing the equivalent of middle-school football players? Every punt is a TD, and if you somehow don't score on a punt return, you break 5 weak tackles on the way to the endzone on the first play from scrimmage.
Blowout games against gutted teams are an unintended consequence of the league structure and people quitting. It's not realistic to have in a football sim, so we shouldn't try to treat the experience earned from them as realistic either. People are paying a lot of money for their players, but a lot get screwed out of XP because of the system. That's just not fair. At that point, it shouldn't be about realism anymore, but about treating the customer right.
Edited by Sik Wit It on Dec 7, 2009 22:11:09
Edited by Sik Wit It on Dec 7, 2009 22:10:49






























