User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > No punts in 2nd OT cost us the game
Page:
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I'm sorry but from an outside standpoint re-sims are just not plausible. If you're in the other team's shoes, who already won, you would be more pissed than the agent with the AI related bug. To have your win usurped because someone else feels a re-sim is warranted.

Plus, tactics, player builds, etc. may have changed as well.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I'm sorry but from an outside standpoint re-sims are just not plausible. If you're in the other team's shoes, who already won, you would be more pissed than the agent with the AI related bug. To have your win usurped because someone else feels a re-sim is warranted.

Plus, tactics, player builds, etc. may have changed as well.


if there was a TRUE bug that bort has confirmed as a bug, the other owner would have to suck it up, he won because of a bug, if there was a quicker process to identify and correct bugs, re-sims would be possible.

if an owner complains that they won because of a bug and than lost after a re-sim, i don't think he would get much sympathy by anyone cause his win was not earned.

just my 2 cents.
 
TheBear
Roll Tide
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Checked the AI. Seems like a real bug. Posted to Bort.


Thanks Hikariu for sticking with this and reporting back what the big dog said. Job well done!
 
TheBear
Roll Tide
offline
Link
 
Srry,,double post
Edited by TheBear on Nov 20, 2009 10:23:39
 
TheBear
Roll Tide
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I'm sorry but from an outside standpoint re-sims are just not plausible. If you're in the other team's shoes, who already won, you would be more pissed than the agent with the AI related bug. To have your win usurped because someone else feels a re-sim is warranted.

Plus, tactics, player builds, etc. may have changed as well.


I don't think a re-sim is plausible at this point either. If us losing this game helps expose a flaw in the sim and prevents it from happening to anyone again then we can live with it.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheBear
Originally posted by Mat McBriar

I'm sorry but from an outside standpoint re-sims are just not plausible. If you're in the other team's shoes, who already won, you would be more pissed than the agent with the AI related bug. To have your win usurped because someone else feels a re-sim is warranted.

Plus, tactics, player builds, etc. may have changed as well.


I don't think a re-sim is plausible at this point either. If us losing this game helps expose a flaw in the sim and prevents it from happening to anyone again then we can live with it.




you are a better man than I am sir.
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Known bug affects the outcome of an important game and nothing is going to do be done about it?
Great job, you cease to amaze me.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sixx
Known bug affects the outcome of an important game and nothing is going to do be done about it?
Great job, you cease to amaze me.


It wasn't known until it affected the outcome of a game. He's not doing nothing, he's fixing it. In addition, it's not a bug that result in one team exploiting it to harm another team.

What would you have him do?
 
Link
 
How about do a re-sim where if the original team that won loses, they can opt for another re-sim? Tedious, I know, but I think that would be the most fair.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
they will never do re-sims
 
We_Rule
offline
Link
 
If this were truly an open system, then this particular game would be placed in the announcements, and the game would be re-set to after the 1st OT, and the teams would play one quarter for all the marbles. Since this would actually require some work, then NGTH....... sadly. This seems to me to be a blaring issue with GLB, and versus putting their best foot forward to fix it, they will simply ignore it as isolated & move on like has happened before. "Our lack of vision to all possible outcomes has screwed you, and for that we are sorry........beta game.......cannot see all contingencies.......burp" haven't we heard this before?

I applaud The Bear for his attitude here, and it is hard for all parties when there is an issue where one team did get screwed, but the other team was deserving too maybe. This is why there is a team of people making sure that the sim is correct, and they re-test and then re-test again to make sure the product isn't flawed...... oh wait...... thats right, they dont. Too busy working on colors and lolcoaches I guess.......
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Sixx

Known bug affects the outcome of an important game and nothing is going to do be done about it?
Great job, you cease to amaze me.


It wasn't known until it affected the outcome of a game. He's not doing nothing, he's fixing it. In addition, it's not a bug that result in one team exploiting it to harm another team.

What would you have him do?


Bad choice of wording on my part.

Either way that's a major flaw in the sim. It's not like one player acting funny for one play, it instead affected a whole quarter of game planning. Who's to say what the outcome would have been if the OT ai was followed, there's only one way to find out. But it won't happen.
 
Sixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by We_Rule
If this were truly an open system, then this particular game would be placed in the announcements, and the game would be re-set to after the 1st OT, and the teams would play one quarter for all the marbles. Since this would actually require some work, then NGTH....... sadly. This seems to me to be a blaring issue with GLB, and versus putting their best foot forward to fix it, they will simply ignore it as isolated & move on like has happened before. "Our lack of vision to all possible outcomes has screwed you, and for that we are sorry........beta game.......cannot see all contingencies.......burp" haven't we heard this before?

I applaud The Bear for his attitude here, and it is hard for all parties when there is an issue where one team did get screwed, but the other team was deserving too maybe. This is why there is a team of people making sure that the sim is correct, and they re-test and then re-test again to make sure the product isn't flawed...... oh wait...... thats right, they dont. Too busy working on colors and lolcoaches I guess.......


 
Grr8WhiteHype
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
I'm sorry but from an outside standpoint re-sims are just not plausible. If you're in the other team's shoes, who already won, you would be more pissed than the agent with the AI related bug. To have your win usurped because someone else feels a re-sim is warranted.

Plus, tactics, player builds, etc. may have changed as well.


So you reward the team that won because of a mistake outside of their opponents control? You do realize that many sports leagues actually do replays and that actually entails getting real people back to suit up and play.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grr8WhiteHype
So you reward the team that won because of a mistake outside of their opponents control? You do realize that many sports leagues actually do replays and that actually entails getting real people back to suit up and play.


Name one sports league, besides FIFA, and even then it rarely happens.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.