User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Team Captain Feature:
Page:
 
Flash83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
What I mean by not necessary is that I don't see any net benefit from it. I'm not really against it I guess, because it wouldn't hurt anything, but I just don't think it is worth the time to implement.


And that's a valid point. With all the things that go along with it, it would require a lot of effort put into it. I think that will be the bottom line as to whether it's included or not - is it worth doing all this? Still, I know I'm biased, but I think it would be an attractive "new" feature to the game. It would at least be another reason to keep the "beta" next to the GoalLine Blitz name.
 
NSchmidt10
offline
Link
 
Good idea. Well thought out as well. +1

My suggestions
I like the 3 total team captains, but would advise maybe limiting 2 captains per unit (2 defense, 1 offense: NOT 3 offense 0 defense).
Each captain receives +2 vision bonus for season, pretty simple, small, easy improvement.

THEN if this 2 per unit change was implemented, then maybe when a captain was on the field it would increase confidence by say 1% or 2% for the team. This increase would stack for either 2% or 4% if both captains were on the field.
Basically, it makes teams choose between:
A) 2%/4% offense confidence increase and 1%/2% defense confidence increase (when captain/captains is/are on the field)
B) 2%/4% defense confidence increase and 1%/2% offense confidence increase (when captain/captains is/are on the field)

Last, this 1% or 2% bonus could potentially grow for every year a player is a captain for the same team? Would a half percent increase be to much? If it's 2% initially, then maybe the 2nd season a player is captain for the same team it is 2.5%?

As for special teams, the confidence bonuses would never apply during special teams plays this avoids teams making DT/DE/OL/CB as the sole captains of every single team.

I have wanted captains for a while, this is kind of what I thought would work. Thoughts?

Schmidt
Edited by NSchmidt10 on Oct 11, 2009 16:44:19
 
Flash83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NSchmidt10
Good idea. Well thought out as well. +1

My suggestions
I like the 3 total team captains, but would advise maybe limiting 2 captains per unit (2 defense, 1 offense: NOT 3 offense 0 defense).
Each captain receives +2 vision bonus for season, pretty simple, small, easy improvement.

THEN if this 2 per unit change was implemented, then maybe when a captain was on the field it would increase confidence by say 1% or 2% for the team. This increase would stack for either 2% or 4% if both captains were on the field.
Basically, it makes teams choose between:
A) 2%/4% offense confidence increase and 1%/2% defense confidence increase (when captain/captains is/are on the field)
B) 2%/4% defense confidence increase and 1%/2% offense confidence increase (when captain/captains is/are on the field)

Last, this 1% or 2% bonus could potentially grow for every year a player is a captain for the same team? Would a half percent increase be to much? If it's 2% initially, then maybe the 2nd season a player is captain for the same team it is 2.5%?

As for special teams, the confidence bonuses would never apply during special teams plays this avoids teams making DT/DE/OL/CB as the sole captains of every single team.

I have wanted captains for a while, this is kind of what I thought would work. Thoughts?

Schmidt


Sounds like you have been thinking on this issue for a while. I agree with most of it myself, as the ideas are better than mine, I think. It's up to Bort now. This was the type of discussion I was looking to start though. It's added to my first post.

I actually do disagree with the Special Teams unit not receiving a Team Captain though. Special Teams is a third of the game, and we have a great return man we've been giving the award to for a while now. We'd like to recognize him for that. But I'm not sure how you could limit it to not giving the award to three Special Teams players, other than not having it work for Special Teams. Still, it's a third of the game and should be considered as such. Maybe the script could run like the Endorsements, only have one triggered per unit (offense, defense and Special Teams?)
Edited by Flash83 on Oct 11, 2009 16:55:36
Edited by Flash83 on Oct 11, 2009 16:51:24
 
Link
 
lets get a mod in here lol to look this over!
 
jpjn94
doc ock
offline
Link
 
I like the idea Nice work Flash!

 
Flash83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jpjn94
I like the idea Nice work Flash!



Thanks man! Nice to see you here.
Edited by Flash83 on Oct 11, 2009 16:56:44
 
Mr. Likable
offline
Link
 
Seems like a waste.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
If no-one has suggested it before, there's already an EPIC Suggestion about this from me...or there was at one point...if it's not there, I'm on board (I didn't read all of this suggestion but it looked good from scanning it)
 
Link
 
We already have SA's and VA's that add confidence as well as stamina. That tbh, is enough.
Coin flips are not needed.
If a player is in the Marketplace, then he isn't a team captain anymore. Would be pretty pointless to say he is.
What if a team doesn't want any team captains and he wants the team to all be equal? Why force a team to have them?
 
Flash83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by G.O.D Turner
If no-one has suggested it before, there's already an EPIC Suggestion about this from me...or there was at one point...if it's not there, I'm on board (I didn't read all of this suggestion but it looked good from scanning it)


I was hoping I was first to it, but figured I probably wasn't. I haven't checked the Epic Suggestion Thread. Hopefully there's more to it here that adds to it.
 
inurbase
offline
Link
 
signed

epic idea imo
 
Flash83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
We already have SA's and VA's that add confidence as well as stamina. That tbh, is enough.
Coin flips are not needed.
If a player is in the Marketplace, then he isn't a team captain anymore. Would be pretty pointless to say he is.
What if a team doesn't want any team captains and he wants the team to all be equal? Why force a team to have them?


Typically our starting tailback will only play 30 some plays per game, yet his post-game morale is ALWAYS in the tank, win or lose, good performance or bad performance. His confidence attribute is high enough, though he doesn't have VAs currently geared toward it. There apparently aren't enough confidence SAs/VAs for halfbacks. If you're a team owner, check your team out after each game. You may find there are players who consistently have their post-game morale at a pretty low bar, even if their confidence attribute is decent enough.

I agree with the Marketplace option - he is no longer a team captain if he's not on the team. It could be good to say he was a former Team Captian, like he used to have stats on that team. Those stats still mean something, so the fact he was a team captain should mean something as well. It would make it easier for them to get signed.

There could be an option for a team to not feature team captains, though that's not an option in real life. I know this isn't real life though, and if a team really doesn't want them, maybe they should have that option.
Edited by Flash83 on Oct 11, 2009 17:10:14
Edited by Flash83 on Oct 11, 2009 17:08:55
 
dawgs1235
offline
Link
 
yes
 
gableguy049
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Flash83
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

We already have SA's and VA's that add confidence as well as stamina. That tbh, is enough.
Coin flips are not needed.
If a player is in the Marketplace, then he isn't a team captain anymore. Would be pretty pointless to say he is.
What if a team doesn't want any team captains and he wants the team to all be equal? Why force a team to have them?


Typically our starting tailback will only play 30 some plays per game, yet his post-game morale is ALWAYS in the tank, win or lose, good performance or bad performance. His confidence attribute is high enough, though he doesn't have VAs currently geared toward it. There apparently aren't enough confidence SAs/VAs for halfbacks. If you're a team owner, check your team out after each game. You may find there are players who consistently have their post-game morale at a pretty low bar, even if their confidence attribute is decent enough.

I agree with the Marketplace option - he is no longer a team captain if he's not on the team. It could be good to say he was a former Team Captian, like he used to have stats on that team. Those stats still mean something, so the fact he was a team captain should mean something as well. It would make it easier for them to get signed.

There could be an option for a team to not feature team captains, though that's not an option in real life. I know this isn't real life though, and if a team really doesn't want them, maybe they should have that option.


Haven't noticed any trend in any of our players contantly being in the tank on moral.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.