User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
AdamD210719
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
I dont like 5 or 6....just becasue you win big doesn't mean you should gain less. I dont like rewarding teams for not winning games. You could "throw" games to try to screw with teams.

1-4 all seem fairly legit though.



This makes sense because if you play a team that sucks, your stats look pretty but you should not be rewarded with as much XP. So which do you want? Stats or XP? You can't have both.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

Again, this punishes good teams that stay together. Why?

If a BBB team wins back-to-back championships, they could STILL find themselves in a league where they are being punished for leveling wisely.

There are already SOOOOOOOOO many aspects of this game that balance things for lower-leveled players:

1. XP gets harder to earn.
2. Training is more expensive and yields lower results.
3. SP cost become less valuable as stats increase.

As the game advances everyone is already going to end up at EXACTLY THE SAME skill level, why add even more?


Good teams that stick together should win a championship and move up. The idea is not a punishment; it's a reward to players who play better competition.


Yeah, we should, but instead we lose to a clearly inferior team with 35 higher chemistry because they all joined the game together and made a team. All of the hard work that my owner and I put into finding good players was wasted because teams that own all of their players or play with their friends will beat us anyway because of chemistry. Then we will be punished for it.

We already spent all last season watching the worse teams in the league catch up to us because lower level guys level-up faster. Now, they'll level up even faster, and everyone is going to be exactly the same. What's the fun in crossing your fingers for a dead-even 50-50 sim every night? What's the point of putting all of the work in making a great team? I've spend hours and hours on this game...

There are SOOOO many ways that good teams are punished already.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
I realize that the point of this is to avoid having the lv15 player that wants to drop to BBB so he can XP up and dominate a league. I think 1-4 should pretty much handle this, especially if it is done on a sliding scale. The actual implementation of the program should not be revealed so as to reduce the loopholes...don't say what players are going to determine the average level of your team. It could be the entire roster, could be the starting line-up, could be 'best possible' line-up to remove advantage of dropping top players in the depth chart...

Additionally this helps the new owner of a gutted team recover. Or a team like ours (Ottawa Chiefs Canada AAA#2) that played all last season outmatched...we were 3-13...we beat the two teams that were relegated and our inter-conference matchup. So essentially every team that stayed beat us last season. This would give us hope of making up a bit of the 3-4 level deficit we face on average.

I think we'll be a bit more competitive than last season, but this gives us a bit more hope.

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
There are SOOOO many ways that good teams are punished already.


We don't punish good teams. In fact, they end up with more cash, good morale, high fan support. Good teams don't need to be propped up because they are, well, good.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AdamD210719
Originally posted by bigtisme

I dont like 5 or 6....just becasue you win big doesn't mean you should gain less. I dont like rewarding teams for not winning games. You could "throw" games to try to screw with teams.

1-4 all seem fairly legit though.



This makes sense because if you play a team that sucks, your stats look pretty but you should not be rewarded with as much XP. So which do you want? Stats or XP? You can't have both.


Yeah, but do you have a choice of whom you play?
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Also with getting a penalty for playing teams with lower levels

Since teams are able to bring in players so a team could add say level 21's to replace level 13's during the season. But the teams that had to play them at the start of the year get penalized for playing them early.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Agree with the common sentiment; 5 & 6 need to be tossed, and don't penalize good teams for playing bad ones.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Serenity
Also with getting a penalty for playing teams with lower levels

Since teams are able to bring in players so a team could add say level 21's to replace level 13's during the season. But the teams that had to play them at the start of the year get penalized for playing them early.


Not if it's based on league level, as opposed to opponent's level.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
I realize that the point of this is to avoid having the lv15 player that wants to drop to BBB so he can XP up and dominate a league. I think 1-4 should pretty much handle this, especially if it is done on a sliding scale. The actual implementation of the program should not be revealed so as to reduce the loopholes...don't say what players are going to determine the average level of your team. It could be the entire roster, could be the starting line-up, could be 'best possible' line-up to remove advantage of dropping top players in the depth chart...

Additionally this helps the new owner of a gutted team recover. Or a team like ours (Ottawa Chiefs Canada AAA#2) that played all last season outmatched...we were 3-13...we beat the two teams that were relegated and our inter-conference matchup. So essentially every team that stayed beat us last season. This would give us hope of making up a bit of the 3-4 level deficit we face on average.

I think we'll be a bit more competitive than last season, but this gives us a bit more hope.



Instead of making the rest of the league play down to your level, how about dropping down to a lower level league. Do you realize that you are punishing the whole league to make your team "competitive"?
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
All teams in your league would be punished equally for playing that lesser opponent. So I don't see it as a one team punishment. And in the overall scope of an entire season, one game where you earn 1/2 normal experience wouldn't be a huge issue.

I would gladly accept the 'penalty' considering there are also advantages. In fact, I think against an 'equal' opponent a blowout vistory should actually net more experience.


Edit.. Also, I would use Mean/Median when computing League Quality instead of average, for the same reason I posted in my previous example. Median is a truer representation of the League's quality.
Last edited Jun 6, 2008 17:19:03
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by thunderdoozer

There are SOOOO many ways that good teams are punished already.


We don't punish good teams. In fact, they end up with more cash, good morale, high fan support. Good teams don't need to be propped up because they are, well, good.


I'm not saying good teams should be propped up, but all of these ideas you are throwing out just seem to lead to an inevitable state of all teams being nearly identical. It's already set up like that in the XP system. Not only will everyone catch up to each other and be stuck at level 30 (for example) for a season, but the difference between level 25 and 30 is going to be smaller than the difference between level 1 and 2 because of the cost of SP.

Look, I totally dig this game, and think you are doing a great job, but I just don't want this to end up with everyone at the same level, because that takes away half of the strategy. Something simple, like "no signing level 10s or above to new leagues" should keep the "DROP DOWN PWN3RS" in check, IMHO.
Last edited Jun 6, 2008 17:18:36
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98


I would gladly accept the 'penalty' considering there are also advantages. In fact, I think against an 'equal' opponent a blowout vistory should actually net more experience.



Agree with this. But I think GLB is very clear in against connecting XP with performance.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Enkidu98



I would gladly accept the 'penalty' considering there are also advantages. In fact, I think against an 'equal' opponent a blowout vistory should actually net more experience.



Agree with this. But I think GLB is very clear in against connecting XP with performance.


Yes, and it could be exploited by throwing the game.
 
justafish2002
offline
Link
 
People are making this out to affect everything.

Most games will stay the same. Only a few teams will be affected majorly.
 
rams78110
ROIT
offline
Link
 
I'm all for it!

I have 2 level 5's that often play versus level 11-17. so that would be great.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.