User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Jakemall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Zones are really good if you have a fast defense but they don't work right. Under players almost all always go into M2M coverage with the first guy who runs through their zone...which really shouldn't happen, they should shadow them but once the guy leaves their zone, he should be handed off to the over the top guy.


Which is kinda of the opposite of real life... Zones allow you to make use of players who don't quite have the same speed as their m2m counterparts but are highly intelligent and don't miss takcles.
 
Chysil
Mod
offline
Link
 
ya it seemed like even with them set to cover zone shallow they really would no go to their zone and cover near 10-13 yards from the LOS

kind of bad...
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jakemall
Originally posted by jrry32

Zones are really good if you have a fast defense but they don't work right. Under players almost all always go into M2M coverage with the first guy who runs through their zone...which really shouldn't happen, they should shadow them but once the guy leaves their zone, he should be handed off to the over the top guy.


Which is kinda of the opposite of real life... Zones allow you to make use of players who don't quite have the same speed as their m2m counterparts but are highly intelligent and don't miss takcles.


Which is why zone defense is screwed up. I made a thread yesterday saying that.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jstevens
Originally posted by jrry32

Zones are really good if you have a fast defense but they don't work right. Under players almost all always go into M2M coverage with the first guy who runs through their zone...which really shouldn't happen, they should shadow them but once the guy leaves their zone, he should be handed off to the over the top guy.


and this is the point i am trying to get across to Bort & company...

Zones are flawed and not allot of people care that much about it, why they don't care i am not sure cus Zones can be a very useful approach in certain situations if they are executed correctly by the players.

IMO Zones are a basic football strategy, just like man2man, bump and run, blitzes, etc....
there is really no point having zones optional if they don't work, yet Bort keeps adding new player features instead of fixing the basics of the game.


I totally agree:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3289142&page=last#28627777
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jstevens
Not trying to bash your post Kurieg but i am not looking for a "i generally find" answers....i want the reason behind this from a "creator of this game" standpoint....

Individual Tactics shouldn't matter one bit in a zone for one...they are both set on Balanced and it happened all game from the same formation, so you can't tell me they got fooled from Run to Pass settings standpoint...if anything, lower level guys, no vision, etc.... if they get fooled they should still go to that zone and be fooled doing the one thing they are suppose to do which is cover the Under Zone, not stay back deeper than the players who are meant to cover the Deep Zones

How fast they are shouldn't matter either but if you wanna know i opened both their builds....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=794079
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=779741

i wanna know why they completely neglected the zone coverage called.....

i find it odd that this was posted on a workday at 8am and the only Mod or Worker of "The Game" to chime in, only has "Stay on topic rather than bashing the game. Also, changing title to Zone Coverage Bug." to say on this subject....

Hell, give me a we are testing it now, or we tested it and it's messed up or even tell me to F' Off...come on Mods/Bort...give me an understanding on this




I meant -100 to 100 on the pass distance coverage slider tactic.

Bort coded it such that underneath zone defenders will tend to run deeper than you'd probably expect. I don't know what his reasoning was - I'm guessing it was to protect the users or because the original basic AI zones were so horrible they needed help not giving up the house.

 
ddingo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jstevens

Not trying to bash your post Kurieg but i am not looking for a "i generally find" answers....i want the reason behind this from a "creator of this game" standpoint....

Individual Tactics shouldn't matter one bit in a zone for one...they are both set on Balanced and it happened all game from the same formation, so you can't tell me they got fooled from Run to Pass settings standpoint...if anything, lower level guys, no vision, etc.... if they get fooled they should still go to that zone and be fooled doing the one thing they are suppose to do which is cover the Under Zone, not stay back deeper than the players who are meant to cover the Deep Zones

How fast they are shouldn't matter either but if you wanna know i opened both their builds....
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=794079
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=779741

i wanna know why they completely neglected the zone coverage called.....

i find it odd that this was posted on a workday at 8am and the only Mod or Worker of "The Game" to chime in, only has "Stay on topic rather than bashing the game. Also, changing title to Zone Coverage Bug." to say on this subject....

Hell, give me a we are testing it now, or we tested it and it's messed up or even tell me to F' Off...come on Mods/Bort...give me an understanding on this




I meant -100 to 100 on the pass distance coverage slider tactic.

Bort coded it such that underneath zone defenders will tend to run deeper than you'd probably expect. I don't know what his reasoning was - I'm guessing it was to protect the users or because the original basic AI zones were so horrible they needed help not giving up the house.



I think much of the problem stems from the fact that the DPC play images with zones simply do NOT coincide with how the zones are laid out on the field. I think Bort could solve much of the problem by expanding the viewable area in the DPC w/o increasing the area where players can be positioned.
 
jstevens
offline
Link
 
bump
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jstevens
bump


Are you going to actually answer my question?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by jstevens

bump


Are you going to actually answer my question?


Kurieg, if that is true...it only reveals more brokenness in Zones, that slider is labeled the MAN COVERAGE Slider. Not the Coverage slider so taking it as that, it should only be relevant on man to man coverage.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by kurieg

Originally posted by jstevens


bump


Are you going to actually answer my question?


Kurieg, if that is true...it only reveals more brokenness in Zones, that slider is labeled the MAN COVERAGE Slider. Not the Coverage slider so taking it as that, it should only be relevant on man to man coverage.


I don't think it is true, but I'm covering all bases. TBH, I've never tried to assign someone to a zone that's so far in front of their starting position, so I'm honestly not certain what's "normal" for that type of situation in the sim. I get putting guys near the line and having them backpedal, but not the opposite.

This basically looks a lot like "man w/o move" behaviour when the defender starts off the LOS.

 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ddingo
I think much of the problem stems from the fact that the DPC play images with zones simply do NOT coincide with how the zones are laid out on the field. I think Bort could solve much of the problem by expanding the viewable area in the DPC w/o increasing the area where players can be positioned.


I think they're actually pretty close. I'm not sure I get this point.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
I think they're actually pretty close. I'm not sure I get this point.


Some of them are way off. The Deep Weak Half "Cover Zone Deep" assignment, is more or less off of the top of the DPC page(15+ yards), where as it is shown on the DPC page to be about 10 yards from the line of scrimmage.

I'll put this in my report covering zone issues.
 
timmahhh
offline
Link
 
check to see how your safeties tactics are. if they are set to playing conservative and 5-7 yards off the man so they dont get beat, you have your answer. he went to go to his zone, guy came to it, so he backed off according to his player tactics. no bug, just your players tactics doing it
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by timmahhh
check to see how your safeties tactics are. if they are set to playing conservative and 5-7 yards off the man so they dont get beat, you have your answer. he went to go to his zone, guy came to it, so he backed off according to his player tactics. no bug, just your players tactics doing it


A short zone player should move directly to the short zone. If an offensive player passes through his zone he should do his best to cover that man until the man runs out of his zone, at which point he should hand off the player to another defender and re-set to his regular zone.
 
steellithium
offline
Link
 
Zones aren't perfect, but you should keep in mind a couple things.

1. As had been suggested, fix your coverage settings.

2. Don't use zone 3rds recklessly. Anyone passing through that huge zone will trigger a reaction from that player. If two players zones overlap, they will go into retard mode until they pass their vision checks. The zone 4th and 5th exist for a reason. If you set one person to the zone 3rd, set the other zones more precisely in the same area.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.