User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
carumba10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Tommie Frazier excelled as a leader and an option QB, he also could throw a decent football, he was by no means great at it, but the fact is Nebraska didnt have to pass, they were more dominant then any team you could possibly think of in recent history


All your so called examples work against your theory that Frazier was one of the best college QBs of all time.

-career 49% completion rate. Horrible.
- career he averaged 14 pass attempts per game. 14 ?

The facts are, which you support, is Nebraska dominated teams. They did that with their OLine and defense. They literally ran people over. When defenses put 8-9 people in the box, because they had to to try and stop the run game, Frazier would play action and take a shot downfield to a receiver facing man coverage with no help over top. Absolutely he was a RB who could throw a bit off of play action. Which was exactly what Nebraska needed from the QB position. He would have failed miserably in a more convential offense.

Best ever ? Please.

 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
I won't tear apart your lame examples. It will take forever and I'm bored with Frazier.

But I will say in response to your last sentance... "runningback-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot" is not discounting any QB with added dimension of speed. It's my way of saying a shitty QB that only made it because of his speed.

On that note.. I'll leave you to wipe the Frazier sperm off your chin. Tell him I said high next time he's fucking you in the ass.


You wouldnt be able to tear apart anything, because you know I'm right. Frazier and shitty aint in the same sentence.

"On that note"
You fantasize about dudes fucking alot dont ya? Thats pretty homo, but I should have figured it out a while ago, considering you know jack shit about football. I assumed you were just actually mentally retarded, but homo makes a lot more sense.
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by carumba10
All your so called examples work against your theory that Frazier was one of the best college QBs of all time.

-career 49% completion rate. Horrible.
- career he averaged 14 pass attempts per game. 14 ?

The facts are, which you support, is Nebraska dominated teams. They did that with their OLine and defense. They literally ran people over. When defenses put 8-9 people in the box, because they had to to try and stop the run game, Frazier would play action and take a shot downfield to a receiver facing man coverage with no help over top. Absolutely he was a RB who could throw a bit off of play action. Which was exactly what Nebraska needed from the QB position. He would have failed miserably in a more convential offense.

Best ever ? Please.


He was offered scholarships out of high school by all the major colleges, so apparently they didnt think he would had "failed miserably". Either way you can say that about any player on any team, Brian Westbrook would be just an average at best RB in a power running scheme. Peyton Manning would be horrible in an option offense. Hell you could even say tradition 4-3 pass rushing DE's would fail as DE's in a 3-4 scheme. So that response means nothing, all players need the right scheme to excel. Matter of fact I know Tommie Frazier would be a better QB in a passing scheme, then Manning would be in an option one, does that make any of them better or worse then the other? No, it means completely nothing at all, so dont give me that bs. What you define as a QB, may be different then others, back in the mid 90's option offenses were alot bigger then they are today, but whatever the case a QB is a QB, doesnt really matter how much he throws or runs, what matter is that he wins, the leader of the offense, and thats what Tommie Frazier was.
I think you guys have no idea what were arguing about, this isnt who's the best talent of all time, its the best QB and he may have had a 49% completion percentage, but the more important percentage was 91.7%, which was his winning percentage as a starter, and would be a hell of alot higher had he not had the blot clot problem.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Originally posted by Godzirra

I won't tear apart your lame examples. It will take forever and I'm bored with Frazier.

But I will say in response to your last sentance... "runningback-lined-up-in-the-QB-spot" is not discounting any QB with added dimension of speed. It's my way of saying a shitty QB that only made it because of his speed.

On that note.. I'll leave you to wipe the Frazier sperm off your chin. Tell him I said high next time he's fucking you in the ass.


You wouldnt be able to tear apart anything, because you know I'm right. Frazier and shitty aint in the same sentence.

"On that note"
You fantasize about dudes fucking alot dont ya? Thats pretty homo, but I should have figured it out a while ago, considering you know jack shit about football. I assumed you were just actually mentally retarded, but homo makes a lot more sense.


I have forgot more about football than you will ever learn. You are retarded if you think someone is the best QB ever just because that persons team was awesome. I could have got an MVP if I played for Nebraska back then... and I can throw better than that shitty QB Frazier. Fucking Turner Gill was as good as Frazier... he just didn't have the dominating team around him. Just cause the guy can run around while playing the QB spot doesn't make him a good QB. He sucked as QB. He was good at running. Period! 47% completion? How is that even possible... especially on a team like Nebraska with the fucking O-line like they had. If you can't complete 60% of your passes on a team of that caliber, you should be shot. The guy was a fuckstain that could run.

I think you are not understanding the arguement from carumba and me. We are not saying he was horrible. We are not saying he didn't play QB.

We are both saying the guy was a horrible QB. Excellent runner... but dookie as QB.

Fucking McFadden lined up behind center. He was an awesome runner. Did that make him an awesome QB? Fuck no! At least know the fucking arguement before you question someones knowledge of football.

Face it, just because there was a QB after his name on the roster, and he was a good runner, doesn't make him a good QB. Do I have to spell it out using symbolic logic to show that is not a sound statement? Not only is it NOT sound, it's NOT valid.

You want to say he is the best Leader, or best runner from the QB spot, or best "winner"... thats fine. At least thats more valid.

But best QB because he won alot of games and accomplishments doesn't make him a QB. It just makes him a winner (because of his team) that lined up behind center. Big difference.
 
onlyrockerfan
offline
Link
 
I think your talking to THEE Tommie Frazier, otherwise the back and forth on why he's the "best" would have stopped by now lol
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
I have forgot more about football than you will ever learn.


thats cute.
but i highly doubt it.

Originally posted by Godzirra
I could have got an MVP if I played for Nebraska back then... and I can throw better than that shitty QB Frazier.


No you couldnt have and no you cant.

Originally posted by Godzirra
Fucking Turner Gill was as good as Frazier... he just didn't have the dominating team around him.


Turner Gill had a better arm and he wasnt too far behind him in terms of running the ball, he was a better talent then Frazier, but not a better QB/Football Player. I also think your mistaken about him not having a dominating team around him....Mike Rozier and Irving Fryar were very dominant football players, that offense was amazing. The defense was the only piece lacking, but even then, they werent all that bad.

Originally posted by Godzirra
He was good at running. Period! 47% completion? How is that even possible... especially on a team like Nebraska with the fucking O-line like they had. If you can't complete 60% of your passes on a team of that caliber, you should be shot. The guy was a fuckstain that could run.


Not that it was a big difference but it was actually 49%. Tommie Frazier didnt have an NFL caliber arm, it was average, but I've seen much much worse. He also didnt have great WR's, but overall theres not much else to say about his arm, but the fact he started 4 years and threw about as much passes as some QBs do in one season shows that he didnt have to pass, it wasnt required of him. So the 49% really means nothing all.








Originally posted by Godzirra
I think you are not understanding the arguement from carumba and me. We are not saying he was horrible. We are not saying he didn't play QB.


that shitty QB Frazier
doesn't make him a good QB
He sucked
The guy was a fuckstain that could run
We are both saying the guy was a horrible QB

I do believe based on the above quotes, that you might be saying he was horrible, he could just run.

Originally posted by Godzirra

At least know the fucking arguement before you question someones knowledge of football.


The argument is, is Tommie Frazier the best QB of all time. I said yes because a quarterback is a flexible position, some offenses prefer a pocket passer others an option QB, and some just a dual threat. All of them line up behind the center, all of them are the leaders of their offense, all of them are expected to be game managers and realistically thats all a QB is, is a game manager. It requires an adequate arm at best, but most importantly is knowledge of the offense, decision making, leadership and a winning mentality. Tommie Frazier was one of the best of all time at all of those skills, he may not have had a great arm and he wasnt the best running QB either, he was good at it, but not the best, but even without those skills, he mastered the important ones, he made amazing decisions, even as a sophomore playing in the national championship. He was a proven leader, because even with the most talent in the world (Notre Dame, Texas, OU, Miami, Florida State, Tennessee) you can still underachieve, but because of his leadership and his ABILITY TO WIN GAMES, is why Nebraska went down as one of the most dominant teams of all time. We all understand the argument, we come to a disagreement about what makes a QB, and thats simply it.

Originally posted by Godzirra
But best QB because he won alot of games and accomplishments doesn't make him a QB. It just makes him a winner (because of his team) that lined up behind center. Big difference.


So what else really is there, he accomplished more then any other QB before him and after him (depending on Tebow this season), he's recognized as one of the top college football players of all time, what else could the guy had done? Theres not much.

and for the record, I believe you have mental problems not because you dont believe tommie frazier is the best of all time, because I really dont care if you do or dont. I believe you have problems, because you claim to know football, but yet you feel a QB is a passer first and foremost, yet from the very beginning of football, QB's have always just been what I'm trying to explain GAME MANAGERS. With your argument, I could reverse it and say Troy Aikman, Dan Marino, Payton Manning, and Tom Brady were all just decent players, because they had sub par running abilities, but I would never argue that because they all had great decision making skills and were/are all proven winners, and thats what makes them great QB's. Passing offenses need a QB who can throw first, where as Option/Rushing Offenses need a QB who can run first, whatever they're first responsibility may be doesnt make them any less of a QB and thats where your whole logic is mistaken. Their job is to manage, lead, and win. If they can master those 3 things, thats what makes a normal QB, an amazing QB, and Tommie Frazier was able to do all of that.
 
nottom
offline
Link
 
QBs get way more credit than they deserve, especially in college.
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nottom
QBs get way more credit than they deserve, especially in college.


I agree. The Heisman trophy should be opened up, the best player in the country isnt always a QB/RB/WR.
 
Sithas~Cult~
FireDown!
offline
Link
 
Steve McNair
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Originally posted by Godzirra

I have forgot more about football than you will ever learn.


thats cute.
but i highly doubt it.

Originally posted by Godzirra

I could have got an MVP if I played for Nebraska back then... and I can throw better than that shitty QB Frazier.


No you couldnt have and no you cant.

Originally posted by Godzirra

Fucking Turner Gill was as good as Frazier... he just didn't have the dominating team around him.


Turner Gill had a better arm and he wasnt too far behind him in terms of running the ball, he was a better talent then Frazier, but not a better QB/Football Player. I also think your mistaken about him not having a dominating team around him....Mike Rozier and Irving Fryar were very dominant football players, that offense was amazing. The defense was the only piece lacking, but even then, they werent all that bad.

Originally posted by Godzirra

He was good at running. Period! 47% completion? How is that even possible... especially on a team like Nebraska with the fucking O-line like they had. If you can't complete 60% of your passes on a team of that caliber, you should be shot. The guy was a fuckstain that could run.


Not that it was a big difference but it was actually 49%. Tommie Frazier didnt have an NFL caliber arm, it was average, but I've seen much much worse. He also didnt have great WR's, but overall theres not much else to say about his arm, but the fact he started 4 years and threw about as much passes as some QBs do in one season shows that he didnt have to pass, it wasnt required of him. So the 49% really means nothing all.








Originally posted by Godzirra

I think you are not understanding the arguement from carumba and me. We are not saying he was horrible. We are not saying he didn't play QB.


that shitty QB Frazier
doesn't make him a good QB
He sucked
The guy was a fuckstain that could run
We are both saying the guy was a horrible QB

I do believe based on the above quotes, that you might be saying he was horrible, he could just run.

Originally posted by Godzirra


At least know the fucking arguement before you question someones knowledge of football.


The argument is, is Tommie Frazier the best QB of all time. I said yes because a quarterback is a flexible position, some offenses prefer a pocket passer others an option QB, and some just a dual threat. All of them line up behind the center, all of them are the leaders of their offense, all of them are expected to be game managers and realistically thats all a QB is, is a game manager. It requires an adequate arm at best, but most importantly is knowledge of the offense, decision making, leadership and a winning mentality. Tommie Frazier was one of the best of all time at all of those skills, he may not have had a great arm and he wasnt the best running QB either, he was good at it, but not the best, but even without those skills, he mastered the important ones, he made amazing decisions, even as a sophomore playing in the national championship. He was a proven leader, because even with the most talent in the world (Notre Dame, Texas, OU, Miami, Florida State, Tennessee) you can still underachieve, but because of his leadership and his ABILITY TO WIN GAMES, is why Nebraska went down as one of the most dominant teams of all time. We all understand the argument, we come to a disagreement about what makes a QB, and thats simply it.

Originally posted by Godzirra

But best QB because he won alot of games and accomplishments doesn't make him a QB. It just makes him a winner (because of his team) that lined up behind center. Big difference.


So what else really is there, he accomplished more then any other QB before him and after him (depending on Tebow this season), he's recognized as one of the top college football players of all time, what else could the guy had done? Theres not much.

and for the record, I believe you have mental problems not because you dont believe tommie frazier is the best of all time, because I really dont care if you do or dont. I believe you have problems, because you claim to know football, but yet you feel a QB is a passer first and foremost, yet from the very beginning of football, QB's have always just been what I'm trying to explain GAME MANAGERS. With your argument, I could reverse it and say Troy Aikman, Dan Marino, Payton Manning, and Tom Brady were all just decent players, because they had sub par running abilities, but I would never argue that because they all had great decision making skills and were/are all proven winners, and thats what makes them great QB's. Passing offenses need a QB who can throw first, where as Option/Rushing Offenses need a QB who can run first, whatever they're first responsibility may be doesnt make them any less of a QB and thats where your whole logic is mistaken. Their job is to manage, lead, and win. If they can master those 3 things, thats what makes a normal QB, an amazing QB, and Tommie Frazier was able to do all of that.


Did not read... too long, and you have already proven you don't know shit.
 
Godzirra
offline
Link
 
I don't even think Frazier was the best black "QB" ever, let alone best "QB".

Willie Totten was a better "QB".
McNair was too.
Doug Williams was too.
Even Hackney
McNabb
JaMarcus Russell was an awesome college QB... and he could actually be a QB not just a runner. He could probably throw Frazier farther than Frazier could throw a ball.. and much more accurately too.

And when I say "QB, I mean "QB" not a "RB lined up behind center", like Frazier.
 
3ball
offline
Link
 
Rickey Foggie
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Godzirra
I don't even think Frazier was the best black "QB" ever, let alone best "QB".
Willie Totten was a better "QB".
McNair was too.
Doug Williams was too.
Even Hackney
McNabb
JaMarcus Russell was an awesome college QB... and he could actually be a QB not just a runner. He could probably throw Frazier farther than Frazier could throw a ball.. and much more accurately too.
And when I say "QB, I mean "QB" not a "RB lined up behind center", like Frazier.


You're a dumbass
Edited by blackshirt54 on Sep 17, 2009 19:02:05
 
Sithas~Cult~
FireDown!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackshirt54
Originally posted by Godzirra

I don't even think Frazier was the best black "QB" ever, let alone best "QB".
Willie Totten was a better "QB".
McNair was too.
Doug Williams was too.
Even Hackney
McNabb
JaMarcus Russell was an awesome college QB... and he could actually be a QB not just a runner. He could probably throw Frazier farther than Frazier could throw a ball.. and much more accurately too.
And when I say "QB, I mean "QB" not a "RB lined up behind center", like Frazier.


You're a dumbass


Godzirra is right.
 
blackshirt54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sithas
Godzirra is right.


All of you are wrong on the definition of a QB.
There was better talents then Tommie Frazier, but to say Jamarcus Russell or Darrell Hackney are even close? thats ridiculous. Willie Totten? who had Jerry Rice as his WR lol practically any QB would look good having Rice. Mcnair and williams played at much smaller colleges then those in the argument, they may not have had the talent around them, but they were great players playing against weak competition anyways, kind of like how everybody looks good when the play the lions. McNabb was amazing in college, matter of fact he was offered to play for Nebraska, Im not arguing who a better black QB was though, im arguing the best college QB of all time. I'm not questioning that there was better talents then him, people with better arms then him, or even QBs that could run better then him. Because I know there was, but this point right here is when we come to a disagreement. Your opinion of a QB is somebody who can throw first, which in many cases, that is true, however in many college offenses its about running first, but that dosnt make them any less of a QB. A QB is not about how strong his arm is or how fast he can run, a QB is completely about his ability to MANAGE a game, LEAD his team, and his desire to WIN. Thats a QB, the guy who lines up behind the center and accomplishes those 3 things, whether he does it with his arm or his feet, thats up to the offense, but the key is to win. Tommie Frazier accomplished more then all of the QBs you named, and all the QB's you could ever name. He completely dominated college football, whether he was playing the best defenses in the country, nobody shut him down. You can say he had a great team, and I agree, but the fact he dominated 3 teams in national championships (FSU, UF, Miami), all of those teams had amazing talent too. This is why i question your knowledge of football, because your believe a QB is about throwing a football, which its not.
A possession WR is just as much a WR as a speed WR
A blocking FB is just as much a FB as rushing FB
A run blocking OL is just as much an OL as a pass blocking OL
A pass rushing DE is just as much a DE as a run stopping DE
A run stopping LB is just as much a LB as a coverage LB
A cover 2 CB is just as much a CB as a man to man CB
A hard hitting S is just as much a S as a deep coverage S
So what makes a RUSHING QB ANY LESS A QB THEN A PASSING QB
football is diverse, on any given play you can players on the field ranging from 6'8 340 to 5'6 180, it doesnt really matter, because they're all simply football players, so to categorize a QB as just somebody who can throw, is pretty much something id expect a woman to say ("hes the guy that throws the ball right..?") No QB accomplished as much as Tommie Frazier, and what you accomplish on the field is what makes you the best, not how much talent you have.
if you dont read all of this you can fuck off, cause you clearly dont understand the real game of football anyways.
Edited by blackshirt54 on Sep 18, 2009 14:15:11
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.