Originally posted by blackshirt54
Originally posted by Godzirra
I have forgot more about football than you will ever learn.
thats cute.
but i highly doubt it.
Originally posted by Godzirra
I could have got an MVP if I played for Nebraska back then... and I can throw better than that shitty QB Frazier.
No you couldnt have and no you cant.
Originally posted by Godzirra
Fucking Turner Gill was as good as Frazier... he just didn't have the dominating team around him.
Turner Gill had a better arm and he wasnt too far behind him in terms of running the ball, he was a better talent then Frazier, but not a better QB/Football Player. I also think your mistaken about him not having a dominating team around him....Mike Rozier and Irving Fryar were very dominant football players, that offense was amazing. The defense was the only piece lacking, but even then, they werent all that bad.
Originally posted by Godzirra
He was good at running. Period! 47% completion? How is that even possible... especially on a team like Nebraska with the fucking O-line like they had. If you can't complete 60% of your passes on a team of that caliber, you should be shot. The guy was a fuckstain that could run.
Not that it was a big difference but it was actually 49%. Tommie Frazier didnt have an NFL caliber arm, it was average, but I've seen much much worse. He also didnt have great WR's, but overall theres not much else to say about his arm, but the fact he started 4 years and threw about as much passes as some QBs do in one season shows that he didnt have to pass, it wasnt required of him. So the 49% really means nothing all.
Originally posted by Godzirra
I think you are not understanding the arguement from carumba and me. We are not saying he was horrible. We are not saying he didn't play QB.
that shitty QB Frazier
doesn't make him a good QB
He sucked
The guy was a fuckstain that could run
We are both saying the guy was a horrible QB
I do believe based on the above quotes, that you might be saying he was horrible, he could just run.
Originally posted by Godzirra
At least know the fucking arguement before you question someones knowledge of football.
The argument is, is Tommie Frazier the best QB of all time. I said yes because a quarterback is a flexible position, some offenses prefer a pocket passer others an option QB, and some just a dual threat. All of them line up behind the center, all of them are the leaders of their offense, all of them are expected to be game managers and realistically thats all a QB is, is a game manager. It requires an adequate arm at best, but most importantly is knowledge of the offense, decision making, leadership and a winning mentality. Tommie Frazier was one of the best of all time at all of those skills, he may not have had a great arm and he wasnt the best running QB either, he was good at it, but not the best, but even without those skills, he mastered the important ones, he made amazing decisions, even as a sophomore playing in the national championship. He was a proven leader, because even with the most talent in the world (Notre Dame, Texas, OU, Miami, Florida State, Tennessee) you can still underachieve, but because of his leadership and his ABILITY TO WIN GAMES, is why Nebraska went down as one of the most dominant teams of all time. We all understand the argument, we come to a disagreement about what makes a QB, and thats simply it.
Originally posted by Godzirra
But best QB because he won alot of games and accomplishments doesn't make him a QB. It just makes him a winner (because of his team) that lined up behind center. Big difference.
So what else really is there, he accomplished more then any other QB before him and after him (depending on Tebow this season), he's recognized as one of the top college football players of all time, what else could the guy had done? Theres not much.
and for the record, I believe you have mental problems not because you dont believe tommie frazier is the best of all time, because I really dont care if you do or dont. I believe you have problems, because you claim to know football, but yet you feel a QB is a passer first and foremost, yet from the very beginning of football, QB's have always just been what I'm trying to explain GAME MANAGERS. With your argument, I could reverse it and say Troy Aikman, Dan Marino, Payton Manning, and Tom Brady were all just decent players, because they had sub par running abilities, but I would never argue that because they all had great decision making skills and were/are all proven winners, and thats what makes them great QB's. Passing offenses need a QB who can throw first, where as Option/Rushing Offenses need a QB who can run first, whatever they're first responsibility may be doesnt make them any less of a QB and thats where your whole logic is mistaken. Their job is to manage, lead, and win. If they can master those 3 things, thats what makes a normal QB, an amazing QB, and Tommie Frazier was able to do all of that.
Did not read... too long, and you have already proven you don't know shit.