User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This Bug has been ruining my whole season
Page:
 
teamriots
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by teamriots

Originally posted by Signalsgt


Your tackle is giving up 6 levels to that DE, that being said it's the overall blocking Code of the O-line.

Bort's only tried to fix it once, give him four or five more shots at it.


the whole 6 levels thing is disturbing... 6 levels shouldn't be THAT much of a difference.. especially at such high levels

I know this isn't a parity thread, but there is no parity in GLB, which is slightly retarded.

lvl 50 players stand absolutely no chance whatsoever against lvl 60 players, when, realistically, the only difference between
the two stated players are some VA's and probably a few SA's due to having 50 more skill points for the lvl 60 player.

while I do think the sim is pretty solid right now, the part that is NOT solid is the part where anyone of higher level automatically
dominates the lower level player. I don't know what the solution is other than much enabling much stricter caps, even for high lvls.


Untrue. A well build lv. 50 can play decent - even vs. a well build lv. 60.


Sorry, it is not true. It's very rare.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB

...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715078&pbp_id=12046786
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715078&pbp_id=12048121
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715078&pbp_id=12048140

DE this season overall: 38 tkl, 25 sack
DE vs. your team: 7 tkl, 7 sack
...
...did you EVER wonder, why all those DEs perform so great vs. your team?

I mean: playing your o-line seems almost a guarantee for having the best game of the season.

Maybe think about that instead of posting?





I took a look at this specific team facing other top opponents
Vs Korb (1 sack in 6 plays)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715076&pbp_id=10399488 - DE defeats double team (LT big mama, LG Roadgrader Davies)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715076&pbp_id=10399591 - DE blocked (LT big mama, LG Arnold J. Rimmer)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715076&pbp_id=10401316 - DE defeats double team (LT big mama, LG Arnold J. Rimmer)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715076&pbp_id=10401496 - DE defeats double team (LT Rudi Mentar, LG Arnold J. Rimmer)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715076&pbp_id=10401664 - DE blocked (LT big mama, LG Der Guard)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715076&pbp_id=10402336 - DE blocked LT Rudi Mentar, LG Arnold J. Rimmer)
Note: The LG does nothing, never tries to block. Sometimes the LT win the battle and sometimes he losses. But in RL a double team block (which should be happening here) is not beaten up 50% of the times.

vs Normandy (0 sacks in 2 plays)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715072&pbp_id=6240267 - DE blocked (LT Michael Ray, LG Protein Fart)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715072&pbp_id=6229475 -DE blocked (LT Michael Ray, LG Yeorsh TeLah)
Note: Porto defense didn't used the exploit too much, and when they tried too they uses a wrong location for the DE (aligned infront of the LG), allowing the LG to be effective.

vs Dublin (0 sacks in 1 plays)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715062&pbp_id=9575161 - DE defeats double team (LT General Jackson, LG Pork Chop Cash)
Note: Single time I seen the defense uses the LG/LT exploit

My take: Looking at the sacks stats is irrelevant.
 
HATEMOBSTER
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by teamriots
wow good job throwing gas on the fire, that was really fantastic. there's no such thing as "offensive people" or "defensive people". Please don't spout ignorance just to look brash and egotistical. It is obviously an exploit and offenses have zero chance of stopping it. You cannot move O-Linemen around like D-Lineman otherwise I am sure they would have scrunched the dots together on the O-Line to disallow any gap exploits. And if they were able to do that "you defensive guys" would be bitching that offense was able to stop you from exploiting. STFU is what I suggest.


I never asked what you suggested. The blocking system obviously isn't perfect and has had that hole for a few seasons now. Bort might as well take away the entire D-play creator because any halfway decent play that creates pressure or gets sacks is an obvious exploit. I wasn't trying to sound brash or egotistical. Generally I don't take part in these discussions because it's irritating to hear the constant complaints whenever something semi successful is found.

So let's see, we can't line the RE to the far outside of the tackle so a fast and agile blitzing ROLB can attempt to get pressure b/c that's an exploit. We can't line the RE between the LT and LG b/c that's an exploit. We can't use zone specialist on our safeties and other members of the defense because that creates an unfair advantage. How about we just shift the RE as far to the strong side as dotballingly possible so every weakside rush goes for a TD? Would that make you feel better? Assclown.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HATEMOBSTER
I never asked what you suggested. The blocking system obviously isn't perfect and has had that hole for a few seasons now. Bort might as well take away the entire D-play creator because any halfway decent play that creates pressure or gets sacks is an obvious exploit. I wasn't trying to sound brash or egotistical. Generally I don't take part in these discussions because it's irritating to hear the constant complaints whenever something semi successful is found.

So let's see, we can't line the RE to the far outside of the tackle so a fast and agile blitzing ROLB can attempt to get pressure b/c that's an exploit. We can't line the RE between the LT and LG b/c that's an exploit. We can't use zone specialist on our safeties and other members of the defense because that creates an unfair advantage. How about we just shift the RE as far to the strong side as dotballingly possible so every weakside rush goes for a TD? Would that make you feel better? Assclown.


The problem is not the defensive plays. The only issue that they expose the poor job that was done on the blocking coding for OLs in general and LGs in specific. As a "offensive line guy" I am quite happy with the new abilities of the defense and would like to see more of them. It make the trenched interaction more fun and realistic. I also hope that sometime in the near future we will get the redoing of the blocking, so sacks and TFL will we the affect of good defense planning and builds and not an exploit of bad code.
It is very boring building players that always win, no one calls to nerfing the defense.
 
iv82much
offline
Link
 
I see this bug constantly. 2,3 rushers vs 5+ getting good pressure? How the heck can 5 guys not just keep 2 guys knocked down every time they get up?

Plz get this fixed. This bug can destroy this entire season. I see more and more teams starting to exploit this crap. Do we want to see another disaster like the strong I slam bug a few seasons ago? There were people starting threads about quitting this game because of that.

Not only that, but then every one else drops into coverage, great chance of not completing a pass vs that. This defense will completely take away any 2 minute drill or late game lead.
 
jpjn94
doc ock
offline
Link
 
I was really worried about this DE because of this thread, but we managed to only get sacked once and it wasn't by the DE.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=715079

Didn't win the game, but I'm not too concerned with an exploit. It's more of a problem with OL blocking.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jpjn94
I was really worried about this DE because of this thread, but we managed to only get sacked once and it wasn't by the DE.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=715079

Didn't win the game, but I'm not too concerned with an exploit. It's more of a problem with OL blocking.


It is known that an very good LT compared to the DE can make the block. The issue is that the LG isn't effective those making it a one on one block from a tough angle (for the LT) rather than a double team block.

In the 1st half of that game you haven't faced the "exploit" even once. Purto shifted the DE toward the G which help blocking the play (The G got a hit on the DE which made him bounce toward the LT). Still in all cases the LG is very passive, and most times a sack is prevented only since the QB scrambles which allow the LT to regain the block (due to something that look to me as a pathing/build issue with the DE)
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715079&pbp_id=12855596
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715079&pbp_id=12856808
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715079&pbp_id=12856899

Look again at the play in the OP and you can see the 'right' way to align the DE for a maximal effectiveness of the LT/LG gap bug.

by the way, in this play there is is an obvious block in the back - ugly
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715079&pbp_id=12857230
 
URL54MVP
offline
Link
 
I am the DC for Porto. Look Redbull has been getting pressure from everywhere since he joined Porto. RDE, LDE in gaps, outside tackles....every season he has produced regardless of the changing sim. He was putting up big numbers before this whole LOT/LG "exploit/bug/whatever" came up. As best as I remember Bort said he adjusted something and otherwise the thing is "working as intended". Now I certainly don't think OL/DL interactions are anywhere near good but it is hard for me to call this play an exploit when in my own personal experience with my defense this gap alignment is far from 100% in getting sacks. Is it a "sweet spot" at times? Sure. I mean hey look at what happened to us last season:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=589149

But you know I kind of blame our playcalling for that disaster because we passed something like 80% of the game despite knowing what was likely to happen.

And that leads me into the problem with Denmark as I see it. You guys are too predictable. You called 100% passing plays in that game against one of the better rushing DE in the league. And I pretty much saw that coming. I tend to pack in the DE a lot more when I expect an insanely high percentage of passes. Does that mean I'm looking to exploit? Like I said as far as I am concerned the thing is "working at intended" until Bort changes something else. All I know is nobody is going to shed any tears for my defense if I don't get a pass rush and get killed in the air. Take that as you will. All I know is being a DC in a Pro League is stressful enough without worrying about hurting someone's feelings over using alignments that they perceive to be "unfair". Porto has one, maybe two shots left at making a title run in Pro League. And I run my D the same way I always do. I adjust my defensive fronts from game to game based on scouting and if I have a play I think will be effective against a particular opponent, yes I am going to use it.

So as far as not running that defense as much against other opponents, there is a reason for that. Some of these other teams run a wide enough variety of plays including some runs left that I adjust my defense appropriately. And you can believe what you want but the origins of myself pinching the DE down was when I was looking to merely stack the middle of my defense against teams that run inside a lot. Well low and behold I see Redbull is talented at splitting that gap. Our other DE have played RDE before and they never get sacks the way Redbull does. To me, it is about builds vs builds more than anything. That is based on my own observations. I run the pinched ends on Ocho Cinco at times too and hardly ever get sacks from it. That makes my POV = Redbull must be good enough to be a one man exploit I guess. Granted, there have been enough threads on the subject since then that it appears other DE get that jump too. But like I said, I don't see it as an exploit and honest to god no matter how shitty it sounds (and I really am not trying to sound shitty here) the way to stop ME from doing that is.........not passing 100%. I'm not attached to those gaps, I'll get away from it in a New York minute based on trends and scouting.

That is my response in a nutshell.
Edited by URL54MVP on Sep 8, 2009 21:38:39
 
URL54MVP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula

Note: Porto defense didn't used the exploit too much, and when they tried too they uses a wrong location for the DE (aligned infront of the LG), allowing the LG to be effective.


Because I don't line up my defense every week with "exploit" in mind. It adjusts based on how I think the DL needs to be aligned to best defend the assortment of plays I expect from each formation.
 
URL54MVP
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715078&pbp_id=12042688

Now in fairness Ure does split the gap there too.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715078&pbp_id=12051856
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715079&pbp_id=12851290
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715077&pbp_id=11226564

I've seen people call this play an exploit too yet I don't feel like it has been nearly effective enough for myself to consider it an exploit. In fact some games I barely use it. I have other plays I like to mix in.

 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by URL54MVP
Because I don't line up my defense every week with "exploit" in mind. It adjusts based on how I think the DL needs to be aligned to best defend the assortment of plays I expect from each formation.


Originally posted by URL54MVP
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715078&pbp_id=12042688

Now in fairness Ure does split the gap there too.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715078&pbp_id=12051856
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715079&pbp_id=12851290
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715077&pbp_id=11226564

I've seen people call this play an exploit too yet I don't feel like it has been nearly effective enough for myself to consider it an exploit. In fact some games I barely use it. I have other plays I like to mix in.



The word exploit making people crazy since they think it either indicates of doing something dishonest or that someone is trying to nerf players.
In both cases the pass rush succeed due to a serious issue with the LG mechanics, more exactly his blindness. It may that with vision at 80 the problem disappear, but the read should be easy one and should not force such a very high vision. Also anyone that ever build a OG knows that the 3 attributes versus 2 attributes fight against the DTs (and lack of decent VAs) make it unrealistic to get vision past the second softcap (similar to the advantage HBs has over LB).
In RL the block needed to take the DE or the LB are among the easiest their is. The pre-snap read is trivial and nothing and the situation should favor the offense (whether is two OLs vs a DE, or a LG vs a LB shooting a gap without any diversion). The fact that the defenses can use this kind of pass rushing give them an advantage pass oriented of offenses (rushing 3-4 players against 5 OLs and getting instant pressure throw the inside lanes). That advantage is in contradiction with football logic.
Since offense is overpowered in GLB, many team can survives the exploits, but two wrong doesn't make a right.
 
URL54MVP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Bort didn't implemented a complete fix. He nerfed the super acceleration for the DE (also known as teleportation). As you can see there is no teleportation in your replays.

You can join this thread:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3201107
Have fun arguing with the "don't nerf my DE" people and being ignored by the mods. The bright side is that you will have company.


I thought Bort had fixed the issue myself. Apparently not? Porto has been giving up far, far fewer sacks this season. Last season our QB was sacked a career high 53 times. He had never been sacked more than 22 times prior to Season 10. This season he has only been sacked 17 times in 12 games. A fairly marked improvement over last season. That is part of what plays into my mindset that it is happening as Bort intends for the time being if he did indeed make some kind of fix as you say..........hey if he wants to make the LG block better that is fine. Things in the sim change every year as it is my job as a DC to adjust.

The sim overall needs a lot more work before we worry about things like coaching. Hey I could complain about a lot of things that work against the defense at times in the sim too........like how retarded the LB pathing gets at times. 2 or more guys will just run straight into an engaged block and essentially cause one blocker to take 3 guys out of a play at once. It goes from broken to fixed to broken again over time it seems. A fine tuned sim will benefit both offense and defense ultimately IMO.

I just want to be clear I am not against interactions being improved but nothing is perfect in this game and everyone both OC and DC has to deal with some things we aren't always thrilled with.
 
URL54MVP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
The word exploit making people crazy since they think it either indicates of doing something dishonest or that someone is trying to nerf players.
In both cases the pass rush succeed due to a serious issue with the LG mechanics, more exactly his blindness. It may that with vision at 80 the problem disappear, but the read should be easy one and should not force such a very high vision. Also anyone that ever build a OG knows that the 3 attributes versus 2 attributes fight against the DTs (and lack of decent VAs) make it unrealistic to get vision past the second softcap (similar to the advantage HBs has over LB).
In RL the block needed to take the DE or the LB are among the easiest their is. The pre-snap read is trivial and nothing and the situation should favor the offense (whether is two OLs vs a DE, or a LG vs a LB shooting a gap without any diversion). The fact that the defenses can use this kind of pass rushing give them an advantage pass oriented of offenses (rushing 3-4 players against 5 OLs and getting instant pressure throw the inside lanes). That advantage is in contradiction with football logic.
Since offense is overpowered in GLB, many team can survives the exploits, but two wrong doesn't make a right.


I gave up on trying to pretend dotball is like real life football many seasons ago.

And yeah I guess I let the word "exploit" drive me crazy but it does feel like people are saying I am doing dishonest things in running my defense. That does upset me a tad. The things that I use that are considered "exploits" now were just new plays I stumbled into on my own or were posted as plays with good potential in private DPC forums......before anyone was calling out the plays as exploits. I did not read threads saying OMG GUYS USE THIS PLAY IT IS TEH EXPLOIT. I starting pinching the DL for certain running plays and stumbled upon how good Redbull was at shooting the gap at pass plays too. The 326 ROLB blitz is just a simple variation of the old 335 weak ROLB blitzes that I used to run. Somebody posts it in a private forum saying it is effective at getting pressure so I try it. It does get pressure better than other blitzes I use. But then next thing I know that play has it's own thread in Bugs forum. As a DC it is just frustrating that during our every constant battle with a changing sim that when we find something that seems above average useful, it gets lambasted as an exploit or bug or whatever. In my experience Pro Leagues are pretty damn ruthless so.........do I abandon an alignment that works just because my treasure is another man's bug? I agree ultimately two wrongs don't make a right but that is seemingly the way this sim has been since I can remember. Until or if Bort ever makes the sim more solid then what else can you do?


Edit - also I definitely don't see it as an issue of people trying to nerf DE. Redbull was getting sacks at an amazing rate before this "gap" controversy. Just look at his numbers since joining Porto in season 7.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=583722&pbp_id=19619886
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=583722&pbp_id=19620190
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=583722&pbp_id=19620246
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=586541&pbp_id=21313442
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=586541&pbp_id=21320114
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=585745&pbp_id=20466246
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=478471&pbp_id=11486402 - at LDE too
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=478471&pbp_id=11486838 - LDE
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=478471&pbp_id=11490354 - LDE
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=478471&pbp_id=11492197 - LDE

That is a small sampling of his season 9 sacks. The guy has always produced wherever I put him. Therefore to me I never paid much special notice to him getting sacks "in the gap" last season until I started seeing threads complaining about it. I just always figure the guy is going to produce regardless of what happens with the sim.
Edited by URL54MVP on Sep 8, 2009 22:54:29
Edited by URL54MVP on Sep 8, 2009 22:47:34
Edited by URL54MVP on Sep 8, 2009 22:33:30
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by URL54MVP
I thought Bort had fixed the issue myself. Apparently not? Porto has been giving up far, far fewer sacks this season. Last season our QB was sacked a career high 53 times. He had never been sacked more than 22 times prior to Season 10. This season he has only been sacked 17 times in 12 games. A fairly marked improvement over last season. That is part of what plays into my mindset that it is happening as Bort intends for the time being if he did indeed make some kind of fix as you say..........hey if he wants to make the LG block better that is fine. Things in the sim change every year as it is my job as a DC to adjust.

The sim overall needs a lot more work before we worry about things like coaching. Hey I could complain about a lot of things that work against the defense at times in the sim too........like how retarded the LB pathing gets at times. 2 or more guys will just run straight into an engaged block and essentially cause one blocker to take 3 guys out of a play at once. It goes from broken to fixed to broken again over time it seems. A fine tuned sim will benefit both offense and defense ultimately IMO.

I just want to be clear I am not against interactions being improved but nothing is perfect in this game and everyone both OC and DC has to deal with some things we aren't always thrilled with.


Bort nerfed DEs by limiting the acceleration they got after splitting the double team, stopping the teleporting DEs bug. This fix now allow the LT to regain blocks and it look just ugly:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715079&pbp_id=12857230
Also slowing down the DE gave some extra time for the QB which reduced the amount of sacks.

But the real bug was that there is no double team block since the OGs are too static. I am quite sure that if Bort was implementing a football solution instead of a nerf, the problem would be solved and the DEs could enjoy their attributes as before (probably effects in other game situations).

The problem with the OLs blocking mechanism is part of the game since season 1 and never being addressed in a serious way. Every few season Bort introduce some changes that never solve the core issue which is the football logic (except the OT being able to take a step backward to form a pocket, also known as the big DE nerf).
In term of "football looks" of the replays, the blocking (specially OL/DL) is one of the leading wrongs in the game. And it is here since ever.

About the defense issue, I totally agree there are many silly things that need to be corrected: QB hurrying, pursuit responsibiltes, choosing blitz gap and drop zone, coverage issue with HBs/TEs, deep zones logic (and that is probably a ultra short list)
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by URL54MVP
I gave up on trying to pretend dotball is like real life football many seasons ago.

And yeah I guess I let the word "exploit" drive me crazy but it does feel like people are saying I am doing dishonest things in running my defense. That does upset me a tad. The things that I use that are considered "exploits" now were just new plays I stumbled into on my own or were posted as plays with good potential in private DPC forums......before anyone was calling out the plays as exploits. I did not read threads saying OMG GUYS USE THIS PLAY IT IS TEH EXPLOIT. I starting pinching the DL for certain running plays and stumbled upon how good Redbull was at shooting the gap at pass plays too. The 326 ROLB blitz is just a simple variation of the old 335 weak ROLB blitzes that I used to run. Somebody posts it in a private forum saying it is effective at getting pressure so I try it. It does get pressure better than other blitzes I use. But then next thing I know that play has it's own thread in Bugs forum. As a DC it is just frustrating that during our every constant battle with a changing sim that when we find something that seems above average useful, it gets lambasted as an exploit or bug or whatever. In my experience Pro Leagues are pretty damn ruthless so.........do I abandon an alignment that works just because my treasure is another man's bug? I agree ultimately two wrongs don't make a right but that is seemingly the way this sim has been since I can remember. Until or if Bort ever makes the sim more solid then what else can you do?


A OC/DC that doesn't uses "exploits" that can help the team win is doing wrong to his job. It is on Bort to set the rules, and OC/DC should maximize the win chance within the rules.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.