User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - Item Crafting
Page:
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by whitewolf

I definitely think all crafting should require you to have had the skills as a player in order to do it. If I never had Line General how can I possibly teach it?

The rest of it sounds neat, the tiered system certainly sounds good.


Ah, that's an interesting take. You can only teach the SA's you learned? It would probably make the +% bonuses more popular.


It might. Another possibly neat thing might be people that were really good at something, like say deflecting passes, would get a minor bonus to making items related to that. But really good would have to be people that earned trophies in a certain stat.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by whitewolf

I definitely think all crafting should require you to have had the skills as a player in order to do it. If I never had Line General how can I possibly teach it?

The rest of it sounds neat, the tiered system certainly sounds good.


Ah, that's an interesting take. You can only teach the SA's you learned? It would probably make the +% bonuses more popular.


Make the % bonuses and SA's like AEQ, but make it to where the player has to achieve the same lvl as buying AEQ and using Bonus tokens too. So a lvl 1 doesn't have like 20% tackling chance or 5 super vision. Or do they have to update them with their own BT's?
 
christianhall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by christianhall

By disappears, do you mean the item is permanently deleted, or it just returns to the coaches 'inventory', and he can then make it available for purchase for another player?


Gone gone. We want to encourage players to stick around and use their equipment, not make an infinite supply of equipment.


OK. What if the coach and player both leave at the same time to go to the same team, in order to stick together. Would that be an exception to the item deletion rule? Obviously if it was, you'd need a way to tell that the player and coach are both moving at the same time. Perhaps contract and trade options that allow both the player and coach to be signed at the same time (obviously with separate contracts though). On second thoughts though, people may try to exploit by signing multiple players and coaches together to keep equipment, though I think that exploit could be covered by the fact there are limited coaching spots.
 
christianhall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by whitewolf

I definitely think all crafting should require you to have had the skills as a player in order to do it. If I never had Line General how can I possibly teach it?

The rest of it sounds neat, the tiered system certainly sounds good.


Ah, that's an interesting take. You can only teach the SA's you learned? It would probably make the +% bonuses more popular.


As you have to purchase these modifiers to use on the equipment, how about just make the ones which were learned as a player slightly cheaper than those not used. This keeps the door open to allow players to create items with any positions modifiers that they like, but gives an incentive to stick to the players natural position.
 
Link
 
and also to make it up to so many pieces you can use. Is it like endorsement deals or is it like an actual piece of EQ like AEQ counts as?
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Brandonhicks16
and also to make it up to so many pieces you can use. Is it like endorsement deals or is it like an actual piece of EQ like AEQ counts as?


I would think only 1 piece per player, in a "Coaches Item" slot.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by christianhall
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by christianhall


By disappears, do you mean the item is permanently deleted, or it just returns to the coaches 'inventory', and he can then make it available for purchase for another player?


Gone gone. We want to encourage players to stick around and use their equipment, not make an infinite supply of equipment.


OK. What if the coach and player both leave at the same time to go to the same team, in order to stick together. Would that be an exception to the item deletion rule? Obviously if it was, you'd need a way to tell that the player and coach are both moving at the same time. Perhaps contract and trade options that allow both the player and coach to be signed at the same time (obviously with separate contracts though). On second thoughts though, people may try to exploit by signing multiple players and coaches together to keep equipment, though I think that exploit could be covered by the fact there are limited coaching spots.


Since the underlying thing paying for all this is the team itself, I would think they would not want other teams to benefit. It's also just a lot simpler to have a clear line: You leave the team, you lose the item.
 
Link
 
Come on bort please respond to some of this. It's YOUR THREAD
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Brandonhicks16
Come on bort please respond to some of this. It's YOUR THREAD


He has been responding. How about a little patience, Bort has a lot to do.
 
jkid2
offline
Link
 
quick question: will coaches be able to boost as coaches even though they can't as players?
 
Link
 
Yes I know this, I'mjust impatient and want to know now.

But I'll pick up on this Tmrw, I'm going to a party tongight so need to shower, and get dressed so I can leave by 915
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jkid2
quick question: will coaches be able to boost as coaches even though they can't as players?


Idk, I wouldn't think so, but how long will a coach be able to coach, Jo Pa and Bobby Bowden are in their 80's, so How would we cap that?
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Interesting, would these items be limited to one bonus, or could they have dual bonuses similar to standard AE's such as two +% bonuses on one item?
Edited by Saris on Sep 4, 2009 19:32:07
 
christianhall
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Interesting, would these items be limited to one bonus, or could they have dual bonuses similar to standard gear, such as two +% bonuses on one item?

Was just about to ask this. I reckon that there will have to be a max on the number of modifiers an item can have. I' reckon it will be the same as a piece of advanced EQ, though maybe Bort has other ideas. Also, when the crafted item is purchased by the player, is it considered upgraded to the same level as advanced EQ ie level 0?
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
I just want to make sure of something...the items made here must follow the exact same rules current AE follows. Nothing can start out as +2 SA, nothing can have +1 SA +1 SA, nothing can come with a bonus of more than +3 Attribute or +5%, right?

Essentially, having a crafting coach should be useless if everyone on your team already has the "perfect" AE (highly, highly doubtful, but you know what I mean). Crafting shouldn't be allowed to make new godly items, it should just be a way of controlling the current AE store.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.