User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Bug against 5WR offense formation... Is it a bug?
Page:
 
jdpbernal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
wow only 52 vision, could be a failed vision check.


Failed vision check? C'mon man, there's no one in front of the center for him to fail a vision check.
 
jdpbernal
offline
Link
 
I knew people will say that its a failed vision check but here's the build of the center that was playing on the plays that I posted.

Strength: 103.95
Blocking: 85.69
Speed: 49
Tackling: 17.16
Agility: 61.16
Throwing: 10
Jumping: 10
Catching: 10
Stamina: 58.42
Carrying: 10
Vision: 58.16
Kicking: 8
Confidence: 51.16
Punting: 10

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
I don't think it's a bug to be honest, looks more like they're using the DPC to avoid the C with their players - effectively putting 3 men vs 3 men on the O-Line (and trying to weight it to one side) alienating or reducing the benefit of having 5 O-Liners out there.

The O-Line should adjust better really, but it doesn't at the moment. It's exploity in a "everyone does it and it's not really such an exploit as it is an oft repeated ploy that doesn't work all that often."
 
jdpbernal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
I don't think it's a bug to be honest, looks more like they're using the DPC to avoid the C with their players - effectively putting 3 men vs 3 men on the O-Line (and trying to weight it to one side) alienating or reducing the benefit of having 5 O-Liners out there.

The O-Line should adjust better really, but it doesn't at the moment. It's exploity in a "everyone does it and it's not really such an exploit as it is an oft repeated ploy that doesn't work all that often."


All throughout the game when I ran the 5WR SG formation and they ran that DPC formation the center just hangs in there and does nothing. Is that not a bug?

On some plays, I see that the other team did not line up the NT against the RG which is different DPC formation.

 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
I don't think it's a bug to be honest, looks more like they're using the DPC to avoid the C with their players - effectively putting 3 men vs 3 men on the O-Line (and trying to weight it to one side) alienating or reducing the benefit of having 5 O-Liners out there.

The O-Line should adjust better really, but it doesn't at the moment. It's exploity in a "everyone does it and it's not really such an exploit as it is an oft repeated ploy that doesn't work all that often."


didn't bort say though, that with the DPC he wanted to avoid exploits with guaranteed sacks(i forget the term he used though).

this seems to fall under that category.
 
jdpbernal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RMiller517
didn't bort say though, that with the DPC he wanted to avoid exploits with guaranteed sacks(i forget the term he used though).

this seems to fall under that category.


Well as per post by Koncorde that this is not an then let's use that DPC formation against 5WR SG offense set.
I'll recommend that DPC play to all the teams that I play in and beat that 5WR SG formation to thy kingdom come.

Edited by jdpbernal on Sep 4, 2009 11:40:25
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RMiller517
didn't bort say though, that with the DPC he wanted to avoid exploits with guaranteed sacks(i forget the term he used though).

this seems to fall under that category.


Is it a guarranteed sack? Overload blitz are a known factor in the game. The MLB piggy backing the NT and the NT engaging the RG only is a very common tactic. However it doesn't always work.

I don't really count any interaction between level 45 guards, centers vs level 57+ DE's and DT's a particularly fair comparison to make when gauging whether something is a "bug" when it only seems to have worked against 1 team.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
^ excalty there is a big level difference between the d-line and that center/o-lne
 
jdpbernal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Is it a guarranteed sack? Overload blitz are a known factor in the game. The MLB piggy backing the NT and the NT engaging the RG only is a very common tactic. However it doesn't always work.

I don't really count any interaction between level 45 guards, centers vs level 57+ DE's and DT's a particularly fair comparison to make when gauging whether something is a "bug" when it only seems to have worked against 1 team.


I'm going to run this formation on a same level teams to make sure that it is bug OR not a bug.
 
jdpbernal
offline
Link
 
@ Koncorde
- even though the levels are different, you have to take into consideration that the C there just didn't do anything at all. I mean, he just sat in the middle with a mild attempt to go at the NT but "decided" not to. That's what surprised me. The center should have at "least" tried to engage the NT and help out the RG.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
His "mild attempt" might have been a block attempt, which failed because of the level difference. After that he's out of position to make a play.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
i'd love to see some sort of testing server game where a 5WR set is run and this is the defense, with an optimally build C and RG.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RMiller517
i'd love to see some sort of testing server game where a 5WR set is run and this is the defense, with an optimally build C and RG.


I'd like to see this happen in more than 1 of the other 9 games that same defence has played this season already...
 
jdpbernal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
I'd like to see this happen in more than 1 of the other 9 games that same defence has played this season already...


Your wish is my command.... here are your plays same team but different opponents.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=728375&pbp_id=9504029
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=728388&pbp_id=8658661

I would believe there will be other in there but I don't have a lot of time to watch every team on my league play.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Magically their NT makes an impact, it's the RG that fails in both those examples...

This tells me that:
A - your NT didn't do his job.
B - their RG didn't do their job.

Moar.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.