It'll be weird in AA or AAA when you need to gameplan more than a couple of times a season like in the minors
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Uncapped Minors = Worst part of GLB / Fix = Top Season 12 Priority
Octowned
offline
offline
Give it another season. WPL caused a lot of pre-mature jumps into AA, leading to some real garbage AA teams and no talent left in the uncapped minors. After a few seasons of established uncapped play, things will level out I imagine.
But yeah, my team was one of the "win by 50+ every time" last season. 20-0. Doing OK in AA, but certainly not a force yet. Kind of a weird jump... we're adjusting, though.
But yeah, my team was one of the "win by 50+ every time" last season. 20-0. Doing OK in AA, but certainly not a force yet. Kind of a weird jump... we're adjusting, though.
merenoise
offline
offline
Originally posted by griffin8r
PS:
It's bad enough it used to take 3-4 seasons to get from a 13-cap BBB to AA in a reasonably competitive region.
Now it takes a MINIMUM of 4 just to get to uncapped.
And you want more? Bite me. I want at least a snowball's chance in hell of making it to the WL with one roster of players, instead of having to build an intricate network of farm teams because whiners made it impossible to get from 13 to Pro in fewer than 10 seasons.
Yeah, I agree with Griff. More caps isn't the answer. The problem which arises from more caps is that there is always going to be a contingent of people who want a higher cap because their builds and/or game planning aren't up to the task. Truth is some teams are going to be stuck in the minors uncapped league until they gut, not because of level disparity but because they are filled with builds that are sub par because they recruited at the top of the previous cap rather than going for lower leveled but more efficiently built players. Other teams will end up staying mired because they are crappy at game planning, scouting or other GM related issues. The cream of the crop will pull themselves out and get to AA fairly quickly. And really isn't that the goal of the cloud? To separate the wheat from the chaff so to speak?
PS:
It's bad enough it used to take 3-4 seasons to get from a 13-cap BBB to AA in a reasonably competitive region.
Now it takes a MINIMUM of 4 just to get to uncapped.
And you want more? Bite me. I want at least a snowball's chance in hell of making it to the WL with one roster of players, instead of having to build an intricate network of farm teams because whiners made it impossible to get from 13 to Pro in fewer than 10 seasons.
Yeah, I agree with Griff. More caps isn't the answer. The problem which arises from more caps is that there is always going to be a contingent of people who want a higher cap because their builds and/or game planning aren't up to the task. Truth is some teams are going to be stuck in the minors uncapped league until they gut, not because of level disparity but because they are filled with builds that are sub par because they recruited at the top of the previous cap rather than going for lower leveled but more efficiently built players. Other teams will end up staying mired because they are crappy at game planning, scouting or other GM related issues. The cream of the crop will pull themselves out and get to AA fairly quickly. And really isn't that the goal of the cloud? To separate the wheat from the chaff so to speak?
xsujx
offline
offline
Originally posted by merenoise
Yeah, I agree with Griff. More caps isn't the answer. The problem which arises from more caps is that there is always going to be a contingent of people who want a higher cap because their builds and/or game planning aren't up to the task. Truth is some teams are going to be stuck in the minors uncapped league until they gut, not because of level disparity but because they are filled with builds that are sub par because they recruited at the top of the previous cap rather than going for lower leveled but more efficiently built players. Other teams will end up staying mired because they are crappy at game planning, scouting or other GM related issues. The cream of the crop will pull themselves out and get to AA fairly quickly. And really isn't that the goal of the cloud? To separate the wheat from the chaff so to speak?
So, how would having like a 45 cap in what is the current "uncapped minors" stop them from rising? All it would do is keep these "sub par" builds from having the luxury of competing against players 15 levels below them.
Yeah, I agree with Griff. More caps isn't the answer. The problem which arises from more caps is that there is always going to be a contingent of people who want a higher cap because their builds and/or game planning aren't up to the task. Truth is some teams are going to be stuck in the minors uncapped league until they gut, not because of level disparity but because they are filled with builds that are sub par because they recruited at the top of the previous cap rather than going for lower leveled but more efficiently built players. Other teams will end up staying mired because they are crappy at game planning, scouting or other GM related issues. The cream of the crop will pull themselves out and get to AA fairly quickly. And really isn't that the goal of the cloud? To separate the wheat from the chaff so to speak?
So, how would having like a 45 cap in what is the current "uncapped minors" stop them from rising? All it would do is keep these "sub par" builds from having the luxury of competing against players 15 levels below them.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by walker1
Or you could have an uncapped minors roof. Something like if you are over level 45 you need to play in a real region. I know they have "penalties" or something but that isn't going to matter to much.
So what if there's more 45+ players than there is roster space? People just have to start retiring? And trust me, there is...
As for the topic...leagues are impossible to balance, because if it isn't levels making blowout games, it is builds, if it isn't builds, it is tactics, etc etc.
As for the "I don't want it to take 10 seasons to make it to the WL!!!"...how else do you expect to make it? The best players in the game are going to be in their 10th or 11th season...if you could make it there in 5 seasons, you wouldn't compete anyway.
The uncapped leagues are far from perfect, but perfect is unachievable in a game with this much customization anyway.
Or you could have an uncapped minors roof. Something like if you are over level 45 you need to play in a real region. I know they have "penalties" or something but that isn't going to matter to much.
So what if there's more 45+ players than there is roster space? People just have to start retiring? And trust me, there is...
As for the topic...leagues are impossible to balance, because if it isn't levels making blowout games, it is builds, if it isn't builds, it is tactics, etc etc.
As for the "I don't want it to take 10 seasons to make it to the WL!!!"...how else do you expect to make it? The best players in the game are going to be in their 10th or 11th season...if you could make it there in 5 seasons, you wouldn't compete anyway.
The uncapped leagues are far from perfect, but perfect is unachievable in a game with this much customization anyway.
TyrannyVaunt
offline
offline
Originally posted by Boxcutter
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Stop with the additional caps. I am tired of beating the piss out of everyone in the cloud. Lets just get on with it already and put us up against some equal fucking talent.
Wake up tyranny, the 38 capped has become one of the toughest leagues to win (most competitive) because everybody wants to skip being in the graveyard.
Be more specific - more caps = equal talent.
Levels don't mean equal talent dip shit... Especially as you go higher and higher. A build that is bad at lvl 21, fucking sucks at lvl 42.
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Stop with the additional caps. I am tired of beating the piss out of everyone in the cloud. Lets just get on with it already and put us up against some equal fucking talent.
Wake up tyranny, the 38 capped has become one of the toughest leagues to win (most competitive) because everybody wants to skip being in the graveyard.
Be more specific - more caps = equal talent.
Levels don't mean equal talent dip shit... Especially as you go higher and higher. A build that is bad at lvl 21, fucking sucks at lvl 42.
Edited by TyrannyVaunt on Aug 30, 2009 01:36:41
merenoise
offline
offline
Originally posted by xsujx
Originally posted by merenoise
Yeah, I agree with Griff. More caps isn't the answer. The problem which arises from more caps is that there is always going to be a contingent of people who want a higher cap because their builds and/or game planning aren't up to the task. Truth is some teams are going to be stuck in the minors uncapped league until they gut, not because of level disparity but because they are filled with builds that are sub par because they recruited at the top of the previous cap rather than going for lower leveled but more efficiently built players. Other teams will end up staying mired because they are crappy at game planning, scouting or other GM related issues. The cream of the crop will pull themselves out and get to AA fairly quickly. And really isn't that the goal of the cloud? To separate the wheat from the chaff so to speak?
So, how would having like a 45 cap in what is the current "uncapped minors" stop them from rising? All it would do is keep these "sub par" builds from having the luxury of competing against players 15 levels below them.
And then when those players hit level 46 and want a level 48 cap? Or when they hit level 55 and then want a level 60 cap? Good teams can get out of the uncapped minors with mostly level 40-45 players which is essentially 1 cap above 38. I was a recruiter for an uncapped team last season with players in exactly that range and they promoted out because of the glut of teams that gutted + the WL promotions. That team went 14-2 last season and beat several teams with players in the 50s. This season we are getting shelled in AA but we knew that was coming and are willing to take our lumps this season since we will be well positioned next season.
All adding caps does is add more rungs to climb up. I have no problem fighting to move up the ladder but if the ladder has endless rungs added each season what is the point?
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Levels don't mean equal talent dip shit... Especially as you go higher and higher. A build that is bad at lvl 21, fucking sucks at lvl 42.
And this. Emphatically.
Originally posted by merenoise
Yeah, I agree with Griff. More caps isn't the answer. The problem which arises from more caps is that there is always going to be a contingent of people who want a higher cap because their builds and/or game planning aren't up to the task. Truth is some teams are going to be stuck in the minors uncapped league until they gut, not because of level disparity but because they are filled with builds that are sub par because they recruited at the top of the previous cap rather than going for lower leveled but more efficiently built players. Other teams will end up staying mired because they are crappy at game planning, scouting or other GM related issues. The cream of the crop will pull themselves out and get to AA fairly quickly. And really isn't that the goal of the cloud? To separate the wheat from the chaff so to speak?
So, how would having like a 45 cap in what is the current "uncapped minors" stop them from rising? All it would do is keep these "sub par" builds from having the luxury of competing against players 15 levels below them.
And then when those players hit level 46 and want a level 48 cap? Or when they hit level 55 and then want a level 60 cap? Good teams can get out of the uncapped minors with mostly level 40-45 players which is essentially 1 cap above 38. I was a recruiter for an uncapped team last season with players in exactly that range and they promoted out because of the glut of teams that gutted + the WL promotions. That team went 14-2 last season and beat several teams with players in the 50s. This season we are getting shelled in AA but we knew that was coming and are willing to take our lumps this season since we will be well positioned next season.
All adding caps does is add more rungs to climb up. I have no problem fighting to move up the ladder but if the ladder has endless rungs added each season what is the point?
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
Levels don't mean equal talent dip shit... Especially as you go higher and higher. A build that is bad at lvl 21, fucking sucks at lvl 42.
And this. Emphatically.
Edited by merenoise on Aug 30, 2009 01:54:36
Ronnie Brown 23
offline
offline
Originally posted by Signalsgt
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
[ ]Cares
[x}Trolls
ITS fails to realize that a significant majority of players in this game are in the minors and will eventually progress through the shitstorm that is the uncapped cloud. The average player who doesn't have his path all planned out before his player is even rolled probably will just quit after his non-slowbuilt player can't find a team anywhere.
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
[ ]Cares
[x}Trolls
ITS fails to realize that a significant majority of players in this game are in the minors and will eventually progress through the shitstorm that is the uncapped cloud. The average player who doesn't have his path all planned out before his player is even rolled probably will just quit after his non-slowbuilt player can't find a team anywhere.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
ITS fails to realize that a significant majority of players in this game are in the minors and will eventually progress through the shitstorm that is the uncapped cloud. The average player who doesn't have his path all planned out before his player is even rolled probably will just quit after his non-slowbuilt player can't find a team anywhere.
Any player can find a team...
ITS fails to realize that a significant majority of players in this game are in the minors and will eventually progress through the shitstorm that is the uncapped cloud. The average player who doesn't have his path all planned out before his player is even rolled probably will just quit after his non-slowbuilt player can't find a team anywhere.
Any player can find a team...
Badhands
offline
offline
If I had it my way, and I never will because it makes too much sense, WL would be achievable in the 9th season of a team's existence. That way you can have seasons 9, 10 and 11 with the same players to try to fight your way to the top of WL before you need all new guys... I suppose it's possible now, but only for the winningest of teams.
Cap 13
Cap 21
Cap 28
Cap 34
Uncapped
AA
AAA
Pro
WL
WL
WL
Cap 13
Cap 21
Cap 28
Cap 34
Uncapped
AA
AAA
Pro
WL
WL
WL
xsujx
offline
offline
Originally posted by merenoise
And then when those players hit level 46 and want a level 48 cap? Or when they hit level 55 and then want a level 60 cap? Good teams can get out of the uncapped minors with mostly level 40-45 players which is essentially 1 cap above 38. I was a recruiter for an uncapped team last season with players in exactly that range and they promoted out because of the glut of teams that gutted + the WL promotions. That team went 14-2 last season and beat several teams with players in the 50s. This season we are getting shelled in AA but we knew that was coming and are willing to take our lumps this season since we will be well positioned next season.
All adding caps does is add more rungs to climb up. I have no problem fighting to move up the ladder but if the ladder has endless rungs added each season what is the point?
Spreading out the caps, as has been mentioned more than once, while putting the highest cap somewhere in the 40s or at 50 would alleviate that problem. As it is, a player seeking to get to the top is not constrained by the ladder and can offer himself up every season to whatever league he's qualified for. A team can sidestep the issue by not being so needlessly obsessed with starting out at the lowest possible cap.
And then when those players hit level 46 and want a level 48 cap? Or when they hit level 55 and then want a level 60 cap? Good teams can get out of the uncapped minors with mostly level 40-45 players which is essentially 1 cap above 38. I was a recruiter for an uncapped team last season with players in exactly that range and they promoted out because of the glut of teams that gutted + the WL promotions. That team went 14-2 last season and beat several teams with players in the 50s. This season we are getting shelled in AA but we knew that was coming and are willing to take our lumps this season since we will be well positioned next season.
All adding caps does is add more rungs to climb up. I have no problem fighting to move up the ladder but if the ladder has endless rungs added each season what is the point?
Spreading out the caps, as has been mentioned more than once, while putting the highest cap somewhere in the 40s or at 50 would alleviate that problem. As it is, a player seeking to get to the top is not constrained by the ladder and can offer himself up every season to whatever league he's qualified for. A team can sidestep the issue by not being so needlessly obsessed with starting out at the lowest possible cap.
fallingmercury
offline
offline
Originally posted by Octowned
Give it another season. WPL caused a lot of pre-mature jumps into AA, leading to some real garbage AA teams and no talent left in the uncapped minors. After a few seasons of established uncapped play, things will level out I imagine.
But yeah, my team was one of the "win by 50+ every time" last season. 20-0. Doing OK in AA, but certainly not a force yet. Kind of a weird jump... we're adjusting, though.
No, don't give it another season. This sort of thing naturally gets even worse as levels continue to spread out.
The uncapped leagues are a huge, huge failure. One that could have been avoided had Bort listened to the people who predicted the exact problems that came to be.
Give it another season. WPL caused a lot of pre-mature jumps into AA, leading to some real garbage AA teams and no talent left in the uncapped minors. After a few seasons of established uncapped play, things will level out I imagine.
But yeah, my team was one of the "win by 50+ every time" last season. 20-0. Doing OK in AA, but certainly not a force yet. Kind of a weird jump... we're adjusting, though.
No, don't give it another season. This sort of thing naturally gets even worse as levels continue to spread out.
The uncapped leagues are a huge, huge failure. One that could have been avoided had Bort listened to the people who predicted the exact problems that came to be.
BengalFish
offline
offline
I have to agree that uncapped minors is a joke. I own a Level 34 Casual cap team that is most certain to get promoted to uncapped casual ball next season. I've already informed the team that I'm not interested and I'm gutting the roster and starting over with that team. I'm hoping to PM support and get demoted to the bottom and build or recruit new players.
It truly is a joke and GLB needs to either have Level 41, 45 cap leagues for Casual, or not have uncapped casual at all.
It truly is a joke and GLB needs to either have Level 41, 45 cap leagues for Casual, or not have uncapped casual at all.
Tibbar
offline
offline
uncapped is a nightmare, have teams with all 60+ players in uncapped minors where we have 38-50 lvl players... only so much builds can make up for, and yes we will win 10 or 11 games this season... but there are a few games that are just not going to happen for us no matter what we do cause they are 10 to 15 lvls ahead of us all up and down the roster...
uncapped minors should not exist...
uncapped minors should not exist...
headsigh
offline
offline
I always believed hard caps were fine. That it would be easy to just, say, when you promote, if you have players over the cap for the league you're going into, you could get the two choices
a) You stay in the cap, but the sim cuts all players that over the cap on your team.
b) You move up one higher cap and get to keep your players.
Same for demotion and tanking, (e.g. staying in the cap with current players, dropping down and cutting the over-the-cap players). You can gut, but you're not taking your over-the-cap players for the ride.
a) You stay in the cap, but the sim cuts all players that over the cap on your team.
b) You move up one higher cap and get to keep your players.
Same for demotion and tanking, (e.g. staying in the cap with current players, dropping down and cutting the over-the-cap players). You can gut, but you're not taking your over-the-cap players for the ride.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























