User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > OL still not picking up blitzers who start far from the LOS
Page:
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
The problem as I see it....OL who have no one lined up opposite to them fail horribly at picking up the blitz. This makes ZERO sense.

An OL without a DL in front of them should be able to easily read a blitz and at least force the blitzer to make a play to get around. There is no situation in which the above play should work as it does.


Agree 100%, this is just an "exploit" of poor coding.
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula

These are my favorite, why try to block the ROLB, when the DT is so conveniently near by. Opposite to the run direction and in front of the C - an easy block is much better than running up field
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712918&pbp_id=7991493

by the way, you may recognize the team.


Have you looked at the play diagram for this one? If so, I think you answered your own question for this.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mocfam10
Have you looked at the play diagram for this one? If so, I think you answered your own question for this.


I was going to comment on that part of the play earlier. It's really a poorly designed play that makes no sense what so ever. Only arm chair QBs that has never played football would draw up plays like this. Football is more than just drawing some x and o's.

If you have the FB going one way, and the HB going the other way with the ball, you are running a mis-direction trying to make the LBs think run strong side with the FB read. However, pulling the LG is a dead give away to the LBs that the run is to the weak side. This is like Indian poker bluffing.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mocfam10
Originally posted by tragula

These are my favorite, why try to block the ROLB, when the DT is so conveniently near by. Opposite to the run direction and in front of the C - an easy block is much better than running up field
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712918&pbp_id=7991493

by the way, you may recognize the team.

Have you looked at the play diagram for this one? If so, I think you answered your own question for this.


The play diagram http://goallineblitz.com/images/plays/118.gif calls the LG to block up field and not to his right. It is basic football (I mean something 12 years old kid know) if you don't have an assignment on the LOS you go to the second level.
Plays diagrams for the run play like that cannot contain the blocking information, since it changes with defense alignment. The most basic way to get them right (without making diagrams for each defense, like high level real football team does) is have a pre-determined blocking scheme. The simplest one is:
Head -> gap -> second level.
For the LG in the replay:
Head = no one
Gap = no one
Second level = ROLB (or anyone else in the wrong jersey color, if he cannot catch the ROLB).
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
Originally posted by mocfam10

Originally posted by tragula


These are my favorite, why try to block the ROLB, when the DT is so conveniently near by. Opposite to the run direction and in front of the C - an easy block is much better than running up field
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=712918&pbp_id=7991493

by the way, you may recognize the team.

Have you looked at the play diagram for this one? If so, I think you answered your own question for this.


The play diagram http://goallineblitz.com/images/plays/118.gif calls the LG to block up field and not to his right. It is basic football (I mean something 12 years old kid know) if you don't have an assignment on the LOS you go to the second level.
Plays diagrams for the run play like that cannot contain the blocking information, since it changes with defense alignment. The most basic way to get them right (without making diagrams for each defense, like high level real football team does) is have a pre-determined blocking scheme. The simplest one is:
Head -> gap -> second level.
For the LG in the replay:
Head = no one
Gap = no one
Second level = ROLB (or anyone else in the wrong jersey color, if he cannot catch the ROLB).


EDIT:

After a second look, the play actually calls for a block down on the interior linemen with the off side G pulling. (Despite how it's drawn up.) Meaning the C blocks down on the NT...LG slides inside to get the DT and the RG pulls and gets the first person that shows. But the RG got caught in the wash. The RG should have been picking up the ROLB....not the LG.

Edited by mocfam10 on Aug 28, 2009 09:16:08
Edited by mocfam10 on Aug 28, 2009 09:15:08
Edited by mocfam10 on Aug 28, 2009 09:14:25
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mocfam10
EDIT:

After a second look, the play actually calls for a block down on the interior linemen with the off side G pulling. (Despite how it's drawn up.) Meaning the C blocks down on the NT...LG slides inside to get the DT and the RG pulls and gets the first person that shows. But the RG got caught in the wash. The RG should have been picking up the ROLB....not the LG.



What !? why block opposite to the run, never heard of that trick.

The NT (if you actually want to bother hi, since RL NTs will never catch that play from behind) can be picked up by the RT or the FB You just need to delay him for 1/2 second to make sure he cannot chase the play from behind.
The LG is pulling and blocking the first man he see, typical GLB he decide to quit on the pull and block the NT. But if he could make the pull he would rpobably take the RDE, SS or ROLB (whoever comes first). The LG getting a block on the ROLB/MLB is an extra defender out of the pursuit. Much better than have a knitting break with the C and DT.
Edited by tragula on Aug 28, 2009 09:31:55
Edited by tragula on Aug 28, 2009 09:31:43
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula

What !? why block opposite to the run, never heard of that trick.

The NT (if you actually want to bother hi, since RL NTs will never catch that play from behind) can be picked up by the RT or the FB You just need to delay him for 1/2 second to make sure he cannot chase the play from behind.
The LG is pulling and blocking the first man he see, typical GLB he decide to quit on the pull and block the NT. But if he could make the pull he would rpobably take the RDE, SS or ROLB (whoever comes first). The LG getting a block on the ROLB/MLB is an extra defender out of the pursuit. Much better than have a knitting break with the C and DT.


Bort has "trap" play logic for an outside pitch. It's even in your avatar. lol. Block down and pull a backside player for a lead block. The HB should really have counter play action in the diagram and coding of this play. The RG isn't having a picnic with the C and DT. It's just incorrect diagram for the play he coded. And compounded by the RG stopping his pull and trying to go upfield too fast. Or, the DT and NT got too much of a push and he couldn't get around them.

EDIT:

Also, I've seen many NT blow up a play like this especially if they get a great jump. It's one hole left of center. Considering this acts more like a counter trap than an outside pitch, it's more than possible.
Edited by mocfam10 on Aug 28, 2009 09:47:30
Edited by mocfam10 on Aug 28, 2009 09:45:50
Edited by mocfam10 on Aug 28, 2009 09:45:49
 
northstar09
fist flint
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tragula
What !? why block opposite to the run, never heard of that trick.

The NT (if you actually want to bother hi, since RL NTs will never catch that play from behind) can be picked up by the RT or the FB You just need to delay him for 1/2 second to make sure he cannot chase the play from behind.
The LG is pulling and blocking the first man he see, typical GLB he decide to quit on the pull and block the NT. But if he could make the pull he would rpobably take the RDE, SS or ROLB (whoever comes first). The LG getting a block on the ROLB/MLB is an extra defender out of the pursuit. Much better than have a knitting break with the C and DT.


Actually it's very common to block "opposite the run" especially when someone is pulling.

On the play you showed, the RG is pulling to the left. The Center has to block the NT, because the ROT will never reach him. This is because defensive linemen are taught to follow their man if he pulls (so when the RG pulls, the NT will just follow him down the line and kill the play in the backfield). So the Center blocks down on the NT to keep this from happening. The LG then has to pick up the DT, since the Center is blocking the NT.

The blocking on that play was actually pretty good EXCEPT for the pulling RG. He should have had the ROLB, but he decided to block the NT as well. If he would have pulled correctly, and if the LT wasn't a pansy, that play would have been successful.
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by northstar09
Originally posted by tragula

What !? why block opposite to the run, never heard of that trick.

The NT (if you actually want to bother hi, since RL NTs will never catch that play from behind) can be picked up by the RT or the FB You just need to delay him for 1/2 second to make sure he cannot chase the play from behind.
The LG is pulling and blocking the first man he see, typical GLB he decide to quit on the pull and block the NT. But if he could make the pull he would rpobably take the RDE, SS or ROLB (whoever comes first). The LG getting a block on the ROLB/MLB is an extra defender out of the pursuit. Much better than have a knitting break with the C and DT.


Actually it's very common to block "opposite the run" especially when someone is pulling.

On the play you showed, the RG is pulling to the left. The Center has to block the NT, because the ROT will never reach him. This is because defensive linemen are taught to follow their man if he pulls (so when the RG pulls, the NT will just follow him down the line and kill the play in the backfield). So the Center blocks down on the NT to keep this from happening. The LG then has to pick up the DT, since the Center is blocking the NT.

The blocking on that play was actually pretty good EXCEPT for the pulling RG. He should have had the ROLB, but he decided to block the NT as well. If he would have pulled correctly, and if the LT wasn't a pansy, that play would have been successful.


Thank you.

Even though this doesn't really address the issue of the thread. lol. But it does explanation this particular play. IMO, it's counter trap (counter trey...whatever your team's logic may be) blocking scheme for an outside weak pitch.

 
northstar09
fist flint
offline
Link
 
Lol yeah it's not directly related to the thread, but as a former Center I feel obligated to explain blocking schemes whenever possible

And I agree that the play should be a counter. On a normal pitch/toss you wouldn't have the backside guard pulling, only someone playside. The HB does seem to hesitate at the snap, but not enough for it to fool the defense the way a counter should.
 
mocfam10
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by northstar09
Lol yeah it's not directly related to the thread, but as a former Center I feel obligated to explain blocking schemes whenever possible

And I agree that the play should be a counter. On a normal pitch/toss you wouldn't have the backside guard pulling, only someone playside. The HB does seem to hesitate at the snap, but not enough for it to fool the defense the way a counter should.


100% agree
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by northstar09
Actually it's very common to block "opposite the run" especially when someone is pulling.

On the play you showed, the RG is pulling to the left. The Center has to block the NT, because the ROT will never reach him. This is because defensive linemen are taught to follow their man if he pulls (so when the RG pulls, the NT will just follow him down the line and kill the play in the backfield). So the Center blocks down on the NT to keep this from happening. The LG then has to pick up the DT, since the Center is blocking the NT.

The blocking on that play was actually pretty good EXCEPT for the pulling RG. He should have had the ROLB, but he decided to block the NT as well. If he would have pulled correctly, and if the LT wasn't a pansy, that play would have been successful.


I stand corrected. If that is a counter play you do need to pay more attention to the NT. But without a counter a simple chip from the RT (the NT is aligned outside shoulder of the RG) should be enough. Or Just let the FB do something on the play.

GLB wise, I am just happy if that RG can pick up a RDE/LB/DT coming through the LOS.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Also, is your guy on run focus?


balanced.

but if this keeps up, it's going to be pass.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
The problem as I see it....OL who have no one lined up opposite to them fail horribly at picking up the blitz. This makes ZERO sense.

An OL without a DL in front of them should be able to easily read a blitz and at least force the blitzer to make a play to get around. There is no situation in which the above play should work as it does.


Amen.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ddingo
Are you shitting me?

I'll just post my own guy since this is an insanely retarded request.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=72435


I just noticed that this guy is a RG, and is irrelevant to the discussion. Of course RGs have to be faster. They pull on twice as many plays, and the plays the pull on are some of the most effective outside runs in the game.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.