User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
I'm trying to get details from Bort related to Pump Fake etc.

I suspect that the issues here are not the same issues experienced many seasons ago.

There are several reasons for a CB to "lose" a WR:
A - creative route run.
B - pump fake.
C - First Step
D - Vision check fail.

I suspect that there are cases of critical failures. It's something I have raised with other issues before. Notably if you have a WR who perhaps has Awe Inspiring then you damage the CB's vision. Tiredness and loss of Morale damages a CB's vision.

If a CB fails his initial vision check at the snap then:
A - he wont track First Step.
B - he may track a Pump Fake.
C - he may bite on a head fake or creative route.
D - all of the above.

In the early seasons of GLB there were issues with the coverage distance being a set value of X and the speed/acceleration being set to a constant value of Y which meant that CB's and WR's would never intersect unless the CB was slower than the WR. This isn't that issue.

At the same time however I believe the above issues all existed, but were probably obscured by the more basic mechanical failure.


Even if the CB fails the vision check at the line, why would they ever step forward?

Not to mention my CB doesn't even do this anymore now that I backed his coverage distance off. Also, he has 75 vision with 12 in Super Vision. Not the highest, but you'd think he'd be able to at least be smart enough to backpedal at the beginning of the play.

Anyways I appreciate the help though. If it is failed vision checks, the step forward thing should be taken out. Maybe they are slow to react to a streak play or something, but they should never step toward the LOS...especially since we don't even have press coverage in this game.
 
DL24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Even if the CB fails the vision check at the line, why would they ever step forward?

Not to mention my CB doesn't even do this anymore now that I backed his coverage distance off. Also, he has 75 vision with 12 in Super Vision. Not the highest, but you'd think he'd be able to at least be smart enough to backpedal at the beginning of the play.

Anyways I appreciate the help though. If it is failed vision checks, the step forward thing should be taken out. Maybe they are slow to react to a streak play or something, but they should never step toward the LOS...especially since we don't even have press coverage in this game.


IRL, you see CBs get burned BADLY sometimes, bite on a head fake during a route, or a stop and go, and step forward.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Stepping forward off the snap though? That only happens when they're playing press coverage, which we don't have.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
I can understand them stepping forward during the route trying to jump it, or getting faked out by a cut/head fake/juke/whatever, but it shouldn't happen right off the snap on the LOS. Almost every route besides the WR screen or any Drag routes have the WR running forward at least off the snap. I'd rather them give up these short passes than get burned deep.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
A failed vision check would cause a player to incorrectly find the intersect between himself and the player he is in coverage with. Combined with things like head fake etc it's possible that the CB is even biting on the initial movement by the WR and making an incorrect shift. Pump fake, creative route running etc can all cause the CB to dither or move in directions that aren't essentially correct.

Because the WR is on the LOS in most of the examples the result of a fail is often more severe (and the effect of a fail coupled with any success by the QB or WR SA's results in a more spectacular looking fail).

With the existence of the screen pass and certain other short routes, as well as creative route running it really isn't quite right to state "should never step toward the LOS". We know from experience that in GLB it's exceedingly unlikely that stepping forward will result in anything good - but the player in GLB doesn't have that awareness.

On another thought - I'd have to check with Bort but I suppose that a failed vision check could lead to:
E - reading the play as a Run.

Which'd be another reason for the CB to move forward.
 
Duo
offline
Link
 
Usually IRL CBs step forward to press. There isnt press in this game so it really shouldnt be happening

 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Seems like an easy fix would be to just have it coded that the CB will never step forward at the snap.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Seems like an easy fix would be to just have it coded that the CB will never step forward at the snap.


Exactly. I could care less if my CB gives up a 2 or 3 yd gain on a drag route or a quick hook, but giving up 20+ yd passes and TDs shouldn't be the result of a failed vision check...if that's even what it is. Again, I doubt that's the problem.

-I haven't seen this since I backed off my coverage
-I hadn't seen this for 2 or 3 seasons, and only saw this in one game when I tried closer coverage with my CB
-The previous time this kept happening to him, I solved it by backing off the coverage distance
-It seems to happen the majority of times when the offense is going "up"
-My CB's play was day and night when all I did was change his coverage distance. Same vision, yet he failed a bunch of vision checks one day, and hasn't since?
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
It's ok Sik. My CB has twice as much agility as speed, so he doesn't have a problem with it.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
He has the banana man x-factor obviously.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Exactly. I could care less if my CB gives up a 2 or 3 yd gain on a drag route or a quick hook, but giving up 20+ yd passes and TDs shouldn't be the result of a failed vision check...if that's even what it is. Again, I doubt that's the problem.

-I haven't seen this since I backed off my coverage
-I hadn't seen this for 2 or 3 seasons, and only saw this in one game when I tried closer coverage with my CB
-The previous time this kept happening to him, I solved it by backing off the coverage distance
-It seems to happen the majority of times when the offense is going "up"
-My CB's play was day and night when all I did was change his coverage distance. Same vision, yet he failed a bunch of vision checks one day, and hasn't since?



A fix that would make more sense is press coverage. If it's set to 0-1 then it press covers, and a STR check happens. Crit failure on either player KD's them. Otherwise it could be treated as a version of blocking, weighted heavily to the WR.

Edit: I'm the one that pointed out this issue in Season 9 in the thread of WR's crying they couldn't score deep. And it's really the only time they score on deep routes, when the CB bites hard on the snap.
Edited by Adderfist on Aug 27, 2009 01:51:46
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Seems like an easy fix would be to just have it coded that the CB will never get beat by the WR.


fyp
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Exactly. I could care less if my CB gives up a 2 or 3 yd gain on a drag route or a quick hook, but giving up 20+ yd passes and TDs shouldn't be the result of a failed vision check...if that's even what it is. Again, I doubt that's the problem.

-I haven't seen this since I backed off my coverage
-I hadn't seen this for 2 or 3 seasons, and only saw this in one game when I tried closer coverage with my CB
-The previous time this kept happening to him, I solved it by backing off the coverage distance
-It seems to happen the majority of times when the offense is going "up"
-My CB's play was day and night when all I did was change his coverage distance. Same vision, yet he failed a bunch of vision checks one day, and hasn't since?



A fix that would make more sense is press coverage. If it's set to 0-1 then it press covers, and a STR check happens. Crit failure on either player KD's them. Otherwise it could be treated as a version of blocking, weighted heavily to the WR.

Edit: I'm the one that pointed out this issue in Season 9 in the thread of WR's crying they couldn't score deep. And it's really the only time they score on deep routes, when the CB bites hard on the snap.


Press coverage should be nice, but it shouldn't be tied like this to coverage distance. You might want your corner to cover very tight but not press. And you might want to press, but then give the WR some cushion after the press (assuming you had some success re-routing him and didn't get blown by on the press).
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Duo
Usually IRL CBs step forward to press. There isnt press in this game so it really shouldnt be happening


Ya, critical difference there.

A - real life.
B - GLB.

Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by jdbolick

Seems like an easy fix would be to just have it coded that the CB will never step forward at the snap.


Exactly. I could care less if my CB gives up a 2 or 3 yd gain on a drag route or a quick hook, but giving up 20+ yd passes and TDs shouldn't be the result of a failed vision check...if that's even what it is. Again, I doubt that's the problem.

-I haven't seen this since I backed off my coverage
-I hadn't seen this for 2 or 3 seasons, and only saw this in one game when I tried closer coverage with my CB
-The previous time this kept happening to him, I solved it by backing off the coverage distance
-It seems to happen the majority of times when the offense is going "up"
-My CB's play was day and night when all I did was change his coverage distance. Same vision, yet he failed a bunch of vision checks one day, and hasn't since?


1 - Coverage distance influences fakes. The further you are away, the less likely it is to have effect. This has been a pretty fundamental mechanic since season 4.

2 - And this has been happening every day since Bort removed the static speed modifier.

3 - As above.

4 - minor differences in animation exist.

5 - as per 1. Also when he fails vision checks when not playing tight coverage he has a cushion that instructs him to "maintain a 3 yard gap" which overrides "stay on top of the guy". When a player is instructed to have a 0 yard gap he will literally stand on top of the receiver as soon as possible regardless of his motion.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Fair enough, but I still think the failure of a vision check should maybe freeze a defender for a second...not make them take a step in the wrong direction. Again, when do you ever see a CB doing that when not playing press coverage? I just don't get the logic there.

1) Do I see where the WR is running off the snap?
-yes? cover him
-no? take a step in the opposite direction the play is going
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.