User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ijg
Very good, but FYI, this is essentially what monsterkill script does if you haven't seen it. A more user friendly version would be nice but honestly, I'm not sure this gives me that much new.


Yes, I've seen it. I suppose adding some easier scouting tools would lessen the gap between those who use the script and those who don't.
 
RandomBeast
offline
Link
 
makes it easier (and more fun) to scout if it is more user friendly
 
Star Star
offline
Link
 
Ok some possible Stats for The Scouting Page: Scaks given Up: the Number of Times A QB Has Been Sacked, Sacks: The Number of Sacks They Have, Interceptions Alowed, Interceptions, Rushing Touchdowns, Passing Touchdowns, Safteys for, Safteys Agianst, Special Teams Touchdowns.
 
Redass Ranch
offline
Link
 
Instead of just the last few games... let us select the games that we are interested in.... because the last 3 to 5 games could have been against gutted teams... and the "scouts" would want to look at what team "X" did against the other top teams...
 
AirMcMVP
Mod
offline
Link
 
Why not build in the abilities of the Monsterkill script and give the owner/scout/GM the ability to build custom scenarios? That would make that tool available to everyone and would probably help with server strain/bandwidth usage.

http://img504.imageshack.us/img504/2137/samplemonsterkill.jpg
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AirMcMVP
Why not build in the abilities of the Monsterkill script and give the owner/scout/GM the ability to build custom scenarios? That would make that tool available to everyone and would probably help with server strain/bandwidth usage.

http://img504.imageshack.us/img504/2137/samplemonsterkill.jpg


Yeah pretty much add the script to the game itself?

Maybe break it down into the "complex" and "basic" scouting? For those that wouldn't want the full deal.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I'm now thinking for the scouting/tendencies stuff, have basically a list of the team's games this season, with checkboxes next to them. You check off the games you want to analyze, and click "update" and it spits out the tendencies data based on that. Perhaps have a limit of 5 or 6 games to make sure it doesn't kill the server.

One problem is defense, if we want to scout that at all: DPC makes it pretty hard to do, especially if a play gets deleted after it's used. Best I could do is probably % of 4-3/3-4/nickel/dime, etc, but with DPC plays even that is hard. Defense would likely need to still be mostly a manual scouting process, outside of stats like ints/pds/sacks.
 
ijg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ijg

Very good, but FYI, this is essentially what monsterkill script does if you haven't seen it. A more user friendly version would be nice but honestly, I'm not sure this gives me that much new.


Yes, I've seen it. I suppose adding some easier scouting tools would lessen the gap between those who use the script and those who don't.


that's fair, though I was hoping you could come up with a way to leverage it to make it even better. The weaknesses of monsterkill are the lack of play sortability (i.e. I may know they run left 30% of the time, but I still have to go by hand to try to find the actual plays) and the lack of player specific information, e.g. how many passes are thrown/to at CB or WR X and how many catches does he get/give up.
 
RandomBeast
offline
Link
 
when scouting defense, you often look by offensive play call anyway - how do they defend 3rd and long, etc. so as long as you can filter by offensive down/distance, and it lists the general defense formation (3-4, 4-3, etc.) based on lineup on the field, scouts can watch plays from there to see the exact defense called.
 
Star Star
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm now thinking for the scouting/tendencies stuff, have basically a list of the team's games this season, with checkboxes next to them. You check off the games you want to analyze, and click "update" and it spits out the tendencies data based on that. Perhaps have a limit of 5 or 6 games to make sure it doesn't kill the server.

One problem is defense, if we want to scout that at all: DPC makes it pretty hard to do, especially if a play gets deleted after it's used. Best I could do is probably % of 4-3/3-4/nickel/dime, etc, but with DPC plays even that is hard. Defense would likely need to still be mostly a manual scouting process, outside of stats like ints/pds/sacks.


ok but the Other Team could change up the Tendancy's Completly, so that it's hard to figure them out, almost imposible to get a good scouting on it, so you'd have to baseyou Teams Defense offense on Guess Work rather than Fact.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I bet I could do some graphical stuff with the tendencies if I wanted to. Line/bar charts, or those circular area charts you always see in RPG's to show skill pcts.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Perhaps have a limit of 5 or 6 games to make sure it doesn't kill the server.


Bort, you need to have a separated table to store post-processed stats after games instead of going back to each game to retrieve the data. This way, it won't kill the server and can handle more games.
Edited by buffalobills_tw on Aug 11, 2009 14:22:29
 
Link
 
One important one imo would be average number of plays and total number of plays for last 3 games for all the player. This is really helpful to see where the opponents would be lacking energy later in the game, because sometimes there are teams with a lot of one position but they end up being mostly special teams or bench warmers and then you would be able to figure out which of your positions need the more depth etc.
 
Kitna
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'm now thinking for the scouting/tendencies stuff, have basically a list of the team's games this season, with checkboxes next to them. You check off the games you want to analyze, and click "update" and it spits out the tendencies data based on that. Perhaps have a limit of 5 or 6 games to make sure it doesn't kill the server.

One problem is defense, if we want to scout that at all: DPC makes it pretty hard to do, especially if a play gets deleted after it's used. Best I could do is probably % of 4-3/3-4/nickel/dime, etc, but with DPC plays even that is hard. Defense would likely need to still be mostly a manual scouting process, outside of stats like ints/pds/sacks.


maybe have a % the defense blitzes with a postion

if thats possible
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
when scouting defense, you often look by offensive play call anyway - how do they defend 3rd and long, etc. so as long as you can filter by offensive down/distance, and it lists the general defense formation (3-4, 4-3, etc.) based on lineup on the field, scouts can watch plays from there to see the exact defense called.


With the DPC, 3-4 isn't always 3-4, though

And if the play gets deleted after it's used, I'd have no clue what the content was without parsing each and every replay (which would take forever and a day).
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.