User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Add 10 season decline to the NEVER going to happen list
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Martin
I think the decline should be based on positions. Like in real life, at 30, you are almost done as a HB. But you can play up to late 30s,a round 40, as a quarterback. So the game will still be somewhat unrealistic. Also, if all FP boosts were even, I think it would make sense. Add in decline but have it vary by positions, but let FP boosts be equal. After all, the positions that suffer from being the most costly to boost, are the ones that normally have the biggest factors in game.


That's good in theory, but considering that with the exception of HB, the two highest demand positions are QB and WR and those are some of the longest career positions, it's easy to see why this won't work.

Originally posted by
...After all, some of us pay for this.


I pay for this too, and what I'm paying for is a fair game that is entertaining. What some people seem to be paying for is a single player game with other people "allowed" to fill in the gaps. It's ok as long as their players still have an edge over the field. I seriously hope my group outnumbers the latter, but I'm not so naive.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
How about instead of a "son" inheriting skills from the father, he gets the higher level equipment from his father. He'd still start at LV1, but might have a lv42 piece of equipment...He'd still have to level up like all the other players, but there would be a small advantage for the first few seasons, and over time other players would catch up, much like real life.


This is actually not that worst idea I've ever heard. I mean the bonus might be too high (maybe let him wear his level 24 gear but not higher, or something), but I think the basic principle is solid.
 
jasonshepp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Animalmother

Thats super nice to hear Bort and as long as It stays open for re-working then im sure the right thing will happen when the time comes.
In the meantime know your scaring away hardcore MMORPG guys though.
The market is so dam big people are screaming for the long term game.

Everyone alive till all stats are 100 is pretty funny concept...im not sure anyone has suggested that lol.

Would move my Kicker to NT if that were the case


This game IS long-term. Christ Bort and Co. are giving back 70% of your money spent to keep playing. Imagine WoW giving back $11 of every $15 spent each month, that's unheard of.

The idea that a player should keep playing beyond 10 years is silly. 10 years is a totally arbitrary number, but once you've hit your peak (and probably the 2 or 3 solid playing years after it) feel free to get 70% of ALL FPs investing in that toon back and make another one.

If Bort's generosity is "scaring away hardcore MMOers" then speaking strictly for myself, I'd say "good".


That's actually like saying WoW gives you back 11 of your 15 but you can only play your character for a year and then are forced to start a new one...
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by rbedgood

How about instead of a "son" inheriting skills from the father, he gets the higher level equipment from his father. He'd still start at LV1, but might have a lv42 piece of equipment...He'd still have to level up like all the other players, but there would be a small advantage for the first few seasons, and over time other players would catch up, much like real life.


This is actually not that worst idea I've ever heard. I mean the bonus might be too high (maybe let him wear his level 24 gear but not higher, or something), but I think the basic principle is solid.


How about a storage facility for custom gear? Once your player retires you strip him of his custom gear and put it into storage so you can hand it out to another player? Of course the level 8 tree will not be active until the new guy hits lvl 8.
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 16:55:11
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by LoperK
They just locked my thread...I don't understand why...Everyone was making great ideas.


why did they lock that other thread? There were some great suggestions there and by locking it, the mods are giving the impression that this the discussion on this issue is over. Bort said that decline will happen at some point (notice he didn't specify 10 seasons), but he is still open to other ideas about extending the life of the player.

I think whoever locked that thread was a little trigger happy there.
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 17:02:24
 
tmarze
offline
Link
 
I agree a decline do need to happen,in the NFL no team can stay elite forever.perhaps 2 seasons after the 10th season player's could play at max,then the decline starts.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jasonshepp
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by Animalmother


Thats super nice to hear Bort and as long as It stays open for re-working then im sure the right thing will happen when the time comes.
In the meantime know your scaring away hardcore MMORPG guys though.
The market is so dam big people are screaming for the long term game.

Everyone alive till all stats are 100 is pretty funny concept...im not sure anyone has suggested that lol.

Would move my Kicker to NT if that were the case


This game IS long-term. Christ Bort and Co. are giving back 70% of your money spent to keep playing. Imagine WoW giving back $11 of every $15 spent each month, that's unheard of.

The idea that a player should keep playing beyond 10 years is silly. 10 years is a totally arbitrary number, but once you've hit your peak (and probably the 2 or 3 solid playing years after it) feel free to get 70% of ALL FPs investing in that toon back and make another one.

If Bort's generosity is "scaring away hardcore MMOers" then speaking strictly for myself, I'd say "good".


That's actually like saying WoW gives you back 11 of your 15 but you can only play your character for a year and then are forced to start a new one...


When did anyone say this game was supposed to be like WoW? Nothing wrong with variety.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Faux Bear
Originally posted by LoperK

They just locked my thread...I don't understand why...Everyone was making great ideas.


why did they lock that other thread? There were some great suggestions there and by locking it, the mods are giving the impression that this the discussion on this issue is over. Bort said that decline will happen at some point (notice he didn't specify 10 seasons), but he is still open to other ideas about extending the life of the player.

I think whoever locked that thread was a little trigger happy there.


Any thread advocating an idea in the "Never Going To Happen List" should and, I presume, will be locked.

If someone suggests "no boosting," for example, that's made a thread lockable for a month or more.
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
You can criticize it but Bort has told me plainly that it is never going to happen. But by all means discuss to your hearts content.


but by all means discuss to your hearts content. Then the thread was locked?

Also Bort said that at some point in some way there will be player decline. This certainly does not sound like someone who has made up his mind about the mechanics or the specifics of the plan. That other thread had a lot of good ideas and I think it's a shame to have locked it.
 
big_n_rich
offline
Link
 
Bort,

I think you could be missing out on a decent revenue opportunity. If you cap off the growth after the players have played for 10 seasons give the agents the "pay to play" in a senior league option. That way if folks want to keep playing in a nonadvancing, nondeclining league (and are willing to pay you enough flex points to turn the profit after server costs) why not let them. The sanctity of the records for the 10 year career will be maintained for your Hall of Fame purposes and retirement for a flex point partial refund would remain as a preferred option for many (but not all). As we get closer to that point just put up a poll to gauge the interest. If there isn't enough to support a league then the option falls off the table, if there is (16/32 teams times 40 player minimum) then that is clearly a large enough population of the games playing customers that you don't want to ignore.
 
Animalmother
offline
Link
 
All this sounds so much like real life I cant contain my excitement!

If the goal is to keep it like real life as bort stated then maybe we should alter our thinking towards Real life.

The avg NFl career is 4 years not 10.
Coaches die just like players.
You need a wife to have children and they are no lock to make the NFL.
There is no such thing as a retirement League.
If people get injured it doesnt lengthen there career.
Equiptment doesnt do anything but protect you from injury.
If my parents were given 100 chances to re-roll me I wouldnt mind being a bit taller.
You cannot play 80% Man to Man cover and win football games.
In real life this game...uh yea.

Im a bit disapointed in the Model if following real life is the goal...when all the rules have already been broken for a RL Sim.
Lets try to help come up with ways to solve it based on real life senerios I guess but that alot harder imo.

The first thing off the table should be thinking of ourselves as NFL players from day 1.
The senerio is Pop warner to JV to HS to Coll to Pro's and you set a timeline.
But we created 345 lb 6 "5 DT's so you have to wipe POP... JV and HS out of the mix.
So now were creating college players. 4 years avg lets say. (2 is real life)
The avg NFL career is 4-5 years so at 10 seasons its about as close to real life as your going to get.
So how do we fix it and follow the model.
I dont think its reincarnation or eternal retirement.

Im going to like the other side of the fence on this....lets keep it REAL!

Haha im jk ofcourse

and just because 1 guy wants a thread locked...the 700 posts seem to beg to differ.
If anything sticky it imho or open a pure suggestion only thread and mod the crap out of it.
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 17:46:27
 
LoperK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Faux Bear

Originally posted by LoperK


They just locked my thread...I don't understand why...Everyone was making great ideas.


why did they lock that other thread? There were some great suggestions there and by locking it, the mods are giving the impression that this the discussion on this issue is over. Bort said that decline will happen at some point (notice he didn't specify 10 seasons), but he is still open to other ideas about extending the life of the player.

I think whoever locked that thread was a little trigger happy there.


Any thread advocating an idea in the "Never Going To Happen List" should and, I presume, will be locked.

If someone suggests "no boosting," for example, that's made a thread lockable for a month or more.


It wasn't a thread saying to get rid of the idea, it was coming up with different ideas to make it better. The mod Galkuris was retarded enough to lock it for no reason when we were all trying to put out ideas that Bort never was against.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Wanting to get 100% of the FPs back is a crazy idea. As Americans we pay TONS of money for entertainment every year - heck, since food is a form of entertainment let's make that every day. Part of the price you pay is for the opportunity to play/enjoy whatever it is you bought. If you buy a video game and want to sell it back at Gamestop after 1 year, there is NO WAY you are getting back 100% of what you payed. Probably they will give you closer to 50% in store credit and 15% in real money back. Part of the price you payed went towards the year of use and enjoyment you got out of the game.
Last edited Jun 1, 2008 17:50:10
 
.blitz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Animalmother
All this sounds so much like real life I cant contain my excitement!

If the goal is to keep it like real life as bort stated then maybe we should alter our thinking towards Real life.

The avg NFl career is 4 years not 10.
Coaches die just like players.
You need a wife to have children and they are no lock to make the NFL.
There is no such thing as a retirement League.
If people get injured it doesnt lengthen there career.
Equiptment doesnt do anything but protect you from injury.
If my parents were given 100 chances to re-roll me I wouldnt mind being a bit taller.
You cannot play 80% Man to Man cover and win football games.
In real life this game...uh yea.

Im a bit disapointed in the Model if following real life is the goal...when all the rules have already been broken for a RL Sim.
Lets try to help come up with ways to solve it based on real life senerios I guess but that alot harder imo.

The first thing off the table should be thinking of ourselves as NFL players from day 1.
The senerio is Pop warner to JV to HS to Coll to Pro's and you set a timeline.
But we created 345 lb 6 "5 DT's so you have to wipe POP... JV and HS out of the mix.
So now were creating college players. 4 years avg lets say. (2 is real life)
The avg NFL career is 4-5 years so at 10 seasons its about as close to real life as your going to get.
So how do we fix it and follow the model.
I dont think its reincarnation or eternal retirement.

Im going to like the other side of the fence on this....lets keep it REAL!

Haha im jk ofcourse

and just because 1 guy wants a thread locked...the 700 posts seem to beg to differ.
If anything sticky it imho or open a pure suggestion only thread and mod the crap out of it.


wow, I love that shit. Nice lol
 
LoperK
offline
Link
 
OPEN UP MY THREAD AGAIN! THIS IS RIDICULOUS!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.