User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JHight
Originally posted by Gott

Originally posted by JHight


Just demote the non-playoff teams to their respective regions and the conference champions from the Pros are promoted up. This ensures at least 2 teams per region in the WPL, while still giving more powerful leagues the opportunity to have multiple spots in the WPL over time.

This also gives a better shot at providing balance across the leagues while still making sure that current rivalries and friendships stay intact for the near future.


What if all four OPL teams make the playoffs? Then no OPL teams get promoted?


If all 4 teams from OPL get into the playoffs, then no OPL teams would be demoted, but the current OPL conference champions would still be promoted up to replace the non-playoff teams.

The beauty of the system is that strong league will be able to achieve more spots, but no matter what, every league will still have at least 2 teams in the WPL.


But this may mean that say 4 oceana teams all get demoted... 2 more are getting promoted, but you then have to kick out 2 teams from pro down to AAA, and so on...
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazy454
Originally posted by Joebarber

Originally posted by Havoc


[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1
Edited by the man of doom on Jul 27, 2009 18:55:53
Edited by the man of doom on Jul 27, 2009 18:55:29
 
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by crazy454

Originally posted by Joebarber


Originally posted by Havoc



[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1


+1
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
Keep it simple

Top 1 from each conference goes up each year. Top 2 this season only.

Keep always 2 teams per conference in pro league. This means one gets demoted every year, even if it was 2nd place and the other was first.

This way you ALWAYS promote the winners, and you just really compete against the others from your conference to "stay" in the world league. You can request demotion if you want however (if you would normally stay) and get another team to come up from your league.


Why, in a World League, would you just want teams to compete with only teams from their old region to stay? It's a World League, no?
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by the man of doom

Originally posted by crazy454


Originally posted by Joebarber



Originally posted by Havoc




[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1


+1


+1
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
How about...

First Season: Any team that made the conference finals gets moved into the league. Regular tiebreakers used to determine spots for gutting teams (eg. LOL). Put teams from the same conference into the same conference in WPL.

Future Seasons: The worse team from the two teams that came from the same conference gets demoted (tiebreakers: Playoff wins, Record, Point Differential or something like that). Teams that make the championship game of their Pro leagues get promoted to World Pro. In the case of a gutting scenario, the gutted team gets dropped. If both teams gut, the promote the conference finalist from the Pro conference.

Example: For OPL Zeta, two teams in WPL in the same conference. Whichever team does worse gets demoted, with a new team from OPL Zeta coming up.

This way, there will always be two teams from each pro conference in the league.

Cons
There are a few flaws in this system.

1) A team like the Benitos could dominate for eternity, meaning that other teams from the same conference could not stay in WPL for more than one season. I don't see this as a huge issue though... in the past, if the Benitos kept winning the championship, no other team in SAPL could win anyway.

2) People can still argue that teams in USAPL are better... and in the long run, unlike the initial scenario, you will probably not have the best 32 teams in the league. However, you do get better representation, and this should hopefully prop up the value of some pretty shitty Pro Leagues (APL, EEPL, OPL come to mind immediately) more than the OP's proposed system, where, if USAPL was better (debatable), the league could be flooded with teams from that league.

3) This essentially makes some Tourneys (definitely ToC) pretty worthless. But eh. Whatevs.
 
UMBF
offline
Link
 
I think we need to convince Bort that its ok to demote teams to a region other than their original one. We need to balance out the regions. USA Pro is the toughest because that's where most of the best players want to play. If the World League becomes the toughest league, then players may not be as biased towards USA Pro.
 
ksychic
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by the man of doom


Originally posted by crazy454



Originally posted by Joebarber




Originally posted by Havoc





[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1


+1


+1


 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
lol soccer wins imo
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by crazy454

Originally posted by Joebarber


Originally posted by Havoc



[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1


So... how will the relegated teams be handled..? Teams will end up randomly in some other leagues?

Agree with the playoff thing.. European Soccer FTW
 
JHight
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
Originally posted by JHight

Originally posted by Gott


Originally posted by JHight



Just demote the non-playoff teams to their respective regions and the conference champions from the Pros are promoted up. This ensures at least 2 teams per region in the WPL, while still giving more powerful leagues the opportunity to have multiple spots in the WPL over time.

This also gives a better shot at providing balance across the leagues while still making sure that current rivalries and friendships stay intact for the near future.


What if all four OPL teams make the playoffs? Then no OPL teams get promoted?


If all 4 teams from OPL get into the playoffs, then no OPL teams would be demoted, but the current OPL conference champions would still be promoted up to replace the non-playoff teams.

The beauty of the system is that strong league will be able to achieve more spots, but no matter what, every league will still have at least 2 teams in the WPL.


But this may mean that say 4 oceana teams all get demoted... 2 more are getting promoted, but you then have to kick out 2 teams from pro down to AAA, and so on...


Yes, so Pros may have to demote the bottom 3 teams instead of the bottom 2 for one season if such an event were to occur. Overall, not a terribly difficult job to do. Just give preference to demoted WPL teams over teams that are 3-13 or 2-14 at the bottom of the Pros.
 
Link
 
Other things to consider is:

1) How do you deal with teams that gut?
2) Where do you send teams that are demoted?

 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by crazy454
Originally posted by Joebarber
Originally posted by Havoc


If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1


+1


How do you match-up for those play-in games? Why would the #17-#24 teams get an extra, one-game shot to stay in the WL when they've already had a season to demonstrate their competitiveness (or lack of) there?
 
JHight
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by the man of doom

Originally posted by crazy454


Originally posted by Joebarber



Originally posted by Havoc




[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1


+1


How do you figure out who faces who?
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by the man of doom


Originally posted by crazy454



Originally posted by Joebarber




Originally posted by Havoc





[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1


+1


+1


-1

Need more turnover than that... otherwise it'll be even harder to get into WPL. That's not what we need. We need more fluidity so that the best teams every season will be in there. In general, the best two teams from a conference in one season will NOT be the best two teams the next season.

As well, it doesn't do anything to solve demotion issues. Where do the 8 demoted teams go? What happens if 4 are from OPL, 3 from APL and 1 from EEPL for example? Who goes where?

Poorly thought out to be honest.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.