User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > How To Fix World League Demotion
Page:
 
GhostMachine
not an ad min
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
I already posted my solutions. Unfortunately Bort wants a solution that will please everyone, and this is not going to happen. So instead we get a 'compromise' which fails to please everyone equally.

Either use the two up, two down region-linked method, or relegate the bottom howevermany and randomise their destinations. Possibly have a poll on this amongst qualifying teams? And allow people to opt out of promotion to WPL if they don't think they can stomach it, though I doubt many would take up such an option.


There has to be a better way than two up region-linked. If it's randomized demotion, I'm not too sure that anybody would be happy with that.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JohnnyDollar
Originally posted by Vando

I already posted my solutions. Unfortunately Bort wants a solution that will please everyone, and this is not going to happen. So instead we get a 'compromise' which fails to please everyone equally.

Either use the two up, two down region-linked method, or relegate the bottom howevermany and randomise their destinations. Possibly have a poll on this amongst qualifying teams? And allow people to opt out of promotion to WPL if they don't think they can stomach it, though I doubt many would take up such an option.


There has to be a better way than two up region-linked. If it's randomized demotion, I'm not too sure that anybody would be happy with that.


There isn't, and after precisely one season people will stop caring anyway because the whole 'oh god must get back to USA Pro its da best' will go away when people realise it doesn't matter, because the WPL will be the new sauce.
 
GhostMachine
not an ad min
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Originally posted by JohnnyDollar

Originally posted by Vando


I already posted my solutions. Unfortunately Bort wants a solution that will please everyone, and this is not going to happen. So instead we get a 'compromise' which fails to please everyone equally.

Either use the two up, two down region-linked method, or relegate the bottom howevermany and randomise their destinations. Possibly have a poll on this amongst qualifying teams? And allow people to opt out of promotion to WPL if they don't think they can stomach it, though I doubt many would take up such an option.


There has to be a better way than two up region-linked. If it's randomized demotion, I'm not too sure that anybody would be happy with that.


There isn't, and after precisely one season people will stop caring anyway because the whole 'oh god must get back to USA Pro its da best' will go away when people realise it doesn't matter, because the WPL will be the new sauce.


A random shuffle would piss a lot of people off IMO, but then again I don't own a team
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3040177 epic
 
GhostMachine
not an ad min
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vrshah
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3040177 epic


Originally posted by vrshah
Top 2 teams are in from each PRO conference for next season.

Next season (season 11), along with world league games, you simultaneously run the 64-team tourney.

Best 32 teams are in the world league from that tourney the following season (S12) and the other teams that did not make the cut get put back in their respective leagues.

Then every season you have a world league running simultaneously w/a 64-team pro tourney to decide the make-up of the WPL for the following season.


Easy fix

So MM and OFG might not be there the very first year but look...you have to start somewhere and build a model and sometimes that involves a little injustice.

Your other solution is to have an extended off-season this season, run the 64-team tourney and then put the best 32 teams in WPL.

Then next season, you can run another 64-team tourney concurrently w/WPL games or again in the off-season.

Why is there so much opposition to running both ideas at the same time instead of having to pick and chose one or the other?

As far as excess game-planning goes? Who cares?...Most of the top teams game plan to hell 24/7 anyway. If you want to get there bad enough, you'll GP to do it.
Originally posted by Crawly


Terrible. Just a basic world league is easier to handle. Why is a tournament also necessary?


1. to handle promotion/demotion to and from WPL
2. to handle all the teams that don't finish top 2 in their conference but belong



 
GhostMachine
not an ad min
offline
Link
 
Give me a second to break this down. It's making my head hurt.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
What happens when the WPL winner gets sim-screwed out of the tourney early on somehow?

You KNOW it will happen...
 
GhostMachine
not an ad min
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
What happens when the WPL winner gets sim-screwed out of the tourney early on somehow?

You KNOW it will happen...


What happened to your, "can't please everyone mentality"


Actually, I like this idea the best out of all.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JohnnyDollar
Give me a second to break this down. It's making my head hurt.


He's basically saying use current Pro standings for the first WPL season, then redraw it every season based on the placings in the 64 team tourney so its fully independent of regions.
 
GhostMachine
not an ad min
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
Originally posted by JohnnyDollar

Give me a second to break this down. It's making my head hurt.


He's basically saying use current Pro standings for the first WPL season, then redraw it every season based on the placings in the 64 team tourney so its fully independent of regions.


I think that is a great way to keep it regionalized without screwing things up. I can see the WPL champion getting knocked first round pissing people off, but I think this idea is the best of the bunch so far.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JohnnyDollar
Originally posted by Vando

What happens when the WPL winner gets sim-screwed out of the tourney early on somehow?

You KNOW it will happen...


What happened to your, "can't please everyone mentality"


Actually, I like this idea the best out of all.


You can't please everyone, but you should look to please the world champions over the 5th placed team in USA Pro.
 
GhostMachine
not an ad min
offline
Link
 
Also thanks for breaking it down. I'm slow.
 
. Ninja
offline
Link
 
I say bottom 16 teams get demoted and put back into their respective leagues (none playoff teams). And let's say if the USA league for example doesn't have anyone demoted then no pro teams would move up from that region. Who says you have to stick to the 2 down 2 up rule for the world league?

If you have to stay in a pro league even though you won the league, it wouldn't be that big of a deal, you have a great shot of going back to back.

In order for a world league to win you can not stick with the 2 up 2 down rule.
 
GhostMachine
not an ad min
offline
Link
 
Bumped for



Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by JohnnyDollar

Originally posted by Firenze


Originally posted by JohnnyDollar



Should have named it ***OFFICIAL World Pro League Batching Thread*****

FML


When you become an Admin, you can change all the titles you want.


Support Ticket Sent


How is J$ not an admin of this site yet?

-Turtle


 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
Also, i'm pretty sure i outlined how this would work like, 3 months ago o_O


Yes, you did ... still the best option ...

Originally posted by turnit643
World League

Suggested conference structure and promotion / relegation schedule.

* spelling out gart's suggested framework as I understand it (from here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2958454&page=8 )


▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬▬


► Initial formation of the World League:


○ Season 10's final four teams from each of the eight Pro leagues get pulled up to form the initial 32-team World League.

○ The World League would be built with the same Alpha-Zeta conference structure as the rest of GLB's leagues and teams fill in to the WL according to their established Alpha-Zeta affiliation.

○ Following the initial promotion from the current Pro leagues to the World League, each Pro League will have four more slots to fill from AAA on top of the usual four, plus guts. So, in Season 11, each Pro league would experience an influx of at least eight AAA's (four naturally promoted + four World League replacements + gut replacements.)


World League - Alpha Conference:
1. APL Lion 1
2. APL Lion 2
3. CPL West 1
4. CPL West 2
5. EEPL Alpha 1
6. EEPL Alpha 2
7. OPL Alpha 1
8. OPL Alpha 2
9. SAPL Satchmo 1
10. SAPL Satchmo 2
11. SEAPL Naga 1
12. SEAPL Naga 2
13. USAPL West 1
14. USAPL West 2
15. WEPL Alpha 1
16. WEPL Alpha 2

World League - Zeta Conference:
1. APL Elephant 1
2. APL Elephant 2
3. CPL East 1
4. CPL East 2
5. EEPL Zeta 1
6. EEPL Zeta 2
7. OPL Zeta 1
8. OPL Zeta 2
9. SAPL Dizzy 1
10. SAPL Dizzy 2
11. SEAPL Garuda 1
12. SEAPL Garuda 2
13. USAPL East 1
14. USAPL East 2
15. WEPL Zeta 1
16. WEPL Zeta 2


► Subsequent promotions and demotions to and from the World league:

○ World League teams that qualify for the playoffs (16 teams) remain in the World League.

○ World League teams that fail to reach the playoffs (16 teams) return to their home Pro league.

○ Pro league Champions and runners-up (16 teams) promote to the World League.

○ At all times, each region would be repped int he World League by at least 2 teams.

○ At most, 4 teams from any region will be demoted to their original Pro league each season (2 back into each conference.)

○ At most, 2 teams from any region will be promoted to the World League each season (1 from each conference.)

○ When the situation arises that two teams are demoted back into a Pro conference at the same time, room is made for the second team by demoting an additional team from Pro to AAA, and then from AAA to AA if necessary. Removing gutted teams along the way can help with this. This is an idea that has been questioned - fearing the Pro-to-AAA demoted team would not be happy with it. Keep in mind that additional AAA teams were pulled up before they naturally should have been promoted to replace teams headed to the World League, so this is the other side of the same coin.

○ Over time this system allows regions that deserve more representation to get it. If teams from one region are able to succeed (make the playoffs) in the World League, they will stay and others from their region will join them there. In the most extreme case, one region could potentially have 18 representatives while the other 7 regions have only their 2 reps. Getting from the initial 4 reps to the potential top of 18 would take 7 seasons, would be very tough and unlikely, but possible.


► Pro's of this format:

○ Fair initial set-up.

○ Ensures representation from all regions in the future.

○ Allows for stronger leagues to eventually send more reps to the World League.

○ Requirement to stay in the World League (qualify for playoffs) is tough - as it should be for an ELITE league.

○ Turnover rate will be half of the league each season, allowing for new blood on a regular basis.

○ Promotion / relegation is handled in a fair manner.

○ Some regional conference rivalries will be preserved.

○ The long-awaited World League can finally begin.


► Con's of this format:

○ Initial season will not house the best 32 Pro teams in the game.

○ other?


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.