Originally posted by ryanshaw
Originally posted by NotRippedYet
Playcalling isn't really random within your SIM, but random within the scope of the game as a whole. Has nothing to do with an AI not being followed at all, you just got shit on by the way Bort setup the playcalling randomization.
This is correct. The sim playcalling is not random and the sim uses changes in the playcalling to get the result it 'wants'. I have been through this a million times - you play a team that is better than you and all of a sudden it starts calling the worst plays possible, ignoring your gameplan and having huge runs of similar plays called at once (eg lots of passes in a row in a run heavy AI) . I put up a post last season and even worked out the stats of the playcalling coming out the way it did based on the AI inputs to show it was highly unlikely to be the result of chance. In my playoff game this season, I had a 35% chance of calling a running play out of the I formation on first down. Actual result - 1 of 21 (eg 4%). Random my arse!
The reality is that Bort won't change it - it has been pointed out enough times. I believe that he uses this as part of game balance and is concerned that there would be upsets all the time if people started being able to control the playcalling exactly the way they want.
No. Just no.
It's random. Sometimes it's random in your favor. Sometimes it's random calling your not-so-good plays more often.
Originally posted by NotRippedYet
Playcalling isn't really random within your SIM, but random within the scope of the game as a whole. Has nothing to do with an AI not being followed at all, you just got shit on by the way Bort setup the playcalling randomization.
This is correct. The sim playcalling is not random and the sim uses changes in the playcalling to get the result it 'wants'. I have been through this a million times - you play a team that is better than you and all of a sudden it starts calling the worst plays possible, ignoring your gameplan and having huge runs of similar plays called at once (eg lots of passes in a row in a run heavy AI) . I put up a post last season and even worked out the stats of the playcalling coming out the way it did based on the AI inputs to show it was highly unlikely to be the result of chance. In my playoff game this season, I had a 35% chance of calling a running play out of the I formation on first down. Actual result - 1 of 21 (eg 4%). Random my arse!
The reality is that Bort won't change it - it has been pointed out enough times. I believe that he uses this as part of game balance and is concerned that there would be upsets all the time if people started being able to control the playcalling exactly the way they want.
No. Just no.
It's random. Sometimes it's random in your favor. Sometimes it's random calling your not-so-good plays more often.






























