User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Gameplan doesnt run in playoff game WTF?
Page:
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw
Originally posted by NotRippedYet



Playcalling isn't really random within your SIM, but random within the scope of the game as a whole. Has nothing to do with an AI not being followed at all, you just got shit on by the way Bort setup the playcalling randomization.


This is correct. The sim playcalling is not random and the sim uses changes in the playcalling to get the result it 'wants'. I have been through this a million times - you play a team that is better than you and all of a sudden it starts calling the worst plays possible, ignoring your gameplan and having huge runs of similar plays called at once (eg lots of passes in a row in a run heavy AI) . I put up a post last season and even worked out the stats of the playcalling coming out the way it did based on the AI inputs to show it was highly unlikely to be the result of chance. In my playoff game this season, I had a 35% chance of calling a running play out of the I formation on first down. Actual result - 1 of 21 (eg 4%). Random my arse!

The reality is that Bort won't change it - it has been pointed out enough times. I believe that he uses this as part of game balance and is concerned that there would be upsets all the time if people started being able to control the playcalling exactly the way they want.


No. Just no.

It's random. Sometimes it's random in your favor. Sometimes it's random calling your not-so-good plays more often.
 
monkeyskin
offline
Link
 
This formation does not exist in my AI

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=688040&pbp_id=17359183

I've done the tester, etc..
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bhall43
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by ddingo


Originally posted by islander1



Originally posted by Sik Wit It




Originally posted by islander1





Did one of you have the tactics/AI page open after 1pm?



Don't know.

But as for the FG thing:

http://img407.imageshack.us/img407/5112/picture5w.png

LOL. In the very same picture you have us kicking a FG, and the AI tester saying Punt. I love it.


auto adjust? ldo?


Turned off of course.

Bhall's OAI was set last night and my defense was in place 2 hours prior to the game. FWIW, the defense was run as loaded. Very frustrating to play a great team like Washington and something like this happens.

No one on the Lincoln team is suggesting that we win the game if it didn't happen. Only that we rolled out the one-legged man in the ass-kicking contest.


You have my regrets either way. I'm not suggesting at all this couldn't have happened to you guys. I'm just going through my OC mistakes over my career, and what caused them. I asked about the AI being open before gametime because once - and this is way back in S5 - I left my DAI open while a scrim with Halifax was running, and it ended up running basic AI. Hilarity ensued.


edit: oh, and TSE's guide says use auto-adjust at 50, so I didn't want to assume



if i had some small thought that this could be my error on something i did in that plan...i would never have brought it up and would have just came out and told the guys i was sorry...but i mean...i looked through this plan about 100 times now...had several others look through it...and then checked it again...like Dave said...not saying it changes the result of the game...but come on...at least give me a fighting chance there...some of the play calls were just horrendous...stuff that i didnt even have in the playbook even...worst part is i spent all day planning for this game yesterday only to watch the CPU plan it for me...


I'm really sorry
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by monkeyskin
This formation does not exist in my AI

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=688040&pbp_id=17359183

I've done the tester, etc..


stamndard 3-1-7 cover 3?
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by monkeyskin

This formation does not exist in my AI

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=688040&pbp_id=17359183

I've done the tester, etc..


stamndard 3-1-7 cover 3?


Dime.
 
monkeyskin
offline
Link
 
What I mean is, against 5WR it does not exist.

It only happened once, I'm having problems and it's completely random.
Edited by monkeyskin on Jul 23, 2009 18:17:12
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by monkeyskin


This formation does not exist in my AI

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=688040&pbp_id=17359183

I've done the tester, etc..


stamndard 3-1-7 cover 3?


Dime.


indeed.
 
monkeyskin
offline
Link
 
I don't run dime against 5WR... and it only happened once, lol
 
crazy454
what
offline
Link
 
I logged into my al a few hours before my game and the defense was reverted back to what is was before, and the Offense was an Al I have never seen.
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by ryanshaw

Originally posted by NotRippedYet




Playcalling isn't really random within your SIM, but random within the scope of the game as a whole. Has nothing to do with an AI not being followed at all, you just got shit on by the way Bort setup the playcalling randomization.


This is correct. The sim playcalling is not random and the sim uses changes in the playcalling to get the result it 'wants'. I have been through this a million times - you play a team that is better than you and all of a sudden it starts calling the worst plays possible, ignoring your gameplan and having huge runs of similar plays called at once (eg lots of passes in a row in a run heavy AI) . I put up a post last season and even worked out the stats of the playcalling coming out the way it did based on the AI inputs to show it was highly unlikely to be the result of chance. In my playoff game this season, I had a 35% chance of calling a running play out of the I formation on first down. Actual result - 1 of 21 (eg 4%). Random my arse!

The reality is that Bort won't change it - it has been pointed out enough times. I believe that he uses this as part of game balance and is concerned that there would be upsets all the time if people started being able to control the playcalling exactly the way they want.


No. Just no.

It's random. Sometimes it's random in your favor. Sometimes it's random calling your not-so-good plays more often.


Sorry, but the statistics do not back this up - it happens far too often to be random. Even in this case, the chance of this outcome is less than 1.5% and I had pretty much the same experience in the playoffs last year (3% chance of the same playcalling outcome in that case). I have not been breaking any mirrors! This issue has been widely reported and even Bort has hinted that there are some 'issues' with the random number generator. In addition, there have been tests done where people have set their AI to 100% run and it still calls passes.

My own theory is that the sim autoadjusts to your bad plays even when autoadjust is off if the other team are stronger than you, or as part of some kind of momentum effect. I maintain this is out of order since playcalling should not be subject to this kind of interference - it should follow exactly what you have set.

It is a dangerous game to always support the sim and assume that any complaints are unfounded - this is why so many things never end up getting fixed....
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Bump! More threads are popping up with more of the same crap!
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by ryanshaw


Originally posted by NotRippedYet





Playcalling isn't really random within your SIM, but random within the scope of the game as a whole. Has nothing to do with an AI not being followed at all, you just got shit on by the way Bort setup the playcalling randomization.


This is correct. The sim playcalling is not random and the sim uses changes in the playcalling to get the result it 'wants'. I have been through this a million times - you play a team that is better than you and all of a sudden it starts calling the worst plays possible, ignoring your gameplan and having huge runs of similar plays called at once (eg lots of passes in a row in a run heavy AI) . I put up a post last season and even worked out the stats of the playcalling coming out the way it did based on the AI inputs to show it was highly unlikely to be the result of chance. In my playoff game this season, I had a 35% chance of calling a running play out of the I formation on first down. Actual result - 1 of 21 (eg 4%). Random my arse!

The reality is that Bort won't change it - it has been pointed out enough times. I believe that he uses this as part of game balance and is concerned that there would be upsets all the time if people started being able to control the playcalling exactly the way they want.


No. Just no.

It's random. Sometimes it's random in your favor. Sometimes it's random calling your not-so-good plays more often.


Sorry, but the statistics do not back this up - it happens far too often to be random. Even in this case, the chance of this outcome is less than 1.5% and I had pretty much the same experience in the playoffs last year (3% chance of the same playcalling outcome in that case). I have not been breaking any mirrors! This issue has been widely reported and even Bort has hinted that there are some 'issues' with the random number generator. In addition, there have been tests done where people have set their AI to 100% run and it still calls passes.

My own theory is that the sim autoadjusts to your bad plays even when autoadjust is off if the other team are stronger than you, or as part of some kind of momentum effect. I maintain this is out of order since playcalling should not be subject to this kind of interference - it should follow exactly what you have set.

It is a dangerous game to always support the sim and assume that any complaints are unfounded - this is why so many things never end up getting fixed....


I'm not someone who always supports the sim. I just don't think there's a predetermined outcome, then all the plays are made up to match that. It doesn't even make sense, and I'm almost sure it's not true. I'm sure there's cases where someone put 100% run and it passed all the time. Like I said in this thread, it's very possible the play calling bugs sometimes. But to say it's pre-determined for the better team to win, then all the plays are generated is stupid and a cop-out.

Remember Season 8? The Strong I Slam season?

A team I'm on in CPL knew we were outmatched facing Halifax in the 1st round, so me and a friend convinced the OC to just run the SI-Slam all game. We lost by 3, and the play calls were almost exclusively Strong I Slam. He did add a few other plays in there though, so it wasn't 100%.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=465432

If we didn't run the Strong I Slam, we probably would've lost by at least 30. So by your logic, the score would've been a lot farther apart than that, then it would fill the game with plays to conform to the score, with plays we didn't even call. That didn't happen.

When Drygerian threw their Week 16 game to screw SI's old team out of the playoffs, did the sim "come up" with this 120-115 loss, then fill in all the plays to make the game conform to that?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=588202

What you're saying is just ridiculous.
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

I'm not someone who always supports the sim. I just don't think there's a predetermined outcome, then all the plays are made up to match that. It doesn't even make sense, and I'm almost sure it's not true. I'm sure there's cases where someone put 100% run and it passed all the time. Like I said in this thread, it's very possible the play calling bugs sometimes. But to say it's pre-determined for the better team to win, then all the plays are generated is stupid and a cop-out.

Remember Season 8? The Strong I Slam season?

A team I'm on in CPL knew we were outmatched facing Halifax in the 1st round, so me and a friend convinced the OC to just run the SI-Slam all game. We lost by 3, and the play calls were almost exclusively Strong I Slam. He did add a few other plays in there though, so it wasn't 100%.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=465432

If we didn't run the Strong I Slam, we probably would've lost by at least 30. So by your logic, the score would've been a lot farther apart than that, then it would fill the game with plays to conform to the score, with plays we didn't even call. That didn't happen.

When Drygerian threw their Week 16 game to screw SI's old team out of the playoffs, did the sim "come up" with this 120-115 loss, then fill in all the plays to make the game conform to that?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=588202

What you're saying is just ridiculous.


You have actually mis-interpreted what I said and as a result you have missed the point. I never claimed that the sim determined the result of the game and then went back and worked out the plays. What I did say is that the sim messes around with the randomness of the playcalling. This is almost undeniable based on the stats - the question is how and why. It is my GUESS that the sim has some built in momentum counter (which would be reasonable based on what Bort has said) which probably starts off the game favouring the stronger team (as you would expect). As momentum moves against you in a game (which is affected by the results of plays) the sim then alters the weighting of your playcalls in the AI against plays that are doing well. As a result, the worse things are going for you in a game the more of a departure there will be from the preset AI percentages. This is all guesswork but it does seem to fit the pattern I have seen. My point is that if the sim is adjusting the percentages it is totally wrong and unfair as there is no reason that the coaches would suddenly be unable to do basic arithmetic on the sidelines just because you start doing badly on the field!

None of your examples disprove what I have said. Your SI slam game was close because you called runs all the time - so what? I did not actually claim (others have) that the sim makes up playcalls that you never called - I said it changes the percentage chance of some AI outputs being called. If you were running 90% the same play it is pretty unlikely that this would make much of a difference.

You need to stick to the facts. If you have certain playcalls with a 35% chance of being called and they actually get called only 1 time in 21 plays, the statistical chances of that happening are very, very small. It is quite easy to find similar examples and taken together they show with a high degree of likelihood that the plays are not being selected strictly at random based on the percentages in the AI. Whether this is because of a deliberate effect (as I have guessed) or just because the random number generator is screwed is a matter of interpretation, but the fact that Bort or the admins have refused consistently to answer this matter does make me think it is the former.
 
kadafitcd
offline
Link
 
Don't you all love it when the Mods disappear when there is a legitimate problem. But when you bring up something like playoff xp they pop in and give you a link to the not goin to happen thread and lock down your thread. This needs to be addressed. Atleast let us know you are looking into these problems FFS!
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by islander1

Did one of you have the tactics/AI page open after 1pm?



Don't know.

But as for the FG thing:

http://img407.imageshack.us/img407/5112/picture5w.png

LOL. In the very same picture you have us kicking a FG, and the AI tester saying Punt. I love it.


I had problem with the OAI/DAI tester from the replay page. It sometime runs the wrong test.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.