User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > FWIW, I totally do not believe in an X-factor
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
People still missing what 'x-factor' is imo. Sure, we know all about how good co-ordinating and having good players around you makes you play better and put up great stats, and how fixing/improving builds makes you play better too.

But x-factor is that thing which defies all this and the actual build itself, and height/weight. A player with such unexceptional build and with mediocre players around him, even a shit co-ordinator, yet that player performs above their level, etc.

It's easier to see x-factor in that circumstance, than trying to assign x-factor to every great stat-machine in a mighty Pro-League team of level 69ers. In really young players like level 1-24 is where you can really see it or not, where it stands out, cos builds are so undeveloped.



Yes I believe in chupacabras too.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Well, it's your fault for building generally good solid builds, playing in good leagues and in good teams with winning seasons. It'd be like trying to find an ugly girl in a Miss Universe pageant.

X-Factor is more evident on crappy teams where players just stand out for no reason, with no spectacular builds, no reason for them being so good/fast/strong/etc. Stand out like a tall blonde babe in an arabic third world nation.
Edited by GG on Jul 23, 2009 01:09:11
 
Pariah
offline
Link
 
I have some early X-Factor comics.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Well, it's your fault for building generally good solid builds, playing in good leagues and in good teams with winning seasons. It'd be like trying to find an ugly girl in a Miss Universe pageant.

X-Factor is more evident on crappy teams where players just stand out for no reason, with no spectacular builds, no reason for them being so good/fast/strong/etc. Stand out like a tall blonde babe in an arabic third world nation.


I have to admit that I've seen some builds out there that most would consider absolutely horrendous, yet no matter where they go, they always perform at a very high level. I don't know if it's x-factor, or just that the majority of these shit builds are SUPER balanced, so they're able to win rolls with their second & third attributes factored in, whereas what we all consider a "good build" wins primarily on that first attribute, and a little help from #2.



Ex:
WR: 120 speed, 80 agility, 70 catching, 40 carrying, 30 strength
WR: 75 speed, 60 agility, 60 catching, 50 carrying, 50 strength


We'd all expect #1 to outperform, but in many cases, I've seen builds like #2 perform extremely well.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
I don't know if it's x-factor


It's x-factor!
But yeah, that's what i mean, they just excel "in spite of" their meh builds etc.
Also, it's evident in like this example....

A LB only level 24-ish, still slow-building the rest of their attributes, might have something like only 30 in tackling and strength, because they went for speed/agility first. Anyway, they never miss tackles. Or, if the team gets pounded, and most other players are missing like 5 tackles each, he might only have 1.
Meanwhile, other LBs, who've got like 50-50 in strength, tackling, same level or higher, are missing tackles all the time, even when agents pump more into strength-tackling-agility, they just keep missing them. While the other player, as he progresses from level 24 to level 40 on, continues to be a tackling machine and getting better and better as their tackling-strength increases to 50-60.

Edited by GG on Jul 23, 2009 01:24:28
 
Bloodfart
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by Forbin

I don't know if it's x-factor


It's x-factor!
But yeah, that's what i mean, they just excel "in spite of" their meh builds etc.
Also, it's evident in like this example....

A LB only level 24-ish, still slow-building the rest of their attributes, might have something like only 30 in tackling and strength, because they went for speed/agility first. Anyway, they never miss tackles. Or, if the team gets pounded, and most other players are missing like 5 tackles each, he might only have 1.
Meanwhile, other LBs, who've got like 50-50 in strength, tackling, same level or higher, are missing tackles all the time, even when agents pump more into strength-tackling-agility, they just keep missing them. While the other player, as he progresses from level 24 to level 40 on, continues to be a tackling machine and getting better and better as their tackling-strength increases to 50-60.



maybe the ones with 50/50 strength / tackling are set on balanced or power while the other is set to wrap up. my own theory on LB's and tackles is the bigger ones miss less.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Bigger sized LBs? True generally speaking, size/weight does play a part, does help. Tho we often see big LBs mimicking turnstiles, and smaller ones who just rape and plunder anything that moves. And vice versa.
Edited by GG on Jul 23, 2009 01:55:54
Edited by GG on Jul 23, 2009 01:55:17
 
Iron Maiden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Bigger sized LBs? True generally speaking, size/weight does play a part, does help. Tho we often see big LBs mimicking turnstiles, and smaller ones who just rape and plunder anything that moves. And vice versa.


Well, if size and weight has THAT much influence in performance, then why roll for 8's?
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
I've seen and coordinated enough high end player builds to respectfully disagree with Hulk.
 
Dudeamis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Iron Maiden
Originally posted by GG

Bigger sized LBs? True generally speaking, size/weight does play a part, does help. Tho we often see big LBs mimicking turnstiles, and smaller ones who just rape and plunder anything that moves. And vice versa.


Well, if size and weight has THAT much influence in performance, then why roll for 8's?


roll for size and 8s
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fM_AyJH0aFw

X factor
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Well, if size and weight has THAT much influence in performance, then why roll for 8's????????????????????




Some of my players have over 5 million rolls each. Roll for height, weight, 8's, and highest possible attribute
Edited by dpride59 on Jul 23, 2009 06:28:55
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
I strongly feel that when players are in a league of equal talent, that the X-factor is height, weight, and luck. Height and weight give a slight edge when they complement the build in my opinion. Luck seems to be the biggest X-factor since I think there is some randomness programmed into the game.

That's my two cents.
 
randomguymike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HULK
I've had players suck one season and then be awesome 2 seasons later. They didn't pick up an X-factor over night. I just fixed the build with time.

Look at Dooley, people have called that dot an x-factor dot. But the truth is he was very mediocre for a long time, then he got his build right and became a force of nature.

X-factor is a myth. If your dot isn't any good, it isn't cause of some mystical made up reason. Its cause he isn't any good. Doesn't mean you can't salvage him. Dots can go from terrible to dominant, I've seen it plenty of times.


Do you remeber when Dooley opened the build publicly? There is no other explanation than X-Factor. The build was the most unexceptional build I've seen in a while. I've seen 20 backs built the exact same.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
I find it hard to believe that Bort would have thought about coding an x-factor when he is still thinking of things he left out.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.