User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > DPC blitzing when player set to move to another assignment
Page:
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
What are their other settings? Blitz or Zone. I didn;t click all your links but they were in such a location that if they were set to zone then picking up the secondary player looks to have also fit within their zone scheme.

For example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589240&pbp_id=6807973 CB5 to HB-TE... Well if they are set for HB they'll line up where they were. Then, when the HB stayed in to pass block, CB's Zone would have included that TE, so that they picked up coverage on the TE is coincidence not design. If TE had tun an outside route the CB likely wouldn;t have picked them up depending where the TE was on the field at that time.

I'm not making anything up. I did say it sometimes works, and I said that earlier as well. But I am also saying that it is not a BUG that it doesn't always work because _BY DESIGN_ it is not supposed to work (But SHOULD imo)

I'm looking for the thread but there is a thread about the MLB bug where they were NOT blitzing as told to by the DPC but instead sticking to a zone. It was noted very specifically in this thread that it is NOT a checkdown list by someone who knows/is involved in the testing etc. I'll keep looking for it for you, or if anyone else has a link to it that would be great.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
These really poop on your new argument of "well they did it cause of the zone"

ROLB set to FB -HB http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589244&pbp_id=14790739

This one is great - LOLB set to TE - WR2, SS set to HB-TE-WR2 http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589183&pbp_id=10390746

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589244&pbp_id=14787643 SS goes out with the TE there

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589240&pbp_id=6807973 and the CB follows him across there
Edited by odg62 on Jul 24, 2009 14:55:29
Edited by odg62 on Jul 24, 2009 14:51:03
Edited by odg62 on Jul 24, 2009 14:49:20
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
From Thread: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2914543

robbnva's thread about the DPC being broken.

Originally posted by r8
Originally posted by Bort

Yes, the DPC options do only come into effect before the play, as that is when it sets up all the player target actions, and that was the desired behavior initially. I believe I was looking at making the fallback option work after the fact instead, but I do not remember where I got on that. I think I got somewhat sidetracked from it.

Or is the issue really that that player just doesn't blitz, ever, if you set it?


Originally posted by Rate

Yeah, that's what I thought, the before-the-play stuff.

The player just drops into some funky zone/man-to-man most of the time, basically just latching onto the first player to run through their zone.

I definitely think that tying in the fallback option after the fact would be a great addition to the game, because I think that everyone is just assuming that it should be that way. I mean, you'd obviously still want to have a vision check of some sort, but if the player KNOWS that they player they are covering is staying in to block, they should absolutely have the option to blitz.


Originally posted by Bort

Does the player always drop into the zone? It should make him blitz if he is set to it, though he'll line up over his man, etc.


Originally posted by Rate

That's what Robbnva's thing showed, was that they basically never blitz, even when they are set to it. The only time they will actually blitz is if the player they are supposed to be covering is NOT on the field. i.e. if the LOLB is supposed to cover the FB OR Blitz but it's a singleback set, he will blitz. However, if it's set to FB OR Blitz and the FB stays in to block, the LOLB drops into zone anyways.


Originally posted by Bort

Hm, I'm looking through the code and there's a vision check on being able to blitz when your man is set to "block." If you fail it, you do the zone thing instead. It could be that the players are failing it too often, and I should just remove that vision check.

However, I'm wondering if in fact the player is dropping into "spy" on his man, and then he ends up in zone when his spied man blocks. That's the fallback option in general when the play setup can't figure out what to do with the player you're supposed to cover.




So there's the first bit from Bort's mouth.

Yes it seems sometimes that it works. Which I am GLAD for. But its not how things are _supposed_ to work in the current iteration per Bort himself.

You cover the first guy on the field in your check down list. After that, you are supposed to blitz or zone. Sometimes it actually works down your list but thats not by design (Though again.. I stress _it should be_).

 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
I think there was another thread about this too but I'm not going to spend much more time finding it.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
These really poop on your new argument of "well they did it cause of the zone"

ROLB set to FB -HB http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589244&pbp_id=14790739

This one is great - LOLB set to TE - WR2, SS set to HB-TE-WR2 http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589183&pbp_id=10390746

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589244&pbp_id=14787643 SS goes out with the TE there

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589240&pbp_id=6807973 and the CB follows him across there


Yay, you're smarter than r8 and Bort.

Like I said, there is another thread out there as well talking about the Specific Zone the MLB's drop into and more of this was covered in that one too. Same guys involved (You know.. dudes like r8 and Bort) discussing the DPC and the 'checkdown' list...
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
That long quote above mentions absolultley nothing about checking down to another assignment, in other words it says absolutley nothing about a player who is set to move to another man assignment after his initial assignment stays into block.

literally nothing.

That only talks about a player who is set to "FB or blitz"

Again, since you really seem to be having a hard time with this, the thread you linked and the posts you quoted have nothing to do with checking off to another man. That thread is about D players with one assignment not blitzing. That is why the change was made. Since the change guys now blitz instead of checking off to the next man or staying in their zone. Not to mention, the first few quotes in that post are pre live DPC.

Even after the replays i posted you still insist on saying D players dont check off assignments.

Can you admit your wrong, or will you continue to just keep talking out your ass?
Edited by odg62 on Jul 24, 2009 15:13:13
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Enkidu98
Originally posted by odg62

These really poop on your new argument of "well they did it cause of the zone"

ROLB set to FB -HB http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589244&pbp_id=14790739

This one is great - LOLB set to TE - WR2, SS set to HB-TE-WR2 http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589183&pbp_id=10390746

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589244&pbp_id=14787643 SS goes out with the TE there

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589240&pbp_id=6807973 and the CB follows him across there


Yay, you're smarter than r8 and Bort.

Like I said, there is another thread out there as well talking about the Specific Zone the MLB's drop into and more of this was covered in that one too. Same guys involved (You know.. dudes like r8 and Bort) discussing the DPC and the 'checkdown' list...


really dude? your still gonna say that this replay the CB fell into a zone? http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589240&pbp_id=6807973

Which zone is that? Flat Middle?

Stop it dude, your looking worst with each post you make
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
really dude? your still gonna say that this replay the CB fell into a zone? http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=589240&pbp_id=6807973

Which zone is that? Flat Middle?

Stop it dude, your looking worst with each post you make



The 'Zones CB's fall into are based on their starting positions. Part of the other thread was asking about if we could maybe assign the zone the LB fell into because the MLB zone appears to be a tiny little zone thats useless so that when he does decide to zone he's taken out of the play.

So, since you had CB5 as the coverage here, CB 5's natural zone is just a little circle around where CB5 normally lines up. His DEFAULT zone would have overlapped with the TE's path and the TE would have been in that zone thus he picks it up. (For an example, go to the DPC, create a new DPC play, and first thing first, go to friggen CB#5 and change him to 'cover zone' Which default zone shows up for him dude? Does it happen to overlap with the coverage he fell into? By jove I think it does!

Also, see r8's comment above where he says they'll often jsut drop into M2m against the closest target.

The thing you are not realising is I am saying it is BETTER if it really is a checkdown list. I DO NOT disagree that it SHOULD be a check down list.

What I am saying though is that it does not always ACT like a check down list.
Note: DOES NOT ALWAYS ACT LIKE A CHECK DOWN LIST.

That is because if you read the DPC description it says _specifically_ the first person in their checkdowns that is on the field is the one they cover and IF that person stays in to block instead of runs a route, then they will zone or blitz as specifed.

It is a very simple if|then operand.

Its not If|then check another if|then and if|check another if than. If it were, I would hope that Bort would have worded it that way so that it would be more clear.

So you are arguing with me about something I have said SHOULD be the normal behaviour, but that per things said in the thread linked above and the MLB zone thread I can;t find right now, that its not set up that way.

Its cover your first coverage and if they do not run a route, zone or blitz. Its not a true check down as I have had it explained, seen in threads, and as it shows up in the instructional verbiage in the DPC.


EDIT: so, when people complain that it DOESN'T check down that the player blitzes ro zones if their FIRST target on the list stays in to block, that this is NOT a bug and it meets the TEXT of the DPC and its description of how things work.

NOT A BUG =/= Should work this way anyway.

I know that is a subtle difference for some, but it makes perfect sense to me.

EG... Something SHOULD work some waym but presently doesn't even though the set up for it seems perfectly logical to work the way we think it SHOULD work.

That means it should be a suggestion, something along the lines of.. 'Please Make DPC Man Coverage List work as a check down list' in the suggestions forum, not a DPC Checkdown list doesn;t work, when the DPC text makes it pretty clear it is NOT a checkdown list the way you would like it to be _DESPITE_ occasional evidence of it working the way you want it to.... because you wouldn;t be complaining in the BUGS forum if it worked that way all the time now would you? Instead you cam with examples of where it WASN'T working, which is actually how, per the present description, it is supposed to be working.

Capische?
Edited by Enkidu98 on Jul 24, 2009 15:32:41
Edited by Enkidu98 on Jul 24, 2009 15:29:41
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
One more thing:

This should be instructive on why it would be nice to be able to determine the zone you want your man to cover if he does decide to go zone because his coverage stays in to pass block.

You can look at the 'defauls' zones for each position, and sometimes these defaults are actually bad places for the player to end up per the play they were lined up against.

EDIT - Sorry last edit.

I sent my question on and requested that they possibly come to this thread and give us a more definitive answer.

For clarity sake on my position.
I BELIEVE it is best if it works as a checkdown list. I think this is how it SHOULD work.
I understand though from the DPC wording that it is not a check down list except for the pre-snap decision on who the player covers and if this player they are assigned to cover pass blocks, then they will Blitz|Zone. It does not make another _post_ snap vision check to try to move further down their 'check down' list.

I'll refrain from responding any more until this gets clarified. And again, for the record I would PREFER that post snap there are additional checks so it does work like a true check down list.
Edited by Enkidu98 on Jul 24, 2009 15:45:57
 
r8
offline
Link
 
My apologies for not getting to this sooner I could've prevented a lot of pointless arguing.

But this is correct:

Originally posted by Enkidu98
In that discussion it was stated very specifically that it is NOT a progression list as you expect it to be.

They go down the list and cover the FIRST player on the list regardless of what that player is set to do.
IF the selected man does not run a route THEN they do Blitz|Zone.

It DOES NOT say, They cover the first man on their list. IF their selected man stays in to block THEN they check status on the next player, etc until all selections are exhausted and then Blitz|Zone.


Right now the progression only counts PRE-SNAP. Here's a few different examples.

Say you have your LOLB set on TE -> HB or Blitz
If the TE is on the field, and runs a route, the LOLB covers the TE.
If the TE is on the field, and stays in to block, the LOLB moves to the "Blitz" part.
If the TE is NOT on the field, and the HB runs a route, the LOLB covers the HB
If the TE is NOT on the field, and the HB stays in to block, the LOLB moves to the "Blitz" part.

We have talked about making the progression work post-snap (like it probably should, tbh), but right now it does not work that way.

Here's the discussion on it straight from the test server in the words of Bort.

Originally posted by Rate
Found a little thing.

http://test.goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1263&pbp_id=278464

The MLB here is set to Cover FB, TE, OR Blitz.

Can we make it so that he covers the TE when he reads the FB is blocking instead of skipping straight to Blitz?


Originally posted by Bort
Hm, not as easily. The coverage options are sort of forgotten after the play is set up. I wonder also: would it make defense too easy to set up and too overpowered?


Originally posted by tpaterniti
So I am confused. How does it work? And why does it give you more than 1 option if it either reads the option you picked first or last but nothing in between?


Originally posted by Bort
For if your player is not in the play.

If you select FB, for instance for the first guy, and it's a shotgun play, the player will move on to the next player. Otherwise, it's always the first on the list.


Originally posted by Deathblade
Always assumed it was progressive...it's just how it should work : /

Kind of dumb to have a player set to cover the HB or FB, and if the HB blocks, the player stands there with his thumb in his ass.


Originally posted by Zickzack
Agreed, and I am pretty certain that is what about 90% of the player base believes. Any chance that this can/will be changed at some point?


Originally posted by Bort
Maybe; I will have to think on how to make it work.


So yes, what Enkidu is saying is exactly how it works now, but yes, we are looking at ways to make it work during the play as well.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Who are you Jesse Cosopolis?

Yes i understand what you are saying, i have understood it from your first post ITT.

I have demonstrated that i understand what you are saying several times.

I have also shown clear examples that prove quite effectivley that what you are saying is wrong.

Despite replays that go against everything you have said, depite the fact that you keep spewing the same bullshit and acting like because you drop a name it makes it correct even when its clearly wrong, you continue to act like you are right.

Your only argument is, "i know there is a thread somewhere that Bort and r8 have a quote in and im right cause i said so"

Well while your right cause you said so [sarcasam] I must be wrong for showing definitive proof that yes, D players do checkdown on assignments.

Obviously, showing the same play from before the change, with the MLB and SS CHECKING OFF to other receivers and showing the SAME PLAY(with one minor adj.) after the change with the MLB and SS blitzing is not enough for you to understand that yes, D players checkdown assignments when prompted too in the DPC.

I guess im gonna have to keep finding replays until you "Capische" this. Obviously showing a CB assigneed to cover the HB then TE folllow a TE about 15 yards across the feild in what is CLEARLY MAN 2 MAN COVERAGE is not enough for you to understand that yes, D players checkdown assignments when prompted too in the DPC.

Obviously showing a replay where the LOLB set to cover the TE then WR2 follow WR2 15 yards downfeild in what is CLEARLY MAN 2 MAN COVERAGE is not enough for you to understand that yes, D players checkdown assignments when prompted too in the DPC.

Those are not zones. period.

I listed what, about 10 replays, 4 of which beyond any doubt show the checkdown process, how many more do you have to see?

Edited by odg62 on Jul 24, 2009 15:52:31
 
r8
offline
Link
 
1) Calm down a little odg, it's just a forum

2) Might wanna go back and read my post. Enkidu is right.
 
odg62
offline
Link
 
well i look pretty dumb, but i still dont see how the replays i posted dont show the progression. specifically the one where the CB chases the TE across the feild.

and the play i posted where the SS and MLB go to their progression pre change and blitz post change.
Edited by odg62 on Jul 24, 2009 15:57:30
 
Link
 
Originally posted by r8
Say you have your LOLB set on TE -> HB or Blitz
If the TE is on the field, and runs a route, the LOLB covers the TE.
If the TE is on the field, and stays in to block, the LOLB moves to the "Blitz" part.
If the TE is NOT on the field, and the HB runs a route, the LOLB covers the HB
If the TE is NOT on the field, and the HB stays in to block, the LOLB moves to the "Blitz" part.


What if the setting is "SS on HB->or Zone" and the SS is still blitzing like on these plays I posted:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=687779&pbp_id=17522885
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=687779&pbp_id=17523694

This is a SS with almost 70 vision, so a failed vision check can't be it.

am I misunderstanding something?
 
r8
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
well i look pretty dumb, but i still dont see how the replays i posted dont show the progression. specifically the one where the CB chases the TE across the feild.


That's the way the "Zone" works for the Cover options, it basically creates a small zone around the player, and they lock onto the first player that cuts through it. So it's actually kind of a Zone2Man deal.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.