Very interesting, T. That post has a lot of very good points.
bamaplaya1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ts-Rock
Originally posted by griffin8r
At this point, Bort has it set to disregard blowouts, which rewards great players on middle-tier teams.
What it needs to do is disregard non-playoff teams, which will make it a lot more dynamic early in the season, but as the playoff picture clarifies, will result in a much better balance.
There are some teams (like the 34 cap I play for) that dominated nearly all the games they played. To have their players basically not in consideration for MVP because they kicked so much ass? Well, we're back to the kindergarten thing, giving people blue ribbons because they tried....
got that from thread in main forum
we had the same issue with our team....check out the huge seperation in stats here...
so I'm a little baffled by the MVP. This is a comparison for of the MVP winner in uncapped #2. Barry 2k9 is the winner and the #3 guy Speed "MVP" Optional and the #5 guy Chief Tenderfoot.
Speed and Chief play on the same team and were far and way the best RB's in the league despite being the lowest level RBs of any playoff team. The comparison is only vs the playoff teams.
Can someone please tell me why this guy Barry is the MVP over these other two candidates. I thought I heard that the MVP is takes in account the % of total offense 1 guy makes up for his team. Is this why Barry wins over two RB's on the same team?
Season Totals:
Barry 2k9 (lvl 61): 1,696.5 Rush yards, 47 Rush TDs, 7.3 avg, 106 Ruhs YPG.....94 Rec, 1,101.5 Rec Yards, 11 Rec TDs, 68.8 Rec YPG
Totals: 2,798 yards, 58 TDs, 174.9 YPG
Speed "MVP" Optional (lvl 46): 3,860 Rush yards, 85 Rush TDs, 14.2 avg, 241.3 Rush YPG....32 Rec, 497.5 yards, 11 Rec TDs
Totals: 4,357.5 yards, 96 TDs, 272.3 YPG
Chief Tenderfoot (lvl 43): 4,740 Rush yards, 93 Rush TDs, 12.4 avg, 296.3 rush YPG....3 Rec, 12 yards, 2 Rec TDs
Totals: 4,752 yards, 95 TDs, 297.0 YPG
Team . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Barry 2k9 vs Playoff Teams
East Asia . . . . . . . . 14 car, 64.5 yards, 4.5 avg, 0 TDs..........8 rec, 21 yards, 0 TDs
Victorica. . . . . . . . . 20 car, 25.0 yards, 1.3 avg, 0 TDs..........2 rec, 7 yards, 0 TDs, 1 Fum
California . . . . . . . . 2 car, 14.0 yards, 7.0 avg, 0 TDs..........5 rec, 24 yards, 0 TDs
St. John's . . . . . . . 14 car, 38. 5 yards, 2.8 avg, 0 TDs.........5 rec, 33.5 yards, 0 TDs
Glasgow . . . . . . . . .NA
MMC . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 car, 111.0 yards, 13.9 avg, 2 TDs.......1 rec, 13.5 yards, 0 TDs
Huntsville . . . . . . . 14 car, 38. 5 yards, 2.8 avg, 0 TDs.........6 rec, 42 yards, 0 TDs
W.C. . . . . . . . . . . . .17 car, 121.5 yards, 7.1 avg, 4 TDs.......12 rec, 140 yards, 0 TDs, 1 Fum
Totals: 89 carries, 413 yards, 4.6 avg, 6 TDs.....39 catches, 281 yards, 0 TDs
Game Avg: 12.7 carries, 59.0 yards, 4.6 avg, .85 TDs.......5.6 catches, 40.1 yards, 0 TDs
Team . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Speed Optional vs Playoff Teams
East Asia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . NA
Victorica. . . . . . . . . 20 car, 107.0 yards, 5.4 avg, 0 TDs..........1 Fum
California . . . . . . . 18 car, 182.0 yards, 10.1 avg, 2 TDs........2 Fum
St. John's . . . . . . . 17 car, 97.0 yards, 5.7 avg, 0 TDs.............2 rec, 18.0 yards, 0 TDs
Glasgow . . . . . . . . 24 car, 275.5 yards, 11.4 avg, 4 TDs
MMC . . . . . . . . . . . .13 car, 294.0 yards, 22.6 avg, 7 TDs.........2 rec, 93.5 yards, 1 TDs
Huntsville . . . . . . . 22 car, 332.5 yards, 15.1 avg, 9 TDs........1 rec, 25.0 yards, 1 TDs
W.C. . . . . . . . . . . . .20 car, 252.0 yards, 12.6 avg, 6 TDs..........2 rec, 14.5 yards, 2 TDs
Totals: 134 carries, 1,540 yards, 11.5 avg, 28 TDs.....7 catches, 151 yards, 4 TDs
Game Avg: 19.1 carries, 220.0 yards, 4.6 avg, 4.0 TDs.......1 catch, 21.6 yards, 0.57 TDs
Team . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chief Tenderfoot vs Playoff Teams
East Asia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . NA
Victorica. . . . . . . . . .30 car, 133.5 yards, 4.5 avg, 2 TDs
California . . . . . . . 20 car, 355.5 yards, 17.8 avg, 4 TDs
St. John's . . . . . . . .19 car, 92.5 yards, 4.9 avg, 1 TDs
Glasgow . . . . . . . . 16 car, 154 yards, 9.6 avg, 4 TDs
MMC . . . . . . . . . . . .24 car, 426.5 yards, 17.8 avg, 10 TDs
Huntsville . . . . . . . 23 car, 435.5 yards, 18.9 avg, 9 TDs
W.C. . . . . . . . . . . . .32 car, 317.5 yards, 9.9 avg, 3 TDs
Totals: 164 carries, 1,915 yards, 11.7 avg, 33 TDs.....0 catches, 0 yards, 0 TDs
Game Avg: 23.4 carries, 273.5 yards, 4.6 avg, 4.7 TDs
Here is the starting OL for each team the RB's play on
Glasgow........Barry.....lvl - 61.....LT - 58.....LG - 53.....C - 44.....RG - 51.....RT - 57
East Asia.......Chief.....lvl - 43.....LT - 49.....LG - 52.....C - 50.....RG - 50.....RT - 50
East Asia.......Speed...lvl - 43.....LT - 49.....LG - 52.....C - 50.....RG - 50.....RT - 50
tl;dr
Originally posted by griffin8r
At this point, Bort has it set to disregard blowouts, which rewards great players on middle-tier teams.
What it needs to do is disregard non-playoff teams, which will make it a lot more dynamic early in the season, but as the playoff picture clarifies, will result in a much better balance.
There are some teams (like the 34 cap I play for) that dominated nearly all the games they played. To have their players basically not in consideration for MVP because they kicked so much ass? Well, we're back to the kindergarten thing, giving people blue ribbons because they tried....
got that from thread in main forum
we had the same issue with our team....check out the huge seperation in stats here...
so I'm a little baffled by the MVP. This is a comparison for of the MVP winner in uncapped #2. Barry 2k9 is the winner and the #3 guy Speed "MVP" Optional and the #5 guy Chief Tenderfoot.
Speed and Chief play on the same team and were far and way the best RB's in the league despite being the lowest level RBs of any playoff team. The comparison is only vs the playoff teams.
Can someone please tell me why this guy Barry is the MVP over these other two candidates. I thought I heard that the MVP is takes in account the % of total offense 1 guy makes up for his team. Is this why Barry wins over two RB's on the same team?
Season Totals:
Barry 2k9 (lvl 61): 1,696.5 Rush yards, 47 Rush TDs, 7.3 avg, 106 Ruhs YPG.....94 Rec, 1,101.5 Rec Yards, 11 Rec TDs, 68.8 Rec YPG
Totals: 2,798 yards, 58 TDs, 174.9 YPG
Speed "MVP" Optional (lvl 46): 3,860 Rush yards, 85 Rush TDs, 14.2 avg, 241.3 Rush YPG....32 Rec, 497.5 yards, 11 Rec TDs
Totals: 4,357.5 yards, 96 TDs, 272.3 YPG
Chief Tenderfoot (lvl 43): 4,740 Rush yards, 93 Rush TDs, 12.4 avg, 296.3 rush YPG....3 Rec, 12 yards, 2 Rec TDs
Totals: 4,752 yards, 95 TDs, 297.0 YPG
Team . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Barry 2k9 vs Playoff Teams
East Asia . . . . . . . . 14 car, 64.5 yards, 4.5 avg, 0 TDs..........8 rec, 21 yards, 0 TDs
Victorica. . . . . . . . . 20 car, 25.0 yards, 1.3 avg, 0 TDs..........2 rec, 7 yards, 0 TDs, 1 Fum
California . . . . . . . . 2 car, 14.0 yards, 7.0 avg, 0 TDs..........5 rec, 24 yards, 0 TDs
St. John's . . . . . . . 14 car, 38. 5 yards, 2.8 avg, 0 TDs.........5 rec, 33.5 yards, 0 TDs
Glasgow . . . . . . . . .NA
MMC . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 car, 111.0 yards, 13.9 avg, 2 TDs.......1 rec, 13.5 yards, 0 TDs
Huntsville . . . . . . . 14 car, 38. 5 yards, 2.8 avg, 0 TDs.........6 rec, 42 yards, 0 TDs
W.C. . . . . . . . . . . . .17 car, 121.5 yards, 7.1 avg, 4 TDs.......12 rec, 140 yards, 0 TDs, 1 Fum
Totals: 89 carries, 413 yards, 4.6 avg, 6 TDs.....39 catches, 281 yards, 0 TDs
Game Avg: 12.7 carries, 59.0 yards, 4.6 avg, .85 TDs.......5.6 catches, 40.1 yards, 0 TDs
Team . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Speed Optional vs Playoff Teams
East Asia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . NA
Victorica. . . . . . . . . 20 car, 107.0 yards, 5.4 avg, 0 TDs..........1 Fum
California . . . . . . . 18 car, 182.0 yards, 10.1 avg, 2 TDs........2 Fum
St. John's . . . . . . . 17 car, 97.0 yards, 5.7 avg, 0 TDs.............2 rec, 18.0 yards, 0 TDs
Glasgow . . . . . . . . 24 car, 275.5 yards, 11.4 avg, 4 TDs
MMC . . . . . . . . . . . .13 car, 294.0 yards, 22.6 avg, 7 TDs.........2 rec, 93.5 yards, 1 TDs
Huntsville . . . . . . . 22 car, 332.5 yards, 15.1 avg, 9 TDs........1 rec, 25.0 yards, 1 TDs
W.C. . . . . . . . . . . . .20 car, 252.0 yards, 12.6 avg, 6 TDs..........2 rec, 14.5 yards, 2 TDs
Totals: 134 carries, 1,540 yards, 11.5 avg, 28 TDs.....7 catches, 151 yards, 4 TDs
Game Avg: 19.1 carries, 220.0 yards, 4.6 avg, 4.0 TDs.......1 catch, 21.6 yards, 0.57 TDs
Team . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Chief Tenderfoot vs Playoff Teams
East Asia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . NA
Victorica. . . . . . . . . .30 car, 133.5 yards, 4.5 avg, 2 TDs
California . . . . . . . 20 car, 355.5 yards, 17.8 avg, 4 TDs
St. John's . . . . . . . .19 car, 92.5 yards, 4.9 avg, 1 TDs
Glasgow . . . . . . . . 16 car, 154 yards, 9.6 avg, 4 TDs
MMC . . . . . . . . . . . .24 car, 426.5 yards, 17.8 avg, 10 TDs
Huntsville . . . . . . . 23 car, 435.5 yards, 18.9 avg, 9 TDs
W.C. . . . . . . . . . . . .32 car, 317.5 yards, 9.9 avg, 3 TDs
Totals: 164 carries, 1,915 yards, 11.7 avg, 33 TDs.....0 catches, 0 yards, 0 TDs
Game Avg: 23.4 carries, 273.5 yards, 4.6 avg, 4.7 TDs
Here is the starting OL for each team the RB's play on
Glasgow........Barry.....lvl - 61.....LT - 58.....LG - 53.....C - 44.....RG - 51.....RT - 57
East Asia.......Chief.....lvl - 43.....LT - 49.....LG - 52.....C - 50.....RG - 50.....RT - 50
East Asia.......Speed...lvl - 43.....LT - 49.....LG - 52.....C - 50.....RG - 50.....RT - 50
tl;dr
ryan_grant-25
offline
offline
Lol, so when hudson spanked my team, that was considered a blowout? even though i made the 6th seed? Woot i fucked you over GIK 

GridIronKing34
offline
offline
Originally posted by ryan_grant-25
Lol, so when hudson spanked my team, that was considered a blowout? even though i made the 6th seed? Woot i fucked you over GIK

Lol, so when hudson spanked my team, that was considered a blowout? even though i made the 6th seed? Woot i fucked you over GIK


letchkins
offline
offline
The discrepancy is most likely from % of team offense and the fact that blowout games don't count for jack.
Ts-Rock
offline
offline
Originally posted by letchkins
The discrepancy is most likely from % of team offense and the fact that blowout games don't count for jack.
yea I have gathered that roughly if you win by 60+ the stats don't count. We only had 2-4 games under 60 the other guy had 9.
The discrepancy is most likely from % of team offense and the fact that blowout games don't count for jack.
yea I have gathered that roughly if you win by 60+ the stats don't count. We only had 2-4 games under 60 the other guy had 9.
GridIronKing34
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ts-Rock
Originally posted by letchkins
The discrepancy is most likely from % of team offense and the fact that blowout games don't count for jack.
yea I have gathered that roughly if you win by 60+ the stats don't count. We only had 2-4 games under 60 the other guy had 9.
Over half of Hudson's game were won by 50-60+ points... yet only one of Jesse C's games were won by 50-60+ points (a lot of were 30-40 point wins).
What a bunch of BS, IMO.
Originally posted by letchkins
The discrepancy is most likely from % of team offense and the fact that blowout games don't count for jack.
yea I have gathered that roughly if you win by 60+ the stats don't count. We only had 2-4 games under 60 the other guy had 9.
Over half of Hudson's game were won by 50-60+ points... yet only one of Jesse C's games were won by 50-60+ points (a lot of were 30-40 point wins).
What a bunch of BS, IMO.
Edited by GridIronKing34 on Jul 24, 2009 13:30:11
Ts-Rock
offline
offline
I was told by a Mod that it is being looked into this off-season....whatever that means
jo_cacao
offline
offline
MVP TROPHY STOLEN FROM BILLY BONZO???
Jesse C (HB) Ottawa Force
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=32256
+1,622 yards rushing (8.7 YPC)
+16 rushing touchdowns
+2,022.5 receiving yards (16.6 YPC)
+22 receiving touchdowns
Mathew Chapman (HB) Hudson Hitmen
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=68044&playoffs=0
+2,588 yards rushing
+39 rushing touchdowns
+1,081 receiving yards
+18 receiving touchdowns
Billy Bonzo (HB) Sackville Blitz
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=171442&playoffs=0
+2,674 yards rushing
+49 rushing touchdowns
+672 receiving yards
+15 receiving touchdowns
Billy had 17 less touches than Chapman this season, but he scored more (he is the best Goal Line Back in the Conference) and his yardage per carry is better (Billy : 9.4 yards , Chapman : 8.7). Billy was held under 4 YPC once during this season and fumbled the ball only 2 times.
So here comes the judgement : Billy is the best overall Runner in the conference, Jesse is the best receiving RB, and Chatman is nothing
and if you don't trust me, take a look at Billy's, Jesse's and Chatman's playoffs stats.
Jesse C (HB) Ottawa Force
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=32256
+1,622 yards rushing (8.7 YPC)
+16 rushing touchdowns
+2,022.5 receiving yards (16.6 YPC)
+22 receiving touchdowns
Mathew Chapman (HB) Hudson Hitmen
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=68044&playoffs=0
+2,588 yards rushing
+39 rushing touchdowns
+1,081 receiving yards
+18 receiving touchdowns
Billy Bonzo (HB) Sackville Blitz
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=171442&playoffs=0
+2,674 yards rushing
+49 rushing touchdowns
+672 receiving yards
+15 receiving touchdowns
Billy had 17 less touches than Chapman this season, but he scored more (he is the best Goal Line Back in the Conference) and his yardage per carry is better (Billy : 9.4 yards , Chapman : 8.7). Billy was held under 4 YPC once during this season and fumbled the ball only 2 times.
So here comes the judgement : Billy is the best overall Runner in the conference, Jesse is the best receiving RB, and Chatman is nothing

and if you don't trust me, take a look at Billy's, Jesse's and Chatman's playoffs stats.
Edited by jo_cacao on Jul 25, 2009 16:28:46
GridIronKing34
offline
offline
Originally posted by jo_cacao
MVP TROPHY STOLEN FROM BILLY BONZO???
Jesse C (HB) Ottawa Force
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=32256
+1,622 yards rushing (8.7 YPC)
+16 rushing touchdowns
+2,022.5 receiving yards (16.6 YPC)
+22 receiving touchdowns
Mathew Chapman (HB) Hudson Hitmen
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=68044&playoffs=0
+2,588 yards rushing
+39 rushing touchdowns
+1,081 receiving yards
+18 receiving touchdowns
Billy Bonzo (HB) Sackville Blitz
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=171442&playoffs=0
+2,674 yards rushing
+49 rushing touchdowns
+1,081 receiving yards
+15 receiving touchdowns
Billy had 17 less touches than Chapman this season, but he scored more (he is the best Goal Line Back in the Conference) and his yardage per carry is better (Billy : 9.4 yards , Chapman : 8.7). Billy was held under 4 YPC once during this season and fumbled the ball only 2 times.
So here comes the judgement : Billy is the best overall Runner in the conference, Jesse is the best receiving RB, and Chatman is nothing
and if you don't trust me, take a look at Billy's, Jesse's and Chatman's playoffs stats.
Change your receiving yards to 672 yards... like they really are!
MVP TROPHY STOLEN FROM BILLY BONZO???
Jesse C (HB) Ottawa Force
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=32256
+1,622 yards rushing (8.7 YPC)
+16 rushing touchdowns
+2,022.5 receiving yards (16.6 YPC)
+22 receiving touchdowns
Mathew Chapman (HB) Hudson Hitmen
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=68044&playoffs=0
+2,588 yards rushing
+39 rushing touchdowns
+1,081 receiving yards
+18 receiving touchdowns
Billy Bonzo (HB) Sackville Blitz
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=171442&playoffs=0
+2,674 yards rushing
+49 rushing touchdowns
+1,081 receiving yards
+15 receiving touchdowns
Billy had 17 less touches than Chapman this season, but he scored more (he is the best Goal Line Back in the Conference) and his yardage per carry is better (Billy : 9.4 yards , Chapman : 8.7). Billy was held under 4 YPC once during this season and fumbled the ball only 2 times.
So here comes the judgement : Billy is the best overall Runner in the conference, Jesse is the best receiving RB, and Chatman is nothing

and if you don't trust me, take a look at Billy's, Jesse's and Chatman's playoffs stats.
Change your receiving yards to 672 yards... like they really are!
jo_cacao
offline
offline
Originally posted by GridIronKing34
Change your receiving yards to 672 yards... like they really are!
done, sorry for the mistake
but that doesn't change anything : Billy is by far the best runner in the eastern conference.
And when you consider that Chatman played behind the 2nd best OL in the league (1238 pancakes) and Billy behind the 11th best OL (687 pancakes) there is nothing else you can say to plead you cause, GridIron
Change your receiving yards to 672 yards... like they really are!
done, sorry for the mistake
but that doesn't change anything : Billy is by far the best runner in the eastern conference.
And when you consider that Chatman played behind the 2nd best OL in the league (1238 pancakes) and Billy behind the 11th best OL (687 pancakes) there is nothing else you can say to plead you cause, GridIron
GridIronKing34
offline
offline
Originally posted by jo_cacao
Originally posted by GridIronKing34
Change your receiving yards to 672 yards... like they really are!
done, sorry for the mistake
but that doesn't change anything : Billy is by far the best runner in the eastern conference.
And when you consider that Chatman played behind the 2nd best OL in the league (1238 pancakes) and Billy behind the 11th best OL (687 pancakes) there is nothing else you can say to plead you cause, GridIron
So you're taking all the credit away from your offense line? I've been on some teams that pancaked very little yet played better than those that pancaked a lot.
There was no one else you were really sharing carries with. Sure you have one back that got 107 carries... but our third back got 80 carries. Our second back got over 200 carries.
Billy got the carries in the 4th quarter when the defense was worn down and Sackville was up big. Chapman didn't.
Say what you want, but put us on the same team, Chapman outperforms Billy.
We'll see what happens tomorrow though. Maybe then you'll realize Chapman >>>>>>>>>>>>> Billy
Originally posted by GridIronKing34
Change your receiving yards to 672 yards... like they really are!
done, sorry for the mistake
but that doesn't change anything : Billy is by far the best runner in the eastern conference.
And when you consider that Chatman played behind the 2nd best OL in the league (1238 pancakes) and Billy behind the 11th best OL (687 pancakes) there is nothing else you can say to plead you cause, GridIron
So you're taking all the credit away from your offense line? I've been on some teams that pancaked very little yet played better than those that pancaked a lot.
There was no one else you were really sharing carries with. Sure you have one back that got 107 carries... but our third back got 80 carries. Our second back got over 200 carries.
Billy got the carries in the 4th quarter when the defense was worn down and Sackville was up big. Chapman didn't.
Say what you want, but put us on the same team, Chapman outperforms Billy.
We'll see what happens tomorrow though. Maybe then you'll realize Chapman >>>>>>>>>>>>> Billy
jo_cacao
offline
offline
Originally posted by GridIronKing34
There was no one else you were really sharing carries with. Sure you have one back that got 107 carries... but our third back got 80 carries. Our second back got over 200 carries.
Billy got the carries in the 4th quarter when the defense was worn down and Sackville was up big. Chapman didn't.
You play in a run heavy team. Hudson had 220 more running plays that Sackville this season, that's the reason why your backups had a lot of touches.
And by the way, in most of Sackville games, when we were leading by 30+ pts at the half billy didn't record a single touch in the entire 2nd half ...
Just to let you know, Chatman broke 199 tackles this season
Billy : 239
you're good. But you're not the #1.
There was no one else you were really sharing carries with. Sure you have one back that got 107 carries... but our third back got 80 carries. Our second back got over 200 carries.
Billy got the carries in the 4th quarter when the defense was worn down and Sackville was up big. Chapman didn't.
You play in a run heavy team. Hudson had 220 more running plays that Sackville this season, that's the reason why your backups had a lot of touches.
And by the way, in most of Sackville games, when we were leading by 30+ pts at the half billy didn't record a single touch in the entire 2nd half ...
Just to let you know, Chatman broke 199 tackles this season
Billy : 239
you're good. But you're not the #1.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























