User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Player Personality Suggestion
Page:
 
Coltsfan18
offline
Link
 
Drifter was thinking the same way i thought when i read the topic.

How about for new players. when creating a player to be asked 5- 10 questions that can start shaping a persons personality. that way owners can "scout" potential players and know what type of player they are getting.
 
DTapp51
offline
Link
 
i think its a pretty good idea, that must have taken a long time to write up...
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Coltsfan18
Drifter was thinking the same way i thought when i read the topic.

How about for new players. when creating a player to be asked 5- 10 questions that can start shaping a persons personality. that way owners can "scout" potential players and know what type of player they are getting.



I think that's a good diea as well.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Coltsfan18
Drifter was thinking the same way i thought when i read the topic.

How about for new players. when creating a player to be asked 5- 10 questions that can start shaping a persons personality. that way owners can "scout" potential players and know what type of player they are getting.

That's a cool idea, but there still would need to be a way to change your personality. It would get frustrating trying to find a run-stopping NT who has a Team Leader personality, especially when there are so few NTs out there already.


DTapp51, it didn't take that long to write up... Only about 10-15 minutes.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Legacy
Originally posted by Coltsfan18

Drifter was thinking the same way i thought when i read the topic.

How about for new players. when creating a player to be asked 5- 10 questions that can start shaping a persons personality. that way owners can "scout" potential players and know what type of player they are getting.

That's a cool idea, but there still would need to be a way to change your personality. It would get frustrating trying to find a run-stopping NT who has a Team Leader personality, especially when there are so few NTs out there already.


DTapp51, it didn't take that long to write up... Only about 10-15 minutes.



Welcome to the same problems real NFL owners have. All 3 attributes would have beneficial effects of some kind. Fame guys would bring more revenue. Performance guys (maybe call them workout warriors) are going to be top performers and leadership guys are going to make everyone a little better.

You'll find that some people are fairly balanced or some people might really go down one road or another. The key would be to make sure that each of the 3 are balanced so that you don't have everybody going down one particular road.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Legacy

Originally posted by Coltsfan18


Drifter was thinking the same way i thought when i read the topic.

How about for new players. when creating a player to be asked 5- 10 questions that can start shaping a persons personality. that way owners can "scout" potential players and know what type of player they are getting.

That's a cool idea, but there still would need to be a way to change your personality. It would get frustrating trying to find a run-stopping NT who has a Team Leader personality, especially when there are so few NTs out there already.


DTapp51, it didn't take that long to write up... Only about 10-15 minutes.



Welcome to the same problems real NFL owners have. All 3 attributes would have beneficial effects of some kind. Fame guys would bring more revenue. Performance guys (maybe call them workout warriors) are going to be top performers and leadership guys are going to make everyone a little better.

You'll find that some people are fairly balanced or some people might really go down one road or another. The key would be to make sure that each of the 3 are balanced so that you don't have everybody going down one particular road.

I see your point, but at the end of the day, it's just a game. It's supposed to be fun. I applaud Bort and DD's attempts at making this as realistic as possible, but they have to strike a balance between what's fun and what's frustrating.

It's simply no fun to be stuck with a player none of the human controlled teams want. It's bad enough that the influx of players at certain positions has made it difficult for a lot of those players to find teams. It's going to be even worse if you narrow the criteria down even more.

They've already provided a way for you to get refunds for a character you're unhappy with, so I don't see how allowing a player to change their personality would be any different. After all, people do change. Cancers on one team might turn out to be team players on another. Just look at the difference between Randy Moss's attitude in Oakland and his attitude in New England.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
I don't think you'll ever find a sim enthusiast who doesn't want more detail.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Also, I'm not advocating "Cancers" on any team. You are inferring that from the fame attribute. Someone who is big in fame would actually be an asset for your team as they would bring you more revenue.
 
Legacy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
I don't think you'll ever find a sim enthusiast who doesn't want more detail.

My point is that there has to be a balance between detail and fun. This is exactly the reason why Bort has said they have no plans for season ending injuries.

Originally posted by drifter
Also, I'm not advocating "Cancers" on any team. You are inferring that from the fame attribute. Someone who is big in fame would actually be an asset for your team as they would bring you more revenue.

I guess I misunderstood what you were referring to, then. I thought you were talking about it as per my original post, not from the other suggestions within the thread.
 
MagiK
offline
Link
 
Personally I think our personalities should be influenced by our fellow teammates and the team itself.

I mean in your example of Randy Moss' attitude from Oakland to New England. The only reason Moss has stopped complaining is because the Patriots are good (they lost in the Superbowl so not that amazing) and also Tom Brady fed his TD-hungry ego.

If Bort and DD could somehow place the "10 questions" (Posted by some dude in the thread) and put it into a compatibility chart (maybe they should ask match.com for their formula ). We could have that Brady + Moss duo.

Now I personally do not see this happening anytime soon, maybe in the third season, it just seems too complicated. But I seriously like Legacy's idea, and with having the compatibility attribute, you can boost your own player but also boost your teammates as well.

In the end we all win
 
Truistwon
offline
Link
 
I think that a couple things are being looked at incorrectly in this forum. First, while some players are labeled "Cancer", "Rabble Rouser", "Big Talker", or whatever else a lot of them(including TO) are loved by their teammates(Mcnabb excluded). Having someone who oozes confidence line up next to you can be very contagious. I've learned through personal experience that a team with no swagger will usually underachieve whereas a team with that "Electric Personality" will be able to withstand rough times and succeed.

Also, not everything a team leader does is positive in the eyes of their teammates. I remember when I was a captain we had an extra long practice that ended with us doing sprints for about 30 minutes. Coach was ready to let us go, but since a lot of people were coasting I and another captain told him not to let us go. No one, myself included, really wanted to be out there and they let us know about it.

I've been the WR who demands the ball and the one that takes pride in blocking without caring about personal stats. I've been the trash talking DB and the defensive playmaker who shuts up and just does his job. I personally feel that the personality types being discussed do not accurately portray people's personalities. Not a bad idea, but I personally would prefer for what types of bonuses you can do to be determined by the scale drifter mentioned as opposed to just having a list for each personality. This is supposed to be an MMORPG.....role play your player personalities. Don't limit mine.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Posted this in it's own thread, but figured I'd throw it in here, since the idea was born in this thread:

Originally posted by drifter
Here's my "formal" proposal:

Since the site itself claims to be a MMORPG, not just a sim, I propose the following idea to add the RPG aspect of managing a player. I give you Locker Room Attributes.

What the Attributes are and how they are obtained:

At player creation, a player will be given 3 Locker Room pts to assign between the three locker room attributes.

Those three attributes are:

1. Fame or Celebrity
2. Leadership or Lockeroom Presence
3. Workout Warrior


In addition, one time in between games, each player will be faced with a multiple choice question. The answer will dictate an increase or decrease in one of the locker room attributes. Some examples of the questions that will be asked:


1. You are approached be a reporter asking for an interview to discuss the last game. Do you:
a) Do the interview and talk about your own performance (+1 fame, -.5 leadership)^
b) Do the interview and talk about your teamates and their excellent performance (+1 leadership, -.5 workout warrior)
c) Decline the interview and hit the weight room (+1 Workout warrior, -.5 fame)

^The player could be told of what his decision will do or it could be left blank.

2. After the game, your teamates want you to hit the hottest club in town with them. Do you:
a) Decline and get some rest (+1 Workout Warrior, -.5 leadership)
b) Hit the club for a while but keep it low key (+1 leadership, -.5 fame)
c) Show the ladies in this town why they call you the man with the moves (+1 fame, -.5 workout warrior)


3. One of the rookies on the team approaches you and asks you to spend some extra time working with him on the playbook
a) Give the kid some pointers (+1 leadership, -.5 workout warrior)
b) Tell him you can't afford to sacrifice your own film room time (+1 workout warrior, -.5 leadership)
c) Give the kid your agent's card and tell him he'd be better off spending some time finding a new agent than looking at film (+.5 fame)*


* The options don't always have to be +1/-.5. They could just be .5 sometimes. The key being that the net game is always the same. If a player has 0 pts in each of the other two attributes he would only ever gain .5 pts in the attribute he was focusing on. Thus a player who focuses exclusively on fame will only receive .5 pt per decision in fame no matter what.

The questions don't all need to straight laced. They could be completely off the wall:


1. Dancing with the Really famous people has approached you and asked you to be on their show.
a) Accept and take it very seriously. Training twice as hard as normal (+.5 workout warrior)
b) Accept it and constantly talk about your teamates whenever on camera (+1 leadership, -.5 fame)
c) Accept it and ham it up on camera whenever possible (+.5 fame)



What the attributes affect:

Fame:

I think there are a number of ways you can work fame into the game.

1. Pro Bowl votes - If you every institute a pro bowl or all star game, fame would increase the regular number of votes a player would receive based on his performance. Perhaps the number of fame pts would increase the number of points by that percentage (ie 10 fame pts would increase pro bowl votes by 10%)


2. Endorsement - Fame would influence the chance of getting an endorsement offer as well as the value of such an offer. Endorsements, in turn, would give the player more money as well as give them the option to equip special equipment with slightly higher than normal bonuses. (unlike equipment the bonuses would be set and couldn't be modified by the user). For example, having a fame of 10, would give a player a random, small, chance of being an offered an endorsement deal. A fame of 50 would be 5X as likely to receive such an offer and the endorsement equipment offered would be 5X more potent.


3. Increased owner revenue. The amount of fame, in total, among an owner's team would be tallied and would increase the $ amount an owner could ask for tickets as well as giving a bonus to ticket and revenue sales.


Workout Warrior

1. The more pts in workout warrior, the more pts a player might receive for training. (Again, this could be as simple as 10 pts = 10% bonus).

2. Workout Warrior pts could also provide a random boost to on the field play. Perhaps 10 pts would mean a 10% chance of playing an intensity level higher than what was set without the added hit to energy. For example, if intensity was set to normal and the player had 10 WW pts, he would have a 10% chance of playing at Intensity level High for that game while only losing the energy as if he'd played normal. If he already had his intesity to high, he would get an even further boost - maybe call it "Inspired".


Leadership

1. The more pts in Leadership the bigger on the field boost to the entire team's confidence. 10 pts would mean that the entire team would play with a 10% boost to Confidence.

2. Leadership would also have a very small chance (10 pts = 1%) of inspring an entire team to play as described in workout warrior 2.


Conclusion


I believe this would add some added depth both the those users only managing players as well as to those users managing teams. As someone building a team, you would want to have some fame guys to boost your revenue as well as some leadership guys to boost the entire team's play and some workout warriors that are going to be among the most skilled players on the field.

You could also add special facilities to team owners. They could spend money on an improved weight room, adding to the allure of attracting workout warriors, or add a cable television contract to appeal to fame hounds.

As a player you have to choose a path for your player. With 16 games in a season, that's only a 16 pt possible gain in any one area at the expense of any other direction. A 5 year player who focused exclusively on Fame would have 43 pts in fame and 0 in workout warrior and leadership. That player is going to have a lot of money and some cool equipment but won't help out his team at all and his cool equipment will not equal the bonuses gained by the Workout Warrior.

In reality, people will probably be more balanced in their approach, leading to a player who after 5 seasons, will have something like 20 pts in leadership, 18 pts in workout warrior and 5 pts in fame.

This adds depth to this game that I have yet to see in many years of playing sims and I think would greatly add to the experience for player and team managers alike.

 
giants66
offline
Link
 
It should be somthing like team leader gives slight boost to everyone while cancer significantly boosts himself or somthing like that
 
atl_falcon-89
offline
Link
 
Players defintly need more to do in between games. How about endoements for +10 players.(I know we haven't quite got there yet but we'll see more 10 + in time)
Last edited Mar 25, 2008 17:54:15
 
RudyS
offline
Link
 
An easy implementation would simply be for every team member that picks a "team leader" option +1 to team morale (even if morale is greater than 100). For every "Cancer action" -2 for team morale.

A team leader option would give your player +1 to two categories (again maybe you could pick which from a list) but also a +2 to your teammates vision and/or stamina and/or confidence on your side of the ball. The team leader bonuses would not be applied to cancer players.

A cancer action might give you +2 in the next game to a three or four attributes (maybe you could pick off a list of several options) and a -1 to EVERY teammate's vision and/or stamina and/or confidence regardless of which squad the cancer plays on.

Let's the players do something between games that can affect the game but not immensely.
Last edited Mar 26, 2008 05:13:03
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.