User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Anti-World League Thread
Page:
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TxSteve
how about - for the 32 teams who earn their way into the world league - they also stay in their current pro league.


they become a member of 2 different leagues - they get twice the games - somehow structure the game times so they don't conflict with their normal schedule.

most of the leagues have at least a few 'cup cake' games that don't need to be scouted / game planned for too intensively - so it doesn't quote double the work load - but it is a lot more work -


but they get more bang for their buck that season - and then - to stay in the world league - they have to be one of the top teams in their pro league as well.


I think it'd be a pain to have to gameplan every day.

A couple of problems:
1) Doubling the workload of owners
2) Teams in the better Pro leagues would have a schedule twice as hard
3) Different Pro leagues sim on different days (I think), so some leagues would have to have 2 games in the same day.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
The entire point of this game is to get the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize.


I agree. And a tournament is better for this than a league. Just like the NCAA B-ball tourney.

Leagues gut, teams/players decline. After ~2 seasons the World League would be no better off than the system we have now. And w/ a tournament you control who is in, and if done right after the Pro League Playoffs you get the best teams. With a World League eventually you just get a cluster fuck at the top w/ 1-10 really good teams, 10-20 good teams, and 21-32 half gutted average teams holding onto their WL slot while other teams are waiting in the wings. You also end up with a few gut jobs.

Remember, it takes probably ~7 seasons of player development to make it to the Pro's if you started a player today. So now you are talking about 3 seasons MAX in the World Pro league with the same group before plateau and decline. Is a declining team really the best team? I would say... No.

Edited by ImTheScientist on Jul 8, 2009 15:07:49
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by dpride59

The entire point of this game is to get the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize. Why would Cobra Kai be against the best 32 teams playing for #1?



Except the World league WOULDN'T be the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize.


It would, if Bort moved the "best 32" teams. 10 USA teams, and the 20 or so best of the rest. Make it simple really, have an application process, Have the conference championship winners get a free pass, have Bort hand out 6-8 passes to the best teams, I.E. Benitos, Hoblosion, if they don't make champ game. then have a play in type deal for the last spots. Would be pretty easy, would allow Bort some leeway to make sure he gets it right, but this would be a huge deal, and I think he could figure out how to ensure the top teams get in.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by dpride59


The entire point of this game is to get the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize. Why would Cobra Kai be against the best 32 teams playing for #1?



Except the World league WOULDN'T be the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize.


It would, if Bort moved the "best 32" teams. 10 USA teams, and the 20 or so best of the rest. Make it simple really, have an application process, Have the conference championship winners get a free pass, have Bort hand out 6-8 passes to the best teams, I.E. Benitos, Hoblosion, if they don't make champ game. then have a play in type deal for the last spots. Would be pretty easy, would allow Bort some leeway to make sure he gets it right, but this would be a huge deal, and I think he could figure out how to ensure the top teams get in.


Play should be the determining factor of who is good, not bort.
 
Magneto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by entropy
I am not a huge fan at this time.


 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by dpride59

The entire point of this game is to get the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize.


I agree. And a tournament is better for this than a league. Just like the NCAA B-ball tourney.

Leagues gut, teams/players decline. After ~2 seasons the World League would be no better off than the system we have now. And w/ a tournament you control who is in, and if done right after the Pro League Playoffs you get the best teams. With a World League eventually you just get a cluster fuck at the top w/ 1-10 really good teams, 10-20 good teams, and 21-32 half gutted average teams holding onto their WL slot while other teams are waiting in the wings. You also end up with a few gut jobs.

Remember, it takes probably ~7 seasons of player development to make it to the Pro's if you started a player today. So now you are talking about 3 seasons MAX in the World Pro league with the same group before plateau and decline. Is a declining team really the best team? I would say... No.



That is why this league would be recirculated every year. Teams that don't make top 8 at end of yr, 4 per conference would be eliminated, and moved down to the pro region, and a new batch of 24 move up. With all of the up can coming builds/players, there is going to be some pretty deep teams/farm systems in place, this would ensure the top stay at the top, and teams who are only there because they found this game first, are shipped off as they won't be able to compete.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

IMO, a "World League" is just a tricky way of Bort wording "League Restructure" because that is what it really is if it happens.


 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by dpride59


The entire point of this game is to get the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize.


I agree. And a tournament is better for this than a league. Just like the NCAA B-ball tourney.

Leagues gut, teams/players decline. After ~2 seasons the World League would be no better off than the system we have now. And w/ a tournament you control who is in, and if done right after the Pro League Playoffs you get the best teams. With a World League eventually you just get a cluster fuck at the top w/ 1-10 really good teams, 10-20 good teams, and 21-32 half gutted average teams holding onto their WL slot while other teams are waiting in the wings. You also end up with a few gut jobs.

Remember, it takes probably ~7 seasons of player development to make it to the Pro's if you started a player today. So now you are talking about 3 seasons MAX in the World Pro league with the same group before plateau and decline. Is a declining team really the best team? I would say... No.



That is why this league would be recirculated every year. Teams that don't make top 8 at end of yr, 4 per conference would be eliminated, and moved down to the pro region, and a new batch of 24 move up. With all of the up can coming builds/players, there is going to be some pretty deep teams/farm systems in place, this would ensure the top stay at the top, and teams who are only there because they found this game first, are shipped off as they won't be able to compete.


It still wouldn't be the best 32 teams.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

Originally posted by dpride59


The entire point of this game is to get the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize.


I agree. And a tournament is better for this than a league. Just like the NCAA B-ball tourney.

Leagues gut, teams/players decline. After ~2 seasons the World League would be no better off than the system we have now. And w/ a tournament you control who is in, and if done right after the Pro League Playoffs you get the best teams. With a World League eventually you just get a cluster fuck at the top w/ 1-10 really good teams, 10-20 good teams, and 21-32 half gutted average teams holding onto their WL slot while other teams are waiting in the wings. You also end up with a few gut jobs.

Remember, it takes probably ~7 seasons of player development to make it to the Pro's if you started a player today. So now you are talking about 3 seasons MAX in the World Pro league with the same group before plateau and decline. Is a declining team really the best team? I would say... No.



That is why this league would be recirculated every year. Teams that don't make top 8 at end of yr, 4 per conference would be eliminated, and moved down to the pro region, and a new batch of 24 move up. With all of the up can coming builds/players, there is going to be some pretty deep teams/farm systems in place, this would ensure the top stay at the top, and teams who are only there because they found this game first, are shipped off as they won't be able to compete.


The same thing that is happening to current Pro leagues will happen there. It will just take 2-3 seasons. The first season will be good, and that is it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by ImTheScientist


Originally posted by dpride59



The entire point of this game is to get the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize.


I agree. And a tournament is better for this than a league. Just like the NCAA B-ball tourney.

Leagues gut, teams/players decline. After ~2 seasons the World League would be no better off than the system we have now. And w/ a tournament you control who is in, and if done right after the Pro League Playoffs you get the best teams. With a World League eventually you just get a cluster fuck at the top w/ 1-10 really good teams, 10-20 good teams, and 21-32 half gutted average teams holding onto their WL slot while other teams are waiting in the wings. You also end up with a few gut jobs.

Remember, it takes probably ~7 seasons of player development to make it to the Pro's if you started a player today. So now you are talking about 3 seasons MAX in the World Pro league with the same group before plateau and decline. Is a declining team really the best team? I would say... No.



That is why this league would be recirculated every year. Teams that don't make top 8 at end of yr, 4 per conference would be eliminated, and moved down to the pro region, and a new batch of 24 move up. With all of the up can coming builds/players, there is going to be some pretty deep teams/farm systems in place, this would ensure the top stay at the top, and teams who are only there because they found this game first, are shipped off as they won't be able to compete.


It still wouldn't be the best 32 teams.


Exactly, a tournament is a much better way of insuring the best 32 teams from year to year.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Sik Wit It

Originally posted by dpride59


Originally posted by ImTheScientist



Originally posted by dpride59




The entire point of this game is to get the best 32 teams fighting for the ultimate prize.


I agree. And a tournament is better for this than a league. Just like the NCAA B-ball tourney.

Leagues gut, teams/players decline. After ~2 seasons the World League would be no better off than the system we have now. And w/ a tournament you control who is in, and if done right after the Pro League Playoffs you get the best teams. With a World League eventually you just get a cluster fuck at the top w/ 1-10 really good teams, 10-20 good teams, and 21-32 half gutted average teams holding onto their WL slot while other teams are waiting in the wings. You also end up with a few gut jobs.

Remember, it takes probably ~7 seasons of player development to make it to the Pro's if you started a player today. So now you are talking about 3 seasons MAX in the World Pro league with the same group before plateau and decline. Is a declining team really the best team? I would say... No.



That is why this league would be recirculated every year. Teams that don't make top 8 at end of yr, 4 per conference would be eliminated, and moved down to the pro region, and a new batch of 24 move up. With all of the up can coming builds/players, there is going to be some pretty deep teams/farm systems in place, this would ensure the top stay at the top, and teams who are only there because they found this game first, are shipped off as they won't be able to compete.


It still wouldn't be the best 32 teams.


Exactly, a tournament is a much better way of insuring the best 32 teams from year to year.


Which we already have, and it's run very well.

I really don't see a need for a World League.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 

Edited by dpride59 on Jul 8, 2009 15:16:15
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Seems like it will cause more harm than good.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sik Wit It
Originally posted by dpride59



That is why this league would be recirculated every year. Teams that don't make top 8 at end of yr, 4 per conference would be eliminated, and moved down to the pro region, and a new batch of 24 move up. With all of the up can coming builds/players, there is going to be some pretty deep teams/farm systems in place, this would ensure the top stay at the top, and teams who are only there because they found this game first, are shipped off as they won't be able to compete.


It still wouldn't be the best 32 teams.


Would be the best 32 game day teams. The only thing we have to determine who is best is wins, and losses. If a team is better then a few of the 32 teams, but yet they don't make league championship, they don't win there 2-3 play in games to the WPL. and they lose to a team they are perceived to be better then, thats too bad, they don't deserve to be there, every team will have a equal chance to get there, if they can't make it thats on them. It would ensure 25-30 of the best 32 our in 1 league, and that would be a awesome fucking goal, for people who did not get here till season 5 to aim for. I am all for this.
 
Sik Wit It
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by Sik Wit It





That is why this league would be recirculated every year. Teams that don't make top 8 at end of yr, 4 per conference would be eliminated, and moved down to the pro region, and a new batch of 24 move up. With all of the up can coming builds/players, there is going to be some pretty deep teams/farm systems in place, this would ensure the top stay at the top, and teams who are only there because they found this game first, are shipped off as they won't be able to compete.

It still wouldn't be the best 32 teams.


Would be the best 32 game day teams. The only thing we have to determine who is best is wins, and losses. If a team is better then a few of the 32 teams, but yet they don't make league championship, they don't win there 2-3 play in games to the WPL. and they lose to a team they are perceived to be better then, thats too bad, they don't deserve to be there, every team will have a equal chance to get there, if they can't make it thats on them. It would ensure 25-30 of the best 32 our in 1 league, and that would be a awesome fucking goal, for people who did not get here till season 5 to aim for. I am all for this.


Top for in OPL =\= Top 4 in USA

Sorry not to pick on you OPL guys, I just needed an example
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.