User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > A BETTER fix to Head Fake and Juke
Page:
 
reedric
offline
Link
 
+1 to the suggestion.


No way Borts fix will address players behind the HB being juked. If putting the cone of vision in will require more coding, then some more programmers should be hired. We are way to far into this game for something to not get fixed because it may be difficult.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by DL24

Guys; enough with the argument over whether certain NFL players were power backs or not. Keep the discussion about finding a better fix for Jukes and Head Fakes.

Last time I checked, you weren't a suggestions mod. Go find a hobby.



Originally posted by jrry32

Whatever jdbolick, I see a Power runner differently then you do.

And apparently the rest of the world, given that Jim Brown is generally described as the greatest power runner of all-time.

Originally posted by

But my point was that those guys could make multiple guys at once miss and they did. So don't try to say or act like people juking multiple defenders never happens IRL. I don't even know what you're arguing.

You couldn't find one single example in the highlight runs of the NFL's greatest elusive backs in history where they juked more than two defenders at one time, and there were only a few examples where they even juked two at once. Therefore Bort's solution is realistic by NFL standards, if you care about such things.

Originally posted by

Are you arguing that Bort's change is better than mine? If so, you have done little to prove your point. I think you are just arguing for the sake of arguing.

I pointed out that the one juke per tick is much more realistic than your infinite jukes as long as the defender is within a certain vision cone. I pointed out that there have been instances where multiple defenders in front of a ball carrier blinked like christmas trees, frozen in place until the HB got past them. I also pointed out that implementing a vision cone would be a major coding challenge that would require very significant changes to the programming.

Look, you're obviously getting defensive because I'm poking giant holes in your suggestion, but get over it. Bort's solution is realistic and reasonable. If it doesn't work out, then you can come back later and explain why, along with what you would prefer to see. Until then, this is a bad suggestion.


I don't even think you understood Bort's change and vision cones are SO long overdue, they should have been implemented long ago as they aren't just needed for this. Poking Giant holes? You have yet to poke a small hole. Going back to Bort's change, there were never multiple jukes on the same tick before...at least from how I am comprehending it, what he did is he made it so only guy 1 guy could get faked per tick. So it wasn't indefinite jukes in 1 tick, it was multiple people being faked in 1 tick. Having a system like I described is a much better and more practical fix as well as it allowing Bort fix some other things. And you pointing out the problems with the old system, does NOTHING against my suggestion because I am not suggesting we use the old system.

Oh and BTW, try watching the Gale Sayers tape, at some point around 1:00, he jukes just about the entire defense. And like I said, having TWO or more players in the vision cone as to where they can get juked is HIGHLY unlikely to happen.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reedric
+1 to the suggestion.


No way Borts fix will address players behind the HB being juked. If putting the cone of vision in will require more coding, then some more programmers should be hired. We are way to far into this game for something to not get fixed because it may be difficult.


I agree, they also need to add it for blocking interaction so players will no longer be able to engage multiple guys at the same time and so OLs can't engage a guy in front of him, then disengage him and immediately engage a guy directly behind him. It would also improve defensive pathing.(well I hope it would)
Edited by jrry32 on Jul 4, 2009 22:01:00
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
If not a cone, Do a proximity check on the dot thats (going to) get faked out. Then if there's anything in that area, have them do a vision check as well.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
If not a cone, Do a proximity check on the dot thats (going to) get faked out. Then if there's anything in that area, have them do a vision check as well.


this is a good compromise
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
Originally posted by Adderfist

If not a cone, Do a proximity check on the dot thats (going to) get faked out. Then if there's anything in that area, have them do a vision check as well.


this is a good compromise


Agreed. Tis why I posted it ;P
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
If not a cone, Do a proximity check on the dot thats (going to) get faked out. Then if there's anything in that area, have them do a vision check as well.


Definitely a good idea.
 
kuaggie
offline
Link
 
how would this be coded is my only question. Other than that, good suggestion.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kuaggie
how would this be coded is my only question. Other than that, good suggestion.


Not my area of expertise but if this does take awhile, then Bort should start on it or have someone help. He has needed vision cones in the game for quite awhile especially in blocking interaction as well.
 
teamriots
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by kuaggie

how would this be coded is my only question. Other than that, good suggestion.


Not my area of expertise but if this does take awhile, then Bort should start on it or have someone help. He has needed vision cones in the game for quite awhile especially in blocking interaction as well.


Hasn't he stated that vision cones are part of the coding? They simply are not shown in-sim? That was my understanding.

Anyways, the fake % nerf is pretty complex. It has completely changed the game, just like that.

Elusives are now too limited in their capabilities, and powerbacks are still nerfed, so I guess that's where we're at.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by teamriots
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by kuaggie


how would this be coded is my only question. Other than that, good suggestion.


Not my area of expertise but if this does take awhile, then Bort should start on it or have someone help. He has needed vision cones in the game for quite awhile especially in blocking interaction as well.


Hasn't he stated that vision cones are part of the coding? They simply are not shown in-sim? That was my understanding.

Anyways, the fake % nerf is pretty complex. It has completely changed the game, just like that.

Elusives are now too limited in their capabilities, and powerbacks are still nerfed, so I guess that's where we're at.


Yep and I don't think they are because GLB blockers don't really have them. A Blocker can engage a guy directly in front of him, disengage him and immediately engage a guy directly behind him.
 
teamriots
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32

Yep and I don't think they are because GLB blockers don't really have them. A Blocker can engage a guy directly in front of him, disengage him and immediately engage a guy directly behind him.


I've noticed on the WR screen, that the LOT blocking seems broken. The LOT must commit to the CB and let the RDE go, but if you watch it, I notice the LOT will give up the RDE and go for the CB, only until the RDE gets close enough to the QB and the LOT retreats and ends up blocking nobody.

But not to get off subject.

This fake % nerf is almost more ridiculous than the blinking dots panic.

It's hard to even address the situation without mocking Bort, because his reactions to forum flamestorms are always to overreact. We can't do subtle fixes. Bort takes problem, reaction, solution to new extremes.

problem|--------------+-----|reaction

this shows the relative reaction of the community vs any actual problem. As you can see, the reaction far outweighs the problem.

reaction|------------------+-|solution

this shows the general solution to community reactions. As you can see, the solution is always meant to remedy the reaction.

solution|-+------------------|problem

this shows how the solution ranks compared to the problem. As you can see, the solution generally misses the problem.

So first, the reaction from the community is a general overreaction. Then the solution always hushes the overreaction from the userbase. When the solution is put it in play, it most often misses the original problem, because it was only meant to silence the mob. No where along the line do the solutions ever directly superimpose the problems that original created the reaction.

Why did elusive backs get out of control? It started because elusive backs were not good enough for multiple seasons. The sim was slowly turned toward elusive backs, because it was understood that elusive superstar HB's dominate the NFL, and they should dominate GLB. After a while, elusives figured out they could go wild on the fake SA's, quick feet VA, fake chance % AEQ, and shake the hell out of the defense.

And now we have reached this point where elusive backs are so good, they have to be nerfed into oblivion? Only 1 defender can be "blinked" per tick? Huh? How does this at all make sense?

What caused the problem? Fake %'s got out of control. But instead of scaling back the % chance, we start down a complete different direction. I don't know. I can't say I get it. Seems like the most logical place to start was the %'s -- the root of the problem that created the community reaction. But why slay the dragon in the heart, if you can first chop its toes off?
 
TJ Spikes
offline
Link
 
What makes more sense to me would be to have the offensive player do some kind of "stutter step," or something in the game, that causes him to lose speed when he does his move. If a player is Juking and Head Faking, it's going to slow him down having to look around and wiggle his body or whatever physical contortions the player does to attempt the fake.

It also would be more realistic if there was some kind of timer on how often a player could fake. Maybe once every 5 ticks or something like that. Otherwise, the player would spend too much time "dancing" and wouldn't gain any ground.

On top of that, it makes sense to have diminishing returns on fakes, certainly on the same play, but also over the course of the game. Defenders have learning curves, and don't continually fall for the same moves 3 or 4 times on the same play. The good defenders won't fall for the same fake for the rest of the game... maybe forever. Maybe once the defender would get faked out of his shoes and fall down, the second time maybe he hesitates but doesn't completely bite, after that he probably should have smartened up.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TJ Spikes
What makes more sense to me would be to have the offensive player do some kind of "stutter step," or something in the game, that causes him to lose speed when he does his move. If a player is Juking and Head Faking, it's going to slow him down having to look around and wiggle his body or whatever physical contortions the player does to attempt the fake.

It also would be more realistic if there was some kind of timer on how often a player could fake. Maybe once every 5 ticks or something like that. Otherwise, the player would spend too much time "dancing" and wouldn't gain any ground.

On top of that, it makes sense to have diminishing returns on fakes, certainly on the same play, but also over the course of the game. Defenders have learning curves, and don't continually fall for the same moves 3 or 4 times on the same play. The good defenders won't fall for the same fake for the rest of the game... maybe forever. Maybe once the defender would get faked out of his shoes and fall down, the second time maybe he hesitates but doesn't completely bite, after that he probably should have smartened up.


Yep and I agree teamriots.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
I don't even think you understood Bort's change and vision cones are SO long overdue, they should have been implemented long ago as they aren't just needed for this.

Actually I was the one who mentioned where he had said that he'd like to do it someday, then speculated that he hasn't because it presumably would be a massively complex thing to code. Until the sim has vision cones, then it's useless to propose changes based on using vision cones.

Originally posted by
Poking Giant holes? You have yet to poke a small hole.

Sure. The reality is that, no matter what I say, you will insist that I haven't undermined your argument. You simply won't acknowledge any such thing, regardless of who it comes from. You have your heart set on this suggestion.

Originally posted by
Having a system like I described is a much better and more practical fix as well as it allowing Bort fix some other things.

This is both stupid and wrong. It's stupid because you're saying that a "solution" requiring massive changes to the sim (vision cones) would be more practical than the relatively simple and straight-forward change. It's also wrong because your proposal would do nothing about multiple defenders in front of the ball carrier being juked repeatedly, which was a problem.

Originally posted by
Oh and BTW, try watching the Gale Sayers tape, at some point around 1:00, he jukes just about the entire defense. And like I said, having TWO or more players in the vision cone as to where they can get juked is HIGHLY unlikely to happen.

You're once again confusing jukes with cutting back against the grain and eluding defenders who are overpursuing. The two are not remotely the same. In real football, jukes are almost always one on one, and neither of us could come with any examples where there more than two defenders juked by one move.


Originally posted by teamriots
This fake % nerf is almost more ridiculous than the blinking dots panic.

Hardly. A juking HB can still break long gains by juking one defender at a time. I've already seen that in numerous replays since the change.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.