Ya we played and dominated the Shadowbane server (Carnage) we were on for 9 months solid before our server shut down and the game basically collapsed.
I played Ultima Online for 8 years - 6 on OSI (Sonoma) shards and another 2 on Player Ran (Defiance UO & a UO Gamers server) ones. I was a Great Lord when the entire game was Dread Lords, and I went Stat Loss Red when the rep system changed because all the other pretenders went blue when the Risk went up.
I know a thing or two about hardcore PvP and what it takes to stand with the best.
But to stand here and say that the PvP in WoW sucks because you don't get to loot a piece of uterly usless armor - like in UO - is just ignorant. There has never been a more competitive brand of PvP than the Arena Ladder system in WoW.
Never.
- UO didn't really have good balance between mages and dexers. I HATED the UO:R changes to melee
- Shadowbane was too buggy to really say who was the best. My character was given 1600 extra training points. lol
- DAoC was a gank fest
- AC was garbage
- SWG was about luck - not skill.
- WoW is about gear, but when you get into the 1800-1900 range in Arena the gear is pretty even. Don't confuse that with the 1800 ranked players killing some new level 80 in a Battleground. It's NOT the same.
I beta tested Darkfall and I thought it was meh. The player control is sloppy, and the combat feels like a slow motion version of Oblivion. It's PAINFULLY tedious going anywhere because travel speed in relation to the size of the map is FAR too slow.
I know why people get frustrated with WoW pvp and the big thing is that gear doesn't drop. I don't know about you guys, but I had several houses in UO and they are all packed with crap that I looted off other people. By the last couple of years I was playing, the only reason I picked up regs is because you needed them to cast spells. The armor and weapons I almost never grabbed because I played a caster.
I was never the best dueler on my server - I could hold my own - but I was one of the best team fighting mages on Sonoma at the time I played, and a tremendously efficient PK. In Shadowbane, William and I had a *little* sucess, one could say:
http://www.purpledragons.net/forum/index.php?topic=20148.0Go to that link and read my story about Shadowbane. Sorry if it's a little long - if you played Shadowbane or enjoy good stories about PvP, you'll probably enjoy it as much as the other people who read it did.