User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > GLB Evolution - Decline, Coaching, etc
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Forget the length of time for a moment, I've seen this idea before (turning players into coaches) and would love to see it implemented.


Right, if you ignore the 20 seasons thing, the coaching thing is a great idea.

The 10 season limit is fine imo. It's a little short, but it promotes good rotation in personnel and overall in teams.
 
willm
offline
Link
 
great job explaining it all dude, i think a hall of fame is just awesome idea, and evolving in to a coach would assure that i wouldnt get bored with the game after 10 months or a year of playing! hopefully byu the time we are looking at season ten, this could be done!~
 
willm
offline
Link
 
the only idea i would change a little is retire to hall of fame? it should be a privelage to get voted into the hall of fame so that we could actually look through it next season, and say wow that guy did all that? so after every season a ballot should be sent out to everyone's inbox that has a list of the players at each postion that chose to retire to the hall of fame, and you can only vote say 5 per position. thats over 100 player a season. the list will get long quickly. maybe even cut it down to 5 offensive and 5 defensive players. not everyone should go to the hall of fame.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by willm
the only idea i would change a little is retire to hall of fame? it should be a privelage to get voted into the hall of fame so that we could actually look through it next season, and say wow that guy did all that? so after every season a ballot should be sent out to everyone's inbox that has a list of the players at each postion that chose to retire to the hall of fame, and you can only vote say 5 per position. thats over 100 player a season. the list will get long quickly. maybe even cut it down to 5 offensive and 5 defensive players. not everyone should go to the hall of fame.


Agreed. privilege; not a right. Like spandex.
 
willm
offline
Link
 
and you would have to have a head coach, a def. coordinator, o coordinator, qb coach, rb coach, recievers coach, oline coach, te coach, dline coach lb's coach, secondary coach, special teams coach. per team be a lot of coaching positions to open! and you could make it so you have to be a position coach for at least 4 seasons before you could be a coordinator, then 5 seasons as a coordinator and finally you can max out at 6 seasons as a head coach. that is 15 season of coaching after 12 of playing...27 years. puts 21 yrl old rookies finally retiring at 48 years old. and too go with my other idea of voting so many players in to hall of fame, 2 coaches could be voted in each season as well!
 
willm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by willm
and you would have to have a head coach, a def. coordinator, o coordinator, qb coach, rb coach, recievers coach, oline coach, te coach, dline coach lb's coach, secondary coach, special teams coach. per team be a lot of coaching positions to open! and you could make it so you have to be a position coach for at least 4 seasons before you could be a coordinator, then 5 seasons as a coordinator and finally you can max out at 6 seasons as a head coach. that is 15 season of coaching after 12 of playing...27 years. puts 21 yrl old rookies finally retiring at 48 years old. and too go with my other idea of voting so many players in to hall of fame, 2 coaches could be voted in each season as well!


so if your player was awesome and decided to be a coach, he could have the retire into hall of fame option after coaching career. he should some how be able to go into it as player or coach i think though....wow, hate to be a programmer trying to put all this into effect...lol.
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
you just quoted yourself? Why not edit or just continue on...
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dan4GS
Some great ideas GG. Some ideas that came to mind while reading:
--Why make the players play all twenty years before becoming a coach? I think it should be an option at any point. If a player decides to become a coach before lvl 20, then they could start out as as a (current level/3) coach. Thus, a lvl three player retiring would be a lvl one coach, a level 6 guy retiring would be a lvl 2 coach, and a lvl 18 guy retiring would be a lvl 6 coach. Lvl 20's going into retirement could come in as lvl 7 coaches.

--Because of this, you would have to allow coaches to be created just like players, except you come into the league at level one and boosting would have to be restricted, and experienced earned more slowly.

--Why do this at all? If you make people wait twenty seasons before becoming a coach, then the few teams that do get to hire coaches will have a big advantage. If you're going to open up a new facet to the game, allow all teams to have coaches...just none that have really good ones right now.

Just a few thoughts, hope it helps.


I think your points here are very valid. And good thinking.
In retrospect, 20 seasons before you can morph into a coach is too long, and there'd be another year or so before all these 1,000's of teams were able to start hiring coaches.

So, like you said, you give everyone the choice to even start evolving into a coach immediately, in the structure you suggested.

I just think that GLB should be careful not to make becoming a coach too soon, but part of evolving a player after x amount of seasons, in order to give long-time players something to aspire to.

Cybershot/Jed feel, as many of you do, that 20 seasons is too long, but how far ahead is GLB planning to hold onto core users? 2 years isnt really that long. If the GLB experience becomes too quick to master or too quick to just morph ahead, then users can get bored quicker, less challenges ahead, and GLB fails to come up with any other ideas to extend the experience.

I'm not sure what the right amount of seasons is, but i think a player should reach a level before he can become coach. To give newbies a REASON to persist with the game, to keep purchasing FPs, and, learn about the game, about GMing, and how to gameplan as they play the game for a calender year or so. Or, like Dan4GS, said, give them an option (at a cost and retarded development stage) to choose to become a coach earlier. The choice cant ever hurt.

I also think tho that there will be many users out there who dont want to coach or stop playing as a player even in 20 seasons. So there should still be an option imo to allow a certain minority/majority to choose to play on indefinitely as players.

A G-League might be set up, and it might only consist of 4 leagues of 8 teams. Not necessarily 60 leagues and thousands of teams. But catering to a certain % of people who do want to play on.
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
great stuff GG. The good news is Bort and the admins have some time to think this through.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Ive got a playoff game to gameplan for in about an hour against a team sure to spank us, so if i dont reply to anyone I will asap.
 
LiquidSnake
offline
Link
 
Well.....Amen, but 2 years is quite the time for a site to continue success People get bored easily in todays age.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I like it...I have thought of trying to introduce a "coach" class into the game at some point, somehow based on existing or retiring players.

If you could basically "re-class" your player into a Lv1 coach and level him up over time to give bonuses to training, morale/chemistry bonuses, etc, it would be cool. The coach's initial stats could even be based on the player's career length and quality.


The biggest problem you will run into is how to generate stats for all these coaching positions. Attributes and levelling up is fun, but stats are a key part to player enjoyment.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Just being able to create plays/playbooks would captivate me like rattling keys to a baby. But it would have to be actual play creation, plotting routes, etc, and testing it in a simulator/scrimmage. Buying ready-made playbooks or buying/earning plays the higher you go up as a coach wouldn't be fun.
 
anfiach
offline
Link
 
These ideas have potential
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Just being able to create plays/playbooks would captivate me like rattling keys to a baby. But it would have to be actual play creation, plotting routes, etc, and testing it in a simulator/scrimmage. Buying ready-made playbooks or buying/earning plays the higher you go up as a coach wouldn't be fun.


That's fine, but say you come in as a low level Linebacker coach. What "plays" are you going to be able to create? Any defensive play? I think that concept needs a ton more fleshing out.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.