But the bar is GOLDEN !
catcher_0_3
offline
offline
Originally posted by maristfan
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by CTX
SO basically matta, when you say you compare kickers to see how good a team is, you think that if a team has a good kicker they must be good because only good kickers are on good teams. So if I were to have a team of level 1's but have a really badass kicker that team would be good?
No. You use a kicker's bar to determine how good a builder the team / owner is.
For example, a Lvl 32 kicker with a 69 bar is a horrible build. Why would an owner have a kicker with such a bad build on his team? Probably because the owner doesn't understand how builds work and thinks the kicker is actually an OK build. So what does this tell you? That the owner sucks. QED
Never, ever, ever use the scouting bars to judge a player. Use the prior season's performance plus games to date to get a better read on what makes a good build.
For example:
I have a lvl 32 kicker, who combined last season and the games so far this season is 29 for 31 with 94% FGM, converting 155 of 161 XP's.
Your lvl 31 kicker is 23 for 30 in the same period with 77% FGM, only attempting(but nicely converting) 36 XP's.
Then I would look at distance of those missed FG's...my K has 1 missed from 40+ and 1 from 50+, your K has 1 missed from 30+, 3 from 40+ and 3 from 50+.
Even with your gold bar, and my kicker without a gold bar, it would be hard to say that your build is superior looking at those numbers.
Most other positions can be scouted the same way, by examining the statistics. It's a bit like Bill James' sabermetrics, determining value of a player based on performance over time and compared to similar players during the same timeframe.
Chalk up another person who does not understand the technique of slow building. Your argument has now been judged invalid. How about this, I will guarantee you that your kicker has less Kicking, Vision, and Confidence than matta's. Is he a better kicker now since those + special abilities are the only things that truly make a good kicker?
Now I'm going to explain to everyone for the 14th time where matta's point comes to relevance. Ok our kicker is that much better since his 3 main attributes are better than probably anyone else's in our league. Now multiply that by everyone on our team. That means our QB should have more Throwing, Vision, and Strength/Confidence than everyone else. Our Corners should have more Speed, Agility, and Vision than anyone else. And over the course of a career, those things will pay off.
Are you finding any clarity yet?
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by CTX
SO basically matta, when you say you compare kickers to see how good a team is, you think that if a team has a good kicker they must be good because only good kickers are on good teams. So if I were to have a team of level 1's but have a really badass kicker that team would be good?
No. You use a kicker's bar to determine how good a builder the team / owner is.
For example, a Lvl 32 kicker with a 69 bar is a horrible build. Why would an owner have a kicker with such a bad build on his team? Probably because the owner doesn't understand how builds work and thinks the kicker is actually an OK build. So what does this tell you? That the owner sucks. QED
Never, ever, ever use the scouting bars to judge a player. Use the prior season's performance plus games to date to get a better read on what makes a good build.
For example:
I have a lvl 32 kicker, who combined last season and the games so far this season is 29 for 31 with 94% FGM, converting 155 of 161 XP's.
Your lvl 31 kicker is 23 for 30 in the same period with 77% FGM, only attempting(but nicely converting) 36 XP's.
Then I would look at distance of those missed FG's...my K has 1 missed from 40+ and 1 from 50+, your K has 1 missed from 30+, 3 from 40+ and 3 from 50+.
Even with your gold bar, and my kicker without a gold bar, it would be hard to say that your build is superior looking at those numbers.
Most other positions can be scouted the same way, by examining the statistics. It's a bit like Bill James' sabermetrics, determining value of a player based on performance over time and compared to similar players during the same timeframe.
Chalk up another person who does not understand the technique of slow building. Your argument has now been judged invalid. How about this, I will guarantee you that your kicker has less Kicking, Vision, and Confidence than matta's. Is he a better kicker now since those + special abilities are the only things that truly make a good kicker?
Now I'm going to explain to everyone for the 14th time where matta's point comes to relevance. Ok our kicker is that much better since his 3 main attributes are better than probably anyone else's in our league. Now multiply that by everyone on our team. That means our QB should have more Throwing, Vision, and Strength/Confidence than everyone else. Our Corners should have more Speed, Agility, and Vision than anyone else. And over the course of a career, those things will pay off.
Are you finding any clarity yet?
matta
offline
offline
Never, ever use the stats of a kicker mid-slow build. A guy with 90 kicking, 30 conf, and 20 VIS isn't going to hit many FGs. The same guy at the end of that season with 95 Kick, 80 CONF, 70 VIS is a different story. Look at the kicker since he was rounded off last offseason. He's hit several 50+ yarders since then.
matta
offline
offline
Originally posted by
Now I'm going to explain to everyone for the 14th time where matta's point comes to relevance.
It's like trying to explain Shakespeare to a 3 year old. We try to explain the obvious, but they just don't have the mental capacity to understand the argument.
Now I'm going to explain to everyone for the 14th time where matta's point comes to relevance.
It's like trying to explain Shakespeare to a 3 year old. We try to explain the obvious, but they just don't have the mental capacity to understand the argument.
CTX
offline
offline
Yeah, I completely get that. Just like we you said that you judge teams based off their kicker because a kicker's build validates the build of everybody else. And then, you went off on this really convoluted explanation that if you posted on the main forums you would get laughed at. If you don't believe me, do it yourself and try and argue to anybody with half a brain that high kicking bar means the entire team is good.
Hell, I will do you one better. I will post your posts on the main forums about your theory about a kicker's bar and its relation to the entire team. You just say what you want me to say. You can cover your butt and just PM it to me. That way when your opinion gets clowned you can claim that I modified it. Does that sound good?
Next time when you say something stupid just admit to it and move on to another point, instead of clinging onto it out of pride
Hell, I will do you one better. I will post your posts on the main forums about your theory about a kicker's bar and its relation to the entire team. You just say what you want me to say. You can cover your butt and just PM it to me. That way when your opinion gets clowned you can claim that I modified it. Does that sound good?
Next time when you say something stupid just admit to it and move on to another point, instead of clinging onto it out of pride
Edited by CTX on Jun 25, 2009 01:05:16
matta
offline
offline
Originally posted by CTX
If you don't believe me, do it yourself and try and argue to anybody with half a brain that high kicking bar means the entire team is good.
Here's what you don't get. A high kicking bar means that kicker is good. Scouting a good kicker means the owner or GM that hired him knows what he's doing. Having an owner or scout that knows what he's doing means the rest of the team is probably good.
Similarly, have a bad kicker means the owner or scout is bad. This means that the rest of the team is probably bad.
Do I need to go into 3rd grade vocabulary with you?
If you don't believe me, do it yourself and try and argue to anybody with half a brain that high kicking bar means the entire team is good.
Here's what you don't get. A high kicking bar means that kicker is good. Scouting a good kicker means the owner or GM that hired him knows what he's doing. Having an owner or scout that knows what he's doing means the rest of the team is probably good.
Similarly, have a bad kicker means the owner or scout is bad. This means that the rest of the team is probably bad.
Do I need to go into 3rd grade vocabulary with you?
Av3NGeR
offline
offline
Doesn't that apply to any other position? Scouting a good QB means the owner knew what he picked and means that the house is on fire, a good lb, a good fs, a good cb, a good anything means the owner knows what he is doing. So why does it apply only to the KICKER position in your eyes?
CTX
offline
offline
Ok matta, that team you lost to, which team had the better kicker according to the scouting bar?
HINT: It was your guy
So according to your little stupid theory, you lost to an inferior team
HINT: It was your guy
So according to your little stupid theory, you lost to an inferior team
Rennis
offline
offline
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by CTX
If you don't believe me, do it yourself and try and argue to anybody with half a brain that high kicking bar means the entire team is good.
Here's what you don't get. A high kicking bar means that kicker is good. Scouting a good kicker means the owner or GM that hired him knows what he's doing. Having an owner or scout that knows what he's doing means the rest of the team is probably good.
Similarly, have a bad kicker means the owner or scout is bad. This means that the rest of the team is probably bad.
Do I need to go into 3rd grade vocabulary with you?
This is really getting to the point of sadness.......
Originally posted by CTX
If you don't believe me, do it yourself and try and argue to anybody with half a brain that high kicking bar means the entire team is good.
Here's what you don't get. A high kicking bar means that kicker is good. Scouting a good kicker means the owner or GM that hired him knows what he's doing. Having an owner or scout that knows what he's doing means the rest of the team is probably good.
Similarly, have a bad kicker means the owner or scout is bad. This means that the rest of the team is probably bad.
Do I need to go into 3rd grade vocabulary with you?
This is really getting to the point of sadness.......
matta
offline
offline
Originally posted by CTX
Ok matta, that team you lost to, which team had the better kicker according to the scouting bar?
HINT: It was your guy
So according to your little stupid theory, you lost to an inferior team
oh... my.... God.....
I'm done with arguing with you. It's clear that you're either screwing with me or you're incapable of understanding the argument.
Ok matta, that team you lost to, which team had the better kicker according to the scouting bar?
HINT: It was your guy
So according to your little stupid theory, you lost to an inferior team
oh... my.... God.....
I'm done with arguing with you. It's clear that you're either screwing with me or you're incapable of understanding the argument.
maristfan
offline
offline
Any dope can put all of their skill points and training into kicking and confidence (7/9ths of the amazing gold bar), but kicking and confidence alone do not make a good build. FYI, I slow build too...but when you get to the 5th cap instead of dumping into just kicking and confidence it might be time to up the agility, vision, strength, etc. otherwise you're going to be a lvl 28 player shanking 30 yard kicks...embarrassing.
Edit: When did finding one good player who happened to be a kicker (lots of them out there) for your team mean that you would be able to recruit all boosting/CE/slow build players for your other positions?
Edit: When did finding one good player who happened to be a kicker (lots of them out there) for your team mean that you would be able to recruit all boosting/CE/slow build players for your other positions?
Edited by maristfan on Jun 25, 2009 09:04:35
CTX
offline
offline
Originally posted by Av3NGeR
Doesn't that apply to any other position? Scouting a good QB means the owner knew what he picked and means that the house is on fire, a good lb, a good fs, a good cb, a good anything means the owner knows what he is doing. So why does it apply only to the KICKER position in your eyes?
Basically what he said matta.
I think its hilarious that you are sticking by this whole kicker thing to such sad lengths that I am screwing with you and making you look like even more of a jackass.
Just swallow your pride and admit that you were wrong and move on.
Doesn't that apply to any other position? Scouting a good QB means the owner knew what he picked and means that the house is on fire, a good lb, a good fs, a good cb, a good anything means the owner knows what he is doing. So why does it apply only to the KICKER position in your eyes?
Basically what he said matta.
I think its hilarious that you are sticking by this whole kicker thing to such sad lengths that I am screwing with you and making you look like even more of a jackass.
Just swallow your pride and admit that you were wrong and move on.
matta
offline
offline
Originally posted by
When did finding one good player who happened to be a kicker (lots of them out there) for your team mean that you would be able to recruit all boosting/CE/slow build players for your other positions?
The argument is the opposite. Since there are so many good kickers, recruiting a bad player means that you're either bad at recruiting or can't identify good builds. Either way, that's a signal that the rest of your players are equally bad.
And in the case of Lima, who had many builds open in the preseason, that assessment is true.
When did finding one good player who happened to be a kicker (lots of them out there) for your team mean that you would be able to recruit all boosting/CE/slow build players for your other positions?
The argument is the opposite. Since there are so many good kickers, recruiting a bad player means that you're either bad at recruiting or can't identify good builds. Either way, that's a signal that the rest of your players are equally bad.
And in the case of Lima, who had many builds open in the preseason, that assessment is true.
matta
offline
offline
Originally posted by
I think its hilarious that you are sticking by this whole kicker thing to such sad lengths that I am screwing with you and making you look like even more of a jackass.
The hilarious thing is that you can't understand the argument and actually think you're right!
I think its hilarious that you are sticking by this whole kicker thing to such sad lengths that I am screwing with you and making you look like even more of a jackass.
The hilarious thing is that you can't understand the argument and actually think you're right!
Rennis
offline
offline
Originally posted by matta
Originally posted by
When did finding one good player who happened to be a kicker (lots of them out there) for your team mean that you would be able to recruit all boosting/CE/slow build players for your other positions?
The argument is the opposite. Since there are so many good kickers, recruiting a bad player means that you're either bad at recruiting or can't identify good builds. Either way, that's a signal that the rest of your players are equally bad.
And in the case of Lima, who had many builds open in the preseason, that assessment is true.
Jesus can we lock this thread ??!!! Hello, is there a moderator in the house? This is the most asinine thread I have ever had the displeasure of reading. And yes I have read this thread http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2844543&page=1 if that helps you put this in a little perspective.
To be totally honest imo who cares how Matta evaluates teams until he/she wins multiple championships and dominates a few leagues. Until then Matta's methods don't carry any weight in my book. As I am sure my methods should not carry any weight in yours.
Final thing for the love of (insert whatever you love here) please forget this retarded thread and let's move on. Active threads are one thing but dumb ones are just....dumb.
Originally posted by
When did finding one good player who happened to be a kicker (lots of them out there) for your team mean that you would be able to recruit all boosting/CE/slow build players for your other positions?
The argument is the opposite. Since there are so many good kickers, recruiting a bad player means that you're either bad at recruiting or can't identify good builds. Either way, that's a signal that the rest of your players are equally bad.
And in the case of Lima, who had many builds open in the preseason, that assessment is true.
Jesus can we lock this thread ??!!! Hello, is there a moderator in the house? This is the most asinine thread I have ever had the displeasure of reading. And yes I have read this thread http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2844543&page=1 if that helps you put this in a little perspective.
To be totally honest imo who cares how Matta evaluates teams until he/she wins multiple championships and dominates a few leagues. Until then Matta's methods don't carry any weight in my book. As I am sure my methods should not carry any weight in yours.
Final thing for the love of (insert whatever you love here) please forget this retarded thread and let's move on. Active threads are one thing but dumb ones are just....dumb.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























