Originally posted by Festus
Originally posted by Derek McFadden
There is a difference between how animals fight for dominance in the wild, and a human being setting up a dog fighting ring. These are supposed to be domesticated animals. When was the last time you saw a pitbull running around in the wild, let alone the last time you found a dead pitbull in the wild that was killed because he was fighting for a fishing spot? It doesn't happen. In our society fighting dogs is taboo, and its against the law. It was against the law 7-9 years ago when he started this shit, and its illegal now. Vick broke the law and he knew that what he was doing was against the law.
If Vick wanted to eat a pitbull taco he should have taken his ass to Mexico and did the dog fighting thing there where it isn't taboo/illegal. Human beings have animalistic urges, but its not ok if some mongoloid goes around and rapes random women just because its part of their genetic make up. This is similar to T.I.'s situation. They both knew what they were doing was wrong, they did what they wanted anyways, and they have to own up to that. I can guarantee if Vick is re-instated that the NFL will have a PR nightmare brewing with PITA. If the NFL deems the Vick situation as too much of a hindrance from a business standpoint, then they owe it to their shareholders to bring down a lifetime ban on Vick. Bad publicity can really damage the product any business sells, and NFL players are highly marketed by the NFL and their respective teams to help sell the product.
What's the difference between a person fighting dogs and a person running around raping women? In the case of rape, there is a victim. In the case of dog fighting, it's based upon "because I said so".
Ultimately your position comes down the fact that if it's considered taboo then it should be outlawed. If that's the case then you would have no issues with states who have laws that prohibit oral sex and declare such actions as "crimes against nature" punishable by years in prison. Once again, a law based upon "because I said so".
I have no problems with the NFL banning Vick for the actions he committed. It's called freedom of association. But neither should he be punished by loss of freedom, threatened with loss of life and have his bank accounts plundered by the state for actions that caused no harm to another person.
There are vicitims in both scenarios regardless if you believe that animals have no rights or not. These dog fighting rings are not random incidents, these happen in a controlled environment. You can put any animal(dog, cow, mouse, human, etc.) into a similar environment and you will see similar results. Animals act upon animalistic urges/instincts, and they will act aggressively if they feel they are in a threatened position.
Now don't put words in my mouth and say that if its considered taboo it should be outlawed. I didn't say that, and that is not my opinion. Your example about oral sex is ridiculous, but if something like that were passed into law call your congressman and have him fight it. What I am saying is that dog fighting and tax evasion/racketeering is against the law. Laws handed down by the people we vote into office to make laws that are against the culture's ideals or "because I said so" or for whatever reason. Thats why our government runs on a system of checks and balances. If the law is ridiculous or against our rights as a citizen those elected officials are supposed to keep them from being passed into law.
I will agree that Vick shouldn't be punished by a loss of freedom or be threatened with a loss of life. As far as his bank accounts go, well that has more to do with the fact that he doesn't have the ability to repay his loans or fulfill his contractual obligations. I won't begin to imply that I know his financial situation inside out, but I know his earning capacity is much different than it was when this all started. I did hear that he had alot of loans that were outstanding when this started, and spending as much time in prison as he did I just assume that he has defaulted on many of them.
Originally posted by Derek McFadden
There is a difference between how animals fight for dominance in the wild, and a human being setting up a dog fighting ring. These are supposed to be domesticated animals. When was the last time you saw a pitbull running around in the wild, let alone the last time you found a dead pitbull in the wild that was killed because he was fighting for a fishing spot? It doesn't happen. In our society fighting dogs is taboo, and its against the law. It was against the law 7-9 years ago when he started this shit, and its illegal now. Vick broke the law and he knew that what he was doing was against the law.
If Vick wanted to eat a pitbull taco he should have taken his ass to Mexico and did the dog fighting thing there where it isn't taboo/illegal. Human beings have animalistic urges, but its not ok if some mongoloid goes around and rapes random women just because its part of their genetic make up. This is similar to T.I.'s situation. They both knew what they were doing was wrong, they did what they wanted anyways, and they have to own up to that. I can guarantee if Vick is re-instated that the NFL will have a PR nightmare brewing with PITA. If the NFL deems the Vick situation as too much of a hindrance from a business standpoint, then they owe it to their shareholders to bring down a lifetime ban on Vick. Bad publicity can really damage the product any business sells, and NFL players are highly marketed by the NFL and their respective teams to help sell the product.
What's the difference between a person fighting dogs and a person running around raping women? In the case of rape, there is a victim. In the case of dog fighting, it's based upon "because I said so".
Ultimately your position comes down the fact that if it's considered taboo then it should be outlawed. If that's the case then you would have no issues with states who have laws that prohibit oral sex and declare such actions as "crimes against nature" punishable by years in prison. Once again, a law based upon "because I said so".
I have no problems with the NFL banning Vick for the actions he committed. It's called freedom of association. But neither should he be punished by loss of freedom, threatened with loss of life and have his bank accounts plundered by the state for actions that caused no harm to another person.
There are vicitims in both scenarios regardless if you believe that animals have no rights or not. These dog fighting rings are not random incidents, these happen in a controlled environment. You can put any animal(dog, cow, mouse, human, etc.) into a similar environment and you will see similar results. Animals act upon animalistic urges/instincts, and they will act aggressively if they feel they are in a threatened position.
Now don't put words in my mouth and say that if its considered taboo it should be outlawed. I didn't say that, and that is not my opinion. Your example about oral sex is ridiculous, but if something like that were passed into law call your congressman and have him fight it. What I am saying is that dog fighting and tax evasion/racketeering is against the law. Laws handed down by the people we vote into office to make laws that are against the culture's ideals or "because I said so" or for whatever reason. Thats why our government runs on a system of checks and balances. If the law is ridiculous or against our rights as a citizen those elected officials are supposed to keep them from being passed into law.
I will agree that Vick shouldn't be punished by a loss of freedom or be threatened with a loss of life. As far as his bank accounts go, well that has more to do with the fact that he doesn't have the ability to repay his loans or fulfill his contractual obligations. I won't begin to imply that I know his financial situation inside out, but I know his earning capacity is much different than it was when this all started. I did hear that he had alot of loans that were outstanding when this started, and spending as much time in prison as he did I just assume that he has defaulted on many of them.






























