User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > There should be no uncapped leagues in the cloud. If you agree bump this thread.
Page:
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fatcolin123
Well first of hi dmfa,

second we need more perma cap teams and teams affiliated with each other all the way up to pro


I agree... 100% this type of system would create stability. It would end the gutting and the movement we see every year.
 
Fat Colin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rellascout
Originally posted by fatcolin123

Well first of hi dmfa,

second we need more perma cap teams and teams affiliated with each other all the way up to pro


I agree... 100% this type of system would create stability. It would end the gutting and the movement we see every year.


I mean we have the minors already made so why not. And if people do not want to do this then create a second League altogether to make this
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fatcolin123
Well first of hi dmfa,

second we need more perma cap teams and teams affiliated with each other all the way up to pro


o hai

Sorry about the mess. We had to discuss changing the title and getting the idea on the right track.

I think the cloud should be properly ordered and capped. It could even be a very high cap, maybe as high as 50 for a league or two at the top, but they should all be properly ordered.
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Originally posted by fatcolin123

Well first of hi dmfa,

second we need more perma cap teams and teams affiliated with each other all the way up to pro


o hai

Sorry about the mess. We had to discuss changing the title and getting the idea on the right track.

I think the cloud should be properly ordered and capped. It could even be a very high cap, maybe as high as 50 for a league or two at the top, but they should all be properly ordered.


Thanks for getting this back on track. I hope it can serve as good discussion point.
 
Fat Colin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Originally posted by fatcolin123

Well first of hi dmfa,

second we need more perma cap teams and teams affiliated with each other all the way up to pro


o hai

Sorry about the mess. We had to discuss changing the title and getting the idea on the right track.

I think the cloud should be properly ordered and capped. It could even be a very high cap, maybe as high as 50 for a league or two at the top, but they should all be properly ordered.


Well I am not a fan of the caps being raised all the time, because eventually when you get promoted you need to replace starters to get a chance in the higher leagues making the backups want to leave and high lvls going down to lower leagues
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fatcolin123
Well I am not a fan of the caps being raised all the time, because eventually when you get promoted you need to replace starters to get a chance in the higher leagues making the backups want to leave and high lvls going down to lower leagues


Right. This is the final year of leveling/XP for the first crop of players, so now we should know how it will generally level off. If the top possible level is, say, 70, then I think the highest cap of the cloud should be about 10 levels below that, say 60. There should be a few of those, and then a few 54s, a few 48s, and on down the line.

I use the 6-level gradation because that's how many a player can gain in a season after L29: 25*40 + 100 * 16 = 2600 plus 3 boosts.
 
Fat Colin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Originally posted by fatcolin123

Well I am not a fan of the caps being raised all the time, because eventually when you get promoted you need to replace starters to get a chance in the higher leagues making the backups want to leave and high lvls going down to lower leagues


Right. This is the final year of leveling/XP for the first crop of players, so now we should know how it will generally level off. If the top possible level is, say, 70, then I think the highest cap of the cloud should be about 10 levels below that, say 60. There should be a few of those, and then a few 54s, a few 48s, and on down the line.

I use the 6-level gradation because that's how many a player can gain in a season after L29: 25*40 + 100 * 16 = 2600 plus 3 boosts.


yeah I hope they stay perma
 
rellascout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fatcolin123
Originally posted by dmfa41

Originally posted by fatcolin123


Well first of hi dmfa,

second we need more perma cap teams and teams affiliated with each other all the way up to pro


o hai

Sorry about the mess. We had to discuss changing the title and getting the idea on the right track.

I think the cloud should be properly ordered and capped. It could even be a very high cap, maybe as high as 50 for a league or two at the top, but they should all be properly ordered.


Well I am not a fan of the caps being raised all the time, because eventually when you get promoted you need to replace starters to get a chance in the higher leagues making the backups want to leave and high lvls going down to lower leagues


I agree I think a hard cap system is better. It allows everyone more of a chance to be even at the start. Then the GMs and the owners can work to max out everyone XP and grow the team.

I think it if you set up a more permanent structure you could create a nice farm system with 5 dedicated agents. One takes the level 13 capped team. The next takes the 28. The next takes the 28 and then the next takes the 38 capped team. You then have a team in the 2 teams in the pyramid that these minor league teams feed. In this scenario the agents and the owners are working to put people on the right teams in the right cap levels. At the end of each season before promotion you move your player up to stay under your desired cap. You sent your players up as they get better to replace the guys at the top. An owner could then be allowed to stay in a capped cloud as long as they want. You could have the same guy running the capped 28 team every year. He would get better at developing that level of player instead of forcing him to move up.

Everyone keeps moving up the chain. The Pyramid teams do not get gutted. They have a constant flow of players. If one of the owners wants to stop playing for whatever reason the HC or another GM can take over. This would create stability. We all know this happens now anyway but a more concrete method would improve the game.

A pyramid team would actually go and recruit a lower level team to be the farm system. There would be a lot less movement IMHO. Some pyramid teams would still go CPU allowing limited movement up for those who are building to the pyramid. New guys who are new to the game would still have a way to move up into the higher ranks of the game but since there would be a lot less gutting that movement could be properly executed so that you get a reward for winning instead of a year of losing to get up to speed.
Edited by rellascout on Jun 8, 2009 10:22:48
 
josh85_1983
offline
Link
 
the gators were in BBB with us last season, We the birds did not choose a minor uncapped league along with many other teams in that league that were just as good! don't blame the Gators for being here...
 
Fat Colin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rellascout
Originally posted by fatcolin123

Originally posted by dmfa41


Originally posted by fatcolin123



Well first of hi dmfa,

second we need more perma cap teams and teams affiliated with each other all the way up to pro


o hai

Sorry about the mess. We had to discuss changing the title and getting the idea on the right track.

I think the cloud should be properly ordered and capped. It could even be a very high cap, maybe as high as 50 for a league or two at the top, but they should all be properly ordered.


Well I am not a fan of the caps being raised all the time, because eventually when you get promoted you need to replace starters to get a chance in the higher leagues making the backups want to leave and high lvls going down to lower leagues


I agree I think a hard cap system is better. It allows everyone more of a chance to be even at the start. Then the GMs and the owners can work to max out everyone XP and grow the team.

I think it if you set up a more permanent structure you could create a nice farm system with 5 dedicated agents. One takes the level 13 capped team. The next takes the 28. The next takes the 28 and then the next takes the 38 capped team. You then have a team in the 2 teams in the pyramid that these minor league teams feed. In this scenario the agents and the owners are working to put people on the right teams in the right cap levels.

Everyone keeps moving up the chain. The Pyramid teams do not get gutted. They have a constant flow of players. If one of the owners wants to stop playing for whatever reason the HC or another GM can take over. This would create stability. We all know this happens now anyway but a more concrete method would improve the game.

A pyramid team would actually go and recruit a lower level team to be the farm system. There would be a lot less movement IMHO. Some pyramid teams would still go CPU allowing limited movement up for those who are building to the pyramid but since there would be a lot less gutting that movement could be properly executed so that you get a reward for winning instead of a year of losing to get up to speed.


epic imo
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Any scenario where a minor league team doesn't have to be in direct competition with AAA/Pro level teams for talent, just to be able to compete in the minors is fine by me.
 
P@nda
Radioactive
offline
Link
 
I like the perma caps all the way to the AA Level. Bump
 
Fat Colin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nsz8
I like the perma caps all the way to the AA Level. Bump


This would make the most sense and be the easiest to do
 
Caiderman98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
+1 the highest average level teams really should be moved into AA, leaving all your new team purchases in the 'cloud'.


 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Should bring back A (cap 40, 44, 48, 50 or something like that) and leave the caps as they are in the cloud leagues.
Edited by Dub J on Jun 8, 2009 10:50:45
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.