User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Politics and Religion > Something about the Bible I honestly want to know
Page:
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
That was not clarified in the previous statement in regards to divinity. It looked like just believing in Jesus.

Still not the sole definition. It's that Jesus died on the cross appeasing a wrathful God so that all who believes in Him AND the works upon the cross will be saved. Detailed scriptures of the workings of the Holy Spirit which sanctifies does not tell of a entity that coherses Born Again Christians to gas people. Does not tell people to protest in front of funeral homes of fallen soliders or to kill abortion clinic workers/doctors. Does not tell preachers to preach false hope of wealth and 10 steps to better your life... Sorry went off on a tangent.


They really ought to rename the fallacy to the No True Christian fallacy. After all, nobody uses it more often. It often seems that the only true Christian is the one you happen to be talking to.

You'd have lost most Christians at, "appeasing a wrathful God."

And, to be perfectly honest, you knew exactly what I meant by "believing in Jesus."
Edited by captobvious on Jun 9, 2009 09:38:07
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NObodyn0se
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by NObodyn0se
But The Pope is a Christian, right?

I was under the impression that the Pope was a Nazi.

He was. The Pope (as in the office, not as in the current dude) is also responsible for some of the worst tragedies in human history.


benedict was not a nazi.

and yes, the papacy has been responsible for many things (especially during the so-called "pornocratic" era) that were heinous (especially by today's standards)... but "the some of the worst tragedies"? that's a bit of a stretch, don't you think?

also, it flat-out doesn't work to judge an ideology by its adherents. every single self-identified christian could be utterly immoral, and that still isn't necessarily comment on the doctrine/ideology of christianity itself. anyone making sweeping claims about religion needs to properly parse the different senses of the word "religion" first... and doing so does not commit a self-sealing fallacy.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NObodyn0se
But The Pope is a Christian, right?


depends on what you mean... from a theological, ecumenical, or descriptive standpoint, sure.

but from the position of doctrine/etc, roughly half of christianity has flat-out rejected catholicism as false teaching (to varying degrees).
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
They really ought to rename the fallacy to the No True Christian fallacy. After all, nobody uses it more often. It often seems that the only true Christian is the one you happen to be talking to.
You'd have lost most Christians at, "appeasing a wrathful God."
And, to be perfectly honest, you knew exactly what I meant by "believing in Jesus."


it's not quite the same thing, though. i'll grant you that many lay christians are guilty of leveraging self-sealing fallacies... and that even entire doctrines are built on the same (e.g. preservation of saints).

but what you're missing here is that while we do have an objective definition for "scotsman", we absolutely do not have an objective definition for "christian"... so quibbling over the contours of chrisitanity is quite simply not a self-sealing fallacy.
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
They really ought to rename the fallacy to the No True Christian fallacy. After all, nobody uses it more often. It often seems that the only true Christian is the one you happen to be talking to.

You'd have lost most Christians at, "appeasing a wrathful God."

And, to be perfectly honest, you knew exactly what I meant by "believing in Jesus."[/QUOTE




Well know I assumed you meant not the divinity but the person of Jesus. Believe it or not there is even debate on that. That's beside the point...

Let me see if I'm right:

- X group who call themselves Christians were evil
- X-Group used Christianity to further their evil intentions
- Christianity is evil

No?


Edited by Sureal on Jun 9, 2009 11:27:36
Edited by Sureal on Jun 9, 2009 11:26:53
Edited by Sureal on Jun 9, 2009 11:26:38
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
Well know I assumed you meant not the divinity but the person of Jesus. Believe it or not there is even debate on that. That's beside the point...

Let me see if I'm right:

- X group who call themselves Christians were evil
- X-Group used Christianity to further their evil intentions
- Christianity is evil

No?


No. I never made any such argument. I merely pointed out how you were using a fallacy to argue the opposite.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rams78110
Anyone who is not a Christian, or who is named Steelers Insider please refrain from posting here.

There are things that are indisputably wrong in the bible. Why do you insist on following it to whatever extent you do, when it has been proven wrong before? Couldnt there be other fallacies in the bible?


I have seen alot of people point out "contradictions" in the Bible, but going through the list I shot 'em down one at a time withe ease. The only one that got me was the "who is Jesus's grandpa" one.

The idea of contradictions in the Bible is a myth.
 
Sureal
offline
Link
 
I understand what you are saying but in this case that fallacy does not apply.

If I say I played in the NBA yet all the evidence shows that I never did does this mean I played in the NBA?

Just because I claim that I am something does not mean I am. I can be lying to further a cause or some other personal gain.
Edited by Sureal on Jun 9, 2009 11:41:51
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary


The idea of contradictions in the Bible is a myth.


lol
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sureal
I understand what you are saying but in this case that fallacy does not apply.

If I say I played in the NBA yet all the evidence shows that I never did does this mean I played in the NBA?

Just because I claim that I am something does not mean I am. I can be lying to further a cause or some other personal gain.


Just because I pointed out that someone correctly identified a fallacy you used does NOT mean I'm using it as an argument to prove the opposite. You're accusing me of the fallacy fallacy, and you're completely wrong. I haven't said anything to indicate a belief that Christianity is evil. That's an assumption you decided to make on your own.

To summarize:

- You used the No True Scotsman fallacy
- Someone pointed that out
- You used an incorrect argument to support your NTS fallacy
- I pointed out the error of that argument, and verified the correct application of the NTS fallacy

Nowhere in there does it say, "Therefore, Christianity is evil."
 
captobvious
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary
I have seen alot of people point out "contradictions" in the Bible, but going through the list I shot 'em down one at a time withe ease. The only one that got me was the "who is Jesus's grandpa" one.


All 429 of them? LOL
http://www.skepticsannotatedbible.com/contra/by_name.html
 
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by edwardzachary

I have seen alot of people point out "contradictions" in the Bible, but going through the list I shot 'em down one at a time withe ease. The only one that got me was the "who is Jesus's grandpa" one.


All 429 of them? LOL
http://www.skepticsannotatedbible.com/contra/by_name.html


I could shoot down every one...but it gets boring after the first 8
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by edwardzachary


I could shoot down every one...but it gets boring after the first 8


Ok then shoot down the first 7. Bet you can't.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by captobvious
Originally posted by Sureal

- You used the No True Scotsman fallacy


false.

please read what i wrote to you a few posts back.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Originally posted by edwardzachary
I could shoot down every one...but it gets boring after the first 8

Ok then shoot down the first 7. Bet you can't.


you realize there are centuries-old theological counter-arguments to all of those, right?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.