User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > ***Official*** All-Pro Ballot nomination thread
Page:
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Omg we're having a ballet?!!! Sweet!


I just realized the guys in your avatar are already doing ballet.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
That's why i was so excited
 
jptoher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
It takes a hell of a lot of work to browse thru players and pick one. For instance...how would I pick a TE? I would have to go thru and look at the TE for every team, since looking at receiving numbers don't tell me anything, they are all lumped together.

What about a FB? The same.

But as the owner, you know if your guy is a standout and you can bring it to the attention of the league. When it is time to vote, you can't vote for your guy. This is just the process to get the names on the ballet.


No this entire thing is retarded. A lot of positions won't have many votes and on top of that just because a player is a standout on your team doesn't mean he's actually a standout. Much fairer to have each team select a group of nominations not on their team and those with the most votes win.

Either way, the idea of an unofficial pro bowl roster is pretty stupid.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jptoher

Much fairer to have each team select a group of nominations not on their team and those with the most votes win.




I am not spending time looking at the FB on the other 31 teams to decide which one is most deserving of a Pro Bowl nod. Sorry.

Now if owners want to nominate their FB and there are 5 to look at, I will put in the time to cast a vote. How does this not seem like a better system?
Last edited May 26, 2008 17:27:46
 
jptoher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by jptoher


Much fairer to have each team select a group of nominations not on their team and those with the most votes win.




I am not spending time looking at the FB on the other 31 teams to decide which one is most deserving of a Pro Bowl nod. Sorry.

Now if owners want to nominate their FB and there are 5 to look at, I will put in the time to cast a vote. How does this not seem like a better system?


Because the good FB's on teams with lots of other allstars won't get nominated.
 
jptoher
offline
Link
 
Imagine the possibility that say, Tecmo, has 4 people who should be starting pro bowlers on defense but are never nominated because you could only pick three.

edit: You own DFG, so just substitute your team for Tecmo.
Last edited May 26, 2008 17:57:09
 
Link
 
Originally posted by jptoher


Either way, the idea of an unofficial pro bowl roster is pretty stupid.


Yet... here you are.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jptoher
Imagine the possibility that say, Tecmo, has 4 people who should be starting pro bowlers on defense but are never nominated because you could only pick three.

edit: You own DFG, so just substitute your team for Tecmo.


I agree this is a problem. Not sure how to fix it. What I do know is that if you ask owners to put in the time to review all 32 teams this thing will die off quick. I am open to other ideas.
 
Toad22484
offline
Link
 
well our fb has 1300 yards and 21 touchdowns so you don't have to look far . I agree having to look over each team is annoying so perhaps if each team nominates its best 5/6 or however many players and we take a look and vote? just a thought. I like the idea of an all pro vote in I just don't want it to turn into a biased flame war ect.
 
The Duff Man
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toad22484
well our fb has 1300 yards and 21 touchdowns so you don't have to look far . I agree having to look over each team is annoying so perhaps if each team nominates its best 5/6 or however many players and we take a look and vote? just a thought. I like the idea of an all pro vote in I just don't want it to turn into a biased flame war ect.


This is what is proposed in the opening post of this thread, with the added benefit that you can nominate players on other teams if you want to.

 
Toad22484
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Duff Man
Originally posted by Toad22484

well our fb has 1300 yards and 21 touchdowns so you don't have to look far . I agree having to look over each team is annoying so perhaps if each team nominates its best 5/6 or however many players and we take a look and vote? just a thought. I like the idea of an all pro vote in I just don't want it to turn into a biased flame war ect.


This is what is proposed in the opening post of this thread, with the added benefit that you can nominate players on other teams if you want to.



Yeah, but I was just throwing out there that you only nominate players from your own team for everyone else to vote on, and you can't vote your own players onto the all pro team, just nominate them. Just an idea.
 
Gronert
offline
Link
 
OUR TEAM NOMINATIONS:

1st-E.D. Jackson (1488.5yds, 26 TDs {best}, 5.4 average)
2nd-James Triniti (11 INTs {most in both conferences}, FR)
3rd-Mc Toast (10 INTs {2nd best in both conferences})

AROUND THE CONFERENCE (EAST AND WEST):
(in no particular order)

1st-Chad Johnson (144 Rec.)
2nd-Iggy Cantoi (1660 yds, {E.D. Jackson is better though)
3rd-Steven Minneapolis (331 pancakes {most in both conferences})
4th-Moe Jontana (4089 yds, 33 TDs)
5th-QB Eagles (3751 yds, 42 TD {most in both conferences}, 4 INTs, 5 hurries, 5 sack)
6th-Sam Graddy (20 TDs, {most in both conferences}, 6 drops)
7th-Lance Briggs (136 Tackles {most in both conferences}, 8 FF)

VERY TOP PICKS:

E.D. JACKSON
QB EAGLES
JAMES TRINITI
LANCE BRIGGS

BONUS PICK:

BEST KICKER: GOLDEN FOOT
 
mavsman
offline
Link
 
Rebel Yell Nominations:

HB: Robert E. Lee
WR: River Rivers
TE: Drav Marlowe

LB: AC Slater
FS: Clifford Joseph Haris, Jr.
CB: Mike Mickens
 
Hybrid1486
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tank Basterson
Originally posted by killarage

Originally posted by Toad22484


Originally posted by killarage



Originally posted by Tank Basterson




Originally posted by killarage





Originally posted by coyote4848







DT: Tarvaris Jckson: Never mind....he's gone. Who let him go?!


He traded himself off the team. Thus our downfall on defense.


Tarvaris Washington, Tim Harper's guy. Did you know he was going to trade himself?


nope. and the sad thing is, I don't even know what we got in return. I think it was like a LVL 8 CPU guy, and maybe some cash. I know the owner of the team knows, but he's on vacation so I can't ask him.


wow that sucks hard :/.


well, it was our fault in the end. The majority of our team and Harpers' team(s) all know each other from another sim league and the Buffalos had one of his players so he could be a GM and "advise" us as the team progressed. It just so happened that out of the blue his NT was traded to his Pro team and he was no longer a GM. I guess we knew it was going to happen at some point, but without warning and a chance to try and grab a free agent, we were left with a low level backup.

Oh well, what can you do?


That sucks royally!


Tim was a GM on my team, and he helped out a lot until I learned the game...then he grabbed a few guys from my team for last season's playoffs, but nobody noticed since he killed the Calgary team a hell of a lot more than mine...then he told me I could use his DT since the one I had left for his own team...then he kinda nabbed him randomly...and at that point I took him off my GM list and took myself off his...as soon as I get my tackle from his team for next season our affiliation will be over...he's a good guy, he just likes to spring things, like that
 
khit
offline
Link
 
So what about kickers and punters?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.