User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #2 > AA #2 Power Rankings (5/22/08)
Page:
 
Kasz216
offline
Link
 
The Cowboys are 0-0 and the Giants are 0-0.

I don't see your point.
 
NastyLLoyd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ghost187
lol that number 16 spot should go to the Silver Knights, 8-8, we WILL make it to the playoffs


keep dreaming..
 
that1guy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kasz216
The Cowboys are 0-0 and the Giants are 0-0.

I don't see your point.


0-0 now...but preseason rankings have the cowboys as the only NFC team in the top 5. i'm not really adding anything to the conversation here, i'm just a cowboys fan and wanted to drop that in there.

but to YOUR point. you do see teams with worse records being ranked ahead of better teams within the same division and the cowboys are ranked higher in preseason rankings even though the giants won the superbowl and beat the cowboys on their way there. and now in the new season the cowboys definetly don't have a cream puff schedule. so there ya go smart guy!
Last edited May 23, 2008 15:47:33
 
Kasz216
offline
Link
 
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/powerranking

Notice in each division the Power Rankings pretty much equal standings.
Last edited May 23, 2008 15:48:22
 
Jim Mora
offline
Link
 
We're undefeated in Season 3, so I'm sure we'll be on the top of the Power Rankings.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
If power rankings are just recreations of the standings, then they should be called the "official standings".
 
Kasz216
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
If power rankings are just recreations of the standings, then they should be called the "official standings".


They aren't JUST that. There is also the strength of schedule issues.

Which you can see if you go back a few power rankings.

The point of showing you week 18 was to show that when strength of schedule no longer matters record speaks the best. (The season is over.)

That's the reality of Power Rankings... that's how it is done in the pros.

If you don't like your ranking and think you should be higher you have no one to blame but your own team for underperforming.

The Power Rankings in divisions are supposed to suggest how the season will end. Not "put the teams who look good on paper but underperform up top to make them feel better."

The Power Rankings between divisions is where you match up the teams and see which ones look better on paper. That's why you are lucky enough to be ahead of the Grizzles.
Last edited May 23, 2008 18:48:37
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
I think power rankings should rank teams in the order that they would beat one another. Otherwise, you have the messed-up NCAA AP and Coaches polls, which always rank teams higher than better teams just because of overall record.
 
Mrstickball
offline
Link
 
Spears,

If you want to make your team higher on the Power Rankings, then feel free to do the chart after tommorrows game. Until then, whoever makes the list gets to choose their methodology. Alright?
 
Jim Mora
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mrstickball
Spears,

If you want to make your team higher on the Power Rankings, then feel free to do the chart after tommorrows game. Until then, whoever makes the list gets to choose their methodology. Alright?


Agreed! Let's let Spears do the next ranking. To be honest though, I'm excited to see the game between London and SJY. Two of the biggest trash talking teams, who think they're the tops of the league, matching up tomorrow. Should be a great game!
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
where's the SJY trash talk...I need to take a peak at it...
 
Kasz216
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
I think power rankings should rank teams in the order that they would beat one another. Otherwise, you have the messed-up NCAA AP and Coaches polls, which always rank teams higher than better teams just because of overall record.


Well... reality disagrees with you.

Also the AP and Coaches polls actually are trying to pick the best team. That's the only way to do it when the teams don't play the same competition.

In division when everyone plays the same opponents the best team is the one that wins the most games. Period. Your record is who you are. Your record is third place in the east and if you are in third place at the end of the year that is who you are unless you win the championship.

Otherwise even if you just make it to the championship game, you were a lucky team that got hot.

Your season record is who you are. If you don't like it all you can do is endeavor to do better.
Last edited May 23, 2008 20:29:19
 
MrLaBelle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
I think power rankings should rank teams in the order that they would beat one another. Otherwise, you have the messed-up NCAA AP and Coaches polls, which always rank teams higher than better teams just because of overall record.


I like this because was is not London that LOST to the now 5-9 St. Catherines Blizzard so by your "Power Rankings" St. Catherines should be ahead of you because they beat you?

I think Power Rankings should be based on how hot a team is and their strength of schedule and how they have performed overall in the season. (In plain English I like the way Mr. Stickball has set it up.)
Last edited May 24, 2008 00:43:46
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrLaBelle
Originally posted by SpearSrai

I think power rankings should rank teams in the order that they would beat one another. Otherwise, you have the messed-up NCAA AP and Coaches polls, which always rank teams higher than better teams just because of overall record.


I like this because was is not London that LOST to the now 5-9 St. Catherines Blizzard so by your "Power Rankings" St. Catherines should be ahead of you because they beat you?

I think Power Rankings should be based on how hot a team is and their strength of schedule and how they have performed overall in the season. (In plain English I like the way Mr. Stickball has set it up.)


I'm not saying who would beat who on any given day, where luck is a huge factor. I'm saying who would beat who if the teams played each other in a 7-game series, like in basketball or baseball. Obviously any team could beat any other team for one game.
 
Mrstickball
offline
Link
 
Then in 2 hours, produce some Power Rankings for a "Playoff Preview"..
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.