User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > ROLB Drifing Inside On Every Run Play
Page:
 
Samythe41
offline
Link
 
I guess this is the kind of play we're talking about, right?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=477785&pbp_id=7403259
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Samythe41
I guess this is the kind of play we're talking about, right?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=477785&pbp_id=7403259


Yup thats it.
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Samythe41
I guess this is the kind of play we're talking about, right?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=477785&pbp_id=7403259


Pretty much. Happens all the time taking the LB out of the defense against running plays because he decides he'd rather play footsie with the O-linemen.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
Originally posted by Samythe41

I guess this is the kind of play we're talking about, right?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=477785&pbp_id=7403259


Pretty much. Happens all the time taking the LB out of the defense against running plays because he decides he'd rather play footsie with the O-linemen.


And it sets him up perfectly to be blocked by the LG or even the C whereas he would've been free to attack the ball-carrier if the bug was not present.

Whatever Bort needs to do to make them stay put until they begin reacting to the play, is fine with me. I just hope he doesn't end up making a LB who stands still until the play is passed.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
This is the issue, 100% for sure. The player is set to shadow the HB, and the HB is towards the center, so he heads toward him.

So, help me improve the logic. What should he do instead? Stand and wait? What if the ROLB is set to cover and the HB heads to the right? He'll be out of the play at that point. Is that ok?


If the ROLB is set to cover the HB and the HB heads out strongside, the ROLB is fucked no matter what.

I think that Matt's right. Set the LBs to wait and read, and move after deciding what's going on. At least this way LB builders will clearly understand that they can help themselves out with high Vision. Right now, you still need the high Vision, but you need even higher Agility/Speed to overcome the LB drifting out of place.

Really what you might want is a "Spy Man" mode on the HB that somehow drops over to zone or blitz if the HB doesn't come out. The LB in this mode should move laterally full speed if the HB is heading out of the backfield laterally, and move into full man coverage as the HB gets closer to the LOS in the flats. The problem is that your sim lacks the AI for the LB to know to avoid getting tangled up in the O-line.
Last edited May 7, 2009 14:10:50
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by smallbugger

if he's in man coverage of the HB or FB, then he's moving towards the guy he's assign to cover.... which would be an inside movement


This is the issue, 100% for sure. The player is set to shadow the HB, and the HB is towards the center, so he heads toward him.

So, help me improve the logic. What should he do instead? Stand and wait? What if the ROLB is set to cover and the HB heads to the right? He'll be out of the play at that point. Is that ok?


Except that for the two plays I linked, the play was an outside toss, and the linebacker still slowly drifted to the inside of the field. The HB was running around the weakside end, while the linebacker did worse than nothing.

I would VERY much prefer him to simply stand where I put him instead of drifting off. An even better solution would be allowing me to assign him a zone to head to while he was trying to decide what to do.

PinTBC
Last edited May 7, 2009 15:59:39
 
Link
 
It seems the LB-AI needs a revamping altogether. They are obviously the most difficult position to make work properly because they are the only defenders with a run/pass responsibility on every single play. An overhaul sounds like it is needed.

Still, I believe you should have an initial vision check for the LB to determine the play and react to it all while standing still. The LBs coverage of HBs running routes is terrible already since they do not follow at full-speed until the HB is gone.

 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot
It seems the LB-AI needs a revamping altogether. They are obviously the most difficult position to make work properly because they are the only defenders with a run/pass responsibility on every single play. An overhaul sounds like it is needed.

Still, I believe you should have an initial vision check for the LB to determine the play and react to it all while standing still. The LBs coverage of HBs running routes is terrible already since they do not follow at full-speed until the HB is gone.



It doesn't need -total- revamping.

On on those plays they drift to where the handoff occurs.

Just make them take a read step (forward into their assigned gap). During that time is where a LB makes his 'vision check'.
 
Link
 
Thats the best idea I have heard yet, but what I mean is there are problems with coverage as well. Even though the players start by moving in their direction they dont seem to go full speed until they get closer across the LOS. Th

But that would work well i think. Whatever gets them to make the read before moving.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
Originally posted by MattMan Firespot

It seems the LB-AI needs a revamping altogether. They are obviously the most difficult position to make work properly because they are the only defenders with a run/pass responsibility on every single play. An overhaul sounds like it is needed.

Still, I believe you should have an initial vision check for the LB to determine the play and react to it all while standing still. The LBs coverage of HBs running routes is terrible already since they do not follow at full-speed until the HB is gone.



It doesn't need -total- revamping.

On on those plays they drift to where the handoff occurs.

Just make them take a read step (forward into their assigned gap). During that time is where a LB makes his 'vision check'.


Sorry, but today I figured I would be smart. I set my right outside linebacker to hit the weakside flat zone on the weak I play. Figured, that way he had no man check to pass, just a zone where he was SUPPOSED to friggen go to. H eexhibited the same drifting back towards the center of the field behavior that people are complaining about.

On most runs to that side, the Tackle and Fullback moved more than 5 yards, while he barely took a step. In fact my middle linebacker had more tackles on that set than he did. I might as well have not even had him on the fucking field.

PinTBC
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, so pass defense works p much as expected from what I gather; it's just on rushing plays where you're not happy about the reaction.

Yes, I could very easily change the reactions to make him stand in place (or only move vertically?) until he passes his vision check or the ball is handed off. Would that work out?

I guess you're right that if the play goes the opposite way, he's pretty much out of the play anyway (or at least should be).
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, so pass defense works p much as expected from what I gather; it's just on rushing plays where you're not happy about the reaction.

Yes, I could very easily change the reactions to make him stand in place (or only move vertically?) until he passes his vision check or the ball is handed off. Would that work out?

.


Well I wouldnt say the way LBs cover is perfect cuz they dont 'get on it' till the back rounds the corner, but for all intents and purposes its not my concern as much as this LB 'drift' issue.

I would prefer to see the LB not to move at all from his predetermined spot until he passes his first vision check, then let him pursue his responsibility. The vertical movement has the potential to disrupt the LB through being caught too close to the line(and blocked up), or too far from the gap(and late plugging it).

Ill get some opinions in here...

I believe the safest call is to have the LBs just stand still where they have been put. Whether it be DPC or normal AI.
Last edited May 8, 2009 17:41:32
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, so pass defense works p much as expected from what I gather; it's just on rushing plays where you're not happy about the reaction.

Yes, I could very easily change the reactions to make him stand in place (or only move vertically?) until he passes his vision check or the ball is handed off. Would that work out?

I guess you're right that if the play goes the opposite way, he's pretty much out of the play anyway (or at least should be).


You know, I wouldn't have a problem if he has to stand still until he passes a vision check to see if his man is coming out of the backfield when determining to blitz or wait for man coverage, BUT if I assign him to move to a zone, then why on God's green earth wouldn't he do so? There shouldn't even be a vision check involved. If I tell him to go to the flats then he should start his movement there. It should take a vision check before he changes his mind and persues a rushing play in a different direction.

Today my right outside linebacker set to cover the weak flat zone wasn't even moving. He has more than 80 speed, and agility, more than 60 vision, and the Left Tackle was pulling from his line spot, and moving a good five yards down the line where my linebacker was simply standing there picking his ass waiting to get blocked.

Yes, this was a very frustrating game.

PinTBC
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
If they run full speed towards their zones, you run into the guys complaining about LB's running away from the ball. They have to make a read first of some sort. Maybe if there was a DPC option of "run full bore" or something, but for basic tactics, they need to play the run first.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
If they run full speed towards their zones, you run into the guys complaining about LB's running away from the ball. They have to make a read first of some sort. Maybe if there was a DPC option of "run full bore" or something, but for basic tactics, they need to play the run first.


So even if the DPC says that they are assigned to go cover a zone, they are still trying to make a vision check to see if it is a running or passing play? That doesn't make a lot of sense.

Right now with the different offensive plays working, it should be relatively easy to run to different sides if you want to avoid a certain player. This vision check thing for both pass defense and rushing, AND apparently moving into their assigned zone simply makes linebackers much less than useful.

I'm better off putting my linebackers into my bottom 2 CB slots and simply running a 3-1-7, because right now they are relatively useless with at least 61ish vision. As a CB they at least don't have to pass a vision check.

PinTBC
Last edited May 8, 2009 18:13:31
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.