Hey mods, can we at least consolidate on these complaint threads... Pick one "Fix Turnover" thread and make it official then lock all the others. This is getting obnoxious not to mention I've see multiple threads on the same topic.
Forum > Suggestions > A solution to the fumbling issue.
Zadith
offline
offline
Bort already stated in the first big thread where people were just complaining instead of trying to fix the issue...HBs need to start investing in Cover Up. He made it a cheap SA for a reason. I understand your logic Yend but it seems to me Elusive backs should be more prone to fumbles than power backs because power backs tend to hug the ball and just barrel into a tackler and take whatever yards they get. While elusive backs juke and twist all over the place usually allowing the ball to get a bit further away from their body than power backs. Hence the need to invest into cover up. None of the teams I have been on or faced have had these issues so I am not sure where all these problems are coming from unless they are from a bunch of teams with HBs that have 70+ Speed/Agility and 48 or lower Carrying/Strength with 30 confidence...
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 11:49:13
yendorii
offline
offline
I agree that elusives should be more prone to fumbles...when they get hit square. When they are barely clipped and momentum carries them to the ground however they should be less likely to fumble.
Again, I say that for the most part fumbles are fine. I just think defining two types of tackles would make the tackling mechanic make more sense. Perhaps I should recreate the suggestion without the emphasis on fumbles since that seems so controversial atm and have it be a regular sim change suggestion.
Again, I say that for the most part fumbles are fine. I just think defining two types of tackles would make the tackling mechanic make more sense. Perhaps I should recreate the suggestion without the emphasis on fumbles since that seems so controversial atm and have it be a regular sim change suggestion.
Zadith
offline
offline
Originally posted by yendorii
I agree that elusives should be more prone to fumbles...when they get hit square. When they are barely clipped and momentum carries them to the ground however they should be less likely to fumble.
Again, I say that for the most part fumbles are fine. I just think defining two types of tackles would make the tackling mechanic make more sense. Perhaps I should recreate the suggestion without the emphasis on fumbles since that seems so controversial atm and have it be a regular sim change suggestion.
Yeah but Bort will have to do weeks of testing with several different testers looking at it from every angle before making that live since that could lead to exploits which basically do away with fumbles for elusives or making them juke too many tackles. A lot of elusive backs lose the ball without being hit head on. A lot of the time it is when they are doing all their juke moves and the ball gets a little too far out and they just get clipped and it drops...So really them getting clipped or tripped up should lead to fumbles too considering they will be knocked off balance if they are being tripped up.
I agree that elusives should be more prone to fumbles...when they get hit square. When they are barely clipped and momentum carries them to the ground however they should be less likely to fumble.
Again, I say that for the most part fumbles are fine. I just think defining two types of tackles would make the tackling mechanic make more sense. Perhaps I should recreate the suggestion without the emphasis on fumbles since that seems so controversial atm and have it be a regular sim change suggestion.
Yeah but Bort will have to do weeks of testing with several different testers looking at it from every angle before making that live since that could lead to exploits which basically do away with fumbles for elusives or making them juke too many tackles. A lot of elusive backs lose the ball without being hit head on. A lot of the time it is when they are doing all their juke moves and the ball gets a little too far out and they just get clipped and it drops...So really them getting clipped or tripped up should lead to fumbles too considering they will be knocked off balance if they are being tripped up.
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 14:56:54
Zadith
offline
offline
I guess what I am saying is if Bort does make it that way he needs to give HBs the slider or something that works like this...
Juke more tackles but are more likely to fumble - more juked tackles but more fumbles
Try to juke some tackles but don't take too many risks - No bonus to either
Juke less tackles and make sure you don't fumble the ball - Bonus to not fumbling but decrease in tackles juked.
Juke more tackles but are more likely to fumble - more juked tackles but more fumbles
Try to juke some tackles but don't take too many risks - No bonus to either
Juke less tackles and make sure you don't fumble the ball - Bonus to not fumbling but decrease in tackles juked.
kuaggie
offline
offline
Originally posted by G.O.D Turner
Well, all I really do is read the title, ignore what you say and then go on a mindless rant
FYP
Well, all I really do is read the title, ignore what you say and then go on a mindless rant
FYP
Gaz
offline
offline
Originally posted by Zadith
I guess what I am saying is if Bort does make it that way he needs to give HBs the slider or something that works like this...
Juke more tackles but are more likely to fumble - more juked tackles but more fumbles
Try to juke some tackles but don't take too many risks - No bonus to either
Juke less tackles and make sure you don't fumble the ball - Bonus to not fumbling but decrease in tackles juked.
Thats actually a pretty sweet idea.
I guess what I am saying is if Bort does make it that way he needs to give HBs the slider or something that works like this...
Juke more tackles but are more likely to fumble - more juked tackles but more fumbles
Try to juke some tackles but don't take too many risks - No bonus to either
Juke less tackles and make sure you don't fumble the ball - Bonus to not fumbling but decrease in tackles juked.
Thats actually a pretty sweet idea.
yendorii
offline
offline
Originally posted by Zadith
I guess what I am saying is if Bort does make it that way he needs to give HBs the slider or something that works like this...
Juke more tackles but are more likely to fumble - more juked tackles but more fumbles
Try to juke some tackles but don't take too many risks - No bonus to either
Juke less tackles and make sure you don't fumble the ball - Bonus to not fumbling but decrease in tackles juked.
Not exactly how I'd describe it.
If a player is mid-juke and get's hit, chances are it will be a leg tackle or a glancing blow. If a player is running straight at the tackler who gets a clean shot at him then it's more likely that he will fumble. If however a player is mid-juke and the defender still gets a solid hit then the chance for a fumble should skyrocket.
I guess what I am saying is if Bort does make it that way he needs to give HBs the slider or something that works like this...
Juke more tackles but are more likely to fumble - more juked tackles but more fumbles
Try to juke some tackles but don't take too many risks - No bonus to either
Juke less tackles and make sure you don't fumble the ball - Bonus to not fumbling but decrease in tackles juked.
Not exactly how I'd describe it.
If a player is mid-juke and get's hit, chances are it will be a leg tackle or a glancing blow. If a player is running straight at the tackler who gets a clean shot at him then it's more likely that he will fumble. If however a player is mid-juke and the defender still gets a solid hit then the chance for a fumble should skyrocket.
Zadith
offline
offline
I have seen a LOT of HBs in the NFL fumble the ball while trying to juke and they were barely hit. Hell some times they are not even hit and they just hit their own knee or drop the ball. So yeah if you want to make it so elusive backs are better at juking tackles without fumbling you need a slider that increases the risk. There has to be a balance of gains and loses or you are just replacing an exploit that helps the defense with an exploit that helps the offense...
Gisty
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
60+ carrying is not stopping these huge fumble games. It is not a builds issue, it is a sim issue.
fix your build
60+ carrying is not stopping these huge fumble games. It is not a builds issue, it is a sim issue.
fix your build
yendorii
offline
offline
Originally posted by Zadith
I have seen a LOT of HBs in the NFL fumble the ball while trying to juke and they were barely hit. Hell some times they are not even hit and they just hit their own knee or drop the ball. So yeah if you want to make it so elusive backs are better at juking tackles without fumbling you need a slider that increases the risk. There has to be a balance of gains and loses or you are just replacing an exploit that helps the defense with an exploit that helps the offense...
I agree that there needs to be a penalty, I just was thinking of another way of doing it. Perhaps you way is the better way though, it would certainly be easier to implement.
I have seen a LOT of HBs in the NFL fumble the ball while trying to juke and they were barely hit. Hell some times they are not even hit and they just hit their own knee or drop the ball. So yeah if you want to make it so elusive backs are better at juking tackles without fumbling you need a slider that increases the risk. There has to be a balance of gains and loses or you are just replacing an exploit that helps the defense with an exploit that helps the offense...
I agree that there needs to be a penalty, I just was thinking of another way of doing it. Perhaps you way is the better way though, it would certainly be easier to implement.
Zadith
offline
offline
Originally posted by yendorii
Originally posted by Zadith
I have seen a LOT of HBs in the NFL fumble the ball while trying to juke and they were barely hit. Hell some times they are not even hit and they just hit their own knee or drop the ball. So yeah if you want to make it so elusive backs are better at juking tackles without fumbling you need a slider that increases the risk. There has to be a balance of gains and loses or you are just replacing an exploit that helps the defense with an exploit that helps the offense...
I agree that there needs to be a penalty, I just was thinking of another way of doing it. Perhaps you way is the better way though, it would certainly be easier to implement.
heck if you have another way I am all ears. I just don't want another extreme swing from one side to the other. I would rather my players have stats, whether good or bad, on a balanced scale.
Originally posted by Zadith
I have seen a LOT of HBs in the NFL fumble the ball while trying to juke and they were barely hit. Hell some times they are not even hit and they just hit their own knee or drop the ball. So yeah if you want to make it so elusive backs are better at juking tackles without fumbling you need a slider that increases the risk. There has to be a balance of gains and loses or you are just replacing an exploit that helps the defense with an exploit that helps the offense...
I agree that there needs to be a penalty, I just was thinking of another way of doing it. Perhaps you way is the better way though, it would certainly be easier to implement.
heck if you have another way I am all ears. I just don't want another extreme swing from one side to the other. I would rather my players have stats, whether good or bad, on a balanced scale.
yendorii
offline
offline
Originally posted by Zadith
heck if you have another way I am all ears. I just don't want another extreme swing from one side to the other. I would rather my players have stats, whether good or bad, on a balanced scale.
I do want skill guys to have to face a choice between consistency and risk. QB's can do that now with favor long passes and the new open man slider. WR's can do it a little with super elusive (although I don't really think it works). HB's have no risk slider, this could be a perfect way to do it.
My idea is:
Have more fumbles while juking only if the defender hit's you square. If it is a glancing blow then fumble chance should go down.
Your idea is:
Juke more tackles but are more likely to fumble - more juked tackles but more fumbles
Try to juke some tackles but don't take too many risks - No bonus to either
Juke less tackles and make sure you don't fumble the ball - Bonus to not fumbling but decrease in tackles juked
I like them both but yours is probably easier to implement. Maybe a few people will come in and tell us which seems better.
heck if you have another way I am all ears. I just don't want another extreme swing from one side to the other. I would rather my players have stats, whether good or bad, on a balanced scale.
I do want skill guys to have to face a choice between consistency and risk. QB's can do that now with favor long passes and the new open man slider. WR's can do it a little with super elusive (although I don't really think it works). HB's have no risk slider, this could be a perfect way to do it.
My idea is:
Have more fumbles while juking only if the defender hit's you square. If it is a glancing blow then fumble chance should go down.
Your idea is:
Juke more tackles but are more likely to fumble - more juked tackles but more fumbles
Try to juke some tackles but don't take too many risks - No bonus to either
Juke less tackles and make sure you don't fumble the ball - Bonus to not fumbling but decrease in tackles juked
I like them both but yours is probably easier to implement. Maybe a few people will come in and tell us which seems better.
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 15:30:25
Demboyz
offline
offline
30,40,50,60+ carry worked well previous seasons because defenders were mostly on the wrap up tackling setting. Now that more defenders are moving toward power tackling its going to take more carry to hang on to the ball.
this is not rocket science ppl.
this is not rocket science ppl.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























