User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Make Carrying Tactics Relevant To Fumble Chance
Page:
 
player66
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
Wow, this is my 5th season in GLB. I think I have plenty of time to see how the game works and make comments about it. Excuse me for actually be active in the forums and contributing to the community. And why do you need any experience in GLB at all to comment on who fumbles more in real life? I said in my initial post that I didn't have any facts and that it was just kind of how I felt. It could very largely be influenced by the fact that I'm a Bears fan. When I think of an elusive player I think of Devin Hester, who has lots of problems with fumbles. By comparison, Forte, who is much more towards the power side (although yes, not a true power back, probably considered balanced), didn't have a real fumble all year long.


lets just stay on topic no more fighting children
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by kretchfoop

Originally posted by MentalMisfit


guess HB can't get away with only 40 carrying anymore. Doesn't need to be changed at all every defense player had to train tackling to 60-70 to attempt to stop power backs now its your turn to spend 2 seasons getting your carry skill up


I support this post.


Why (keep in mind that the original post on this was about a HB with 60 carrying and 60 strength)?

With the slider, either the high strength/tackling that was added by defenders will make it more likely to cause fumbles to stop the power backs that are trying to break tackles, or the high strength/tackling will make it more likely to stop the power backs from getting anywhere if they are trying to cover the ball up. In either case, that strength/tackling won't be wasted.


Defensive players have to build to deal with both power backs and elusive backs. It is not like we were given a cake walk.

I once suggested a slider that would allow the back to fight for yards/break the tackle V protect the football. Then, running style would be about pathing only.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Defensive players have to build to deal with both power backs and elusive backs. It is not like we were given a cake walk.

I once suggested a slider that would allow the back to fight for yards/break the tackle V protect the football. Then, running style would be about pathing only.


Oh, I know it's been tough on defensive players. Most of my guys play on that side of the ball (and even more used to before I retired them after disbanding the team I helped run to save flex), and I've DC'd a bunch. In fact, most of my forum fights have been for defensive players to try and get balance, which is really all I'm trying to do here. I think the slider should even things out a bit for both offense (cut down on what seems to be a ridiculous amount of fumbles) and defense (by forcing the offense to make a choice between breaking tackles and fumbling).

By the way, my two HBs are two of my least successful players, and I was planning on retiring my elusive back this offseason until the team owner asked me to stay on for one more season, so I'm not in this for HB glory hunting and I don't have any returners.

 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Part of the current problem, I think, is that Sure Tackler (now that it's not broken) and Power Tackler stack in such a way as to make it much easier for defenders to get fumbles. Sure Tackler greatly reduces the risk of playing on balanced/power tackling, and Power Tackler is a huge buff for forcing fumbles. Plus, I think there's a chance that each missed tackle that results in a Sure Tackler re-roll for both defender and ball carrier may give the defender a 2nd chance to use Power Tackler to force the fumble.

Also, the Power Tackler VA is much more powerful than the offensive counterpart (Mr. Reliable). Power Tackler gives a 3% increased chance per level to force a fumble. This applies on every play, including special teams. Mr. Reliable give an equal chance to prevent fumbles, but only on first down. It doesn't help prevent fumbling on any other down and doesn't work at all on special teams. I wonder what would happen to the number of fumbles if the ball carriers had an equal VA to Power Tackler.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
Originally posted by Gyuri1


My suggestion would be to make the likelihood of a fumble highest when the ball carrier is set to the -100 side of the carrying tactics and lowest when the ball carrier is set to the +100 side of the carrying tactic.


I don't have any facts to support this, but to me this seems backwards to me. Usually elusive ball carriers expose the ball much more when making their moves than do power backs.


I was thinking the same thing. Power backs usually cover the ball and plow through, while elusive backs tend to shift the ball around and expose it while attempting stiff arms, jukes, and spin moves.

I do like the idea of a slider of some sort to help out w/ carrying, though.
 
HelfirePenn
offline
Link
 
The backs on our team are not fumbling, so something is either wrong with your players or game planning. Limit the amount of plays, diversify the play calls and lastly get your carry/strength up.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HelfirePenn
The backs on our team are not fumbling, so something is either wrong with your players or game planning. Limit the amount of plays, diversify the play calls and lastly get your carry/strength up.


Not an issue for any of my teams yet, in fact a couple of my teams have taken advantage of it. I'm mostly just concerned with the inevitable phasing out of the elusive back build if you need triple-capped strength and carrying to not fumble multiple times a game against certain teams. You can see by looking at the fumbling stat leaders in the pro leagues that the problem is pretty widespread (at least 5 players in each league but WEPL had 2+ fumbles in their first game, many had more than that).
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 17:50:50
 
ESPNDoe7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
.

2. Introduce a new ball-carrying slider with the two extremes being Fight For More Yards (risk fumbling) and Cover Up (risk getting tackled at the point of impact).


 
gijosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HelfirePenn
The backs on our team are not fumbling, so something is either wrong with your players or game planning. Limit the amount of plays, diversify the play calls and lastly get your carry/strength up.



I agree, through all of preseason, and the few games in so far, Our HBs havent had so many problems as everyone else is having I dont understand... Though, we work in a two back system.. so they split when tired. also, one is elusive the other power, so Im seeing it work in both builds.

where I do see a problem is on STs... and I have a suggestion for thatproblem in this thread:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2588522
 
UltraX
offline
Link
 
Or they can fix their builds >_>
 
Xar
offline
Link
 
There should be some kind of limiting factor on having both Power Tackling SAs and VAs and having Sure Tackling of the same. Be one or the other or balanced, not a monster that can do everything. If you are a power tackler, you get a bonus to forcing fumbles, being a sure tackler you get a bonus to making tackles and are less likely to have broken tackles against you. If you are a balanced defender you get no bonus. If you are a power tackler and use sure tackling techniques they should be less likely to work, and vice versa.

Same goes for RBs and running with the ball, a power back should be able to break more tackles but the chance of fumbling increases, an elusive back shouldn't break many tackles but has a reduced risk to fumbling. Balanced get no bonus.

The slider would help the game sort out tackling, but would need a slider on both sides of the ball. A HB with 100% break tackle vs a LB with 100% wrap-up should negate the bonuses each player gets for the tactics and it comes down to game situation and player build.

+1, but need a defensive slider to level out.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
If you are a great tackler, you are a great tackler. It comes at a cost to other possibilities. I don't like limiting them to one dimension. The defender has to have the speed, agility, and vision to get there, the strength and the tackling to lay the wood.

A RB needs the same things (only carrying instead of tackling). Defenders had to build to stop a power back and still handle the elusive back. Now we are having some success and the offense goes into an uproar. We still have to stop both types of back.

I still can agree with you, though. While it would have made sense to set the same restrictions as bruiser and slippery, we didn't have a slider. Now, he gives the offense another slider to counteract defensive success (which isn't really out of control) rather than add a tackling slider, changing those VAs for defense, and offering a quick reset.

Typical of GLB.
 
Xar
offline
Link
 
Having a slider means that you can set your guy to 75 and 25 and be a bit of both, but more one way, so say the bonus to break tackle is 5% at 100, then the further away from 100 you get the less the bonus is, and the less the negative effect on the other style is. So at 75% power you get 25% elusive/safe tackle, so your penalty to fumbling is lessened but your ability to break tackles is also decreased.

At 50-50 there are no bonuses and you are entirely balanced and rely on build.
Last edited Apr 30, 2009 21:15:04
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
I've noticed that there are concerns that forced fumbles are overpowered this season due to a combination of defenders fixing their builds to adjust to power backs and the fumbling buff that Bort gave to Monster Hit/Big Hit and the Power Tackler VA, to the point where people are suggesting that a back needs 70 strength/70 carrying/5 Cover Up not to fumble multiple times a game (see this thread: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2560130&page=6#21736330 ).

My suggestion would be to make the likelihood of a fumble highest when the ball carrier is set to the -100 side of the carrying tactics and lowest when the ball carrier is set to the +100 side of the carrying tactic.

The football-logic reason for this is that it should be easier for defenders to square up and cause a fumble (or Monster/Big Hit) when the ball carrier is running right at them and harder for defenders to find an angle to square up and cause a fumble when the ball carrier is trying to elude the defender.

The first GLB-logic reason for this is that if it is indeed true that a ball carrier needs high strength/carrying/cover up to not fumble multiple times a game, then there will be no more elusive backs in the game, b/c there aren't enough SPs to spread around.

The second GLB-logic reason for this is that, unlike almost any other overpowered skill set we've had in this game, 4+ fumbles a game is not only unrealistic, but completely destroys the competitive balance.

Anyway, just my $0.02.


actually as it is right now you have a better chance of fumbling if you use the power tactics... and less a chance if you use elusive. It has to do with defenders footing and balance while they try to make the tackle, if the back is juking and they have to extend to try and make the tackle then they are more likely to:

A. miss the tackle
B. have less power behind the tackle.

these are the main reason why a combo back works at all, he gets the defenders off balance enough to break the tackles without having to face them full on... the problem lies in the low carry skill of the elusive style backs due to the long time use of only wrap-up tackling... since they never fumbled before they thought carry was adequate, now that the power tacklers have surfaced (and a lot of them just as agile as the backs, maybe not as fast) you see the fumbles flying.

Defensive linemen already have the agility to match jukes with a HB (one of the things I find ridiculous in this game) and now they are not afraid to lay the big hit on the poor guys trying to return the ball with good footing and balance due to their high vision and high agility.

It's actually quite interesting to see how this all came about.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by G.O.D Turner
Defenders are figuring out that the mindset so far up to this point on offense was to ignore carrying, and go with massive amounts of speed...

Now that they've figured out how to absolutely destroy a speed back...why punish them? I applaud them, and DEMAND the speed back make appropriate adjustments to his carrying attribute so he doesn't fumble so damn much.

Is that so much to ask? I don't want Bort to fix this for you bunch of min/maxers...I want you to adjust to the defense figuring your system out, and exploiting a GLARING HOLE in your build.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.