User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #1 > USA AAA#1 Pro Bowl: see a player you think deserves it?
Page:
 
Colin Sosbee
offline
Link
 
it would be hard for me to vote for chad13 with his ridiculous avatar. i dont think i can take looking at BD that way anymore. just wrong
 
RUN HARD
offline
Link
 
why not just use the stats? Why have owners & agents pimping their players?
 
The Rut
offline
Link
 
No stat for heart....
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RUN HARD
why not just use the stats? Why have owners & agents pimping their players?


Seriously? Stats don't tell the whole story. Lots to consider beyond stats. You should take them into account but I'll take the guy with three picks in tight games against top notch opponents over the guy who has four interceptions and three of them were in blow-outs and one was a hail mary jump ball.

 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
Double Post.
Last edited May 21, 2008 18:51:18
 
BigMike1983
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcnorth
Originally posted by RUN HARD

why not just use the stats? Why have owners & agents pimping their players?


Seriously? Stats don't tell the whole story. Lots to consider beyond stats. You should take them into account but I'll take the guy with three picks in tight games against top notch opponents over the guy who has four interceptions and three of them were in blow-outs and one was a hail mary jump ball.



I totally agree. But unfortunatly that is even how the NFL chooses its Pro Bowlers... Stats... Not saying that I agree with the NFL but it is done that way. For example.. (I'm a Raiders fan so I'm going to use this as an example)...

Nmandi Asomugha was one of the top CB's in the league last year, as was he the year before. He would have made it to the Pro Bowl last year but was not able to find a plane ticket in time to get there because the NFL called him up for it too late. I think he had like 8 or 9 INTs in '06.

In 2007 he was so feared that teams just DID NOT throw to him. I think the average was only 2 times PER GAME! thats crazy. He ended up with 1 INT last season and was the LEAST thrown to starting CB in the league. He wasnt even talked about when it came to the Pro Bowl. Thats just sad.

So what I'm saying is that most players are recognized for their stats not the ladder. Which I TOTALLY DO NOT AGREE WITH. Although I do see where he is coming from, because alot of owners including myself may not have time to check every game for ever one of the top performers to see who "actually" was the better player. It would just be too hard with a busy real life schedule. Now unless we can just name some people with the time to do so to handle this whole process, only then could we get the deserving Pro Bowlers selected. Until then I'm afraid it will be stats that choose who gets the honor.

AGAIN I DO NOT AGREE WITH THIS !!!
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
I have no problem with someone coming on and advocating for a teammate who might be overlooked because of stats or something. It's just lame to come on and say, "pick me!" If you can't get someone on your own team to vouch for you - perhaps you're just not really in the running. And I definitely think owners should try to do some campaigning for who they feel is deserving of being singled out some.

Of course, if you own every player on your team and have no human teammates who could nominate you - I guess you do have to nominate yourself.
 
rogers2000
offline
Link
 
i agree stats dont show everything, but come on, my man Nate Clements blows up Asomugha!

Okay, they both are good, so hopefully people look past just stats!

But on the otherhand it might be easier if the teams did submit a list of their own players who they felt were pro bowl worthy. It would save time for many people, but some players would also fall through the cracks.

I'm not nominating any of my teams players, regardless if any were worthy. Either way this will be fun & interesting!
 
chad13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Colin Sosbee
it would be hard for me to vote for chad13 with his ridiculous avatar. i dont think i can take looking at BD that way anymore. just wrong


hater...
 
HoggLife
offline
Link
 
People that say stats dont matter say that cause their player doesnt have good stats. Build a player right and you might be able to get in the Pro Bowl
 
RUN HARD
offline
Link
 
I agree for CB's (maybe other DB's) and DT's.....stats do not tell the story. Above is a great example of a SHUTDOWN corner shuting down his man...but no stats to show for it. Also DT's that are run stuffers get no real stats as the LB's get the tackles.

So why not use stats for:


QB
HB
Blocking FB (look at pancakes)
FB
WR
Blocking TE (look at pancakes)
TE
PK
P
DE
LB
FS
SS
KR
PR

Maybe for CB's the TOP 2 PASSING DEFENSIVE teams send 2 CB's each, the League Leading CB in INT's makes the team, and the League Leading CB in tackles makes the league.
6 total CB's.

DT---same as above...maybe for DT's the TOP 2 RUNNING DEFENSIVE teams send 2 DT's each, the League Leading DT in SACKS makes the team, and the League Leading DT in tackles makes the league.
6 total DT's.


As far as which teams are #1 & #2 in Pass & Rush DEF....make it they AVG per attempt.

A team may give up 100 yards versus another team that gives up 90. Is 90 better if they are on the field for a lot less plays cause their OFFENSE dominates the Time of Possession?


I also say create a Selection Committee...make it 3-5 owners that look at stats and post the interim Pro-Bowlers and allow owners to give feedback on the initial list. The initial list would come from the 3-5 member committee purely on stats...then owners can male comments why their player deserves it more. All feedback is debated for 3 day period...then the 3-5 member group posts a FINAL ALL-PRO team based on feedback and comments.



Just suggestions guys.
Last edited May 22, 2008 05:01:08
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
Some good suggestions - but again, you gotta watch the games sometimes... our blocking fullback Rynne gets some oancakes, which are the glory blocks, but he always hit someone and clears the lanes AND he's awesome against the blitz. That pass protection doesn't show up for a dude like that.

Team stats should for sure be considered - I know our team has two great DT's who stuff the run each week. Are there some linebackers who have a lot of tackles but they're making them after the back has gained 8 yards? DO you go by total tackles when the worst teams will have more tackles because they're always on the field...

Just a lot to consider. Thanks, dudes. Good discussion.
 
RUN HARD
offline
Link
 
instead of total tackles for LB's...we do Tackles per plays. So a LB with 80 tackles out of 300 plays gets a 26.67 score (or gets a tackle over 26% of the plays)...a LB with 100 tackles in 900 plays gets a 11.11 score. So the LB with 80 tackles has a higher score and is ahead of the 100 tackle LB.

As far as where are they made...no way I can watch film on every LB for every team.

It's not a perfect system,,,,but there is no such thing as a perfect system.
 
mikerynne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcnorth
Some good suggestions - but again, you gotta watch the games sometimes... our blocking fullback Rynne gets some oancakes, which are the glory blocks, but he always hit someone and clears the lanes AND he's awesome against the blitz. That pass protection doesn't show up for a dude like that.

Team stats should for sure be considered - I know our team has two great DT's who stuff the run each week. Are there some linebackers who have a lot of tackles but they're making them after the back has gained 8 yards? DO you go by total tackles when the worst teams will have more tackles because they're always on the field...

Just a lot to consider. Thanks, dudes. Good discussion.



The check is in the mail buddy. :up
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
hahaha

Thanks - I was worried maybe I was laying it on a little thick but upon rereading it's got the kind of believable, sincere tone I was going for.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.