Does that mean it isn't worth listening to?
Forum > General Discussion > Music > What is it with your fetish in thinking that if they can't perform live, you shouldn't listen to them?
LoveGoose
offline
offline
Originally posted by decribb83
Originally posted by Chris LeDoux
Originally posted by decribb83
Here's a preview of Gooses next therad
"What is it with your fetish in thinking that if they don't write their own lyrics you shouldn't listen to them"
And? Plenty of great musicians didn't write their own stuff. Doesn't make the music worse/
No it just makes it not their music, that's all.
Point being? It still could be good music which many people can enjoy listening to.
Originally posted by Chris LeDoux
Originally posted by decribb83
Here's a preview of Gooses next therad
"What is it with your fetish in thinking that if they don't write their own lyrics you shouldn't listen to them"
And? Plenty of great musicians didn't write their own stuff. Doesn't make the music worse/
No it just makes it not their music, that's all.
Point being? It still could be good music which many people can enjoy listening to.
LoveGoose
offline
offline
The Mona Lisa is a picture of a face and nothing more. There is not really any deeper, intrinsic meaning to the painting. It's pretty devoid of a real artistic statement too, yet it's considered the greatest work of visual art ever.
krisdaschwab912
offline
offline
Originally posted by Goose the Redeemer
The Mona Lisa is a picture of a face and nothing more. There is not really any deeper, intrinsic meaning to the painting. It's pretty devoid of a real artistic statement too, yet it's considered the greatest work of visual art ever.
But he wrote it AND performed it. Or...painted it and displayed it. Same thing.
The Mona Lisa is a picture of a face and nothing more. There is not really any deeper, intrinsic meaning to the painting. It's pretty devoid of a real artistic statement too, yet it's considered the greatest work of visual art ever.
But he wrote it AND performed it. Or...painted it and displayed it. Same thing.
Bushido Zin
offline
offline
Originally posted by Goose the Redeemer
The Mona Lisa is a picture of a face and nothing more. There is not really any deeper, intrinsic meaning to the painting. It's pretty devoid of a real artistic statement too, yet it's considered the greatest work of visual art ever.
congratulations on being a shallow, worthless person?
The Mona Lisa is a picture of a face and nothing more. There is not really any deeper, intrinsic meaning to the painting. It's pretty devoid of a real artistic statement too, yet it's considered the greatest work of visual art ever.
congratulations on being a shallow, worthless person?
Gracehoper
offline
offline
I'm with Goose here (and I'm not even drunk).
In order to judge the quality of a an artistic product we need to overcome the misconception that we're experiencing the artist when we're actually only experiencing the piece of art. In other words we need to separate what we think we know about the artist and the actual product of the artist.
Once the product is finished the artist's expression is tied within the product, becoming the product's expression. The product does not change because of whatever shit the artist may do before or after it's finished. If Kurt Cobain kills himself, Michael Jackson is a pedophile or some metal band of whom I've never heard of can't play very well live does not make their records better or worse. That the Italian futurists turned to fascism, that Salvador Dalí openly admitted to join the surrealist movement for fame or that Jackson Pollock's paintings have been recreated by machines do not make their art more or less valuable. That John Fante sold his soul to Hollywood or William Burroughs shot his wife have no relevance to the the importance of their work.
The problem lies in the way modern music (and to some degree all kinds of art) is sold. In order to sell albums the record companies want us to buy into the story of the artists (even if the story is not explicit) as well, thus adding a fake aura of authenticity to the music. It becomes hard for us to separate the art from the image of the artist and once the image of the artist is crackled by reality it rubs off on the way we perceive the art.
A good example of fake aura is the discussion of "real" music vs. electronic music, Die hard rock fans and old people will tell you that rock or jazz or whatever have more "soul" than electronic music because it is "played by real people" and on "real instruments. The basic premise of this statement is of course wrong as they (rock fans and old people) let their idea of the production phase (that they believe that real people were playing) influence the way they hear the finished product. Lots of electronic music is played on synthesizers (by real people) but the rock fans will tell you that these instruments have less soul than e.g. electric guitars. The rock fans then forget that 40 years ago people thought electric guitars had no soul while acoustic guitars did.
It also shows a lack of knowledge of how music is made. Lots of electronic music is played and then cut up and moved around until you can't tell it's a real instrument. Lots of rock is programmed, sample replaced and autotuned - you just can't tell as it is done carefully.
The same thing goes for artists writing their own songs. When an artist has written his er her own material we assume two things:
1) That the artist is tallented enough to write his or her own material.
2) That songs must matter more to the artist if he or she has written the song, especially the lyrics. This adds a certain believability, an aura of authenticity to the music.
Both assumptions are wrong.
The first is blind to the fact that even great songwriters go through an editing phase where the producer and the record company is involved. Only few songs make it to the record exactly as they were written. And even if this was not the case we forget that it is not about how we imagine the songs were written or by whom but about the actual quality of the actual songs.
The second assumption is hard to overcome as once we know that the artist didn't write his or her own lyrics it can be hard to believe the feelings we hear expressed. Again it is the idea of buying the expression of the artist, a piece of the artist and not just a piece of art containing it's own expression that is so deeply rooted in us. But let me tell you: I've worked with singers who felt strongly about their crappy lyrics, singers who felt nothing about their great lyrics, singers who sang their own stuff with no credibility and singers who sang the lyrics of others with so much feeling that it made me proud to record them. If nothing else it taught me that the relationship between the feelings of lyrics and music and the feelings of the performance only exists in the listeners imagination.
What does this mean? Nothing. Real instruments or programmed samples, it makes no difference as you 98% time only hear what the artist / producer wants you to hear, whether it be real instruments, the illusion of real instruments, synthetic electronics, the illusion of synthetic electronics, real feelings or the illusion of real feelings.
Regarding Dragonforce (to whom I've never listened): Let's say they aren't very good live but their albums are awesome (though I very much doubt the latter). The average Dragonforce fan buys the album, likes it, goes to a show and is disappointed with a poor performance. This makes him or her question the circumstances under which the album was made (was it made in a manner that was, dare I say it, "not metal"?) and the album doesn't sound as good now as it's aura has worn off. The poor live performance leads to the assumption that the band must have "cheated" in the studio. But you know what? Every single thing you do in a studio is cheating. You play the instruments one at a time, you do an endless number of takes until it's just right, you cut takes together with the best parts from each performance, you put on effects that are nowhere near anything "real" and you add and dub so many instruments that it would take a band bigger than the audience to play them all live. And it's all good. Because that all comes down to how the album sounds. If you then go out and play a bad concert it's another, isolated problem. But the record sounds exactly the same as it did before.
It's fair to say that a band are great on recordings but shitty live. But to say that a band puts out poor albums because they can't play them live is to misunderstand the core of modern music and the last hundred years of artistic expression.
In order to judge the quality of a an artistic product we need to overcome the misconception that we're experiencing the artist when we're actually only experiencing the piece of art. In other words we need to separate what we think we know about the artist and the actual product of the artist.
Once the product is finished the artist's expression is tied within the product, becoming the product's expression. The product does not change because of whatever shit the artist may do before or after it's finished. If Kurt Cobain kills himself, Michael Jackson is a pedophile or some metal band of whom I've never heard of can't play very well live does not make their records better or worse. That the Italian futurists turned to fascism, that Salvador Dalí openly admitted to join the surrealist movement for fame or that Jackson Pollock's paintings have been recreated by machines do not make their art more or less valuable. That John Fante sold his soul to Hollywood or William Burroughs shot his wife have no relevance to the the importance of their work.
The problem lies in the way modern music (and to some degree all kinds of art) is sold. In order to sell albums the record companies want us to buy into the story of the artists (even if the story is not explicit) as well, thus adding a fake aura of authenticity to the music. It becomes hard for us to separate the art from the image of the artist and once the image of the artist is crackled by reality it rubs off on the way we perceive the art.
A good example of fake aura is the discussion of "real" music vs. electronic music, Die hard rock fans and old people will tell you that rock or jazz or whatever have more "soul" than electronic music because it is "played by real people" and on "real instruments. The basic premise of this statement is of course wrong as they (rock fans and old people) let their idea of the production phase (that they believe that real people were playing) influence the way they hear the finished product. Lots of electronic music is played on synthesizers (by real people) but the rock fans will tell you that these instruments have less soul than e.g. electric guitars. The rock fans then forget that 40 years ago people thought electric guitars had no soul while acoustic guitars did.
It also shows a lack of knowledge of how music is made. Lots of electronic music is played and then cut up and moved around until you can't tell it's a real instrument. Lots of rock is programmed, sample replaced and autotuned - you just can't tell as it is done carefully.
The same thing goes for artists writing their own songs. When an artist has written his er her own material we assume two things:
1) That the artist is tallented enough to write his or her own material.
2) That songs must matter more to the artist if he or she has written the song, especially the lyrics. This adds a certain believability, an aura of authenticity to the music.
Both assumptions are wrong.
The first is blind to the fact that even great songwriters go through an editing phase where the producer and the record company is involved. Only few songs make it to the record exactly as they were written. And even if this was not the case we forget that it is not about how we imagine the songs were written or by whom but about the actual quality of the actual songs.
The second assumption is hard to overcome as once we know that the artist didn't write his or her own lyrics it can be hard to believe the feelings we hear expressed. Again it is the idea of buying the expression of the artist, a piece of the artist and not just a piece of art containing it's own expression that is so deeply rooted in us. But let me tell you: I've worked with singers who felt strongly about their crappy lyrics, singers who felt nothing about their great lyrics, singers who sang their own stuff with no credibility and singers who sang the lyrics of others with so much feeling that it made me proud to record them. If nothing else it taught me that the relationship between the feelings of lyrics and music and the feelings of the performance only exists in the listeners imagination.
What does this mean? Nothing. Real instruments or programmed samples, it makes no difference as you 98% time only hear what the artist / producer wants you to hear, whether it be real instruments, the illusion of real instruments, synthetic electronics, the illusion of synthetic electronics, real feelings or the illusion of real feelings.
Regarding Dragonforce (to whom I've never listened): Let's say they aren't very good live but their albums are awesome (though I very much doubt the latter). The average Dragonforce fan buys the album, likes it, goes to a show and is disappointed with a poor performance. This makes him or her question the circumstances under which the album was made (was it made in a manner that was, dare I say it, "not metal"?) and the album doesn't sound as good now as it's aura has worn off. The poor live performance leads to the assumption that the band must have "cheated" in the studio. But you know what? Every single thing you do in a studio is cheating. You play the instruments one at a time, you do an endless number of takes until it's just right, you cut takes together with the best parts from each performance, you put on effects that are nowhere near anything "real" and you add and dub so many instruments that it would take a band bigger than the audience to play them all live. And it's all good. Because that all comes down to how the album sounds. If you then go out and play a bad concert it's another, isolated problem. But the record sounds exactly the same as it did before.
It's fair to say that a band are great on recordings but shitty live. But to say that a band puts out poor albums because they can't play them live is to misunderstand the core of modern music and the last hundred years of artistic expression.
Last edited Apr 22, 2009 15:28:54
Bushido Zin
offline
offline
separating art from artist is a futile, stupid effort that only serves to diminish both.
hope.
this.
helps.
hope.
this.
helps.
Punk Rock Jocks
offline
offline
Originally posted by Gracehoper
I'm with Goose here (and I'm not even drunk).
In order to judge the quality of a an artistic product we need to overcome the misconception that we're experiencing the artist when we're actually only experiencing the piece of art. In other words we need to separate what we think we know about the artist and the actual product of the artist.
Once the product is finished the artist's expression is tied within the product, becoming the product's expression. The product does not change because of whatever shit the artist may do before or after it's finished. If Kurt Cobain kills himself, Michael Jackson is a pedophile or some metal band of whom I've never heard of can't play very well live does not make their records better or worse. That the Italian futurists turned to fascism, that Salvador Dalí openly admitted to join the surrealist movement for fame or that Jackson Pollock's paintings have been recreated by machines do not make their art more or less valuable. That John Fante sold his soul to Hollywood or William Burroughs shot his wife have no relevance to the the importance of their work.
The problem lies in the way modern music (and to some degree all kinds of art) is sold. In order to sell albums the record companies want us to buy into the story of the artists (even if the story is not explicit) as well, thus adding a fake aura of authenticity to the music. It becomes hard for us to separate the art from the image of the artist and once the image of the artist is crackled by reality it rubs off on the way we perceive the art.
A good example of fake aura is the discussion of "real" music vs. electronic music, Die hard rock fans and old people will tell you that rock or jazz or whatever have more "soul" than electronic music because it is "played by real people" and on "real instruments. The basic premise of this statement is of course wrong as they (rock fans and old people) let their idea of the production phase (that they believe that real people were playing) influence the way they hear the finished product. Lots of electronic music is played on synthesizers (by real people) but the rock fans will tell you that these instruments have less soul than e.g. electric guitars. The rock fans then forget that 40 years ago people thought electric guitars had no soul while acoustic guitars did.
It also shows a lack of knowledge of how music is made. Lots of electronic music is played and then cut up and moved around until you can't tell it's a real instrument. Lots of rock is programmed, sample replaced and autotuned - you just can't tell as it is done carefully.
The same thing goes for artists writing their own songs. When an artist has written his er her own material we assume two things:
1) That the artist is tallented enough to write his or her own material.
2) That songs must matter more to the artist if he or she has written the song, especially the lyrics. This adds a certain believability, an aura of authenticity to the music.
Both assumptions are wrong.
The first is blind to the fact that even great songwriters go through an editing phase where the producer and the record company is involved. Only few songs make it to the record exactly as they were written. And even if this was not the case we forget that it is not about how we imagine the songs were written or by whom but about the actual quality of the actual songs.
The second assumption is hard to overcome as once we know that the artist didn't write his or her own lyrics it can be hard to believe the feelings we hear expressed. Again it is the idea of buying the expression of the artist, a piece of the artist and not just a piece of art containing it's own expression that is so deeply rooted in us. But let me tell you: I've worked with singers who felt strongly about their crappy lyrics, singers who felt nothing about their great lyrics, singers who sang their own stuff with no credibility and singers who sang the lyrics of others with so much feeling that it made me proud to record them. If nothing else it taught me that the relationship between the feelings of lyrics and music and the feelings of the performance only exists in the listeners imagination.
What does this mean? Nothing. Real instruments or programmed samples, it makes no difference as you 98% time only hear what the artist / producer wants you to hear, whether it be real instruments, the illusion of real instruments, synthetic electronics, the illusion of synthetic electronics, real feelings or the illusion of real feelings.
Regarding Dragonforce (to whom I've never listened): Let's say they aren't very good live but their albums are awesome (though I very much doubt the latter). The average Dragonforce fan buys the album, likes it, goes to a show and is disappointed with a poor performance. This makes him or her question the circumstances under which the album was made (was it made in a manner that was, dare I say it, "not metal"?) and the album doesn't sound as good now as it's aura has worn off. The poor live performance leads to the assumption that the band must have "cheated" in the studio. But you know what? Every single thing you do in a studio is cheating. You play the instruments one at a time, you do an endless number of takes until it's just right, you cut takes together with the best parts from each performance, you put on effects that are nowhere near anything "real" and you add and dub so many instruments that it would take a band bigger than the audience to play them all live. And it's all good. Because that all comes down to how the album sounds. If you then go out and play a bad concert it's another, isolated problem. But the record sounds exactly the same as it did before.
It's fair to say that a band are great on recordings but shitty live. But to say that a band puts out poor albums because they can't play them live is to misunderstand the core of modern music and the last hundred years of artistic expression.
I agree with all you've said.
Btw, Dragonforce is good live, but their music sucks.
I'm with Goose here (and I'm not even drunk).
In order to judge the quality of a an artistic product we need to overcome the misconception that we're experiencing the artist when we're actually only experiencing the piece of art. In other words we need to separate what we think we know about the artist and the actual product of the artist.
Once the product is finished the artist's expression is tied within the product, becoming the product's expression. The product does not change because of whatever shit the artist may do before or after it's finished. If Kurt Cobain kills himself, Michael Jackson is a pedophile or some metal band of whom I've never heard of can't play very well live does not make their records better or worse. That the Italian futurists turned to fascism, that Salvador Dalí openly admitted to join the surrealist movement for fame or that Jackson Pollock's paintings have been recreated by machines do not make their art more or less valuable. That John Fante sold his soul to Hollywood or William Burroughs shot his wife have no relevance to the the importance of their work.
The problem lies in the way modern music (and to some degree all kinds of art) is sold. In order to sell albums the record companies want us to buy into the story of the artists (even if the story is not explicit) as well, thus adding a fake aura of authenticity to the music. It becomes hard for us to separate the art from the image of the artist and once the image of the artist is crackled by reality it rubs off on the way we perceive the art.
A good example of fake aura is the discussion of "real" music vs. electronic music, Die hard rock fans and old people will tell you that rock or jazz or whatever have more "soul" than electronic music because it is "played by real people" and on "real instruments. The basic premise of this statement is of course wrong as they (rock fans and old people) let their idea of the production phase (that they believe that real people were playing) influence the way they hear the finished product. Lots of electronic music is played on synthesizers (by real people) but the rock fans will tell you that these instruments have less soul than e.g. electric guitars. The rock fans then forget that 40 years ago people thought electric guitars had no soul while acoustic guitars did.
It also shows a lack of knowledge of how music is made. Lots of electronic music is played and then cut up and moved around until you can't tell it's a real instrument. Lots of rock is programmed, sample replaced and autotuned - you just can't tell as it is done carefully.
The same thing goes for artists writing their own songs. When an artist has written his er her own material we assume two things:
1) That the artist is tallented enough to write his or her own material.
2) That songs must matter more to the artist if he or she has written the song, especially the lyrics. This adds a certain believability, an aura of authenticity to the music.
Both assumptions are wrong.
The first is blind to the fact that even great songwriters go through an editing phase where the producer and the record company is involved. Only few songs make it to the record exactly as they were written. And even if this was not the case we forget that it is not about how we imagine the songs were written or by whom but about the actual quality of the actual songs.
The second assumption is hard to overcome as once we know that the artist didn't write his or her own lyrics it can be hard to believe the feelings we hear expressed. Again it is the idea of buying the expression of the artist, a piece of the artist and not just a piece of art containing it's own expression that is so deeply rooted in us. But let me tell you: I've worked with singers who felt strongly about their crappy lyrics, singers who felt nothing about their great lyrics, singers who sang their own stuff with no credibility and singers who sang the lyrics of others with so much feeling that it made me proud to record them. If nothing else it taught me that the relationship between the feelings of lyrics and music and the feelings of the performance only exists in the listeners imagination.
What does this mean? Nothing. Real instruments or programmed samples, it makes no difference as you 98% time only hear what the artist / producer wants you to hear, whether it be real instruments, the illusion of real instruments, synthetic electronics, the illusion of synthetic electronics, real feelings or the illusion of real feelings.
Regarding Dragonforce (to whom I've never listened): Let's say they aren't very good live but their albums are awesome (though I very much doubt the latter). The average Dragonforce fan buys the album, likes it, goes to a show and is disappointed with a poor performance. This makes him or her question the circumstances under which the album was made (was it made in a manner that was, dare I say it, "not metal"?) and the album doesn't sound as good now as it's aura has worn off. The poor live performance leads to the assumption that the band must have "cheated" in the studio. But you know what? Every single thing you do in a studio is cheating. You play the instruments one at a time, you do an endless number of takes until it's just right, you cut takes together with the best parts from each performance, you put on effects that are nowhere near anything "real" and you add and dub so many instruments that it would take a band bigger than the audience to play them all live. And it's all good. Because that all comes down to how the album sounds. If you then go out and play a bad concert it's another, isolated problem. But the record sounds exactly the same as it did before.
It's fair to say that a band are great on recordings but shitty live. But to say that a band puts out poor albums because they can't play them live is to misunderstand the core of modern music and the last hundred years of artistic expression.
I agree with all you've said.
Btw, Dragonforce is good live, but their music sucks.
Gracehoper
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bushido Zin
separating art from artist is a futile, stupid effort that only serves to diminish both.
Separating art from artist is the only possible way to have any discourse on art.
separating art from artist is a futile, stupid effort that only serves to diminish both.
Separating art from artist is the only possible way to have any discourse on art.
LoveGoose
offline
offline
+1 isn't enough for your post Gracehoper. Very well written and posted. I appreciate your view, particularly on the Dragonforce paragraph.
ßones
offline
offline
/doesn't read thread.
If the artists DOESN'T perform near par of the studio version of a song they are doing I lose the 'it's their ideas, their riff, their emotions' feeling inside. I don't belittle them for that but I usually have that buffer on me when I hear a good studio song by them after hearing them live because of a hesitation that someone else may have tampered it or made it while the band takes full credit for it.
If it's as good as studio or in the ballpark (accounting for bad night performances) or hell loads better my affirmation in the band just gets stronger and gets me into further works better.
If the artists DOESN'T perform near par of the studio version of a song they are doing I lose the 'it's their ideas, their riff, their emotions' feeling inside. I don't belittle them for that but I usually have that buffer on me when I hear a good studio song by them after hearing them live because of a hesitation that someone else may have tampered it or made it while the band takes full credit for it.
If it's as good as studio or in the ballpark (accounting for bad night performances) or hell loads better my affirmation in the band just gets stronger and gets me into further works better.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























